Amy Concannon, Tate Britain, discusses JMW Turner's watercolours

Joseph Mallord William Turner
1 follower
Thank you very much to Geoff for inviting me back.
And it's a real pleasure to be back here.
This is where it all started for me.
And I remember very well the visits that Mary Burkitt made.
And I made much use of her scholarship, her books, while I was here.
And indeed, those books still I draw on in my work at Tate Britain.
And it's especially important for me to talk and come back here
because this was the very room, sitting in that little office,
that my love for Turner's watercolours first started to take root.
I was very fortunate to be here through 2008
and work on the exhibition of Turner's watercolours that we had.
On loan from the Courtauld Gallery in London and working with experts like Cecilia Powell
really kind of ignited a passion.
And that indeed set me on the course for the Masters that I did
and prepared me very well for the work that I do at Tate Britain.
And the exhibition that we had here in 2008
showed the myriad ways in which Turner used watercolour
from quite notational sketches
through to highly finished, very exquisitely detailed watercolours
right over the course of his 60-year career.
And indeed, also tapped into the idea of him making prints for engravings,
watercolours for engravings, which I'll talk about in more detail today.
And in recent years, through my work at Tate Britain,
I've come to know that that selection that we had on show here in 2008,
it was the tip of the iceberg.
I'm in a very privileged position to work directly with the Turner Request.
All the works that were left behind in Turner's studio upon the day he died,
watercolours, every single piece of paper in fact,
that's 30,000 pieces of paper, some of which have sketches on,
some of which are simply blank, and 280 sketchbooks.
All of that is housed at Tate Britain,
so you can see why in selecting watercolours for the recent exhibition of Turner's later work,
we had a lot of fun, but also a rather daunting task ahead of us
of going through many thousands of watercolours.
And each one, as you can see from here,
be it a simple swipe of watercolour wash
through to those more heavily detailed, wonderful Heidelberg,
which was a huge watercolour that became a very popular print.
They've all got a kind of magic about them,
that even when it's set behind glass, like Ullswater,
which Geoff has very kindly brought out for us to see today,
I think their magic is barely contained by that glass.
Now, the word magic is a word that Turner's contemporaries also used to describe his watercolours.
This is St Agatha's Abbey, which was exhibited in Soho in London in 1823
to promote a series of engravings.
There is the engraving.
So you can see all the information that a printmaker would need is in there.
The engraving is very faithful to the watercolour.
So the watercolour was used to promote this series of engravings, which people would buy.
And this work, St Agatha's Abbey, was picked out by Robert Hunt,
who was writing for the influential and provocative journal The Examiner,
whose sharp-willed writers had written rather scathingly of Wordsworth only five years before.
Now, Hunt's review of this watercolour praised its rich arrangement of colour
and went on to describe how,
connected, blended and sometimes delicately contrasted as these colours are,
Turner's effects are exquisitely tender,
but not without sufficient force from a certain magic arrangement,
a graphic secret of his own.
And I always come back to this because I think it's a quote that perfectly sums up
the feeling that you do get in front of one of Turner's watercolours,
be it one of these supreme, highly finished works,
or one of those very minimal, just very effortless, quick sketches.
And such is the technical complexity of Turner's watercolours like this one
that actually, at first glance, and indeed after minutes of studying,
they still manage to conceal the secrets of their genesis.
It's still sometimes not very clear how exactly he's built up this image before your eyes.
And although he made it known that he cared very little for journalists' criticisms,
I've been very helpfully teed off with some rather colourful criticisms of Turner's work.
I'm sure Turner would have liked the description that Robert Hunt gave to his watercolour
as something enigmatic, because by the 1820s,
Turner himself had become somewhat of an enigma,
particularly when it comes to his watercolours.
He was very, very secretive about his techniques,
and indeed anecdotal evidence about his techniques, about his processes,
is still quite rare and we still use it in books about Turner's work.
There are very, very precious few anecdotes that describe the things we saw.
In 1823, the same year that the Examiner hailed Turner a magician,
the first serious account of British watercolour painting was published.
