Dune: Part Two’s Bold Cinematography

Filmmaking Techniques
4 followers
This video is sponsored by Squarespace.
While the first Dune movie was being showered with praise at the 2022 Academy Awards,
director Denny Villeneuve, DP Greg Fraser and the rest of the heads of departments were actually
hard at work preparing to shoot the sequel. Part 2 was even more ambitious. If part 1 built the
and set all the parts in place, part 2 dives straight in with an escalation in drama and
an abundance of large scale set pieces. So let's take a closer look at the cinematography
and show how Dune achieved such bold, ambitious, epic visual storytelling.
Whenever you do a movie you've got to solve a series of problems and some of them are technical,
like how do you get a bit of equipment to a certain place and then there are creative
assertions and a lot of the technical stuff had been solved for us in advance because we'd done
part 1. This, along with the critical and financial success of the first movie,
emboldened the filmmakers and got them considering how they could creatively
and visually elevate part 2. One of the early crossroads they arrived at was how closely they
should retain the look and feel of what they had done in the first film, or if they should
deviate to shooting a different format, use a different palette or implement different lighting
ideas. They landed on maintaining most of the look of the original, keeping a visual continuity in
the cinematic world, but elevating that look in subtle ways or at times by employing riskier
creative decisions like infrared black and white, which we'll get to a bit later.
A starting point for the look came from the camera and lens selection. Both films were
designed to be released across two, or actually three exhibition formats. Two different taller
aspect ratio formats for IMAX cinemas and a 2.39 to 1 widescreen format for regular cinema
and streaming distribution. Part 1 used two different types of lenses. Spherical Panavision
H series lenses to capture the taller IMAX scenes and the 1.6x anamorphic Panavision
Ultra Vista lenses for non-IMAX widescreen scenes. For part 2 they kept the same large
format look of part 1, which they shot on the Alexa Mini LF, while also adding an extra even
larger format Alexa 65 camera. Fraser switched up his lens selection on part 2, getting rid of the
anamorphic lenses and shooting entirely with large format spherical glass. Doing this meant
that they would chop off the top and bottom of the image to arrive at a widescreen aspect ratio.
Rather than shooting anamorphic and getting this ratio natively. The advantage of this is that they
could then preserve the height of the frame for the taller IMAX distribution aspect ratios,
having greater cropping options for all the different distribution formats in post.
When it came to choosing which spherical lenses to shoot on there were two important factors that
affected this decision. Firstly, they had to be large format cinema lenses with enough
coverage for the LF and 65 sensors without vignetting. Secondly, Fraser sought glass that
came with a bit of vintage texture which would counteract the large format high res, crisp
digital Alexa sensors. He landed on two different sets of lenses. One set of Arri Rentals rehoused
version of vintage movie cam lenses from the 1980s with the prime focal length lenses ranging
from 16mm to 180mm that have gentle natural character, a feeling of depth and beautiful
focus falloff. These were combined with textural large format Soviet era glass which were custom
rehoused for modern use by Iron Glass. Going through the film we can see that Fraser often
elected to shoot on longer focal length primes. Shooting on these telephoto focal lengths have
the effect of compressing the background and giving images the feeling that the landscape
is closer to the characters than it would on a wide angle lens. I think this is a beautiful way
giving the sand dunes more of a layered depth, showing the scale of the characters within the
vastness of the imposing desert and making the environment itself feel like a character.
One of the biggest reasons that I think makes this film successful is how they melded a level
of reality and believability to a fantastical story. One of the pitfalls of many studio
blockbusters that take on stories in unrealistic imaginative cinematic universes is that when the
visual language of the filmmaking also takes on an unrealistic tone, I tend to get pulled out of
the story and lose interest. In Dune, even when fantastical impossible things are happening on
screen, because it's shot in a way that is tethered to reality, I stay fully invested with the
characters on the edge of my seat.
When you're shooting something so larger than life, it's important I think to give the audience a grounding,
because if you then suddenly start to become unreal with a situation that's unreal, it doesn't kind of work.
The costumes feel textural, like they've been worn. The environments are authentic and don't
look like they've been shot against a green screen in a studio.
When there are visual effects, they feel fully integrated and a seamless part of the live action
footage. The sci-fi technology has a mechanical believability. And importantly, the camera is
always positioned and operated in a real way that conforms to physics. The perspective never goes
through walls, swoops around the sky or moves in an unnecessary, unmotivated way.
The shots are usually operated from the ground and have a subtle handheld looseness to them.
