世界航海/海軍歷史 原汁生肉 Battle of Dover Strait (1917) - Evans of Broke (or Peck of the Swift)
王者风范
22粉絲
8 次觀看·2025年8月10日
Hello everyone, this is not your regularly scheduled Wednesday video.
This Wednesday's video was supposed to be on the movie U571,
and hopefully that video will still be released at some point in the future.
Indeed, if you're watching this past the first week of release,
maybe that video is out there now. Who knows?
But in any case, of course, the wonderful automated systems on YouTube decided that
any use of the film footage somehow violated copyright,
even though obviously fair use for criticism and review is a thing.
Dispute is in. We will obviously see how it resolves.
As I said, if you're watching this after the first week of release,
you'll know how the dispute is resolved.
But it means that for the moment, there is not a Wednesday video scheduled to come out,
because the one that was scheduled to come out is currently blocked.
Thus, this video.
So this is the break glass in case of emergency Wednesday video.
So you have something to listen to today.
And today we're going to now look at some of the smaller incidents
that occurred in the naval war between Britain and Germany in World War I.
So everyone's heard about the Battle of Jutland.
Most people have heard about things like the Battle of Dogger Bank,
maybe the Battle of Heligoland Bight.
You know, the big flashy ones,
Bombardment of Scarborough, that kind of stuff.
But what a lot of people don't realize is that there were a lot of smaller actions,
fights between destroyer and cruiser formations starting in 1914
and going all the way through pretty much to the end of the war.
There's also obviously the false narrative that the High Seas Fleet never sails after Jutland.
That's a completely separate issue.
But the High Seas Fleet as a whole did sail after Jutland.
And the High Seas Fleet in terms of individual elements definitely was active after Jutland.
And it's one of those smaller actions we're going to look at today.
Once again, we're going to be taking our account from the book
Against All Odds, Battle at Sea 1591-1949 by Alexander McKee,
which some of you who are regular viewers of the channel will know
one or two other similar emergency videos have been taken from.
And this one is detailing the actions of Evans of the Baroque,
that's a Royal Navy destroyer,
in what's termed the Shoot and Scoot Raids of April 1917.
So let us begin.
From boredom, bad food and barracks-type discipline,
the crews of the German battleships were to mutiny in 1918.
But not the men of the cruisers and destroyers,
who found themselves fully employed on warlike work.
There were several British disasters to their convoys from the Shetlands to Norway,
their escorting destroyers being sunk together with many of the merchantmen.
But these battles took place far away.
Much nearer home and therefore much more newsworthy in England
was German destroyer activity in and around the Straits of Dover.
The British supply routes for men and war material to the Western Front in France
lay mainly through the ports on the Kentish coast.
And there was the so-called Dover Barrage of nets and drifters and guard vessels
designed to catch or destroy or deter U-boats from entering the channel
from their bases on the Belgian coast.
And there was the great storm weather anchorage off Dover called the Downs.
All these offered tempting targets for the fast German destroyers
to dash over during the night in what came to be called Shoot and Scoot operations.
They were helped to success on occasion by alterations in their codes,
which were hard for Room 40, the admiralty wireless interception and decoding unit, to crack,
added by much senior admiralty indifference to the importance of their work.
Damn your decoding, why aren't you fighting? was the motto of many.
But Room 40 scored a success on the night of 22-23 January 1917
when the move of a German destroyer flotilla to Zeebrugge on the Belgian coast
was detected in time and intercepted by British force.
On 25 February the Germans obtained surprise but did little damage
and on 17-18 March Room 40 gave timely warning of a destroyer raid which was driven off.
A much larger raid by a dozen German destroyers on the night of 20-21 April
was intercepted by a British force consisting of two exceptionally large British destroyers
which may be classed as flotilla leaders.
The result was to discourage the Germans for ten months.
After a British destroyer, the Paragon, had been sunk on 23 March
the admiralty formed a force of four flotilla leaders, Botha, Faulkner, Swift and Broke.
On this particular night it was the last two which were on patrol.
The Swift had a 6-inch gun forward, an enormous piece compared to the small destroyer,
more worthy of a cruiser, and her captain was Commander A. M. Peck.
