e 15th president of the United States, entered office hoping to preserve national unity—but left as the country fractured. A lifelong bachelor and seasoned diplomat from Pennsylvania, Buchanan believed strict adherence to the Constitution would hold the Union together. Instead, his inaction during the Dred Scott decision, Bleeding Kansas, and the secession crisis made him one of history’s most criticized presidents. Yet Buchanan maintained that he “meant well” for his country, serving in a time when compromise had become impossible.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories, but here in America,
our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history pages.
Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
It's impossible to please everyone. That's true in any walk of life,
no matter what your position in society might be. But it's especially true if you're in a
very important position, such as being President of the United States. The fact that there have
always been at least two very strong parties reflects the fact that American citizens have
very different opinions and views on important issues. It's never easy to please or even serve
all the citizens of such a large country, but some individuals had a harder time than others
when their time in the White House was during a particularly tense period of American history.
Today, we're going to talk about one of the unluckiest Presidents, the 15th President,
James Buchanan. After the Founding Fathers, the first name of a U.S. President which really
stands out is Abraham Lincoln. This beloved 16th President of the United States is fondly remembered
for the role he played in keeping the Union together and serving in the White House during
the Civil War. But who came before him? Who were the Presidents who led to this situation of
part of the country trying to break away and start a whole new nation?
It wasn't just one man and it wasn't just one term in office. This was a tense issue which
had really been building since the Declaration of Independence, that very beginning when the
Founding Fathers felt that they couldn't establish slavery as unconstitutional.
Thus, there was always a fight between the North and the South, abolitionists and
pro-slave owners, the people who believed that slavery was wrong and those who acknowledged
that it was an evil but thought that it would be even more dangerous, evil and deadly to outlaw it
because ultimately they knew that what ended up happening would happen. The South would not give
up slavery without a fight. All this could be blamed on many people, I suppose. Many different
Presidents deserve their own little share of blame in what happened because of certain decisions
they made in admitting some slave states or leaving the issues up to the states. But much of
the blame falls in the lap of the President who was technically in office when the South began to
secede and that is number 15, James Buchanan. Now Buchanan has a few points which make him
noteworthy besides the fact that he was the President in office when the Civil War began.
For instance, he's the only U.S. President from the state of Pennsylvania.
He also is the only U.S. President to never marry, being a lifelong bachelor.
The last President to be born in the 18th century, he was born in 1791 in the Log Cabin in Pennsylvania
to a father who was an Irish immigrant and owned a trading post. When John F. Kennedy
was elected President in 1960, he was regarded by many as the first Irish President but James
Buchanan had that distinction first. However, his father and the rest of his family who were of
Scottish-Irish heritage were not Catholic as Irish people often are. They were Presbyterians
and it was the persecution they had for their faith as well as poverty which drove the Buchanans
to leave the old world and come to America. Buchanan was one of 11 children and as a boy,
he credited his strong moral guidance from his father but his love for learning and his early
education from his mother. She taught him the poems of John Milton and William Shakespeare
and even conversed with him on matters such as politics.
As a boy, he went to the Old Stone College where he got his earlier education
and eventually went to Dickinson College which is still in existence today and is one of the
longest standing universities. It was there that he studied law and ended up beginning a legal
practice afterwards. Now, when he was in college in 1808, he was almost expelled for being involved
in some very rowdy behavior but he asked forgiveness for being involved in some of this
vandalism and the public drinking and he was given one more chance and the next year he graduated
with honors and it seems that at that point he was a pretty respectable citizen onward.
As a young man, he was establishing his law practice before being elected to the House
of Representatives in the 1820s at which point he was the youngest member of the body.
He was a Federalist when he first began his service in Congress which shows just how early
it was because not long after that the Federalist Party would cease to exist being replaced by
a few other parties such as the Whig Party and the Democratic-Republican Party. He next became
a Democratic-Republican aligning with Andrew Jackson's politics thus becoming a Jacksonian
Democrat. His first important position besides Congress was serving as the minister to Russia
under Andrew Jackson. He wasn't pleased when he got this appointment seeing it as a kind of
political exile since he would be way off in St. Petersburg far from the politics of America
and he wasn't wrong. Jackson did intend this as a kind of exile because he found him to be
a troublesome busybody. Apparently he didn't return the admiration which Buchanan had for him.