Its author, William Henry Pyne, credited Turner as one of the artists
who had transformed the topographical style of watercolour landscape,
endowing it with superior feeling, i.e. the depiction of landscapes in a rather poetical way,
allowing the viewer to muse on the feelings that were evoked by that particular landscape.
Again, St Agatha's Abbey is a perfect example of this.
It fuses a very studied, you see in the sketchbook in the exhibition,
Turner was a very diligent maker of sketches,
so it fuses this very studied sense of place,
coming through the accurate details of the buildings and its surrounds,
with an exceptionally strong sense of atmosphere.
You see the long, hazy shadows cast by sunset, probably,
and this kind of hazy colour gives a kind of quiet, calm scene,
which is only disrupted by the echo that is suggested by the sound of the duck
flapping his wings on the water in the foreground.
And that's a motif, as we'll see later on, that Turner comes back to time and time again
to give a kind of, it's an immersive experience when you look at this.
You feel the atmosphere and you perhaps hear the sounds that you're seeing depicted.
Now, as Dean very helpfully laid out,
neither the genre of landscape or indeed the medium of watercolour
were very high up in the hierarchy of art that was promoted by the Royal Academy.
Turner's contributions at exhibition and the many prints published after his work
helped to effect a turnaround in this, elevating landscape as a subject
and increasing the prestige of watercolour,
which had experienced a surge of popularity in the late 1700s
as growing numbers of amateur artists took to the medium.
This somewhat presented a challenge to professional artists wishing to use the medium
because it took on a kind of suggestion that it was an easy medium to master,
that if an amateur artist could master watercolour, then anybody can,
so it was a second great medium.
But some of the watercolours that I'll go into a bit more detail about,
such as these, really show just how much Turner flouted that idea
and how far he would take his response to the challenge,
particularly when it comes to applying colour through watercolour.
So as time went on, Turner's work in the watercolour medium
effected a change in perception of watercolours from being drawings,
tinted drawings of the 18th century, many of which Dean showed through his talk,
through to them being termed paintings, so works of art within their own right,
and that's a huge change and it was effected in rather a short period of time
from the 1790s onwards.
Yet the move to this kind of work within Turner's own oeuvre
over the course of his life, it took place somewhat gradually
and as Andrew Wilton has put it, Turner was a perpetual pupil,
so he was pushing watercolour on to new heights through a combination of working within,
but also audaciously breaking the rules, and as we'll see,
he didn't always invite admiration for his daring.
So Turner began his watercolour journey around the age of 12,
copying from and adding colour to prints,
and you can see him replicating the delicate hatching technique of portrait miniaturists
in this very early self-portrait when he was 15 years old.
His father was very encouraging of the young Turner's talent
and he would display his son's drawings in the window of the barber's shop
that he had in Covent Garden, and he would later continue that support of his son
by becoming Turner's studio assistant, and if any of you have seen the film
that Mike Lee produced last year, the relationship between father and son
It was on the strength of watercolours like these that the young Turner was admitted
at the age of 14 as a pupil to the Royal Academy,
which at Somerset House then it was, was just around the corner from Turner's birthplace and home
in Covent Garden on the Strand, so he had a short way to go.
I often think that Turner's father cut the hair and made wigs for Royal Academicians
and so I sometimes think that perhaps the conversation that went on in the shop
perhaps played a part in encouraging Turner to pursue his ambition.
But the Royal Academy wouldn't teach him how to paint in watercolour,
or indeed how to paint landscapes.
Instead, their teaching, as we've heard, was geared towards the painting of scenes
from classical history in oil, then thought to be the most exalted type of art anyone could aspire to.
But alongside his academy education then, Turner was earning his keep and learning much
as an assistant to the architect Thomas Harglick and the topographical artist Thomas Moulton,
as well as attending a convivial night school for young artists run by the renowned physician
and collector of watercolours Dr Thomas Munro, who drew this portrait of Turner when he was around 20.
And it was here that Turner established a very close friendship with his exact contemporary Thomas Girtin,
the two being employed by Munro to copy landscape watercolours by renowned masters of the medium,
such as some of the figures we've heard about today, John Robert Cousins and Edward Dales.
There's some of the collaborations between Turner and Girtin copying after Cousins and Dales.
