Mixing Film And Digital Footage: Killers Of The Flower Moon

Filmmaking Techniques
4 followers
Colour is a tool that plays a crucial role in cinematography
and can be manipulated to craft a bunch of different looks.
Some of these looks can be pretty heavy-handed, like the quote-unquote Mexican filter,
which punches up the warmth every time the world of the story moves south of the US border.
But other applications of colour like in Killers of the Flower Moon is a bit more subtle,
yet has an unconscious effect on how the story is taken in by audiences.
The workflow behind this cinematography combines old school thinking with new school technology.
This comes from the choice to shoot on both film and digital cameras in different situations
and by thinking about LUTs and digital colour correction in terms of old photochemical
techniques. So let's explain how these principles work
by breaking down the cinematography in Killers of the Flower Moon.
This video is sponsored by Squarespace, the only platform you need to create and manage your website.
Killers of the Flower Moon responds to the long-discussed topic of film versus digital
with why not both? This was a decision influenced by DP Rodrigo Prieto,
who needed to think not only about how his choice affected the look and feel of the movie,
but also how it would practically influence the way they shot it.
Part of the role of the cinematographer is to find ways so that the camera and the lighting
really represent what they're feeling. What's the energy of the scene? What
should it feel like? And a lot of the discussions were about that.
For scenes that featured Osage characters or took place in that world, Prieto wanted to represent
colour in a way that felt natural, which to him, was best achieved by using a film negative with
a film print. The main film he used was Kodak's 35mm 250D5207 stock, which shot scenes that took
place during the day. Because 250D can be shot at a higher ASA rating than Kodak's other daylight
stock, it means that less light is needed to expose, which makes it possible to shoot both
some interiors as well as exteriors on the stock. He swapped this out during Osage ritual scenes
for the less sensitive 50D stock, when he wanted shots to have a tighter film grain that was less
noticeable. He also sometimes used 500T when filming night interiors under tungsten light.
They ran this film through Arri's newest 35mm cameras, the Arri Cam Studio and Light,
with the LT version being better for more compact rigs like steadicam or remote headshots,
and the ST version being able to record at a higher 60fps versus the 48 of the LT.
For one extreme slow-mo sequence they also pulled out an old Arri Flex 435 to shoot at 150fps in the
wide and a digital phantom to shoot the tighter shot at 700fps. A few select frames which needed
to look like old archival footage were also shot on Kodak's 5222 black and white film stock.
To push this newsreel look even further without using visual effects or post-production work,
they shot the film on Scorsese's own 1917 Balin Howell 2709 camera. It needed to be hand cranked
for the motors to move the film past the gate, which meant the frame rate would change depending
on how fast or slow the handle was turned. This gave the footage that unusual feeling of motion
that is associated with the format. So apart from these exceptions, if 35mm felt like the right
format for most of the movie, then why did they also shoot some scenes with a digital cinema
camera? This mainly came down to a technical limitation of film. The most sensitive colour
negative film stock that Kodak produces is rated at 500ASA and is balanced for tungsten light.
This pales in comparison to the low light capabilities of a camera like the Sony Venice 2
that has a dual base ISO of 3200. Since certain scenes needed to be shot in the blue,
the small window of light after the sun has set but before the cool ambient light disappears
altogether, they needed a camera that could shoot and expose with a very small amount of natural
light. Having almost 3 extra stops of sensitivity meant that the Venice could maximise the shooting
window after sunset and continue to shoot scenes quite late as the natural ambience started to
disappear. This was especially useful as they were shooting on Panavision T-series anamorphic lenses
that have a stop of T2.3, which is not a particularly fast lens that lets in a huge
amount of light, unlike faster spherical glass such as the Master Primes with their T1.3 aperture.
So the Sony Venice was chosen instead of 35mm to shoot scenes that took place in low light,
such as dusk scenes where they only used natural ambient light or wide night exterior scenes.
Although this traditional 35mm Kodak colour film was the basis of the look, it did deviate
quite a bit from there to serve the story, thanks to being combined with a more modern
post-production workflow. Scorsese and Prieto did this by coming up with four different LUTs,
which are pre-established looks that can be added on top of the footage that affect the colour,
saturation and contrast, kind of like adding a filter using consumer photo editing software.
They used these different LUTs to support certain feelings at different points in the movie.
