Ultimate 5mm Arrow Shootoff

LEARN ARCHERY
7 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 26, 2025
Comments are disabled for this video.
This is a Victory HLR 5mm hunting arrow. This is a very nice mustache.
And this is the Easton 5.0 5mm hunting arrow.
And today these arrows are going head to head.
Let's get right into it.
Most importantly, we got to see how these arrows shoot.
Here's my scoring system for today.
In the black, three points.
In the yellow, two points.
In the outside black, one point.
Three, six, five target.
You could set this up and do it at home if you want.
If you think for even one minute that we're not going to blow some arrows up today,
oh, you got another thing coming.
Because how are you going to know what the best of the best is without at least
trying to blow them up?
Now we got to shoot them.
That's not absolutely in the middle, is it?
To me, really the most important thing is how do the arrows shoot?
You know, for a regular ordinary fellow like myself.
And I worked up a little scoring system so I can take you guys through a scientific breakdown.
East end, right out of the gate, American made, plus one point.
Victory, cleaner package, plus one.
Overall, I like the ice coating on the Victory HLR.
It slides in and out of 3D targets quite nicely.
And the veins on the back end of the arrow are very cleanly glued on.
So Victory gets the point for aesthetic.
And for the nerds, these are pre-fletched arrows that I squared the front end
and built them to be as similar as possible.
Let's try to make some good shots.
I think that one's in there.
The hat gives me like an additional anchor point.
I kind of got to work around it to shoot.
Is that low or in there, you think?
It's in there.
I'm not going to put them all in there, am I?
This is probably accredited to the great and powerful Justin Grimes
who redid my center serving the other day.
So now my knock fit is quite crispy,
but my center serving was starting to separate a little bit.
That had to be in there, close.
And that felt good.
That wasn't right in there, was it?
We got a little bit of wind.
We got a farmer doing their job a couple hundred yards away.
So I would say today's a pretty average day.
I think it's almost unfair if you shoot with no wind.
You should have a little bit, don't you think?
A little bit, make it fair.
That was left, huh?
In past videos, I've done a similar thing where I've shot arrows,
like shoot one bunch and then shoot the next bunch.
But I think the fairest way if you can do it
and your point of impact is the same
is just to go arrow, arrow, switch, arrow, arrow.
Here we go.
This is the last 5-0.
Is that a little high?
Jeez Louise.
Final arrow, and then we'll go see,
well, you guys get to see the arrows, but we'll go score them up.
Editing Tim here.
If you're interested in any archery stuff in general
or stuff from today's video,
check out PodiumArcher.com.
Use discount code TIMC.
Help you save a few bucks and help support videos like this.
If you enjoy the video, subscribe to the channel.
That really does help.
Is that a little high?
I made a pretty good shot there,
but I think my peep to housing was out a little bit,
but we'll go score them up.
Looks like a couple of flyers,
but shot pretty good there.
Probably better than average.
See what we got for a score.
Okay, I have victory, 2, 2, 2, 3, 3.
And then I have Easton, 3, 3, 3, 3, 2.
That's 14.
So Easton coming out firing.
So did I do my math right there?
Easton, 2, 3, 3, 3, 3.
That makes 14.
And then I have victory, 2, 2, 3, 3.
That's 10, 12.
So right now I have victory, 12.
Easton, 14.
Easton in the lead.
Here we go.
Final round.
Final, final.
Man, that felt good.
Smidge high.
One thing that's kind of interesting is
it seems different bow setups
tend to like different arrow setups better.
So whatever I experienced today
might not be what you'd experience at home.
If you can, if you can,
it's kind of a cool thing to be able to test them side by side.
So before you buy two dozen arrows
and go all in on brand X,
you could buy six and six or three and three,
build them, shoot them,
and see if one's different than the other.
They might be the same, they might be different,
but you don't know until you,
don't knock it until you try it.
You know what I'm saying?
And then remember to knock it before you try it.
Oh, that shot was holding so steady
and then when it broke, it got a little,
a little wiggle.
Well, I didn't like that hole very much.
Oh, that was a little right, huh?
Man, that felt like a good shot too.
I got two Eastons and one victory left.
Is that in there?
That shot felt so good.
Oh, is that a little high?
Yeah, that one bobbed right when it went off.
Okay, here we go.
Final Easton 5-0.
This shot felt good.
I think I'll find out.
Let's go check them out.
We still got to do a proper destruction test
and I am,
I'm walking up on this target.
It looks pretty good.
I would say this is about middle of the road for me.
