James Buchanan, the 15th president of the United States, was a lifelong bachelor, so he called on his beloved niece, Harriet Lane, to be his acting first lady. Buchanan had been the young lady’s legal guardian since she was eleven, so she was happy to act as his hostess when he held political positions abroad and eventually in the White House. Although Buchanan was an unpopular president, Harriet was a very successful first lady, influencing women’s fashion with her style, promoting worthwhile causes, and bolstering her uncle’s reputation through her popularity.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories, but here in America,
our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history pages.
Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
The role of the First Lady is closely aligned with that of the President,
since her only clearly defined role is to be his helper and his hostess.
Usually, the popularity or rating of a First Lady is somewhat closely aligned to the popularity
and rating of the President with whom she served. But one very notable exception to this rule
is Harriet Lane, the First Lady who accompanied her uncle James Buchanan on the eve of the Civil
War. Harriet Lane is often viewed as the first modern First Lady. Now, I've heard this term
applied to at least three different First Ladies, so it's a vague term, but she's compared to First
Ladies of the late 20th century in how involved she was in philanthropic issues, what a popular
hostess she was, and what a trendsetter she became. In stark contrast to the two First Ladies
who preceded her, Harriet Lane was a charming hostess and made the White House a very pleasant
and joyous atmosphere. However, that time in history was not a pleasant and joyous time,
nor was it a successful time for the President alongside whom she served. Harriet Lane isn't
always considered in the rankings of all the First Ladies because she's considered an acting First
Lady. She's one of 11 women who was not married to the President. She was the niece of 15th President
James Buchanan. James Buchanan is the only bachelor President of the United States. While
he wasn't the only President who was unmarried when he was elected, he's the only President who
never married, was not a widower, he just never got married. Thus, Harriet, his beloved niece and
so-called adopted daughter, was his closest political ally, and she was his political
partner, serving in the role that a young wife would. In one ranking which included Harriet Lane,
she was considered the second most popular First Lady, after Jackie Kennedy, which is
quite remarkable considering that James Buchanan is usually ranked as one of the worst Presidents.
That just goes to show that the political issues of a President aren't always that
closely aligned with how successful his First Lady may be. Harriet was born in 1830. She was
the daughter of James Buchanan's sister. Now, James Buchanan had 22 nieces and nephews with whom he was
quite close. Several of them end up being orphaned, and he would be a loving uncle to many. Harriet and
her sister lost their father when she was nine years old. Two years later, when her mother died,
the orphaned girl no longer wished to reside with the other uncle with whom she was staying since
she was going to the school run by some rather harsh spinsters, the Crawford sisters. She
specifically requested that her legal guardian be her beloved Uncle James. This was unusual,
not only for that time, but for any time that the child would get to have the choice, since she had
many relatives. But her wishes were granted, and James Buchanan happily took over the care for her,
seeing that she went to the best schools and lavishing attention on her. He was very close to
and very fond of her. He saw that she got a good education and that she would spend
many holidays with him, and as she began to mature, he transferred her to a school in Washington
so she could be near him. This school was actually a convent, and he asked her before going in if she
thought the influence of the nuns might affect her religion and make her want to change from a
I don't know enough about that faith to say. I'll have to see as I learn more about them.
He was very impressed by this and saw this as a great deal of maturity.
She did end up becoming an Episcopalian later in her life, not a Catholic, but the influence
of the nuns made her very tolerant of other religions throughout her life,
something which was unusual at the time when many people were very anti-Catholic.
This fond feeling she had for other faiths was part of what made her such a great philanthropist.
As a young woman, Harriet, nicknamed Hal, was noted for having a great deal of emotional maturity.
She bore up extremely well under the great tragedy of losing both her parents,
and it was this emotional maturity which made her James Buchanan's closest confidant.
He confided all his personal problems in her as well as his political dealings,
and as she was in Washington, he began to have her come and mingle with him and other Washington
society. She began to know a great deal about the man's world of politics and become friends
with the wives of cabinet members and other important politicians. When he was Secretary
of State under James Polk, she came and would visit the First Lady and make friends with all
these important people. The earliest photograph of her is alongside her uncle and the current
president, James Polk and his wife, as well as former First Lady Dolly Madison in a very old
picture of her. When Buchanan went to Great Britain to serve as the ambassador for the United States,
he took Harriet along with him, and she was very popular in British society. She became good
friends with Queen Victoria, who thought she was a charming young lady, and she won the favor of
all the other political allies, partly making her uncle very popular. In fact, Queen Victoria liked
her so much that she tried to arrange a marriage between her and an important young British
politician because she wanted Harriet to stay in England. Harriet ended up turning down this
proposal and many other proposals. She found all her suitors somewhat pleasant in their attention,
but troublesome and rather too much of a bother. When she was in school, she loved studying history,
literature, and mythology. Those were her favorite subjects, and she excelled at them.
She also studied, of course, French music. She loved the piano as well as playing the harp
and other important subjects such as art and mathematics, geography, etc.
She was noted for being too outgoing as a young woman, but that was one of the reasons why
Buchanan liked her, and he encouraged her intellectual curiosity. He was a good father
figure to her, disciplining her when he found that she had not been as good a girl as she should be,
so he didn't come and visit her on holiday. But he encouraged her in her learning and corrected
her spelling and their letters, making her grow into the kind of political ally he would need.
Buchanan cautioned her against rushing into any marriage arrangement, encouraging her to
make sure that it was the right person and to avoid anything that would be too frivolous or
too hasty a decision. This isn't surprising when you consider that he never married himself,
and I think his advice to her offers a bit of insight into why he himself never married.