Keeping station astern of her was the Broke with a brand new bow
she'd lost the first one ramming another British destroyer at the Battle of Jutland
losing her captain at the same time.
She was now to lose her bow a second time but bring her captain fame.
The Broke had been built by Vickers Armstrong in 1912 for the Chilean Navy
and been requisitioned in 1914 for the British Navy.
Her original name of Almirante Uribe had been changed to Broke
after Philip Broke, captain of the frigate Shannon,
when she took the American frigate Chesapeake in the north of Massachusetts Bay in 1813.
She displaced 1,850 tons and had a crew of 214 including Royal Marines,
an unheard of thing in a destroyer at that period.
In command was Edward Evans who commented that she had
beautiful accommodation for the captain and rotten quarters for everyone else.
She was armed with six 4-inch guns, four of them sighted to fire ahead,
and four 18-inch torpedo tubes.
Evans had a father whose hobby was painting ships.
He had entered the Navy the cheap way as a boy of 15 in January 1895
through the training ship Worcester which prepared lads for the merchant marine
but from where cadet ships to the Royal Navy might be obtained by promising youngsters.
Evans was a small tough lad who gained high marks for everything
except good conduct being classed as a ruffian.
Becoming bored with life in the Royal Navy in peacetime
he volunteered for the polar expeditions then being conducted under Scott,
Shackleton and others and took part in three of them,
gaining material for a book of adventures.
It was whilst lecturing on his three Antarctic expeditions
that he met Elsa Andvord at Kristine in Norway.
This would not have been popular in the British Navy at any time for obvious reasons
so Evans was commanded to report to the Admiralty
where he was told that their lordships did not like naval officers
contracting marriages with foreigners in wartime.
Evans, however, told Admiral Sir Reginald Hall, the head of Room 40,
I don't care if she's a hodentot, I'm going to marry her.
Hall told Evans that he was impudent, but he may have told him a good deal more
for on the night of 20th April 1917,
his biographer noted that Evans said he had
passed word around about an expected German raid,
blaming an extraordinary instinct.
To his wife he said,
the Germans will come out tonight, we're ready for them.
Evans had previously told his crew what his tactics would be in a night action,
to strike direct for the enemy after firing the first torpedo
and to drive right in among them,
ramming or being rammed, as the case may be.
Of course, it was not a good idea to be rammed,
but quite likely because of the high-speed night action,
if you missed the ship you tried to ram,
the next astern of her would probably ram you,
and if you missed ahead, you would also be the one to be rammed.
If Room 40 were right, they were in for an exciting night.
The swift and the brook left Dover
for the ninth night in succession at 7.45pm,
having loaded 233 tons of coal during the crew's rest period.
At 45 minutes after midnight, 7 miles east of Dover,
they sighted an enemy flotilla steaming fast towards them 600 yards away.
The fire gongs sounded in the German ships and in the British,
who were outnumbered, apparently, 6 to 2.
Sub-lieutenant Pepp went on to the bridge.
The German destroyers, whose gun flashes they had seen
as they shelled Dover an hour earlier,
could just be made out,
passing swiftly down the starboard sides
of the two British flotilla leaders.
He says,
Simultaneously, Swift, ourselves, and the enemy opened fire,
and a ripple of flame ran down their line
as blinding flashes lit the dark night.
A roar denoted Swift's mighty 6-inch gun firing.
It was the great flash from that gun,
firing from just forward of the bridge,
which momentarily ruined Commander Peck's night vision
at the critical moment when he was turning his ship to ram.
He missed, but avoided being himself
run down by a German.
Then he turned onto a course parallel to the Germans
and fired his torpedoes, going 25 knots.
One of them seemed to hit.
Of the six men around Broke's forward gun
a few moments ago, only two were left,
but they were still loading and firing.
A ball of burning cordite landed on the bridge,
lighting up the Broke
and making her a target for concentrated fire.
Lieutenant Max Depard, the first officer,
picked out the second ship in the German line,
and as his torpedo sight came on,
he fired and hit.
But when he ordered the second tube to stand by,
there was no answer.
'See what's happening, sub,' he said to Peck.
When Peck reached the tube,
he saw the torpedo men lying dead astride it,
and amid ships there was steam
pouring from the ventilators.