Buchanan was able to establish some successful trade arrangements between Russia and the United
States but he didn't do as well in establishing a good relationship and friendliness with the Tsar
because it was known that he had criticized the Tsar quite publicly in Congress a few years earlier.
After Buchanan's tenure in Russia he was able to return to the United States and eventually be in
the Senate at this point again as a Democrat representing Pennsylvania. He served in both
houses of Congress about 10 years each. During this time he was noted for publicly in his speeches
opposing certain issues but then voting for them. From the very beginning his political stand was
somewhat wishy-washy. He went back and forth on issues because he wanted to keep a degree of peace
and he believed in unity and keeping things together. He was the last president to serve
in the War of 1812 although he was opposed to it. As a young man he didn't think that it was really
something in which the United States should be involved but he ended up joining and fighting
when his neighboring state of Maryland was attacked. He and some other young men were part
of a group who stole horses for the U.S. Army. Buchanan had an interesting birth defect you could
almost say in the fact that his eyes were each week in a different way. One eye could only see
clearly close up and one eye could see well at a distance so he would be known to cock his head
from side to side depending on what he needed to view. He also had a predisposition that made it
hard for him to see unless he tilted his head forward and he also had to incline his head
forward a bit simply because of his nervous system but as a result he was noted to appear
to look like he was staring right at the person who was speaking to him and this made him a very
engaging conversationalist and actually worked in his favor. As early as the 1840s Buchanan had his
eye on the White House and he was a runner-up for the nomination many times. Several presidents
earlier he was always that person who was just a few votes short of getting the democratic nomination.
He almost was nominated for vice president a few times as well. When James Polk, a fellow
democrat, was elected president in 1844 Buchanan became his secretary of state and in fact he was
offered this position earlier by the democratic convention in an attempt to keep him from running
and thus dividing the party. It was sort of a bribery to keep him out of getting involved in
the more tense political situation because many of the parties at this time were weighed down
by being divided having several different candidates. As the secretary of state he helped
with what would become the Oregon Compromise admitting the Oregon territory and establishing
the northern border for what it is today. When Franklin Pierce ran for president in 1852 he was
considered a dark horse candidate. There were two other democrats who were front runners for the
nomination and one of them was James Buchanan but he and his southern opponent were so closely tied
that no agreement was able to be reached and thus the tie ended up being broken by an unexpected
third party. To make up for this disappointment Buchanan was named the minister to Great Britain
under Pierce's presidency and he was very successful in this position. He was viewed
favorably by the British government and he helped establish some of the political boundaries of the
country. Because of how well he did in this position he was very highly regarded when he
returned to the United States. Now by this time he was 65 years old and beginning to think that
the chance to be in the White House had long passed. He even said a few years earlier when
asked if he would run again that the time was too late for him now. He'd had his chance and he never
quite made it and now he was getting too old. Nevertheless he ended up getting the democratic
nomination and beating the first republican to run whose last name was Fremont. He was a very
strong abolitionist and the country wasn't quite ready for that yet. In fact Buchanan's strongest
campaign platform you could say was the fact that he didn't have a very strong position
on the issue of slavery. He was a northerner but he wasn't a strong abolitionist and this made him
a lot like the president who came right before him, Franklin Pierce, another northern democrat
who wasn't a strong abolitionist. Both presidents at the time and since then have been greatly
criticized for not taking a stronger issue on slavery and for pushing the country closer to
civil war by being too friendly to the south. But can anyone really be surprised that that's what
happened? After all both of them basically built their campaign platform on the fact that they
were wishy-washy. They didn't have a strong stance. That was what the democratic party
liked about them because the democratic party was very divided on this point.
They also were the strongest and most established party at this point because the federalist party
was long gone, the Whig party was long gone, a few others had sprung up like the Free Soil Party,
the Anti-Masonic, National Republican, but all of them had petered out at this point
leaving way for the new republican party sometimes called the Grand Old Party which is
the current republican party's origins to spring up with its strongest platform being anti-slavery.