Instead of creating looks based on simple colour ideas and grading like warm vs cool,
saturated vs desaturated or high vs low contrast, the way that they conceptualised
and implemented these LUTs in the workflow used old school concepts based on how cinematographers
used to work with selecting, processing and colour timing film before digital cinematography.
But before we get into how this was achieved, I'd like to thank Squarespace for supporting this
video. Squarespace is the platform I use to create and run my websites, whether that is for this
channel or my own personal cinematography site. As someone who is not overly IT savvy, the reason I
use Squarespace is because it's very intuitive, easy to set up and guides you into beautiful,
modern design choices through their range of customisable templates that you can tweak and
add your own content to. A tool I find useful are their galleries, which can host your photo
or video content to show your clients or collaborators what you can do. All of these
files can be uploaded through their asset library, which makes managing your content a walk in the
park. Head to squarespace.com for a free trial and when you're ready to launch, go to squarespace.com
slash indepthcine to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
The first of the four looks that they created was a normal film LUT that precisely emulated
Kodak 5219 colour negative film stock and produced natural filmic colour. This was used for early
scenes with Osage characters and could be applied to the digital footage shot on the Venice or the
35mm film scans to achieve the same regular film development and print look. The second LUT,
mainly used to present the European characters and world, tried to emulate the look of very early
colour still photography processes such as Autochrome and Photochrome, which was developed
in the early 1900s. Autochrome has more desaturated colour than modern colour negative film
with a brighter, more washed out violet hue in the skies, caused by more magenta in the blues,
desaturated greens and yellows and reds that take on an orange hue. The third LUT, used in the latter
half of the film once the story gets darker and bleak, was based on a photochemical development
process created by Technicolor called ENR. This is fairly similar to bleach bypass development
and creates less saturated colours across the image and increased contrast. The final look
emulated three strip Technicolor which has a more vividly rich saturated colour with deeper
punchy reds and greens and was used for more magical experimental moments in the story
or the separate coda scene which breaks away from the main narrative timeline.
Oh and one scene also used a day for night LUT to make footage that was shot under direct sunlight
during the day appear to be night time footage. These LUTs were created by senior colourist Ivan
Lucas at Company 3 in collaboration with Prieto before production began. Once principal photography
started they would receive either raw files from the Venice or processed and scanned digital files
from the developed 35mm film. The dailies colourist would apply the appropriate LUT to the footage in
baselight grading software and then proceed to do minor colour correction where necessary
using another old school way of working called printer lights. This copies the old method used
to colour time 35mm footage from the lab by only adjusting primary colour and exposure variables.
This could be done through software by raising or lowering the offset which is the overall exposure
of the image, increasing or decreasing the values for the red, green and blue colour channels
and increasing or decreasing the cyan, yellow and magenta values. Basically making broader
adjustments to colour and exposure without using more nuanced correction or masking tools.
Scorsese and his editor worked with these dailies while cutting. Then right at the end of the
process once they had the final cut they could come in and do more nuanced tweaks to the colour
in the final grade or by doing things like isolating secondary colours or adding power windows
and masks. The process of subtly affecting the colour will likely go unnoticed by 99% of the
audience as the movie plays, which is what you want. You don't want it to be so overt and obvious
that changes in colour become distracting. However if we compare these different LUTs side by side,
especially the starting Kodak look and the final ENR look, we can see that they are drastically
different. The first normal film LUT is applied when the story is more comfortable
about the environment and follows the practices of Osage characters. The colours feel natural,
rich and real, with nice contrasts, strong deep greens and a comfortable range between
the deepest blacks and brightest highlights, which shows detail in the shadows. As the story
progresses and we delve into the moral darkness, desperation and corruption of the story and
behaviour of the characters, the colour and life starts getting, literally, drained away from the
image. Compare the Kodak look to the ENR look in this frame, which is shot in a similar lighting
and colour environment. All that deep lovely natural colour in the greens and blues, the healthy
magenta in the skin tones, has been completely sucked out and replaced by warm, very desaturated
tones. Likewise, the contrast has been increased in the ENR LUT so much that the sky is almost
blowing out to a pure white, and the parts of the image in the shadows have lost almost all detail,
which overall feels harsher and less natural. This circles back to Prieto's initial commentary
on cinematography, that the images filmmakers create should represent the
energy and feeling of the characters in the scene as the story progresses.
Hope you enjoyed this video and that everyone has a great new year. Thank you to all the Patrons for
your continued support of the channel, as well as anyone else for engaging with the video.
Otherwise, until next time, thanks for watching and goodbye.