The main steam pipe had been carried away by a shell,
and all the men there had met an agonising death,
scolded.
Another exploding shell threw Peck against the ladder
leading to the bridge,
from where he could hear Evans giving orders
to attack the third ship in the German line.
'Stand by to ram.'
'Hard over and ram, quartermaster.'
The impact, reflected Evans later,
must have been a dreadful moment for those aboard,
the German destroyer, G-42.
In the Broke's engine room,
the artificers believed they had been torpedoed.
'Lieutenant Peck,' remembered.
The crash, when it came, was terrific.
Straight into the enemy, the Broke cleaved her way.
For a few moments,
the doomed ship was carried alongside,
then she slowly heeled over and sank underfoot.
On our lower bridge, there was carnage.
Only the quartermaster, leading Seaman Rawlings, survived,
grasping the wheel from a kneeling position
because his back and legs were riddled with shrapnel.
Now the midshipman, Giles,
grasping a revolver in each hand,
was preparing to lead a boarding party
armed with cutlasses that were always kept in readiness,
but he was knocked down by shrapnel over the eye.
Three Germans managed to crawl aboard
over the stockless anchor,
more ready to surrender than to show a fight.
In this carnage, a shell splinter shattered the compass
and struck the binnacle against which Evans was standing,
a fragment cutting his tunic.
Otherwise he was unharmed, and taking no chances,
he ordered the boarders to be thrown back into the sea,
and then for the Broke to follow the Swift
in her pursuit of the Germans.
On being told that the loss of boiler feed water
meant that the speed was cut by half,
so that pursuit was impossible,
he tried to close a disabled German destroyer
which was stopped and burning some distance away.
This was G85,
possibly the ship that had been torpedoed by the Swift.
On her way, more drifting than steaming,
the Broke with ruined bows
passed German survivors in the water calling for help.
Lieutenant Depard suggested lowering a boat,
to which Evans replied,
'We're not here to look after midnight beavers.'
To the desperate cries from the water of Hilfe, Hilfe,
the British sailors roared back,
'Hospital ships! Lusitania!'
When they reached the burning, drifting G85,
cries of Kamerad came out of the smoke.
Then the forward gun of the German ship opened fire,
possibly because the gun crews had not heard an order to give in,
or perhaps merely they did not agree with it.
In any case, the British regarded this as rank treachery
and fired back with rounds of 4-inch gunfire and a torpedo,
taking no prisoners except a single man in a boat who came alongside.
The seamen were at this point in favour of hanging him,
according to Lieutenant Depard.
The Broke, by now out of action,
anchored near the mine barrage,
when HMS Mentor turned up to offer help.
Her sub-lieutenant recalls the Germans swimming in the water
and Evans leaning over the bridge shouting,
'Remember the Lusitania!'
which may have been an injunction to the men not to save life.
However, between them, the Swift and Broke rescued 140 Germans.
The Swift had one man killed and four wounded.
When the battered Broke was towed into Dover
to roars of cheering and the wild noise of hooters,
there were 21 flag-covered bodies on her upper deck
and 27 wounded below in the sick bay.
Evans, on visiting the seamen's mess deck,
found scores of German sailors being fed with bacon and eggs
by British sailors as if they were entertaining a visiting football team.
Nelson would have approved.
As per his quote,
may humanity after victory be the predominant feature of the British fleet.
But not everyone can swiftly discard the ruthless determination to kill,
which is essential to the winning of battles.
Two days later,
the dead were buried in a hillside cemetery above Dover.
Evans then reflected,
'How hateful war is!
We who had come out unscathed
were not unmindful of the poor relatives,
their drawn cheeks, dimmed eyes and pale faces,
one cannot forget.'
A local court of inquiry arrived at the view that
the total number of enemy vessels engaged was five.
We consider that three were sunk.
The admiralty commanding at Dover disagreed.
Six enemy engaged, but only two enemy sunk.
Notoriously, high-speed actions at night are difficult to dissect.
It's hard even for witnesses who remember everything that happened,
let alone the order in which they occurred,
or to be absolutely sure of all that they observed.
