How The Safdies Shoot A Film At 3 Budget Levels

Filmmaking Techniques
4 followers
This video is sponsored by Squarespace, the all-in-one platform to build your website.
Josh and Benny Safdie are independent filmmakers with a filmmaking language that's
instantly recognisable. Abrasive sound design, telephoto lenses, real locations and stories
driven by panic, desperation and momentum. Across their work they return to characters
trapped by bad decisions, narratives unfolding at breakneck speed and urban environments that
feel hostile and claustrophobic. In this video we'll look at how the Safdie brothers made the
lower budget Heaven Knows What, the medium budget Good Time and the higher budget Uncut Gems,
examining what aspects of their filmmaking changed as the budgets grew and what remained
Heaven Knows What represents the Safdie brothers at arguably their most stripped
back and uncompromising. The film is based on the real life experiences of Arielle Holmes,
who also stars as a fictionalised version of herself.
Josh Safdie first met her on the street while doing research in the Diamond District
for a bigger movie they wanted to make later called Uncut Gems.
After first meeting to potentially cast her as a shop assistant in Uncut Gems,
he later realised there was another more autobiographical film to be made about her life.
The brothers then adapted this into a story formed for the screen which depicted homeless youth,
a romantic relationship, addiction and street life in New York City.
The budget for the film which came from the production company Iconoclast was fairly bare
bones and the production reflected this at every level. The Safdie's shot almost entirely on real
locations, using non-professional actors and available light wherever possible.
The crew was minimal, the gear footprint relatively small and the approach was highly
reactive. Scenes feel like captured reality rather than being staged, with the camera often
struggling to keep up with the characters. The Safdies enlisted DP Sean Price-Williams to shoot
the film. We talked about the movie being an opera of long lens. We always looked at the movie
as an opera and wanted to do as much as we could to kind of combat a documentary vibe,
so no handheld. We shot the whole movie on tripods. Shooting in this way was perhaps a bit
counter intuitive, as standard practice would be to create more of a verite documentary style
realism with a handheld run and gun aesthetic. Instead they treated the situation almost like
filming a wildlife show, by placing the camera very far away from the actors where they wouldn't
be noticeable in public spaces on the other side of the street and using extremely telephoto lenses
with focal lengths up to an insane 2400mm. The only time the camera wasn't on a tripod was
for a few select steadicam tracking shots, which moved with the characters and were also skillfully
captured with a telephoto lens. They maximized the number of shots in these public scenes
and covered the perhaps less accurately repeatable performances of the non-professional actors
by shooting with two cameras at a time. This gave lots of foreground crossing through the frame,
a compressed tight invasive voyeuristic perspective and to get a feeling and energy
of real people on the street reacting to what they thought were real situations
rather than performed ones. To me this long lens viewpoint also visually supports how caught up
and focused the characters are on their own world and experiences. We care less about the
outside world and more about the heightened individual emotions of the characters.
They shot digitally on a Sony F3 in HD on a flat S-Log colour profile with a desaturated look
applied in the grade. They also placed diffusion filters in front of the lens to give the footage
its soft hazy look. We are so far away from the subject with the camera but with the sound we
want the exact opposite. You know you want to be right up there with them. You don't want to feel
as if you're listening from far away, you want to feel as if you're right in the middle of the action.
This technique that they found on Heaven Knows What of balancing a far away but tight visual
perspective with an intimate dialogue mix and dark frenetic synth soundtrack became the backbone of
their directorial style and is a large part of what supports the chaotic, tense heightened nature
of the performances and story. At this budget level the Safdies leaned entirely into their strengths,
realism, performance and urgency. The lack of money forced them to abandon traditional coverage,
elaborate lighting setups or controlled environments resulting in a film that feels
dangerously alive. Before we get into good time and uncut gems I need to say a quick thank you
to Squarespace for sponsoring this video. If you're a filmmaker or creative freelancer,
having a website is a must for getting your work found and taken seriously. What I like about
Squarespace is how quickly you can get something that looks genuinely professional online. Their
design tools make it easy to build a site that actually reflects your taste. You can start with
their templates or use Blueprint AI to generate a layout based on what you do and then tweak
everything with simple drag and drop controls, no coding required. And if you're sharing video work,
Squarespace makes it easy to showcase projects cleanly and professionally. Check out squarespace.com
for a free trial and when you're ready to launch your site go to squarespace.com slash indepthciney
to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. With good time the Safdie brothers
stepped into a more conventional independent film budget, but without abandoning their core aesthetic.
The increased budget, perhaps aided by casting Robert Pattinson in the starring role,
allowed for a more structured production while still maintaining their raw energy.
They were able to have a larger crew, legally secured shooting locations and execute more
technically complex sequences. Although the budget was larger, between an estimated
two to four million dollars, it was still very low considering the amount of locations and action
sequences outlined in the script. Once again the starting point for the film came from the character
rather than the story and plot being the inception. They built Pattinson's character by coming up with
an extensive backstory and drawing from emails he and Benny would exchange as if they were in
character. The Safdies also began leaning more heavily into genre. Good Time is structured as a
one-night explosion of action, borrowing from crime thrillers and exploitation cinema but filtered
through their signature chaos and realism. Although they had more resources to work with,
they stuck with a similar independently minded low budget mindset when shooting.
