德拉克講海軍歷史 美國陸軍人物誌 - “比利”米歇爾:美國航空先驅?還是虛假預言者?
王者风范
22粉絲
311 次觀看·2025年11月21日
在1921年以空襲攻擊作為目標航母的測試中 許多人都承認他曾經是一名教會徒 被傳統教徒批評 但最後卻是正確的
而在另一個極端的測試中 許多人都批評他違背了規則 誤以為是事實 並且誤以為是謊言來呈現一宗根本不存在的案例
我們來看看他實際上做了些什麼
首先 我們來看看他真正的背後人物是誰
比利·密西爾加入了美國軍隊 面對著西班牙-美國戰爭
雖然他在美國迫使西班牙對他們採取控制 但他卻被移送到菲律賓
這就導致了菲律賓-美國戰爭
後來 密西爾被安排到美國的各種通訊公司 並成為了當時的新型飛行機的早期粉絲
他成為了美國通訊組織的航空部隊 並且成為了美國軍隊的先驅
並且成為了美國軍隊的先驅 並且成為了美國軍隊的先驅
美國加入世界大戰後 使他在前線的航空部隊 並且在航空部隊的指揮
使他在前線的航空部隊 並且在航空部隊的指揮
使他得到了大量的公開聲援 但他已經開始建立了一些比較殘酷的關係
與他的高級官員
回到家中 密西爾受到國內軍政的影響
有一個行動 密西爾批准了 嘗試讓航空部隊變得獨立
而軍隊移交了其中一位較為地面的官員 作為航空部隊的首長
以試圖維持其控制
航空部隊 後來成為了軍隊航空部隊 並且是美國軍隊航空部隊
會逐漸得到越來越多的獨立
在1947年 美國軍隊纔出現
但這是給航空主義的歷史學家更多詳細的描述
密西爾當然不僅想要獨立的航空部隊
但就像國際航空部隊所做的 國際航空部隊-航空部隊
他希望這個組織擁有控制 幾乎所有的航空力量 土地和海域
而是在這個時候 他真的開始與美國軍隊鬥爭
在這個時候 美國的戰略計劃
並沒有對於美國防衛的航空部隊有太多的意見
這可能是可以理解的
最初的跨越南方航班 只是剛成立
而那是在最短的時間內 跨越南方航班的最短的一段時間
那是在一艘炸彈航空母艦上 載滿了燃料和沒有其他貨物
而最糟糕的是 那艘航空母艦 最後的航班 最後是在一艘不屬於俄羅斯的貨物航空艦上
那艘航空母艦 最後的航班 最後是在一艘不屬於俄羅斯的貨物航空艦上
因此 我們可以理解 除非美國和加拿大 發生戰爭
那艘航空母艦 絕對不會在那一年或未來 飛到美國
至少 以美國戰略計劃的生命循環來說
如果敵人無法到達美國 通過空中
那理論上 這就意味著 美國不需要大規模的航空母艦 或大規模的海岸防衛航空母艦
有機會有少量航空母艦 通過海岸防衛航空母艦 到達美國
但這就意味著 這是一艘航空母艦的問題
因為這艘航空母艦 無疑會在一艘戰鬥艇旁邊運作
這就是美國航空母艦 擁有的戰鬥艇
因此 任何美國使用的航空力量
必須屬於航空航空母艦
Mitchell, however, declared in public that
should the air force be destroyed
the enemy has practically unhindered access to the country
quite how they were going to do this remained unstated
a theme that you'll come to recognize in a lot of Mitchell statements
by the end of 1919
he had moved on from this to asserting that an air force on its own
would be capable of defeating an entire enemy invasion fleet
no navy battle fleet or army coastal defense artillery required
he also insisted in response to the objection that
even if all of his promises about the effectiveness of dropping tons of TNT
on ships from biplanes were true
a simple fog might then just hide the fleet from sight
until it was too late to do anything about it
or you know the sun might set
with the following statement
in the unlikely event that
the fog and vapor surround the enemy fleet
making accuracy of aim from above impossible
the genius of the Native American
has been able to devise a means of clearing the very heavens of such matter
this is an absolutely new sphere of control over nature's domains
and sounds like the dream of some opium addict
rather than the cold clear achievement of science
yeah, about the only part of that statement that makes any sense at all
is that last bit about the person saying it
having perhaps consumed a little bit too much opium
he would then go on to claim
that he could have a thousand bombers
for the price of a single battleship
although given his own later statements
on the price tag of losing a single bomber
that was a figure that was inflated by around a factor of five
if we're being generous
but his pitch was to try and establish the purchase
of even a mere 500 bombers
as a bargain price
compared to what he styled as
an expensive and obsolete platform
in the form of a battleship
and so in early 1920
he set out his plans to defend the US coast with aircraft
firstly, using zeppelin-like large rigid airships
an incoming enemy fleet would be located
and its position radioed back to shore
second, these airships and enemy airships
which presumably had come with the fleet
would fight it out over said fleet
for control of the skies
although he was a little less clear on
how these zeppelins were supposed to fight each other
thirdly, this airship battle
would inevitably lead to a further battle
between fighters
as the enemy fleet launched what aircraft they had
and fighter, or in US terminology of the time
pursuit aircraft, arrived from land bases
to contest the skies further
fourthly, due to the greater capacity of land bases
in theory the US forces would win
even if it was only by force of numbers
and thus they would establish control of the air
fifthly, the pursuit aircraft
were then to repeatedly strafe the enemy fleet
to prevent them using anti-aircraft guns
sixthly, waves of bombers
each formation 100 strong
would saturate the enemy fleet
with 1,000 and 2,200 pound bombs
dropped in formation from altitude
seventhly, if the attack waves of level bombers
had left anything still afloat
there could be torpedo bomber attacks
to finish off the survivors
and eighthly, if there were any survivors after that
US submarines could be called in
and directed from the air to finish them off
if the enemy happened to attack at night
or in a time of fog or cloud
then presumably after the magical cloud clearing device
had also allowed the airships to spot the fleet
the aircraft would drop flares
to illuminate the targets for attack
he also insisted that the US Navy
should be made to scrap their program
of flying boat bases
which it was in the process of establishing
for the purposes of aerial recon
all along the US coastline
not because they wouldn't be effective
but simply because they wouldn't be under his control
this was then followed up by a declaration
that the air service would soon have
an aircraft capable of carrying
six 1,000 pound bombs
which would then give each aircraft
half a dozen chances to hit a ship
in fact, at the time
