📈 Are you on track with the Baby Steps? Get a Free Personalized Plan. https://ter.li/5h1r0i
Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/u1cerc • 🏘️ Find a Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Agent - https://ter.li/ni98m5 • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
[Music]
brought to you by the Every Dollar app.
Start budgeting for free today.
>> My husband and I are in disagreement
about whether or not to uh gift one of
our kids money. And um one of us feels
like um we have been generous to them
financially and it's time for them to
stand on their own two feet. And the
other one of us says, "We have uh much
to be grateful for and we have um money
and we should uh give them the money if
we can afford it." So,
>> neither neither one of you are right.
>> Yeah.
>> Both both of you are wrong. Good.
>> You know why? Because neither one of you
said,
>> "What's best for this kid over the next
20 years?"
>> One of you said, "I've got some money.
I'll just throw them lollipops."
>> And the other one said, "I don't care."
They just stand on their own. Neither
one of you asked the question, what's
best for the kid?
>> Okay. What's best for the kid in this
situation?
>> Yeah, that's what I'm asking.
>> So, yeah. So, um we're retired, quite
comfortable financially. We were um we
are on baby step seven and um
>> So, you've got the money in question.
How much money are they asking for?
>> Well, they're not asking.
>> Okay. How much money are we proposing?
I'm proposing $30,000.
>> Why? What do they need $30,000 for that
grown people can't go get on their own?
>> Okay. So, um my daughter married someone
with considerable student loan debt.
>> Mhm. And um they have um not been
attacking it with gazelle intensity in
part because they keep being hopeful
like many young people are that their
loans would be forgiven.
>> And so they've kind of um not paying on
it aggressively.
>> And my son and they they live uh
uh frugally I would say they live in a
modest house. They don't have any car
payments. My son-in-law has been um
driving a beater for the last couple
years and my daughter's car is starting
to have some significant issues. So,
they they have to replace their cars
>> and they don't have the money in the
bank to um
>> do they not make any money?
>> Two different vehicles. They do make
money.
>> Where's their money going?
>> Y
um
>> if it's not going the student loan, it's
not going to cars. Where's it going?
Well, they have two kids, so I don't
>> How much they make, Josephine? Do you
know?
>> Do you know what their income is?
>> I think Yeah, I think their income's
about 180 a year.
>> You've got to be kidding me. They make
$180,000
and they're driving a couple of beaters
and mommy's going to bail them out. Come
on, Joseph. Did you just hear that?
Well, he has significant student loans.
>> I don't care. He's not paying on them.
He's waiting on Biden. Oh, wait. Biden's
not president anymore.
>> Yeah.
>> He's not even paying down aggressively.
>> He makes $180,000
a year and they're pissing their money
away.
>> I I
>> Yeah, I'm sorry. You lose the darling.
You lose.
>> Where do they live, Josephine? Where do
they live?
>> Um they live um in Michigan.
>> So they're not in a place where the cost
of living is super high.
>> No, they they they they have significant
discipline issues and spending issues
and giving them $30,000 is definitely
giving a drunk a drink.
>> Okay. All right. So
>> definitely
>> um just mind my own business. And
>> it's not mind your own business. It's
okay to be a mom that loves.
>> But you don't want to be you don't want
to be an enabler
>> cuz the math that you just gave me is
crazy.
>> It's crazy.
>> Yeah.
>> A young couple making $180,000 called me
up just on the air here and said, "We're
driving a couple of hoopties and we're
not going to pay off our student and
we're not going to pay off our student
loan debt because we're waiting on the
government to do it."
>> Um I I would we would we would put them
on a Ramsey program called Beans and
Rice. rice and beans. Get on a budget.
Quit going out to eat. Quit going on
vacations you can't afford. Go buy
yourself a decent $10,000 car and pay
cash for it. And then roll up your
sleeves and clean up your dad gum
student loan mess. Be a grown-up. That's
what they would that's the speech they
would get if they called here.
>> Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
>> And you know why I would give them that
speech? Because I love them.
>> Yeah.