Or if the camera does move, it's usually tracking the motion of characters.
Always keeping the photography grounded in reality.
Well, almost always. But before we get there, I'd like to thank Squarespace for sponsoring this video.
Every cinematographer and filmmaker, even those as big as Greg Fraser, have a website.
You can build this over at Squarespace. Gone are the days where you need to employ someone with
super advanced web design skills to build a site for you. Squarespace makes setting one up simple.
It's easy to get started with their new guided system, Squarespace Blueprint, where you can
select from custom curated layouts and styling options to build an online presence custom
tailored to your liking. Then use their optimized SEO tools to get your portfolio seen. You can also
integrate and connect your social accounts seamlessly to further promote your brand
and get eyes onto your work. So head over to Squarespace to get started with a free trial.
And when you're ready to launch, go to squarespace.com in-depth Cine to save 10%
of your first purchase of a website or domain. So part of the look relied on keeping the
cinematography grounded. However, certain moments and set pieces like the eclipse scene
or the introduction of a new planet Giddy Prime introduced very bold stylistic photographic ideas.
One concern that they had when introducing a new planet and character to the story
was that audiences may get confused between it and the main planet Arrakis. Giddy Prime would
be introduced with an exterior scene in a sandpit with a similar neutral color palette to Arrakis.
To avoid confusion Villeneuve proposed communicating this change in location by switching
to a monochromatic palette. Fraser stylistically elevated this idea even further by proposing
black and white infrared. But what exactly is infrared? Well cameras capture wavelengths of
light. There is visible light that our eyes can see and also light at different wavelengths which
is invisible to the naked eye. To make sure that none of these infrared light wavelengths outside
the visible spectrum bleed into the regular color space captured by cinema cameras, which would
distort capturing realistic colors, manufacturers add an infrared filter in front of the sensor
which cuts out these rays. However, if you deliberately remove that infrared filter in the
camera and replace it with a visible light cut filter, then the camera will only capture infrared
light. They did exactly this by stripping away the infrared filter layer from the Alexa sensor
and adding a filter in front of the lens which would cut out any excess blue, green and red
visible light. This image could then be desaturated into monochrome for onset monitoring and
post-production. Infrared light isn't exactly flattering to actors. When shooting characters
under hard direct toppy sunlight, it gives them a frightful intimidating pale appearance
with dark eyes, an accurate emotional representation of the central sadistic character
from this world. Overall the color palette on Arrakis closely follows that of the first film,
leaning heavily into a neutral look with browns, hot white skies, grays and blacks.
However, they decided to start the opening scene with a bang by letting it unfold during an eclipse.
To create a distinct look, Fraser used a filter that cut most of the green and blue light,
but kept the visible red light. This pushed a darker orangey-red palette into the scene
with much denser, graduated orange skies than the regular palette.
There's a tendency in modern filmmaking to use an abundance of soft light. If there's harsh
sun outside, most cinematographers' first instinct is to throw a scrim over the talent.
However, part of the beauty of Dune comes from how Fraser works with a combination of soft light
and hard light. He creates a feeling of heat by keeping the light for exteriors hard,
with a crisp distinction between solid shadows and areas with highlights,
pushing the exposure up the curve to a brighter look.
When the characters are inside he decreases this idea of the harsh sun by lighting with a much
softer, more diffused look, with a gentle gradient between shadows and highlights.
He'll weight the exposure far darker for these scenes.
Sometimes punctuating these indoor spaces with little pockets of hard light,
reminding us of the overpowering nature of the desert sun outside.
He masterfully takes a visceral feeling and communicates it using light.
If you want to incorporate film into a movie's workflow,
you can either do so at the beginning by shooting on it,
at the end by making a film print for screening, or both.
Dune did something interesting. They decided to shoot on digital, present on digital in most
cinemas, but inserted an extra step in the middle of this process called film out.
This took the graded digital footage, laser printed it onto Kodak Vision 3 5254 film,
then re-scanned it back to digital.
We went out to film negative and then scanned it back in.
Like it was night and day what it gave the highlights,
what it gave the patina, what it gave the kind of the texture.
The reason for this back and forth was that they felt that shooting on film looked too
sentimental, while acquiring on digital felt too sharp,
clean and lacked the texture that they wanted the world to have.
By doing a film out, they got a bit of the best of both worlds.
Thanks for supporting the channel and making it possible for me to keep making this content
by watching, liking or subscribing to the Patreon.
Until next time, thanks for watching and goodbye.