the MB-1 bomber
which had recently been introduced
into US service
could barely get off the ground
with a single 1,000 pound bomb aboard
and the NBS-1 or MB-2
which was just about to enter service
could manage short distances
carrying two such bombs
in fact, the air service had no such plans
at the time that Mitchell had made his statement
and it would only actually be two months afterwards
that the air service would put out a contract
for the design of a heavy bomber
that could carry five, not six, 1,000 pound bombs
this would result in the XNBL-1
a six-engine triplane
which, if actually purchased
would have cost as much as a battleship
if you only bought two dozen of them
and in the end, the sole prototype
proved a massive disappointment
only capable of reaching out
about 170 miles from its home base
and taking about two hours to get there
it was also completely incapable
of climbing to an altitude
that would allow it to clear the Appalachian Mountains
and unsurprisingly
it was never put into production
Mitchell at this point was already getting pushback
for these and other misleading statements
that he'd made
as well as his attempts to use these statements
to influence government policy
At the same time though
the US Navy had independently decided
to conduct some bombing trials
since a growing school of thought in naval circles
was that their own aircraft
especially those deployed off of
future aircraft carriers
might be useful in crippling
or otherwise impeding enemy ships
which would make them an easier target
for the battle fleet
For this purpose, the old pre-dreadnought Indiana
was converted into a target ship
The tests had a two-fold purpose
Initially, there would be
a three-day exercise
with seaplanes dropping dummy bombs
at the anchored vessel
to test different bombing formations
and to a limited extent, bombing techniques
This would allow the Navy
to optimize the attack profiles
and let them calculate, roughly speaking
how many hits you could expect
to achieve for every 100 bombs dropped
For this purpose,
the outline of a much larger
and more modern ship
was also sketched out
around the anchored pre-dreadnought
so that near misses on the real ship
that would have hit a more modern
and larger vessel could be noted
In clear skies from 4,000 feet
unopposed against an anchored target
the final total of hits
wasn't that bad
Around 10% of dummy bombs
physically hit the old pre-dreadnought
and another 30%
had landed nearby
within the area
that would have been occupied
by a much more recent and larger vessel
like an Omaha-class cruiser
or a Tennessee-class battleship
Next, a series of live bombs
of varying sizes
were physically placed in the sea
at ranges between 75 and 25 feet
from the hull
to determine the effects
of near misses
The sum total effect
of these explosions
was one of the hull plates
sprang a leak
when one of the largest bombs
was detonated about 30 feet away
Typically, that wouldn't have actually
been any danger to the ship
but she'd been so thoroughly stripped
before being handed over as a target
that Indiana lacked
any real watertight integrity
and so she began to slowly settle
albeit at the rate of about
6 inches every hour
Mitchell, of course, would later on
claim that these tests had disabled
the ship's rudder and propellers
which was completely untrue
The Navy, however, decided to tow
the gradually settling ship
to a nearby beach
and proceed with the next stage
of testing, which involved
placing bombs that ranged in weight
from around 200 pounds
up to 1,800 pounds
the latter of which could only
be carried by the NBS-1 bomber
and even then only one at a time
onto the deck of the ship
and then the bombs would be detonated
to simulate what would happen
if the bomb had hit the ship directly
After each explosion
a Navy assessment team
would go aboard to check out the damage
and make notes on what might be done
to improve a ship's survivability
in the face of such aerial attack
The smaller bombs did
essentially nothing
and the big 1,800-pounder
was placed next to one of the
wing-mounted 8-inch turrets
This rather spectacular
high-explosive bomb
which was about half-explosive by volume
did some quite
visually impressive destruction
to the superstructure and the funnels
But when the investigators
clambered over the wreckage
they found that the 8-inch turret itself
which it should be borne out
the bomb had landed
simulated, of course, right next to
was absolutely fine
bar a few electrical cables
that had been knocked loose
and would take a few minutes
to put back in
Although the ship would, of course,
have lost speed
due to the damage from the funnels
its actual fighting capability
wouldn't have been that adversely affected
The Navy concluded, to quote
The damage to material
from aerial bombs was local
Personnel in unprotected positions
within the blast area
would be destroyed
But personnel enclosed
in armoured turrets
would probably not be incapacitated
And considering the probable effect
of defensive gunfire against aircraft
at the low altitude necessary to be accurate
with heavy aerial bombs
against a rapidly moving target at sea