But democrats weren't ready to make such a strong stance. Of course the southern democrats were very
pro-slavery and they thought that the whole party should be that way but there were many northern
democrats who were abolitionists. There also were people like Pierce and Buchanan who were
technically northerners who thought slavery was wrong but who didn't think that the U.S.
government had the right or the power to outlaw slavery or to restrict the slave rights of the
southern states. Buchanan ended up being elected by a decent majority and he was the first president
whose inauguration was photographed. In his inaugural speech Buchanan said that he thought
slavery was of course an important problem but thankfully not the biggest problem the country
was facing. This statement didn't look very good in retrospect even a few months later. He believed
that the issue of whether states should be admitted as slave states or free states was something that
should be left up to the states and that ultimately being united under the constitution was all that
really mattered. Unity, everyone sticking together, all these things sounded good and nothing wrong with
what he said but honestly he was just a little naive about how divided the country was. Maybe
this was partly because he had spent the last four years in England. He hadn't been in the United
States seeing just how tense the battle was becoming. No shots had been fired yet but for
instance the bleeding Kansas situation was a very hot topic and one which cost Franklin Pierce
the nomination when he tried to run for a second term. When he made the issue of Kansas being
admitted as a slave state or a free state something which the state would decide in the Kansas
Nebraska decision that was a very unpopular decision because most northerners thought it
went against the Missouri Compromise which had been passed years ago under James Monroe saying
that new states would not be admitted as slave states if they were north of Missouri or west of
it and Kansas was north of that so that abolished it and James Buchanan went along on the same
principle trying to get Kansas admitted as a slave state. So the northern abolitionists began calling
him a doe face and that was a term used for northerners who were southern sympathizers.
Buchanan didn't want to be viewed as a southern sympathizer. He tried to balance his cabinet
equally with northerners and southerners but basically it was impossible to please either
party. The northerners would only be pleased if he took a strong abolitionist stance and he wasn't
going to do that yet how could the southerners really be pleased unless more slave states were
admitted which was against some previous rulings. Because of how unpopular his decisions were in 1858
the republicans won majority of congress but the government ground to a standstill after that
because the southern democrats kept anything from passing and then even Buchanan would veto a lot
of issues so nothing was happening. Adding to this tension were two very important incidents in 1857
which happened right after Buchanan took office. First the Dred Scott ruling. Now Dred Scott was a
slave but when his master brought him to another state, a free state, he declared that he should
be free now and he tried to sue for his freedom. The matter went to the supreme court and the
supreme court issued the ruling that the government had no right to infringe upon the rights of any
property owners to take away their property and with this ruling they established that slaves
were not regarded as citizens they were just property. This wasn't a popular ruling
but Buchanan felt somewhat betrayed by this yet he upheld it when he could have perhaps overturned
it or gone against it and by doing so he established himself to the northerners as a
complete southern sympathizer. At the same time an economic downturn happened in 1857 because of
the panic of 1857 which was a banking crisis so now the country is also being plunged into
a depression. As well as the issue of the civil war brewing it wasn't a good time for the country
particularly for the man who was in the white house. His goal was to just keep everyone being
friendly but there came a point when he couldn't do that anymore and in December, December 20th
of 1860 after the next president had already been elected Abraham Lincoln the first southern state
seceded South Carolina and by the time he left office in March of 1861 seven southern states
had seceded Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, South Carolina of course and Texas.
To reinforce South Carolina he sent ships to bring backups to Fort Sumter which was under
attack from secessionists. However from the land the secessionists started firing at the ship
and these were the first shots fired in the civil war in early 1861. He happily left office declaring
to Abraham Lincoln when he left that if you are as happy coming into the white house as I am
returning to Wheatland which was his home then you must be the happiest man on earth. He had said when
he took office that he would only have one term and he certainly upheld that but he couldn't have
been more glad to leave. He spent the remaining seven years of his life at his home Wheatland
where he wrote his memoirs which he called The Administration on the Eve of Rebellion.