Now, since she was his political ally, I think it's important to look a little into
why she ended up having this position instead of a wife. When he was a young man, he was engaged
to a young woman named Anna Cole. She was the daughter of a wealthy merchant in Pennsylvania.
Although they were engaged, they didn't spend much time together as he was busy in his budding
political career. It's known that they broke off their engagement. The details aren't terribly
clear in the year 1819. Some say she broke it off, others say that he broke it off, or it may have been
mutual. But shortly after that, she died of convulsive tremors from taking an overdose of
a type of opium. Whether this was an intentional suicide, some kind of an accidental overdose,
or perhaps a prescription for depression, we don't know. But we do know that her father held
Buchanan responsible for her death and that the young politician felt extremely bad about her
death. He wrote very emotional letters to her father begging for his forgiveness and begging
for the right to come to the funeral. He was not allowed to the funeral and the father returned
his letters unopened. This great personal tragedy was said to mar the rest of his life and he claimed
that it was because of this great grief he suffered as a young man that he never sought
female companionship again and he vowed not to ever marry. Now it is believed that when he was
going with Anna Cole, he may have been seeing some other women. So perhaps he was a bit of a
lady's man as a younger man, but this death of his sweetheart at a young age made him vow to not be
involved with women again. It also shaped his political career because he was establishing
a good law practice in Lancaster. But his fiancé's family was very wealthy and very powerful and they
were so against him that they began blackening his name in the area and he couldn't really
continue practicing law there. So he had to move to a different city and there he got involved more
in politics instead of practicing law. When looking at the relationship and the education
and even the political role of Harriet Lane in regards to James Buchanan, it reminds me a lot
of a later first lady, Frances Cleveland, who also would be first lady to the other bachelor
president, Grover Cleveland, yet she was merely the daughter of a friend rather than his actual
niece, although she did call him Uncle Cleve and he helped provide for her education as well.
Similarly, both young ladies were charming hostesses regarded as very pretty and provided
some saving grace and popularity for less popular presidents. It was a great political feat every
time Harriet had to arrange a dinner party at the White House, which she did weekly. She was
very famous for her formal dinners. She had to make sure that she honored all the important
politicians without seating people next to their mortal enemies. By the end of Buchanan's term in
this was basically impossible because everyone was enemies, but she at least remained popular.
In contrast to the gloomy, somber atmosphere of the grieving Pierce administration, Harriet made
the White House a joyous place full of dancing and music. She invited popular literary and musical
figures to the White House, would have salons, many dances were named after her, many songs
were dedicated to her. The popular song, Listen to the Mockingbird, was dedicated to her.
At the inaugural ball, she wore a dress with a neckline that was two inches lower than the
common fashion. It wasn't really low-cut, but before that necklines had been quite high.
This bold stance changed fashion significantly. Women copied her hairstyle, the gowns she wore,
she was used in advertisements, her likeness was often replicated, and her name became very popular
as a name for children. Her uncle had great confidence in her judgment as First Lady,
although she was quite young, 29 years younger than he was, only 26 when she became the First Lady.
She said, uncle places so much confidence in me that he gives himself no uneasiness,
and she was glad at least that she could relieve him of some stress, because from her earliest days
she would write in letters that she was concerned that matters were weighing heavily on him.
It was said, in her affection he found the only solace of his lonely life.
She was his confidant in all matter, political and personal. Perhaps it was because she was such
a devoted confidant to him that she didn't marry for many years, and she lived with him
at most of his houses, eventually moving to Wheatland with him, his estate, after he left
the White House. After the Civil War, she would end up getting married for the first time at the age
of 36, which was remarkably old for a woman to marry for the first time in those days.
She and her husband would have two sons. Sadly, by the year 1884, she had lost her uncle,
both her sons to rheumatic fever and her husband to pneumonia, but she was a woman who was acquainted
with grief, and she didn't let that cast her into an eternal depression or an extended period of
grieving. Instead, she threw her whole heart into philanthropy. She established a boys' school
and started a boys' choir at a cathedral. She had an extensive art collection which, at her death,
she donated to the Smithsonian Institute, giving it to the government. She put herself in charge
of guarding her uncle's legacy as best she could, donating his portrait to the White House later,
and she also established a children's hospital at Johns Hopkins because she left a huge endowment
upon her death. In her original will, she gave them a certain amount of money, yet she continued
to live long after that, and her wealth increased, so she would amend it several times, dictating
that this money should go to establishing a children's hospital in memory of her two beloved
sons who died young. And because of that money, a great deal of research and important advancements
have been made in children's medicine at Johns Hopkins because of Harriet Lane's contribution.
She advocated education and the right for worshiping as you please, and because she was so
popular and beloved, many ships have been named after her, including the presidential yacht
and a few ships which are still in existence today. Harriet Lane was an excellent first lady
in a very difficult time in history. She didn't make many public political statements. Whenever
she did, it was always to support and align with her uncle, because she was truly his helper,
serving as a devoted wife would have, but as a devoted daughter in spirit,
as his beloved niece. He was the most important person in her life for all of her early years,
and it's very clear that it was largely out of a devotion to him that she chose not to marry,
following his example of remaining unwed. Through her dedication to serving the country and
helping her uncle, she established a very great legacy and remains an example of a generous,
kind, loving first lady who was beloved by all, even as her uncle was extremely unpopular.
Although he had a life which was lonely in his early days and marred by extreme political
difficulties in his later days, one bright spot in James Buchanan's life could be
the companionship and love of his dear niece, Harriet Lane, who is a charming young lady and
a great example of what a first lady should be. Thank you for spending this time with me. Please
join me next time for more American Legends.