the entire experiment pointed to
the improbability of a modern battleship
being either destroyed
or completely put out of action
by aerial bombs
Mitchell, of course, declared
that the tests, somehow, proved
that even with a near miss
he could blow a battleship to pieces
The Navy countered this
by pointing out that the Air Service
had yet to actually hit a single ship
with a bomb of any size
as the tests against Indiana
had been conducted by Navy aircraft
and they no more proved
the supremacy of the bomb
any more than firing a torpedo
or a salvo of shells
against the obsolete stationary
and undefended target
would have proved those weapons' superiority
Indeed, the old USS Massachusetts
had recently been actually sunk
by coastal artillery fire
in a test nearby
and no one was claiming that coastal guns
were therefore the arbiters of all sea power
in the future
Of course, shortly thereafter
the admittedly visually spectacular
pictures of the damage to the Indiana
were leaked to the press
and although no one could prove it
most people were pretty sure
who was responsible
Mitchell was off promoting
his latest scare story to Congress
This time he was telling everyone
how an enemy aircraft carrier attack
could wipe out the population
of New York using poison gas
Although
where exactly
an enemy aircraft carrier
or even a fleet of them
was supposed to fit the several thousand tons
of phosgene gas bombs
that were necessary for such a task
according to his estimations
was again not mentioned
He did however also advocate
for turning three old German liners
into aircraft carriers
which I suppose was a good thing
The embarrassingly short range of contemporary bombers
had become more and more apparent
which meant the idea of being able to move the air base
and therefore the aircraft
closer to the target
was becoming something of an obvious benefit
As arguments in front of
various congressional committees
raged back and forth
the Navy pointed out that
tests against an obsolete stationary target
were very different to a moving vessel
aiming to defend itself in the open sea
Mitchell however replied that
it would in fact be easier
to hit a moving target in the open sea
When challenged to
explain that one
he stated the following
suggesting that perhaps the science
of objects in motion
or ships in general
was not exactly his strong suit
To quote
It does not make very much difference
because we employ a mast attack
A ship on the surface of the water in motion
is much easier to hit than an object at rest
because the relative speed between the airplane
and the object being fired at
is the thing that makes it difficult to secure hits
If a water vessel could be moving
at the same rate as an airplane
there would be absolutely no trouble
whatever about hitting it
because all you would have to do
would be to get over the object
and drop the bomb
and as both the airplane and its target
would be going at the same speed
you would be certain to get a hit
Therefore the faster that a water vessel goes
the easier it is to hit from the air
This is not understood at all
by people unfamiliar with bombing
As to turning to the zigzagging
the turns of surface vessels of any kind
are so slow as to be almost negligible
from the air
Yep, ladies and gentlemen
Apparently hitting a vessel
moving at 100 miles an hour
would be dead easy
because the aircraft
also moving at 100 miles an hour
and having presumably teleported
into position above the ship
since of course if they're both
moving at 100 miles an hour
there's no way the bomber
can actually catch up to the ship
would then simply drop its bomb
directly overhead
and since as we all know
all bombs are clearly made of spherical cows
and dropped into a vacuum
they would either
by their own means of inertia
or presumably with some form of propulsion
and an immunity to air resistance
fall relatively speaking
straight down
which would in fact be forward
because of course both target and bomber
are moving
maintaining a uniform forward speed
and thus strike their target perfectly
about the only correct
part of his entire statement
is the inference that a ship
moving at 100 miles an hour
would find it somewhat difficult to turn
although of course that wouldn't be true
with actual sane speeds
he then went on to state
that the high explosive bomb
was the best weapon possible for destroying ships
the armor piercing bomb
and the torpedo were less effective
he argued
on the basis of having less explosive
per unit weight
compared to the high explosive bomb
yeah
he then further announced that he had the men
the aircraft and the bombs
ready to sink a ship
if the navy would just hand over some targets
this came as quite the surprise
to the air service who at this point
in early February 1921
were only just about getting the first few
NBS-1 bombers operational
and were in no way ready or trained
for a mass strike against shipping
but these grandiose statements
had been made in public
and so Mitchell would get his tests
albeit not entirely
to his specification
the navy had already planned
to follow up the tests on the Indiana