>> And you love them, too. The only
difference you and I have is is in how
we manifest that. What I want to do is I
want to create in them habits and uh
systems and processes and character
traits that create a sustainable life
for them where they become prosperous.
That's what I want to create in them.
Giving them money when they're
misbehaving with money does not do that.
>> Okay. All right.
>> That makes total sense.
>> That that's that's where we are. I'm
sorry I laughed so loud at you.
>> I scared me.
But I thought you were going to tell me
they made $30,000 a year or something
and it caught me off guard.
>> I know. I was. Yeah.
>> Wow. Wow. So, yeah. Let me tell you, the
nicest people on the planet are
enablers. They want to help. And the way
they want to help is they just give
somebody money in in a situation that
they don't need to. So, it's the old the
old adage of you you teach a man to fish
and he's he has fish for the rest of his
life. If you give him a fish, he has a
fish for a day. And that's what we're
talk that's the difference in what we're
talking about here.
>> Yeah. And different different scenario
would be
>> Let me tell you what I would do. Let me
tell you what I would do, Josephine.
>> You'd put them in Financial Peace
University.
>> I would and I would match them. And I
would match them.
>> Oh, that's good. Yeah.
>> You know, if you will if you will go buy
if you will save up uh $10,000 or $5,000
for a car, I'll put $5,000 with it so
you can get a $10,000 car.
>> If you will pay down $10,000 on your
student loan, I'll put $10,000 towards
your student loan.
>> Yeah. up to 30. I'm not going to do the
whole stinking substantial. We didn't
ever get the number what substantial is,
but yeah. Um, but I would do some
matching to encourage the proper habits.
>> That's right.
>> Not to prop up
>> and encourage the improper habits.
>> That's right. Yes.
>> But yeah, a matching plan might be and
and I'll tell you what, I'll give you
since I was so tough on you. I'm sorry.
I I'll give you Financial Peace
University to give to them if you can if
you could talk them into doing it. If
you could talk them into doing it. Yeah.
But if you guys will get in Financial
Peace University and you'll start on a
budget and you'll start limiting your
spending and get control and get rid of
the chaos and build a sustainable future
for yourselves and for my grandbabies.
I'll put up money and help by matching
your positive moves
>> up to 30K.
>> Yeah. Because if the call
>> Now that's assuming your husband goes
along with that, Josephine, because you
got to you got to have you got to have
peace in your house because y'all are
still arguing about that too. But
>> totally totally. But if if you and your
husband I would Sharon and I would do
that
>> because if she had called and said they
make 50, they have been paying off debt
like crazy. They're making progress and
one of their cars just died
>> and and we want to come we want to help
them. Yeah. You know what I mean?
>> That's helping them on a path that's
positive.
>> That's right. Exactly. Exactly.
>> That's not that's not u writing checks
for misbehavior.
>> Y
>> which is a drunk a drink. You don't want
to do that. So yeah, I want I want I
want them fishing for life, not fish for
a day.
>> Yes. The good.
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I Well,
>> it is hard, Josephine, though, as a mom,
if you do see, you know, your do they're
struggling and and I could see if they
have a lot of money. If Josephine and
her husband like it is hard, but
reaction, what's hard is you also know
in your heart that they're misbehaving
and that's hard, too.
>> Yes. That they're not paying on the
debt.
>> They're not doing what they need to do.
>> Yeah. And they make $180,000.
Yeah.
>> Mhm.
>> You you
>> That one caught me off guard. I didn't
see that one coming. I got hit in the
back of the head like a boomer hang on
that one.
>> Oh wow. You can't make this day up.
>> I get it, Joseph.
>> You can't make this day up. Wow. Yeah,
that's what I would do. I would do
matching and hang on. Christian will
pick up and we'll set you up with
Financial Peace University if the kids
want to do it. Uh I got a feeling they
don't want to do it, but um
>> maybe they will. This may be the life.
>> If they want the 30,000 and match, maybe
they will. Yeah, if that's assuming
Josephine and her husband both agree on
that.
>> That's fair.
>> Create your free every dollar budget
today. The simplest way to budget for
your