You see, they're perfect examples of the kind of tinted watercolours that abounded in the late 18th century.
But this extracurricular training, combined with the vogue for antiquarian subject matter,
that is, depictions of buildings that fuelled the study of Britain's rich history,
fed into some of Turner's earliest exhibits at prestigious Royal Academy exhibitions.
It was such architectural subjects that first called Turner to the attention of the art critics,
who were impressed enough by the five watercolours he showed at the Academy in 1794.
I should say he exhibited in watercolour before he exhibited in oil.
His education with the architects and at the night school of Thomas Munro
likely gave him that much more confidence in the medium than in oil.
It's the watercolours that really called him to the attention of the critics,
which was no mean feat, because if you've seen depictions of the Royal Academy exhibitions then,
the pictures were hung chock-a-block, floor-to-ceiling, frame-to-frame.
It was a kind of cacophony of work, and it would be very difficult to call attention to yours in that hang.
It's remarkable that in some of his very first few years of exhibiting in that context,
he actually managed to attract the eye of some of the critics when he was still just 19 years old.
This was picked up in accounts of the exhibition.
Apart from heaping praise on Turner's subject matter,
which explicitly targeted admirers of William Gilpin's picturesque tourism,
very important in the development of lakes and appreciation of lake scenery as well,
and Tinton Abbey was a highlight on the picturesque tour of the River Wye,
the language used by the critics in looking at Turner's watercolours
indicates the qualities that were privileged in watercolours of the late 18th century.
We've got a couple of the quotes that say,
there was great precision in the outlines, and it was well coloured.
And the Morning Poll,
continued their account of this talented newcomer's work,
saying that the character of the Gothic architecture is most happily preserved,
and its profusion of minute parts masked with judgment and tinctured with truth and fidelity.
They went on to praise Turner's evident eye for nature.
Now I just want to dwell on this remark for a moment about Turner's eye for nature.
This shows a very clear approval of Turner's rendering of Tinton Abbey in this subject.
And you can see very clearly how this image is built up.
If you were to look at it in the print room at Tate Britain,
which again everybody is very welcome to come and do,
you can see it's built up through rather prominent use of outline,
and using pools of colour in between those outlines,
rather like a jigsaw, building up block by block.
Without, I should say, of course, the body colour, a thicker kind of pigment.
This was pure watercolour, very important for the development of English watercolour painting.
It was seen as something that British watercolourists were proud of,
without the need to use that thicker pigment.
But this style, as I said, emerged from the tinted drawings of the previous generation.
It was considered entirely appropriate for a young British artist.
It was a restrained palette, this was considered very British.
There were no flashy effects.
And we've talked quite at length today about the conflict between Britain and France.
And this was a time in the 1790s when watercolour was being picked up
also in terms of it being a patriotic medium.
So this kind of restrained palette, British subject matter,
showing how wonderful, how grand the British landscape could be,
Turner was really tapping into that patriotic drive.
And the restrained palette, no flashy effects, that was very British.
The French, with their wonderful Donald Sheldon image of a French courtesan
in his bright red velvet jacket, they were flashy.
The British were restrained.
However, the Lancastrian artist Joseph Farrington,
someone who Turner very much looked up to,
expressed concern just two years later,
and I think the difference is palpable,
by he expressed concern about some of Turner's exhibits from 1796.
Clearly it is.
We see from that, through to this much richer, warm colouring.
Farrington thought Turner's works of 1796, ingenious,
that they were injured by their mannered harmony.
Now the idea that it's mannered, it suggests something false,
a pretense that's put on.
This is what the French did, not the British.
So there were some early concerns about Turner's pushing of colour
and pushing of watercolour to the bounds of what was considered proper for British artists.
But this work brings us much closer to the mature but always developing technique
in which Turner was able to represent the world as it appeared to the eye,
without hard edges and without outlines,
and in colours that were richly variated and affected in complex ways by the fall of light.
You can still see at this early stage,
he was very much showing off through architectural subject matter,
which was his home ground.
And he never lost his fascination for architecture.
Indeed, in later life, he expressed the idea that he might want to become an architect,
had he not been an artist.