with tests on a variety of German ships
that had been handed over at the end of World War I
plus potentially
using the old pre-dreadnought USS Iowa
which had been rigged as a radio-controlled
target ship
and thus might be able to answer
the question about hitting a ship underway
in the face of public
and congressional pressure
the navy formally invited the army air service
to either observe
or take part in the tests
for those tests
the submarine U-117
was allocated to be sunk by air attack
which would take place on the 21st of June 1921
the next day
several other U-boats would be attacked
by destroyers
then on the 26th
there would be the search and attack exercise
on the radio-controlled target ship Iowa
on the 13th of July
the ex-German destroyer G-102
would be bombed
then on the 18th the cruiser Frankfurt
and finally on the 20th
and 21st of July
it was planned to attack the SMS Ostfriesland
she was at least a dreadnought-type
battleship
but she was also a Helgeland-class vessel
whose contemporaries were already considered
obsolete in naval service
rather embarrassingly
for Mitchell
the first thing the air service then had to do
was ask the navy to loan them
its bomb sites and bombardiers
since the army lacked both the bomb sites
and the officers trained to use them
for bombing over water
it also turned out that the navy's bomb sites
were generally actually just better
than the handful of bomb sites that the army had
for their own purposes anyway
Mitchell then commenced
practicing against the stranded
Hulk of the Indiana
although initially without actually telling the navy
he was doing so
and this was done in order to get
his air crew's eye in
he then decided to try and move on
to target the obsolete pre-dreadnought
USS Kentucky
which the navy had agreed in principle
to hand over as a guinea pig
since a 2,000 pound bomb
that Mitchell had recently been championing
was in fact still experimental
and needed testing before anyone
went to the trouble of mass producing them
let alone hauling them out to sea to drop on things
however
the Kentucky was found to be in such poor shape
that the navy refused to hand it over
at the last minute
apart from being a somewhat unrealistic target
being a pre-dreadnought
there was some question as to whether it would even survive
being towed out to sea
such was its condition
another pre-dreadnought, the Alabama
was technically also available
and in somewhat better shape
but she'd need stripping out of valuable
recyclable components first
and that would take some time
discussions now began regarding the details
of the tests
no one expected the U-boat
or the destroyer to survive for very long
if they were hit
but the navy made it clear that they did want to examine
the Frankfurt and the Ospreys land
after each attack wave to take detailed notes
on the effects of any hits scored
they stated that Mitchell
was of course free to destroy
the old German battleship
just as long as the navy got to document the process
at each step of the way
otherwise little new would be learned from the tests
other than if you put enough explosive
into a ship, it would potentially sink
Mitchell then tried
to take control of the tests entirely
only to be told in no uncertain terms
that since this was a navy exercise
the army had been invited to
he could either submit to the navy's terms
or he could get lost
in light of the leaks
of information that had occurred
following the Indiana tests
everyone involved was ordered
that no information was to be released
without prior authorization
from senior officers
to clear up any confusion
as to who exactly this might be directed to
Mitchell was personally
instructed to comply
and also instructed to personally
acknowledge receipt of these particular orders
in writing
Mitchell then nearly got himself fired anyway
for trying to politicize
the tragic crash of an aircraft
which had been brought down by a thunderstorm
killing all those aboard
he barely scraped through that incident
but he did manage to pull together enough aircraft
from across the United States
to form his first provisional air brigade
in time for the tests to begin
the tests started off
with a fairly strong showing for air attack
the U-117 was attacked
by three navy F-5L flying boats
on their second pass
coming in at 1200 feet
they scored two hits
for the total expenditure of a dozen bombs
the submarine sank so quickly
taking less than 10 minutes to slip under the waves
that the next wave of aircraft
from the Army Air Service
turned up to find only an expanding ring
of air bubbles and debris
the next test for which aircraft
were to be involved
was of course the hunt for the USS Iowa
the purpose of the exercise
being to determine if aircraft
loaded up under wartime conditions
which obviously included the carriage of bombs
could actually find and attack a ship
before said ship reached its target
the exercise was made
slightly easier by
instead of just leaving aircraft patrolled
the entire U.S. East Coast
they were told that the Iowa was somewhere
in a box 200 miles long
and 50 miles wide
with the box starting
50 miles offshore and ending