For The New World Long, we were able to get that location and secure that location
but we shot it as if we were stealing the shot. We still set up the cameras as if we were going
to steal it when we ran in, so it's like if we get caught we at least have the two shots.
When the cops are looking at us like you know, why are you moving around so surreptitiously,
you have the location. Again they worked with Sean Price Williams and again they used the same
telephoto lens approach. Like on Heaven Knows What they used an A and a B camera to maximise
coverage, with close framing that compressed space and isolated characters within crowded
environments. Often shooting from fixed positions on tripods with super long Canon zoom lenses.
This look was paired with an alive and breathing handheld camera with Zeiss super speed primes,
or an occasional steadicam shot. At T1.3 these fast primes which let more light into the camera
aided them in exposing many of the darkly lit night time sequences.
This time instead of using digital cameras, the slightly boosted budget allowed them to shoot
on film. They decided to shoot 2 per 35mm. This was done for a few reasons.
We're shooting 35 2perf. We're already degrading it a little bit, you know,
because if you shoot 35 clean, you know, after everything's, you know, gone through all the
post-processes, it's so clean that it looks like you could have shot it on, you know, 4k or
something. So we like to try to maintain texture, so we did the 2perf thing. Also it was for cost
reasons. Rather than the standard taller 4perf 35mm, 2perf exposes frames with less height,
which when shot with spherical lenses gives it an aspect ratio closer to widescreen 2.39 to 1.
Because the surface area of the negative is smaller, it also means the film grain is more
noticeable, with a more gritty texture somewhere between 16mm film and 35mm anamorphic.
Lastly, because it uses half the surface area of 4perf, it is twice as cost effective,
with less needing to be spent on purchasing film and developing it.
Unlike Heaven Knows What, Goodtime uses light more expressively. He combined the real world
neon signage, sodium vapour street lights and harsh fluorescents with RGB LED sky panels that
his team set up. These saturated colours dominated the palette, creating a heightened, almost surreal
night time atmosphere that visually added to the story's chaos.
The additional budget allowed for set pieces that would have been impossible earlier. Escapes,
police chases and more controlled stunt work. However these moments are still shot in a way
that feels frantic and unstable, often denying the audience clear spatial orientation.
Goodtime feels like a bridge film, combining the raw aesthetic of their early work
with the narrative propulsion and technical ambition of a larger production.
After many years, that first film that Josh Safdie was researching in the Diamond District
before they shot Heaven Knows What, called Uncut Gems, finally entered production.
10 years ago when we set out to start this project, we wrote the first draft 10 years ago.
One of 160 drafts. A couple things never changed. One, Howard's fate.
The general plot of the basketball player with this gemstone was kind of always there
in that shape and it never was a diamond.
With a larger cast and more famous faces, it represents the Safdie brothers operating at
their largest scale, while still resisting traditional Hollywood polish. The film is
far more expansive in scope, featuring numerous locations, set pieces and elaborate crowd scenes.
Yet despite the budget increase, the Safdies refused to smooth out their style.
Shot again on Kodak 500T35mm, this time by famed DP Darius Conji,
the movie embraced a similar abrasive visual approach.
However, this time using a slightly more mobile camera
that often glides along on a steadicam rather than being stuck in one place on a tripod.
They elevated their camera package by choosing to film in 4 perf anamorphic
rather than 2 perf spherical. This format gave the filmmakers a larger than life dimensionality
which they felt was especially necessary for Adam Sandler's close ups.
The more expensive 4 perf anamorphic also came with a cleaner, tighter grain structure.
So to get back a little more film grain,
they decided to push process the film for one stop over the whole movie.
This is a technique where you intentionally underexpose film
by metering the 500ASA film at 1000ASA and then overdevelop it in the lab for longer than usual
to compensate. Again they went with long lenses, this time C-series anamorphics from Panavision
which included 180, 250 and 360mm focal lengths as well as telephoto zooms.
The long lenses compressed space, made backgrounds feel oppressive and feel like
characters are constantly boxed in by their environments which added to the tension.
Lighting is perhaps a little more controlled than in Goodtime, but still intentionally harsh
and mainly done with practical lights that can be seen in the shot.
Jewelry stores are flooded with artificial light and garish colour, RGB light pulses in clubs,
work is done under vivid cyan practicals and dark night exteriors buzz with colour and noise.
The camera remains restless, often hovering inches from faces, refusing the audience relief.
The editing is aggressive with overlapping dialogue and relentless pacing pushing the
film towards sensory overload. Where the budget truly shows is in logistics rather than style.
Closing streets, getting cameos from celebrities, staging major basketball games,
coordinating large crowds and executing complex sequences with precision,
all while maintaining the illusion of chaos.
The Safdie brothers are filmmakers who have maintained a remarkably consistent creative
philosophy across every budget level, with street casting, telephoto lenses,
intimate dialogue and chaotic plots. At low budgets limitations pushed them towards
radical realism and raw intimacy. At medium budgets they embraced genre
while refining their visual language. At higher budgets they expanded in scale and complexity
without losing the tension, chaos and discomfort that define their work.
Rather than using increased budgets to smooth out rough edges, the Safdies use money to intensify
their ideas, making films louder, denser and more overwhelming.
Thank you for your ongoing support and a special shout out to the dedicated patrons who help make
this channel possible. Otherwise, until next time, thanks for watching and goodbye.