Commander Peck, who was the senior officer,
and according to Evans,
the most modest man in the Royal Navy,
gave Evans a glowing report.
However, a naval member of the London Press Bureau
came up with the title Evans of the Broke,
which had a bold, dramatic ring to it,
whereas Peck of the Swift would have sounded somewhat silly.
A fellow destroyer captain recalled that this publicity
made Evans unpopular with a certain group of officers
who considered him a self-advertiser.
What they did not realise was that to the newspapers he was news,
and so Evans of the Broke it was.
Evans of the Broke sounded the very man
to choose as a liaison officer
to go over to Queenstown in Southern Ireland
to welcome the 1st Division of United States destroyers
under Rear Admiral Simms to arrive in Europe.
His style went down well with the Americans
and also with the merchant seamen
serving at Queenstown with Q, or mystery ships.
By September 1917,
he was the senior destroyer officer at Dover,
Captain Peck having been given the command of a cruiser,
an early assignment being to proceed to Calais,
which in this war was still French and not German,
to pick up a load of gold amounting to 5 million pounds,
consigned anonymously to the Bank of England.
He was to load the gold on board the Broke
and then wait for an escort.
While at lunch, the quartermaster,
in dripping wet oil skins,
entered to say that there was
somebody out there on the wharf asking for you, sir.
There were indeed no less than three drenched figures
trying to shelter simultaneously in a sentry box.
In order of seniority,
they were the Prime Minister, David Lloyd George,
the Chief of the Imperial General Staff,
Sir William Robertson,
and the Secretary of the Cabinet, Sir Maurice Hankey.
It appeared that they were queuing
for the cross-channel steamer,
so Evans offered them a lift
on his own cross-channel steamer
of the Grey Funnel Line.
On being taken down to Evans' cabin,
Lloyd George was startled
to find the floor covered
with little green bags containing gold.
'Do you trust me with all this wealth?' he asked.
'I suppose I shall have to say that I do, sir,'
replied Evans.
The Broke made the crossing in rough seas,
which made her appear more of a submarine
than an outsized destroyer,
but when Evans had seen his passengers
safely packed away in a set special train,
as there was of course no queuing at Dover for them,
he returned to his gold-laden cabin
to find an agitated official
of the Bank of England exclaiming,
'We're one bag short!'
Evans laughed loudly.
The bank official snapped
that he was being too casual.
Evans shrugged off responsibility
on the grounds that it was many years
since the Admiralty had abolished
its kindly custom of paying a percentage
to the captain of any bullion that he carried.
Then, perhaps to plant a seed in fertile ground,
he admitted that a man named George
with a small attaché case
had been in his cabin during the crossing.
Before the Bank of England
could try to arrest the prime minister,
the bags were recounted
and found to be correct.
In October 1917,
Evans was appointed flag captain
to Admiral Bacon,
who ran the Dover Patrol.
Bacon was soon replaced
by a more energetic figure,
Roger Keyes,
who had started the war
as a commodore of submarines,
had played an enthusiastic part
in urging decisive action
at the Dardanelles,
and was soon to plan
what might be a decisive action
against the U-boats
now that the command was in his hands.
But Keyes brought in his own staff
and was thought to be a bit of a snob,
and so Evans,
who had joined via the Merchant Navy,
had to go.
He later became Lord Mount Evans,
but Evans of the Broke
was what he remained at heart.
So there we have it,
a short history
of some of the more notable encounters
of Evans of the Broke,
with of course some insight
into just what the mentality
of various sailors was
in this latter part of World War I,
when it came to conflict
between the two navies.
It is interesting to note
how some of the British sailors,
including Evans,
appeared to be incredibly ruthless
to their German counterparts
in the heat of action,
but simultaneously,
as we saw from the account,
they seemed to have been able
to put that aside
in the immediate aftermath
in order to rescue the German sailors
who were in the water
as a result of their actions.
So with that,
I will wrap up this emergency episode
of the channel,
and hope you're all having a great day,
and hope to see you again
in another video.
Fingers crossed
for the release of U-571.
That's it for this video.
Thanks for watching.
If you have a comment or suggestion
for a ship to review,
let us know in the comments below.
Don't forget to comment
on the pinned post
for dry dock questions.