100 miles offshore
which meant that the ship
was about 2 to 4 hours
steaming if it was a modern battleship
from wherever it was
to pretty much kissing the shoreline
the 200 mile dimension
was of course north to south
and started in the north
at Cape Henlopen and
ended in the south at Cape Hatteras
this meant that in theory
a bomber would have
about 3 to 4 hours to locate
the target before
it could completely attack
its objective and begin withdrawal
which of course would represent a failure
to defend the coast
this was the perfect chance for
Mitchell to demonstrate all aspects
of his claims
and so of course he backed out
forbidding his aircraft from taking part
on the grounds that the fuel pumps of the new
NBS-1 bombers would give out
after a mere 2 hours in the air
instead he asked if the ship
could be moved closer to the shore
to start with
which was refused on the grounds
that a ship that was that close
would already be in bombardment range
before the bombers alerted to its presence
had even cleared their own coastline
instead the search was undertaken
by a mix of US Navy flying boats
and a trio of army non-rigid airships
which would at least simply just
float there waiting for rescue
if they happened to have an engine failure
it took these aircraft
about 2 hours to find the Iowa
in which time
one of the world's faster capital ships
Nagato, Queen Elizabeth
or pretty much any battle cruiser
would have already long
gotten into bombardment position
and then it turned out that the two airships
which had found her
didn't actually have powerful enough radios
to tell anyone about it
except for each other
which meant it would be almost another hour
before one of the flying boats
managed to stumble across them
find the Iowa and call its friends in
to attack
this resulted in a total of 85 practice bombs
being dropped
but even with the Iowa gently rolling along
at a mere 6 knots
without trying to evade or fight back
the number of hits scored was
vanishingly small
a couple of weeks later
it was time for the ex-SMSG-102
to be a victim
this time the Army Air Service
would be the only ones who attacked
with Mitchell showing
his great faith in the brand new
American NBS-1 bomber
by leading the attack in a British De Havilland
DH-4
the attack was carried out in great style
with the Atlantic fleet circling around
as spectators
first came 11 British built
SE-5 fighters
each of which was armed with machine guns
and a series of small fragmentation bombs
these made a number of shallow
dives down to about 200 feet
where they each released a bomb
and a spray of gunfire
which simulated suppressing any
theoretical anti-aircraft defenses
and although the ship was completely stationary
and the release altitude was so low that hitting
the ship's mast was actually a real danger
half the bombs still missed
then came a flight
of 16 other DH-4s
at 1500 feet dropping a series of
100 pound live bombs
and after much churning
of water it was revealed
that every single bomb had missed
then came 15 NBS-1s
each carrying half a dozen
300 pound high explosive bombs
which were to be dropped
in three passes, two at a time
also at 1500 feet
two bombs which landed
right next to the ship
had little apparent effect
but as the attack progressed
another bomb landed just at the base of the
forward funnel and behind the bridge
this clearly did something
as a huge plume of smoke
shot out from the funnel
or possibly displaced soot
most likely the result of a shockwave
and fragments driving down the funnel
and into the engine room
and as the ship began to sink rather rapidly
another hit to the second funnel
sent the ship under 20 minutes
after the first bomb had been dropped
on the one hand a warship had been sunk
on the other hand
it was an 1100 ton destroyer
which had absorbed the attention
of an entire squadron of fighters
and almost three full bomber squadrons
for most of the morning
on July the 18th
it was the turn of the cruiser Frankfurt
to be on the target list
a mixture of army and navy aircraft
lobbed 300 and 250 pound bombs
respectively at the ship
starting at 9.30
by lunchtime, 38 bombs later
the attackers were ordered away
so that the still floating cruiser
could be examined
this done, the attacks resumed
17 more bombs were dropped
before a trio of NBS-1 showed up
and sent 7 larger 520 pound bombs
downrange
the ship was still afloat
and was boarded once more
so that the damage could be recorded
while the party was aboard
another half dozen army aircraft appeared
they'd taken off without permission
and were now running out of fuel
in the interests of watching
more explosions, the inspection party
made haste to leave
and these aircraft then started in
with 600 pound bombs
just after 4 in the afternoon
10 bombs were dropped
resulting in a pair of hits
that didn't seem to do all that much
but the 11th bomb
landed in the water adjacent
to the starboard bridge wing
and as the plume of water subsided
the cruiser could be seen
to be down by the bow
and sinking slowly
the navy evaluation
was that the blast effects
of even the 600 pound bombs
were quite limited
a single decent armour deck