Now understanding the science of light and the quest to paint as the eye sees
was something that occupied Turner throughout his life.
But in the 1790s, he began to experiment with light itself
in a series of what we call now transparencies,
using the very material qualities of watercolour and paper to the actual effect.
The transparency, where a watercolour like this would be backlit,
was a format that the artist Gainsborough had obsessed about before Turner.
Their experiments coincided with the time of huge technical and artistic advances
in things like theatre, scenery and commercial popular entertainment
like panoramas and dioramas, which are kind of like the IMAXs of today.
Three dimensional, all singing, all dancing, visual and sonic experiences.
So when this Welsh mountain scene was inspected by conservators in the 1990s,
it was discovered that its glowing effect was actually supplemented from behind by washes
on another sheet which had been pasted to it.
So if you imagine these two works sandwiched together, glued one to another,
in which the areas of dark wash are supplemented by this.
And if you can imagine it lit from behind, that would give a real transparency to the sky
and it would really exaggerate that glowing sunlight effect.
So he was using, as I say, pigment and paper rather theatrically
to push the capabilities of watercolour and to push its entertainment value.
Especially, this is all the more remarkable because from the first look
it looks like a rather straightforward thing.
The Trust, I remember well, borrowed one of these transparencies from the 2008 exhibition
and I also remember well the problem solving that Geoff and I had to do
in order to display this so that both sides of the thing would see that hole that we put through.
Now, when asked late in life by the young art critic John Ruskin about the key to understanding his work,
Turner put it shortly, and probably rather gruffly,
I've chosen this pair of images to quickly demonstrate his ability to evoke atmosphere
and how that was actually transferable between oil and watercolour.
Even from this digital image, you can see that there's a vast range of techniques in the watercolour on the right
deployed to produce the effects.
There's scraping out.
The white of the watercolour is scraped out, so using either his famously long thumbnail, the eagle claw,
or a sharp knife to scratch out the paper surface to get back to the white of the paper underneath.
There's scrubbing with some kind of sponge or cloth to produce this water vapour
which you can just see through the dark mass of the rocks behind.
There's also stopping out with a kind of protective fluid which would keep whatever colour you'd laid down underneath it back.
They're incredibly complex masterpieces.
But I've also reproduced this pair to scale versus one another.
Now this, which we borrowed in 2006 for the Constable exhibition here, is a big oil painting.
This, by the sands of the day, is an absolutely colossal watercolour.
I mean, even I was shocked when I did this.
I hope I got my maths right. I think I did.
But even I was shocked by this.
But it also shows the ambition of watercolour at that time.
Turner was pushing it to the absolute maximum in terms of size.
Bigger was better.
Call attention to yourself, say, to make the statement that watercolour could be big, grand and entertaining, just like oil.
And there's no difference in subject matter for Turner between the two either.
Now, from his teenage years, Turner travelled in search of subjects that spoke to popular taste.
Castles, abbeys, picturesque and sublime landscapes.
And he found those things here in Britain.
And as you can see, this blog link has five pictures of Coniston Fells and abroad.
His ability to travel to continental Europe had been severely limited by these wars.
But after 1815, peace opened up a whole new world of opportunity for the ambitious landscape artist.
I put this in.
These are the sketches that those two works were derived from.
But it just helps me to tee off into talking about his sketchbooks.
Ah, that's a nice one.
That's a local one.
I'm going to talk about how Turner used his sketchbooks.
That's just a skidor.
It's one of the few examples of Turner's handwriting that I can actually read.
Here we are.
So, as I've said, Turner's sketchbooks...
A colleague of mine, I can't claim this phrase, but a colleague of mine described Turner's sketchbooks as a storehouse of memory.
And I think it's an absolutely perfect phrase to describe these little books.
And you can see just how little they are through the exhibition.
They contain drawings that are detailed, also cursory, poetry, including verses that he penned himself, account-keeping sums, language tips,
and the odd recipe for cures for ailments that he might contract when abroad.
And I won't go into the kinds of ailments that he produced solutions for.
But he also developed a notational language for his sketches, as you saw,
and an outstanding visual memory for atmosphere, light effects, and a sense of place.
