a NOOB tastes the Top 10 Whiskeys For Beginners

Brandy Channel
12 followers
Jul 25, 2025
Finding the best whisk(e)y for yourself is noble endeavor - but bringing some friends along for the ride? That's the kind of Magnificence that MB's are made of. In this episode, Rex and Daniel grab the Whiskey Tribe's list of the Top 10 Whiskeys for Beginner's, and introduce (most of) those whiskeys to - wait for it... a beginner. Will they find the best scotch for their nooby friend? Will a budget bourbon win the day? Could a smooth Irish whiskey slip in for a surprise victory?
Dude, you, you son of a b****.
That was...
Can't pose yourself, dude.
If you're experiencing, like, a really heavy burn, then we need to slow roll this and Rex
is investigating something.
Whiskey is one of these things that it's just more enjoyable with friends.
Whenever you can experience it with other people who are excited about it, they're interested
in it.
As often is the case, you don't necessarily have whiskey enthusiasts in your immediate
circle right out of the gate.
So you've got to rectify that.
And in this video, we're going to be using the list that the tribe created of whiskey
for beginners.
Yeah, the top 10 list, Van Gibson Bastards voted on a couple of years ago, the best whiskeys
for beginners.
We're going to go through those and present them to a real life whiskey beginner.
What kind of whiskey experiences, what kind of whiskey history, what have you tried to
date so far?
What have you had whiskey-wise?
I've had Jameson, I've had Bullet, I've had Jack Daniels.
The big giant classic brands.
What did you think?
Yeah.
I feel like they all kind of just taste the same to be honest with you.
I mean, they all taste the same with Coke, that's for sure.
I think we just uncovered the issue here.
Yeah, I think we did.
I'm going to teach you some basics of whiskey and then we're going to work our way through
some of these to figure out, one, can you tell the difference between these things?
And two, what direction do you prefer?
I suddenly got very concerned about how advanced the YouTube algorithm is because if it can
read facial features, then it's going to see a whiskey channel introducing a 17-year-old
lad to whiskey.
Supposedly he's 24 years old.
Supposedly.
Rex, would you please bring over the Jameson since Alex mentioned that was one of the things
he's had before.
What I want you to be doing with all of these whiskeys on smelling and tasting, right, so
this is a really quick primer.
When you take a whiskey, smell is the majority of taste, right?
So when you smell a whiskey, you're going to take your glass and you want to bring it
in until it feels sharp to the nose and then back it off just a little.
That's the right place for you to smell a whiskey.
If you open your mouth and breathe in through your mouth and nose at the same time, you'll
help the alcohol vapors bypass your science cavity.
All right, so while he's nosing that, so while he's, make sure you are answering.
Motherfucker.
Dude, you, you son of a bitch.
Next thing, when you take a sip of whiskey, don't just throw it down and so there's a
couple of ways to do this, but the first one I like to do is just take a sip and swallow
it and take about as much as you would drink if it was really hot coffee.
If you're experiencing like a really heavy burn, then we need to slow roll this and Rex
is investigating something.
Making sure he's doing it right.
Swallowing correctly?
Good.
Did you get high alcohol burn on that or was it easy?
No, no, no.
It was really easy.
Okay, good.
Good.
So that means that's going to make everything else much easier.
Now, when you're smelling these things and tasting them, what you want to ask yourself
is what does this remind me of?
I feel like it's a mix between like smoke and cinnamon is kind of what I'm, what I'm
interested in.
Okay.
I'm going to jump straight to another category and we're going to go straight into monkey
shoulder.
Should I do a palate cleanser?
Yeah, let me get you a water.
How about this?
Is this coffee?
Is that a palate cleanser?
It can be, but we're going to stick with water.
What the f*** is in here?
What did you do to this?
Reset palate in between meals.
So do the same process.
We're going to move a little more quickly, but each time I want you to smell it a little
bit.
Think about what you're getting, then take your first sip and then smell it again.
And what you're going to want to ask your brain is how is this different?
I guess I'm having, I feel like I don't know, I don't have the knowledge of like the exact
like flavors that go into whiskey.
No, you won't.
You won't.
That's important.
And here's the thing.
Whoever you're trying to get into whiskey, they very much need to understand that there's
not a wrong way to taste or experience this.
Absolutely.
It's a, it's basically the reference points that a person would draw from whenever they're
giving tasting notes.
If they haven't had those experiences, they don't have any reference.
Right.