would protect ships from adverse effects
to their primary fighting capabilities
but the one that had dropped nearby
had acted a bit more like a mine
perhaps unsurprising
given that the 600 pound demolition bomb
carried a similar charge
to the common Mark VI naval mine
and thus anti-aircraft armament
would be needed aboard cruisers
to keep such bombs away
from ships in the future
then of course was the main event
the plan was to start bombing
Ostfriesland at 0900 on the 20th of July
and much like with Frankfurt
after a given number
or type of bombs had been dropped
parties would go aboard to assess the damage
an all-clear signal
was devised which would be displayed
on the focus of a nearby transport
with strict orders given
that no attacks should commence
until that signal was deployed
and if it was deployed mid-exercise
all attacks should be broken off
otherwise the damage assessment team
might be caught aboard the ship
by the next wave of aircraft
to make things ultra-safe for the bombers
the navy would daisy-chain destroyers
from shore to the ship
to act as a waypoint guide markers
and a pair of navy flying boats
would patrol the route
just in case any bomber went down
with mechanical issues
the schedule called first
for a number of 14-inch armor-piercing bombs
to be dropped
these of course went against
Mitchell's ideas of more explosives being better
but others had prevailed
to at least test the idea
as some of you might have guessed
these were essentially
US Navy 14-inch armor-piercing rounds
with tail fins strapped to them
then there would be a series of attacks
with 230-pound bombs
then another wave of 550-pound bombs
then 600-pounders
and then two waves of aircraft
each carrying 1,000-pound bombs
the next day
half a dozen bombers would attack in two waves
with each bomber armed with a single
2,000-pound bomb
this got off to a bad start
when poor weather meant a low cloud base
this was too low for the 14-inch AP bombs
to gain enough speed
to be truly effective
and with the seas too rough
to board the ship
everything was delayed until lunch time
when the seas had calmed down
but the cloud base refused to lift
and so the 14-inch AP bomb test was cancelled
and they decided to just proceed
with the rest of them
with the lightweight bombs dropped
the observation teams went aboard
and in view of the time
just after two in the afternoon
it was decided they were going to skip
the 550-pounders initially
and move straight to the 600-pounders
partly because the bombs
were of similar weight
and also because the 230-pound bomb attack
had been conducted by
navy and marine aircraft
the 550-pound bomb attack
was also scheduled to be done by
navy aircraft
whereas going straight to the 600-pounders
which were to be dropped by army aircraft
would allow the army to actually make
an attack that day
as it was likely the weather
would close in again at some point soon
however
it turned out that
someone had ordered
the NBS-1 bombers aloft
half an hour earlier
than when they were called
and so they showed up in attack formation
while the observation teams were still aboard
luckily the pilots
this time around had the good sense
to check for the all-clear signal
which wasn't in evidence
but even at this short distance
barely 50 miles offshore
the bombers were already
running low on fuel
and they advised they had at most
40 minutes before they would have to return to base
and the observation team
were thus forced to wrap up their assessments
rather rapidly and leave in haste
the navy aircraft
armed with 550-pound bombs
which had been rescheduled to go after the army aircraft
weather allowing
were also ordered into the attack
following up on the army aircraft directly
the navy aircraft
ended up doing somewhat better
their attack pattern
was for the lead aircraft
equipped with the most experienced bombardier
to make its drop
with all other aircraft flying in formation
releasing their bombs
when they saw the lead aircraft
drop its first bomb
this allowed them to score
four hits for eight bombs dropped
while the army aircraft
which came in singly
and dropped one bomb per attack run
managed to miss the
completely stationary battleship
with 10 out of their 11 bombs
most of the bombs that actually hit
simply smashed themselves into oblivion
on the ship's decks
but with the threat of being bombed
by their own side now passed
the damage assessment teams made their way on board
they now discovered that
looting by pierside crews
after the ship had been stripped down
meant that almost every
bulkhead hatch and door
was open and some of them
had even been removed entirely
which left the ship completely lacking
in all watertight subdivision
they closed what doors they could
but they were on something of a time limit
and their main job
was to assess damage
not play around with hatches and doorways
deep in the ship
of the damage there was actually fairly little to see
only a small amount of damage
had been done to the ship's upper works
the most notable thing being
a hole in the focsal which had been made
by the lone 600 pound bomb hit
which had managed to disable