In it he tried to defend his position. He famously stated that history will vindicate my memory
yet his prediction has not come true as of yet. His memory has only been viewed less and less
favorably especially as slavery becomes even more of a controversial topic in the last few years.
Of course people were against it then but now modern historians tend to look back on anyone
who wasn't completely anti-slavery as being very much pro-slavery. Now to be fair that wasn't the
case with James Buchanan. He was known to purchase slaves just so that he could free them. He thought
slavery was wrong but he did not think that the U.S. Constitution had the right to abolish it
or to make a strong stance against it and he didn't agree with abolitionists. He saw them
as extremists and he thought that they were against the unity of the country. Quotes from
James Buchanan reflect his legacy of being conflicted on many issues not making a strong
stance on really any point because he wanted to stay neutral. He's quoted as saying I like the
noise of democracy yet apparently it got a little too noisy for him as he was receiving a lot of
criticism for his actions. He said our union rests upon public opinion and can never be cemented
by the blood of its citizens shed in civil war. Nevertheless he saw that civil war was eminent
as he was leaving the White House and he believed that it could be the end of the free country as
we know it stating many times I am the last president of the United States. He believed
quote there is nothing stable but heaven and the Constitution. He strongly quoted the Constitution
again and again as the thing that would keep the country together and when those southern states
tried to secede he went before Congress and stated I don't think it's legal for the southern states
to secede yet he also didn't think he he or Congress had any power to stop them so that
again shows his contradiction his being torn between different views. One quote which reflects
really what he tried to do is whatever the result may be I shall carry to my grave the consciousness
that I at least meant well for my country. I truly believe that he did mean well he was perhaps
ill-equipped and he has received a bad reputation because of it yet he did truly try to do his best.
Interestingly one later president who defended him was fellow Irishman John F Kennedy who said
about him no one has a right to grade a president even poor James Buchanan who has not sat in his
chair examined the mail and information that came across his desk and learned why he made his
decisions. He was given many nicknames throughout his life he was called old buck because he wouldn't
make a strong stance on either point he was just viewed as being kind of stubborn yet wishy-washy.
Some people called him 10 cent Jimmy because he was so exact about following the letter of the law
and about bookkeeping he would keep track of finances down to the last dime but this regard
for and even obsession with following rules is a big part of what caused his problem. He didn't
think that there was anything in the constitution that could be opposed to slavery he didn't think
there was anything in the constitution that gave him the right to for instance declare war on a
state trying to secede or keep them from seceding. He believed in following the rules even if it made
him unpopular and even if it made his time in office less successful. He was often called old
functionary because he still dressed in the attire that he'd worn as a young man even in his older
days when fashions had changed. This strong adherence to past views is again part of what
got him in trouble. When he was a young man those views on just let slavery take care of itself
let's try to keep it neutral worked it worked for decades but there came a point when it just didn't
work anymore the issue had to be attacked straight on and that's why Abraham Lincoln was very
successful. Buchanan spent his remaining days defending his legacy and if we look at him
honestly I think we can't be too surprised that he did what he did after all was he not elected
for the very reason that he struck a neutral balance that he wasn't too strong on either point
the only way to please the one side the north the abolitionists would have been
to make slavery completely illegal and this certainly would have caused the civil war right
away but the only way to prevent the civil war would have been to give the south exactly what
it wanted which was more slave states unrestricted allowance of slavery in any state and that would
have angered the north so much that they may have attempted some kind of a civil war or a secession
it's easy to look at him and say he made the civil war start it's all his fault but it had to come to
blows eventually it had been postponed for too many decades and finally the only way it could be
tackled was for it to come to blows sadly as it divided the country greatly and it cost a lot of
American lives but Abraham Lincoln was able to come in and be the strong hero partly because he
came in as the civil war was beginning and he wasn't afraid to be against slavery because he
we can but pity poor James Buchanan who truly tried his best in a difficult position
an unenviable position but let us not forget his legacy because he is a very important man
in the history of our country thank you for spending this time with me
please join me next time for more American Legends