So it's going to be very hard for them to verbalize things the way that you as a whiskey
enthusiast, um, would be able to do just the very first sip and even on the nose, leathery.
Oh, interesting.
So that's a little more of that malt musty note.
It could be right.
It's a little bit heavier.
Earthy.
Yeah.
So that's your, uh, space side.
Malt must.
Right.
And as you're doing this with your friend, they should feel like you're not the all knowing
whiskey guru.
No, no, no.
Right.
They should feel like that.
You are doing this with them and exploring.
I wonder what that could be.
It's important to know, Alex, you can't recall patterns you haven't established, right?
So you can't recall whiskey patterns from thin air.
What direction did you prefer?
I like Jamison more.
Okay, good.
So let's move straight into, uh, let's go a little bit classic bourbon.
So hand that Buffalo traces right there in front of you.
The differences with bourbon is immediately two big differences.
One is the grain involved, it's going to be corn, uh, and a lot more in corn dominant
with some rice spice and some malt barley.
And then the biggest difference is going to be, it's using a new charred oak barrel, unlike
Scotland and Ireland where the barrels are going to have already been used before.
So the barrel impact is a little bit lower.
Bourbon is going to have a heavy barrel, woody impact, which is going to result in some flavors
you might find presenting as dense vanillas, dense cherries, and it'll be much sweeter.
I was going to say it actually smells quite a bit sweeter than these last.
Yes, absolutely.
So I think an important point to make is we aren't drinking along with Alex because try
a week, but, uh, having that experience, the same experience with, with your buddy, your
family member.
One of the more interesting things that happens whenever you're tasting whiskey is you're
trying to figure it out, trying to figure it out, trying to put a pin in what a specific
note is.
Then somebody else will say something and immediately that's it.
It's like, how could I not have pinned down that I'm tasting cinnamon?
Of course it's cinnamon.
Uh, now first let me ask you, what did you get on that one?
I don't want to just say like flavor, but more robust, definitely darker than the last
two.
So that's your wooden, more like explosive.
Oh, it's like more dense, more saturation.
So notice that in the first two I didn't give him any tasting notes, but in the third one
I actually suggested some flavors.
Yeah.
What I was trying to do in that, and I do this regularly as I try to give someone the
reward feeling of recognizing something that's actually there.
So they're not going totally blind every single time.
Yeah.
It's, it's the difference, you know, between trying to, uh, create out of the vacuum, right?
Just pulling from the ether of your own experience, trying to recognize, yeah.
Or versus somebody saying, are you actually experiencing something that is akin to vanilla?
Holy crap.
I am.
Let's kick into the bullet rye you have on the far right.
This one, the dominant grain is going to be rye and think of it just like rye bread, right?
It's going to be more spicy, more herbal, kind of almost tea direction potentially.
Some people will use, when it comes to rye, it's not necessarily this one, it's kind of
a lighter rye, but they'll use words like, um, black licorice, and it is on this one
tends to be more like eucalyptus.
Yeah.
I was going to say mint.
Yeah.
Eucalyptus and mint was the second thing I was about to say.
That's a pretty standard MGP flavor profile.
Eucalyptus and mint.
This one burns the most for sure.
It's spicy.
It's burning.
Let's move quickly.
For the first time, we're going to introduce you to a little bit of smoke, but we're not
going to do it with an Isla.
We're going to do it with a mildly peated Highland malt.
I gotta fix this, you know.
So this is Glenfiddich 12.
This is a Highland malt, but it does have a little bit of peat smoke in it, which you
may interpret either as smoke or your brain may interpret it as black pepper.
I want to hear what Alex has to say in terms of how is this comparing to any of the other
whiskeys so far.
This reminds me a little bit more of this one.
Ah, good recognition.
That is the closest thing to it in this lineup.
Yeah, because it tastes more, it's that kind of same leather undertone.
And then the sweeter element, would you say that would be like a fruity sweetness or more
of a floral sweetness?
Definitely floral for sure.
Oh, cool.
Wow, you're picking up floral on a lightly peated malt.
Well done you.
Subtlety and nuance.
That's your two bywords.
Also a minor.
Also a minor, yeah.
You look like a child as far as I'm concerned.
Also a minor, yeah.
Scum!
Destroy the child.
You're 12 years old is what I'm saying, you're 12.
Some of these are probably older than I am.
Yeah, that's possible.
That one's about as old as me.
Oh.
The 12, yeah.
Distilled on your birthday.