Had a couple of flyers, a couple of good shots.
So all in all, fair,
fair representation of a regular ordinary fella like myself.
Okay, so I have 2-2-3-2-2-2-6-3-3.
So that's 12-12.
Okay, 12-12 makes 24.
I got that right.
Double check my math.
That's a two.
That's a three.
That's 12-12 for 24.
And Easton, we got three times three is nine plus four is 13.
That's 27 Easton 24 HLRs,
which to be honest is a little surprising to me.
It's a little surprising to me.
It seems like my bow is spitting out the Easton a little cleaner,
but day's not over yet.
Easton 5.0 destruction test.
Here we go.
I think the real bet is whether or not Tim can hit that X at this distance.
Is he already sighted for it?
Nope.
Oh, same fletches on there too.
You're going to get the same result.
Yep.
Buried.
Let's go check them out.
Not all the way through, but right to the fletch.
So if a person wanted to shoot through stuff,
they'd probably use a fletch that wasn't wider than narrower, huh?
Uh, well, just maybe one that wasn't stiff.
You're kind of screwed no matter what you do,
unless you actually blow a hole through it,
which, you know, and what you see here,
they kind of got the same result, right?
Both of these pretty well made it through what we call this,
some kind of particle board.
That's like a shelf.
That's a particle board shelf with a melamine laminate over it.
A little bit of plastic, a little bit of wood.
Easton 5.0 actual destruction test version 2.0.
Get in here, Josh.
5.0 first up.
Can never be too careful.
There's a lot of bad drivers out there.
Doubly safe on our audio.
5.0
And HLR.
Did you wince when that went off?
Dude, I have a hand on my face.
I'm not losing an eye because of this.
I'd rather get shot in the hand.
Destruction.
Let's go check it out.
Shove the insert downside the arrow on both of them.
Okay, this is very interesting because Josh is the
manufacturer of the titanium.
You definitely went down farther in the Easton.
Looks like we flattened the tip.
Yeah.
You look at the depth of everything, though, they're really close.
It's just for one reason or another.
It's probably there's a, looks like there's a core
on the inside of this 5.0.
Yeah.
And that's pushing it even farther.
But in general, they broke about the same.
I think you got about the same result here, really.
Where this is woven on the outside, still cracked, but there's not like a core in it.
So that it's like the fiber itself is compressing and pushing back as you go in,
which is making it break worse or wider, but they still went in the same.
Both brokey.
So who wins?
I got a scientific method that I'm taking these guys through, but.
Interesting.
We're going to have to go back to the, to the drawing board.
Yeah, let's look at the knocks.
The knock flew out of this one.
No knock split.
But neither of them are cracked.
So really for what you just did to them at 10 yards, that's pretty impressive.
So you would say both of them are hunting arrow approved?
Oh, absolutely.
These should be the two hottest hunting arrows in the industry.
Oh, wait, they are.
All right.
If we look at the destruction side by side on the tip end,
the 5.0 actually frayed out a little more.
And this tip went in a little deeper into the 5.0.
Going off of that, I got to think that the 5.0 is just a little weaker
when it comes to like the sidewall.
So maybe straight carbon versus the wrap.
Maybe the wrap strengthens things up.
In fact, I would actually expect it to.
If we go to the fletching end, you could see the HLR actually went in a little further
and it got held up by the vane.
So that's telling you it got hit with quite a bit of energy.
Like maybe one and a half more inches on the vane side.
So this is very interesting.
Honestly, I'm going to have to take it to the scoreboard
to figure out who the final final is.
Easton wins on price plus one.
Victory wins on damage plus one.
Victory wins on penetration plus one.
Easton won the shoot off, which is huge.
Plus two.
So that puts Easton four points.
Victory three points.
Easton 5.0 is today's winner.
Bam.
Very interesting.
I thought it would be dang near impossible to dethrone the victory
because the victory has been all reliable in my quiver for the last couple of years.
But I think today the Easton 5.0 wins the battle.
I'm not sure who wins the war yet
because this thing is so clean and durable.
I want to spend a little more time figuring out what I'm going to shoot this fall.
I think these are both great arrows to consider.
And if you can, shoot a couple each for yourself
and figure out what your bow wants to spit out.
I get to document what happens for me.
You get to document what happens for you.
And you want to do that because you want to know
what's going to work the best when you're ready to knock an arrow on an animal this fall.
Anyway, I'm going to wrap the video here.
It's been fun.
Subscribe to the channel.
Leave a thumbs up.
That stuff really does help.
And I will catch you back for the next one.