Things that were not so easily captured in pencil.
So he used words throughout to remind himself.
Colouring on the girl, however, with watercolour, took, in his words, too much time.
And he said to a friend that he could make 15 or 16 pencil sketches to every one coloured.
Now you can see below the selection of Turner's sketchbooks,
there's 280 of these, and they're all different, they're all wonderful.
And every so often he goes through and puts labels on.
So these labels are by him, Scotland, Edinburgh.
He uses it very much as a library, as Wordsworth would use his notebooks.
But below that, these two are examples of his watercolour paints.
The difference between them shows the progress in paint technology through the years that Turner was practising.
He was living through the age of industrial revolutions, and technology with paint came on leaps and bounds.
The difference is great.
You see this with pig's bladders and all sorts of metal pigments,
and this is a very special thing that he would take with him on his tours.
It's an old leather book that he's repurposed and applied the tapes to.
And he would buy his watercolours from a maker that you might have heard of,
Winsor & Newton.
And there's a lovely anecdote where he goes into Winsor's shop,
and at this time Winsor was urging Turner to choose the more technologically advanced pigments,
the ones that wouldn't fade in light.
And the artist retorted rather grumpily that,
your job, Mr Winsor, is to make colours,
my job is to use them,
which was a characteristically rough warning to Winsor, stay on your own territory.
But Turner didn't shun new materials,
and his zest for experimentation is seen in one of the trusts on watercolours here,
which I was talking to Jeff about before,
and it's been quite a revelation for me to see this in context actually.
When it came to touring, Turner found that coloured papers offered a shortcut,
perhaps produced at the end of a day's exploring or back in his London studio.
I find these works electrifying.
The blue paper, some of it certainly purchased when he was abroad,
as watermarks tell us,
and the richer pigment of the gouache, that thicker body colour I was talking about,
provided an irresistible combination for well over a decade,
probably because of the economy.
You think of a blue sky day, rather than have to put that blue in yourself,
use the blue of the paper and use the colour on top of that,
but what colour he does use,
and looking at these in a little bit more detail in preparation for the talk,
I'd always thought of these as private musings for Turner,
reflecting on his European travels,
but actually this one that's owned by the Astonolian up here,
was in preparation for a print,
and I wonder just what a printmaker would have made of that blue paper.
It's quite an uncommon thing to hand over a work on blue paper to a printmaker,
but its aesthetic takes us on leaps and bounds into the future.
It wasn't just blue paper that Turner drew on.
This work from Venice is a brown buff-coloured paper that was used for a night-time scene,
again that shortcut to darkness,
and he's used a very dramatic composition again, dotted with stars.
Venice, around 1840, the effect on Turner was transformative.
He was utterly beguiled by the place,
and something special happened,
because, you know how I said he didn't really like to use colour when he was on his travels,
because pencil was much quicker?
Well, suddenly in Venice he slowed down and started to use colour in a way that he'd never before.
This is done from the roof of his hotel, at sunrise,
and it's a technique known as charging,
where you wet through the paper and then drop wet pigment from your brush onto that,
but it produces a lovely molten effect that the sunlight requires.
This is one of my favourites of all time, the Lagoon at Venice.
Venice was a place that an artist could have a very good time indeed with the nightlife there,
and it was a popular marketable subject,
made famous by Byron and had a kind of frisson, an appeal there,
but Turner's visit, as I said, inspired something quite special.
But indeed the whole of Italy had a transformative effect on his work,
both in oil and in watercolour.
This was one that we were lucky enough to borrow in 2008.
Here I've put this slide together of Turner's treatment of Ullswater over the years,
which shows, there's Ullswater in real life,
shows the transformative effect of Italian horizons and Italian atmospheric conditions
moving from, effectively, Britain to Cumbria,
but still staying in Ullswater, which is quite remarkable.
In the three years that I lived here, maybe others here can tell me I'm wrong,
but I never saw Ullswater looking so warm and heavenly.
There are times I'm sure it does.
But as well as these sketchbooks full of information,
it was that memory for the kind of warmth and the beauty of the landscape
that he then started to inject onto the British landscape,
giving it a kind of otherworldly feel.
