The Curious Case of J.M.W Turner's Later Works | Raiders Of The Lost Art

Joseph Mallord William Turner
1 follower
Joseph Mallord William Turner was hailed as a prodigy from an early age and he
went on to have a remarkably successful painting career. He was incredibly well
known during his lifetime and enjoyed a huge amount of success but even some of
his patrons were quite confused by what came up later. These experimental works
would prove highly controversial amongst his contemporaries. Turner's work changed
a lot during his lifetime he wasn't just content to keep doing the same thing. He
was derided for making terrible work with all sorts of unknown mixtures. His
work started off rather realistic and then became more and more expressionist
almost abstract. To many critics this was a step backwards they couldn't
understand what he was doing. However Turner's later dramatic paintings would
be adored by the Impressionists and people who see them today. The
Impressionists really looked back at his work as being pioneering. Turner probably
was the most revolutionary British artist of the 19th century. He becomes
this extraordinary figure revered if you like by those who understood his work
damned and dismissed by others. There are still many mysteries about Turner's
life and even the fate of some of his works. Two of his paintings were stolen
in Frankfurt in 1994 and only a strange sequence of events managed to bring them
back where they belong.
In 1843 when Turner was 68 years old he exhibited a painting called Light and
Colour along with its companion piece Shade and Darkness. They encapsulated the
much more radical style that Turner had embraced in the latter stages of his
career and showed the inspiration he had taken from the theory of colours by
Goethe. But a century and a half after these revolutionary works were first
seen they would vanish from a temporary exhibition in Frankfurt. There was an
exhibition in Frankfurt on Goethe's interest in colour and art and the Tate
Gallery lent two paintings by Turner, major works, which reflected Goethe's
colour theory. These are two late Turner paintings from the period in his life
when he was making these rather amazing kind of proto-Impressionist pieces but
they're also allegorical biblical themes but they're also an argument about Goethe
and because of that they've been chosen to be part of an exhibition in Frankfurt.
These two wonderful paintings were stolen along with one Caspar David
Friedrich painting which I think is sort of quite interesting. The robbers stayed
behind and took the paintings during the night. I was director of programs at the
Tate and my boss was the director, Nicholas Sirota, and he rang me early in
the morning, woke up and took this call and it was very hard to take in what he
was saying, which was that a message had come through that these two Turner
paintings have been stolen in the night and it was really hard to know almost
what Nick was saying. It was such an appalling message but he finished that
call by saying you better bring your passport to work.
It would be years before these Turners would be seen by the public again.
Tremendous efforts would be made to try and reclaim these key elements of
Turner's artistic legacy, a legacy that took a long time to be fully appreciated.
To select, combine and concentrate that which is beautiful in nature and
admirable in art is as much the business of the landscape painter in his line as
in the other departments of art. Turner was born in Covent Garden London in 1775.
The exact date is still unknown but there's a record of his baptism on the
14th of May. Although he had the first name of Joseph, he went by his middle
name of William throughout his life. Turner is born in very very modest
circumstances, you know, he's the son of a barber, grows up in Covent Garden.
Turner started drawing at a really young age. We know that in 1786 he went to Margate
and he made some sketches of the town. He was really from a very small boy out
and about making drawings from life and later on he went to go and visit an
uncle in Berkshire in a place called Sunningwell and we have a whole sketchbook
that exists from that time and a watercolour of Oxford. So his father was
immensely proud of him from a very early age.
When Turner was 12 years old his father put some of his drawings in the window
of his barber shop and they sold. We know that he bragged to an artist friend
saying, you know, my son is going to be an amazing painter, he's going to be an
incredible painter. So he was drawing and sketching from childhood really and
then went on into the Academy from 1789.
The Royal Academy had only recently been established and was still headed by its
very first president, Sir Joshua Reynolds, one of Turner's artistic heroes. Reynolds
himself would head the panel that admitted the precocious young Turner to
the school. Turner entered the school of the Royal Academy at the age of 14 which
was very young and he was a very good student. His education now would have
been rather traditional, a lot of drawing of the human body either from live
models or from plaster casts. What we do know is that he did a lot of topographical
drawing on the side so he was to sort of support himself financially. He
recognised this need for topographical drawings and then was in the Academy. He
first of all started working in the plaster galleries and then moved on.
There's one extant self-portrait from his period, as a young man, and he was
very able. He was just a star pupil I think from the beginning.
Turner exhibited his first oil painting whilst at the Royal Academy, Fisherman at
Sea, which shows a nocturnal scene on the English south coast. But Turner had high
ambitions and travelled across Europe to learn from the great masters at the
best collections, including the Louvre. He was able to achieve his dreams thanks in
part to the support of Walter Fawkes. Walter Fawkes was a Yorkshire landowner
who lived near Leeds in Wharfdale and he spotted Turner's abilities early and
when Turner was 22 he commissioned him to do a series of watercolours of his
estate. Fawkes was an early patron, somebody who believed in his talent and
who was giving him money and buying things off him, which if you're a young
student just out of college is enormously exciting. Walter Fawkes' home
became almost a second home for Turner. He spent a huge amount of time there.