a couple of secondary battery positions
but nothing
had even reached as far as the ship's
armour deck let alone
troubled it
however they did notice something else
potentially a near miss
from one of the bombs or possibly
part of a major flooding of the bunkers
caused by valve failure
while she was being moved
to the test zone
had opened a seam in the forward boiler room
and that
was making the ship list to port
which of course wasn't helped by the aforementioned
lack of any watertight boundaries to contain the flooding
but that was all they had time for
on the day
the next day
even without any damage control pumps
or most of its watertight doors sealed
the Ospreys land was still afloat
albeit it was down three foot
by the stern
and it seemed that the lack of sealed doors
had actually allowed the flooding to spread out
in such a way that the list had corrected itself
overnight and the ship was now on an even
keel at least from port to starboard
the bombers
armed with 1000 pound bombs
who'd been unable to attack the previous day
were then summoned
11 aircraft 6 from the army and 5 from the navy
showed up and the army planes
opened the action
although it took them just over half an hour
to score their first hit
at this point
the orders for the tests
said that the ship should be inspected
as these larger bombs were anticipated
to do a lot more damage
and the boarding party was thus dispatched
when the army bombers
in complete disregard of the revocation
of the all clear
swept around for another pass
frantically the lead bomber was radioed
and informed the observing party
was now heading in
and they should cease bombing
the bomber pilot staggeringly
simply answered that well they'd let the navy
know when it was safe to board
an act of such ridiculous disregard
for the chain of command as to be
pretty much an instant career ender
had the two parties
been in the same service
but of course the observers were navy
and the pilot was army
the inspection party therefore had to haul about
and head for safety as more 1000 pound high explosive
bombs rained down
20 minutes and two more hits later
the army aircraft
apparently had run out of bombs
and decided to head off
signaling that now it was safe to board
the navy bombers
were then ordered to head home
and rearm themselves with 2000 pounders
much as the army bombers would no doubt
be doing at this instant
with Mitchell's almost criminally reckless
airman guaranteed to now be
away for a few hours
the boarding party could examine
the damage they'd done
they found the three direct hits
had done essentially nothing
to affect the ship's ability to fight
the near misses though had aggravated
the existing flooding and without
most of the watertight doors closed
and no pumps or any other power
the ship had settled another two feet
by the stern
by the time this had all been determined
the bombers were on their way back
carrying experimental 2000 pounders
the orders for the test
stated that the navy's aircraft
were now due to attack first
with both navy and army formations
allowed to drop three bombs
and or score two hits
whichever came first
before observation parties would go
aboard again to assess the damage
however Mitchell
now decided to violate orders
completely
ordering the army aircraft to full throttle
thus meaning they arrived ahead of the navy aircraft
and then signalling to observing ships
below that his aircraft would not stop
attacking until they dropped at least
one bomb each
and if that failed to secure two hits
they were just going to keep going until two hits
had been made
this was of course as mentioned a direct
violation of the orders for the test
and this intention
was transmitted just
as the lead aircraft started in on
its attack run which of course
gave nobody a chance to say anything
including countermanding the attack
eleven bombers
eight NBS ones
and three Hanley page 0400s
each armed with a single bomb
began to attack one after the other
the first two bombs missed
the third hit the ship directly
the fourth
bounced off the ship's port side
and exploded alongside
even by Mitchell's suddenly imposed
changes of the rules
they'd scored two hits
and that should have caused a cessation of bombing
but the army aircraft just kept going
and soon a couple more bombs landed close to the ship
also on the port side
she now began to sink by the stern
then rolled over
and about ten minutes later
finally slipped beneath the waves
Mitchell had thus
disobeyed multiple direct orders
placed the lives of
US servicemen in extreme jeopardy
from live ammunition on at least two occasions
and all he'd achieved
was to prove that if an old
obsolete dreadnought with practically
zero watertight integrity
was allowed to halfway flood itself overnight
with no defensive armament
or working pumps
happened to be in good weather
didn't move to evade
or sail in any direction at all
and had its exact position
hand fed to the army air service
they could just about manage to put enough holes
in the ship to finish it off
even though it turned out they couldn't
hit the literal broad side of a barn
most of the time