So his travels on the continent took his work to new colouristic horizons.
But in actual fact, and in these cases, here we are, Ullswater is a bit larger,
and in Windermere, the end results were prints.
I should, while it's bigger, I should point out,
these long sunlit shadows, this kind of pastel colouring,
it's all, if you look at his work from Italy, Campania,
that's the colours he draws on, the Roman one,
and these very skinny and harsh looking clouds,
and even the people in the foreground, they have a kind of European feel.
And again, the effect is similar in this Manchester watercolour of Windermere.
But as I say, these were made for print projects,
and something I learnt quite recently when I was working on the late Turner exhibition
was actually that Turner himself and his contemporaries
didn't always value these works very highly,
because for Turner, who was a keen eye on making money,
it was the print that was the end product.
That was where he would derive his fame and his fortune.
The watercolour was simply a means to an end.
But then, on the back of a tour to Switzerland in 1836,
which reignited his love for Switzerland, the mountains and lakes,
he decided to do something different,
and to start producing watercolours that were actually ends in themselves.
So for a period of four years, in the early 1840s,
Turner visited Switzerland every single year going back.
I haven't really described in detail Turner's personality,
but it strikes me that he was a rather obsessive character,
and we've got 280 sketchbooks in the Turner Bookletter of Tate Britain.
Sketching became a kind of compulsive activity,
as writing was for Wordsworth, but he was always sketching.
There's a lovely anecdote from Venice,
when another artist called William Callow was staying in the same hotel as Turner,
and said that he was out, the artist Callow was out on a gondola,
enjoying a cigar and some fine company of women one evening,
and he looked across the lagoon and spotted Turner in another gondola,
and said that he then felt quite ashamed of himself,
because there he was having a nice time,
and there Turner was still sketching so late into the night.
So from sunrise to sunset, every day, he was sketching.
I sometimes think about the phrase comes to mind,
time is money, comes into my head,
but I think it was also something compulsive,
he was perpetually self-driven to do this.
He was going through Switzerland,
amassing material in his sketchbooks in a customary way.
By this point, his notational sketching language was very skeletal, very pared back.
It's quite difficult sometimes to make out what he's sketching,
but he didn't make sketches for us, he made them for himself,
and he could interpret them.
But on the back of this new-found love of Switzerland,
he began to produce, back in the comfort of his studio in London,
what we call now sample fittings, and this is one.
In some ways, this innovation is related to an essential part of the process
of making watercolours that had been part of his repertoire for a long time,
which is called the colour beginning,
in which he maps out areas of colour in a composition to trial blending techniques,
or to trial out different combinations of colour in relation to one another.
One of these little anecdotes comes up in the relation to colour beginnings.
He was spotted making these during one of his stays at Farmley Hall in Yorkshire,
which was the seat of his patron and friend Walter Hawkes.
Inside Turner's bedroom there were, apparently, cords spread across,
as in that of a washerwoman,
and papers tinted with pink and blue and yellow hanging on them to dry.
Back in Turner's studio in London,
another visitor observed how Turner stretched the paper onto boards,
and after plunging them into water,
he dropped the colours onto the paper while it was wet,
making marblings and gradations throughout the work.
They're two of the only anecdotes that we have about Turner's practice in watercolour,
and I imagine he didn't want to give his secrets away.
These watercolours, these colour beginnings, were private works.
However, the samples that we see,
as their name suggests, these were samples to show clients
potential watercolours that they might be able to buy.
Unique to this late period in his life,
so from 1835 onwards, the point at which he turned 60,
Turner made use of an agent or an art dealer whose name was Thomas Griffith.
Turner charged Griffith with showing these samples,
which ranged greatly in themselves in terms of level of finish and detail,
to a small circle of loyal patrons and collectors that included John Ruskin.
The princely sum of 100 guineas, which was not a small sum at all then,
each had the chance to purchase the finished watercolour based on this sample study.
It was actually quite a gamble for these patrons,
because in many cases they wouldn't see the finished versions.
They'd just have this, and they'd decide whether to pay Turner 100 guineas
on the basis of these very unfinished works.
It was a rather bold move to make.