Fawkes became really a strong patron and supporter but also just a really good
friend. It made sense for him to go outside of London. Turner's career went from
strength to strength and he became one of the most celebrated artists of his
era. But despite his fame we know little about his personal life. He never married
but he may have had two daughters with a widow named Sarah Danby. I hate married
men. They never make any sacrifices to the arts but are always thinking of their
duties to their wives or families or some rubbish of that sort. Later in his
career Turner started to lose the critical praise he'd become accustomed
to with work such as the Fighting Temeraire, first exhibited in 1839. His
paintings began to lose a focus on specific details and his mature style
seen in Snowstorm and Rain, Steam and Speed would instead highlight dramatic
scenes of shimmering light. Critics were not impressed. His work started off
rather realistic and then became more and more expressionist or some of them
in the late years almost abstract and of course to many critics this was a step
backwards. They couldn't understand what he was doing. When they were first
exhibited they were regarded absolutely as sort of strange and very very odd by
some of the critics. I mean they were sort of really dismissed by some as
sort of as far too experimental. He took a lot of flack and these are people who
maybe supported him in his earlier career. He was incredibly well known during his
lifetime and enjoyed a huge amount of success but even some of his patrons
were quite confused by what came up later. The critics were incredibly rude.
There are some criticisms saying that they look like lobster salad, mustard,
whitewash, soap suds. So I think they were just quite bemused by these
seemingly unfinished quite mad riotous paintings that were very different from
what they're used to. I mean they've got wonderful kind of swirls of color but of
course those things that were dismissed in Turner's time have later been
reappraised as great masterpieces. Turner would persevere with his radical style
and made the pioneering decision to leave his works to the British nation.
But this remarkable collection would suddenly be incomplete thanks to a theft
in Frankfurt in 1994. But efforts were being made to make the collection whole
once again. It is only when we are no longer fearful that we begin to create.
Joseph Mallord William Turner died on the 19th of December 1851. He was buried,
as he'd requested, at St. Paul's Cathedral next to his hero Sir Joshua Reynolds.
In an unconventional move for the time, his large collection of finished
paintings, still in his possession, were bequeathed to the British nation.
He left his paintings and drawings to the state which was an unusual thing to do
and it was a huge amount of material. There were 300 oil paintings and 30,000
drawings and watercolors. Turner left a lot of money, a small fortune really.
He left some money to the Royal Academy who have since given the Turner Medal and
also to the National Gallery which took the large bulk of his paintings
which we now know are in the Tate in the claw wing. There have been occasions
through 18th, 19th and certainly in 20th century when artists have done
wonderful things of donating works but Turner was determined not just to kind
of leave a few paintings but to really leave the very best.
We were lucky to have this bequest but he also wanted to make sure that his
life's work was going to be looked after, was going to be kept together and that
people could learn from it and see what a great artist he was. I mean I think he
was very interested in that whole idea of being somebody who had been breaking
new ground. I think to leave that body of work, his
entirety of his career, to the state was really something special, was unique and
and something that was unprecedented.
Indistinctness is my forte.
Only two decades after Turner's death his paintings found a whole new group of
devotees on the continent, the Impressionists, who were particularly
taken with his later works that had once proved so controversial.
In terms of mindset we can definitely see that Turner was a real precursor to
the Impressionists. He was looking at natural effects, atmosphere, light effects,
changing feelings during the day, shadow, darkness, light, how colour affects the
renderings of what you're seeing. So it was really a similar approach and it was
definitely a precursor and we know that some of the Impressionists would have
seen his work.
It was Monet in particular who discovered Turner. Monet fled to
London in 1870 because of the Franco-Prussian War and during this
period he became interested in British artists, not surprisingly, and above all
Turner. We know that he was heavily influenced by Turner as well as Whistler.
Another artist, again, he was looking at the effect of light and colour and
atmosphere at different times of the day and this obviously with his series
became completely intrinsic to Monet's work.
Monet seemed to have really knuckled down and done quite a lot of work. I mean there are a
number of paintings that show London at the time which are very exciting.
The direct influence on the emerging Impressionist movement is clear. However,
some art historians have speculated that part of Turner's output could even be
seen as Expressionist.
He was capturing a moment, capturing the weather,
capturing the feel of how it was to be in something, how much that was in in his
mind and expressing his own feelings. It's hard to tell, but he was definitely
an Expressionist in the terms of capturing what it felt like to be in
that very moment. There's quite a lot of angst and turmoil in there, literally, and
he's obviously very, very interesting in replicating huge storms and big seas and
that sort of clashing nature. Those are very expressive things.