This is going to be one of your smokier malts.
It's in the same category as the two you just compared, however, it's a lot more briny,
salty.
All right, I'm going to notice how this is compared.
You don't have to like these, by the way.
I'm not a huge fan of the malts, this, this, and the smell of this one, I'm not a huge
fan of either.
Okay, so.
Yeah, what are you smelling comparatively?
This reminds me of Johnny Walker.
Oh, no way!
Did you know that that whiskey is the dominant mix in Johnny Walker, adding the smoke?
The smoke in Johnny Walker is almost always coming from that whiskey.
Wow.
That's impressive.
And you're not a fan of malty scotches.
Good to know!
Now that we know, we've narrowed down a preference he doesn't like.
So this was the McAllen.
Are you getting that same leathery thing that you're describing as leather and earthy?
Not as bad.
That one wasn't as bad as these last two.
That means the sherry cask is muting some of those malty, musty notes that the bourbon
cask accents.
What most sherry casks are bringing to whiskeys are going to be kind of like your darker,
heavier fruits, and that could be covering up the maltiness that you seem to not like
in these other ones.
Yeah.
Let's try Elijah Craig next.
So this is, we're going back into bourbon, and this is going to be closer to, well, the
Buffalo Trace.
This one definitely smells sweeter than the last two, which I like.
Yeah.
Do you like sweets?
Not really.
Do you like salt?
Yes.
Interesting.
Yeah.
That one's probably the sweetest that I've had so far, actually.
Yes, absolutely.
Did you like it the best?
Yeah, yeah.
Okay, hold that one here.
This is important.
I like this and Trace.
Yeah, so you're a bourbon guy.
Yeah.
So here's what I want to do.
There's one remaining bourbon that I want you to try, and if you like it, then you've
just done the perfect bourbon to explore with because it's cheap.
And it's good.
It's considered quality.
This reminds me a lot of the Elijah Craig quite a bit.
What do you like better?
This is your Elijah Craig.
Go back to the Elijah Craig.
Tell me the difference between those two.
Kind of maybe intruding some of the, like it's a little harder to contrast just because
I feel like I'm getting mainly ethanol out of this one.
This is where people are getting into just neat pours of spirits.
It could be the most complex, nuanced thing in the world.
If they're not used to a higher proof, that's going to get overwhelmed by the alcohol note.
I always get slightly darker sweet notes in the Elijah Craig than I do in that Four Roses
yellow label.
I mean, I feel like they're so similar.
Like really, it's just the proof that's screwing with my pollen.
It's catching me off.
Yeah.
I feel like this one's more like citrus as well, maybe.
Ah, interesting.
And that would still be-
That's going to be, it's a higher rye mash?
That's Four Roses?
Yeah.
There's more rye in that.
Okay.
Yeah.
So it could absolutely have a slight more spicy, zesty kind of note to it.
I think I like this one.
The Four Roses.
Ah!
Yeah.
That's good for you because you're going to be able to explore that.
Now next steps, maybe not on this episode, for you, start trying it with ice, start trying
it adding water, and start trying it mixing it into things.
I do have a little sample of something, Rex, that I snuck in.
Oh, do you now?
It's not on the list.
However, it's to determine-
No, no.
It's to determine how redneck your roots are.
Okay.
Miss Ward.
So this is a moonshine that Deb made.
Okay.
Using a Saison beer.
Hold on.
There's that empty glass on the end.
Okay.
It smells like grapes.
That's what it smells like.
Interesting.
Now I kind of want to smell that thing.
I'm getting, I got like skunky herbs.
Wow, your hands were really close to my face just then.
That was-
Can't pose yourself, Daniel.
That was a slight caress.
Yeah.
Nice work.
Internal monologue for Daniel.
It's happening.
I feel like this burns less than-
Really?
Daniel Craig and the Four Roses.
All right, just a Daniel Craig.
He is delicious.
I mean, I actually like this-
That was your coffee.
I like this more than-
Wow, he likes Saison distilled more than scotch.
Okay.
We're going to go back the other direction and decide whether or not you can stay on with our company or not.
Skunky, dude.
Did you just call me a pussy?
Bringing in 117 proof.
I think, let's make it a full ounce and a half pour like you would get at a bar.
There you go.
Instead, pour me a whiskey neat.
Cast strength.
What do we got?
Woo!
That's pretty good.
Maybe I am a pussy.
Okay, go ahead and start editing.
Make it more-
I'll never be a millionaire.