But this new intensely, see just how colour-led this period of life was,
gone completely is any sense of outline,
and any sense of linear structures of the watercolours,
pure colour, pure kind of seamless blending of washes and a whole good amount of techniques.
But this new phase wasn't to everybody's taste.
Some collectors turned their nose up,
one of them saying that the Rigi, the blue Rigi, was too blue,
while the agent Thomas Griffith himself noted very warily
that the watercolours were not in Turner's usual style.
So as much as we and the art market today might value these,
Turner was very disappointed with the price he received.
He'd asked Griffith to get him 100 guineas,
but the most he got for any of them was 80 guineas.
And to this Turner famously thought,
ain't they worth more?
And he didn't of course have to sell any work at this point.
He was a rich man, but that didn't matter.
Turner was always ambitious,
and he was conscious in this late period of his life about his legacy.
He knew that he had to get his art out there for it to be disseminated and appreciated,
and for him to be famous in 2015,
because he had his eyes on the prize back then.
Now I wonder if this lower price of 80 guineas in fact
reflects that Turner didn't exhibit these finished works in public.
Turner had lived out his career in the public eye,
being appraised by critics,
so I wonder whether these works that were bypassed that exhibition culture,
bypassed the filter of the critics,
whether perhaps some of the buyers, their confidence was tested
by these not being praised beforehand by critics like Robert Hunt.
But the Blue Rigi and these late Swiss watercolours
have come to be celebrated as some of the finest watercolours ever made,
for good reason I think.
And Turner really pulls out all the stops in these works,
using as one scholar has put it,
every weapon in his armoury.
I came to write about the Blue Rigi in some detail
for the recent late Turner Exhibition catalogue,
and I found it an incredibly daunting task.
Its mastery seemingly defies description.
It's very hard to know where to start.
But I had to start somewhere,
so I decided to start as Turner started,
with the piece of paper.
And we've seen his use of coloured paper already,
but here in the Blue Rigi he reverted to an old favourite.
This is White Wolf writing paper from the Watchman Manufactory.
That's what they're called.
The kind he'd been using for a whole five decades.
And indeed the watermark on this piece of paper
that this watercolour is made on is of 1827.
This was produced in the 1840s.
And Turner would have bought his paper stock in big, huge reams,
and just took one punch off of this stack
and made this watercolour a whole 13 or so years
after he actually purchased this paper.
But he knew this paper inside and out,
and he knew that it would work to make such a beautiful work as this.
He chose the slightly fuzzier side of the paper,
which is the wire side,
and this was a way to give a very subtle texture
to the smooth washes that you see.
So it's not entirely flat,
it's got a very subtle light and shade that flows across it.
And it would also enhance that painstaking stippling and patching.
You can't really see it here,
but when you get very, very close,
this is the mountain, the famous mountain of Uruguay,
which Queen Victoria went up in a sedan chair,
and which I explained to my uncle on two years ago.
It's built up of these tiny, tiny, tiny patch marks.
And you can see actually in the corners there.
And in the corners this serves to focus your eye in the middle.
One of Turner's compositional rules to live by was
to start in the middle,
and I think these work very effectively to do that.
You can also see ducks flapping about on the water.
There's that motif again,
which disrupts the beautiful calm and the tranquillity of the scene.
Now the white of the paper makes an appearance once again at the very top,
in Venus, the morning star.
And it's an expert addition to this,
because it moves your eye around the whole of the composition.
And again, as I spoke about the waterfall,
him using his eagle claw or a knife to scratch out,
to get the white of that kind of frothy water falling down the waterfall,
this is him scratching out the white of the morning star
to give it that real glow and to bring back that white as water and paper.
Now, when I spoke at the beginning about the more technically complex watercolours,
seemingly veiling their make-up and the process of their production,
well, here you have the epitome of that.
One of the very last few watercolours he ever produced,
and I think one of the ones that has never really been surpassed,
in my humble opinion.
And it's still the case that the more I look at this work,
the more I fall in love.
For me, it's an image that's somewhat of a padlock.
It holds all the graphic secrets of Turner's watercolour practice,
which was a magic arrangement of his very art.