Whether he was expressing a sort of internal world, it's hard to know. What we
do know is that he was trying to express what it felt like to be there.
He did work from his preparatory sketches onto larger canvases, but he
was really trying to recall the atmosphere, the effects, everything that
he was looking at around him when he was drawing.
In time, Turner attained the status of Britain's greatest ever painter. But in
1994, there was great fear that his full collection of works would forever
remain incomplete, when Light and Colour, as well as its companion piece, Shade and
Darkness, were stolen from the Kunsthalle Schön in Frankfurt. The two missing
paintings were especially important, as they illustrated Turner's fascination
with the writing of Goethe on the theory of colours. Goethe's colour theory, which
was quite new, was that he was looking at the physiological effects of
colour, how they affected your mood, how colour was perceived from the individual
rather than the way that every eye sees colour. So he was challenging Newton, he
was challenging theories that had gone before, and really looking at colour
through a different perspective. Turner became increasingly interested in the
effects of light on the landscape, and the challenge of depicting it in paint.
And interestingly enough, he titled some of his paintings after expressions that
Goethe used. The two paintings that were stolen from the Goethe exhibition in
Frankfurt had been on loan from the Tate Gallery London. They're very important
because they were part of the Turner bequest, so they're part of those
paintings that Turner himself decided should be donated by him to the nation.
So they were of the highest importance within Turner's work. They were actually
on loan to the gallery from the Tate, and the thieves broke in, and they found
themselves almost entrapped in the museum, and ended up clambering over the
guards, essentially, and getting out. One of them was on the poster for the
exhibition, so at one point I thought, well, you know, did the thieves take it because it
was publicised, it was just on the poster, it was very hard to know. And initially we
at the Tate were very much waiting, you know, was this going to be a political
thing? Was somebody going to be coming up for a ransom demand in a very immediate
sense, or using this as some kind of almost hostage-taking? You don't know, one
was thrown so completely, so far outside my experience, or actually any of our
experience, of those of us working at the Tate. One just didn't know what was
going to happen next. It would be five years since Sandy Nairn
received his initial early morning phone call, and with the painting still no
closer to being found, it was feared that they might be lost forever.
I think in the first five years, it's fair to say, there certainly wasn't a day
that went by without thinking about the Turner paintings, but I wasn't dealing
with it all the time, because there was nothing to deal with, and it was really
only after five years that an opportunity came about. There was a lot
of false leads, a lot of stuff came through. German lawyers would ring up, say
oh, I think I've got somebody who might know something, that person might need a
conversation. None of it led to anything, but of course you kept hoping. The
Frankfurt authorities had actually caught the thieves, but those thieves,
once charged and convicted, had no information about the location of the
paintings, and then once the authorities knew that the paintings had seemed to
have been handed on to others, they allowed us to work. They gave a kind of
special status to a particular German lawyer, Herr Liebrooks, and it was through
him that there was just the possibility of, if a fee for information leading to
recovery could be paid, then there was the possibility that the paintings might
come back. The paintings were insured for 24 million pounds, which was paid to the
Tate as a result of the disappearance. The Tate, however, decided that they would
buy back the titles of the paintings from the insurance company, in order for
them to remain in their possession if they were ever recovered. This would
prove pivotal, as Sandy would receive information which would take him back to
Frankfurt, in the hope of recovering one of the paintings. I had with me the head
of paintings conservation from Tate, and actually we'd been about to leave, we were so
fed up of nothing happening after days of waiting, and then eventually got this
call from Liebrooks saying, you should come, come now, and we went back into
Frankfurt, and back to his office. There was the painting on the table, and it was
fantastic. I mean, it was a completely joyous moment of thinking, after years,
here was one of them, but of course it was only one, and then we had to work on the
second. The first painting to be recovered was Shade and Darkness in July 2000, but
it would be another two years before Sandy would recapture the second. I
presumed that it would be another six months, that we'd get the second one, the same
people, we had to keep it quiet. Eventually, we got new information, so
then we set up another operation, December 2002, and we had the same
amazing moment of being there again with head of painting conservation to check
it, and there it was, without a scratch, out of the frame, no longer in the frame,
but still on its stretcher, without a scratch. For me, there was huge relief to
have spent eight and a half years, and to know that these could go back on show, as
parts of the national Turner bequest, be available again to a proper public, that
was what was so exciting. The immediate feeling in the art world was great
relief that the paintings had come back. They belonged to a public collection,
they were a very important part of Turner's bequest, but very quickly people
realised that it could cause a dangerous precedent, and might encourage thieves to
steal from galleries, so there is that concern. It's a question of saying what
was the Tate's duty, and in my view, and it was confirmed in law, that was the
duty to get them back and to pay a fee for recovery. The two paintings now
reside back in their rightful home as property of the nation, just as Turner
had wished. Despite their turbulent past, both works continue to be shared with
other institutions around the world, allowing millions to enjoy the output of
a true modern master.