and ended up having to rely on the lucky mining effect
of large capacity high explosive bombs
landing nearby
an effect which more modern capital ships
that actually had anti-torpedo defences
would almost certainly be largely immune to
the first part
disobeying orders and putting lives in danger
would have seen him fired
immediately once the chief naval officer
finished writing out a rather acerbic
letter of complaint
but Mitchell was saved, for now
by the press getting a hold of the story
and it was decided
in the middle of that particular firestorm
that in the interest of not looking like
they were getting rid of someone who seemed
at least to the uninformed
to have just proven his point
the matter was quietly dropped
at least for now
Mitchell had, however, made enemies
not just in the navy but also in the army
and his continued insubordination
would see him court-martialed
and forced into retirement a few years later
ultimately
the sinking of the Ostfriesland
actually proved nothing for Mitchell's arguments
the direct hits
had scarcely affected
any of the target ship's fighting power
at least any of the larger ships
and the near misses that had done damage
had acted as if they were mines
and the navy already knew
that an old ship without substantial
underwater defences would be in trouble
if it was hit by three or four mines
so that was nothing extraordinary
If the Ostfriesland
or the Iowa
had been operational
and moving at speed
the simple fact was that they
probably wouldn't have been found at all
they definitely would have completed
any bombardment mission they might have had
and they most likely
would have been back out beyond
the anemic range of the bombers
before anyone could do anything about it
and had they been found
more by luck than judgement
the odds of actually hitting them
would have been slim
so too would history
show Mitchell to be wrong
on almost every count of his assertions
save one, that being
the general one that aircraft would
eventually develop to a point where they could
threaten the existence of warships
even the mighty battleships
but not only was that point two decades
in the future, but even then
Mitchell's favoured tactic of level bombing
with large high explosive bombs
was shown in fact
to be utterly futile
not a single capital ship
was sunk in this manner in World War II
or even especially damaged
indeed, scarcely any ship of any scale
was sunk while underway
by level bombing of any kind
whether you were using high explosive
or armour-piercing bombs
the only ships which took any real damage
at all from level bombing
were, like Ostfriesland, stationary
usually in port
and often subject to either
mass saturation attacks
or involved the use of novel weapons
such as the giant tallboys
or in the case of the one capital ship
that was actually destroyed
while underway in what was technically speaking
a level bombing attack
it needed a remote guided weapon
specifically the Fritz X armour-piercing bombs
that sank the Italian battleship Roma
the aerial threat
against capital ships would instead
manifest itself primarily
from the two weapons
armour-piercing bombs and torpedoes
which Mitchell had dismissed as ineffective
and they were delivered
using the tactics which he either
likewise dismissed
or simply didn't conceive of
low-level torpedo bombing
and dive bombing, respectively
in fact, it could even be argued
that Mitchell's efforts were
doubly counterproductive
in the short term, this
and other stunts that he pulled off
such as the simulated bombing of New York
ended up driving Congress to mandate
and pay for the conversion of the
Lexington and Saratoga into aircraft carriers
strengthening the very navy
that Mitchell had sought to supplant
and in the longer term
the massive flaws in his experiments
ended up forming the opinions of
many naval officers against
the idea of air power being any real threat
which of course then had a
knock-on impact on the importance
placed on aircraft and anti-aircraft guns
in a number of fleets
primarily, of course, the United States Navy
which would in turn likely be
the root cause of the loss
of a number of ships in the early part of World War II
which might otherwise have found
themselves somewhat better defended
of course, there is a flip side
to that argument, which is that
as the result of the supposedly
decisive test against Austria's land
a good many air forces persisted
with the hilariously ineffective
tactic of level-bombing moving ships
far, far, far longer than
they realistically should have
which no doubt preserved a good number
of ships and their crews
where a considerably larger and earlier
investment in dive or torpedo bombers
may have seen those ships sent to the bottom
So, what do you think?
Was Mitchell an early
profit of aviation just
unappreciated in his time
or was he a false messiah
who just so happened to manage
to make one vaguely accurate prediction
amidst a sea of lies?
That's it for this video.
Thanks for watching.
If you have a comment or suggestion for a ship to review,
let us know in the comments below.
Don't forget to comment
on the pinned post for dry-doc questions.
