Wealth Insight's 19-Year Journey: How We Transformed Stock Investing! | Value Research

Invest Insight
9 followers
#Finance #PesonalFinance #InvestInsight #WealthInsight's19-YearJourney: #TransformedStockInvesting! #ValueResearch
Hello and welcome to this special podcast celebrating 19 years of Wealth Insight.
And joining me is the man who's been at the helm of this journey for almost two decades now.
The voice of value research, Dheerendra Kumar.
Dheerendra, let's begin with talking about those early days of Wealth Insight.
How did it really start?
Actually, Wealth Insight happened much after value research came into being.
In fact, value research started in 1990.
Value research started as a stock research company.
We started with public sector research.
But there was no business model.
There was no business model around independent research of stocks in 90s.
Because research means came from brokers.
And brokers made money from brokerage.
And research came free.
Or research came as an add-on.
So it was not possible to run an independent research, buy-side research.
So we had to do nothing but, you know, get into mutual fund.
And that became our mainstay.
We became leader.
And we are still, hopefully, we are still the leader by a wide margin.
Then we started creating the mutual fund scorecard for Economic Times in 1993 onwards.
We invented the mutual fund rating for business today.
And then we published our own magazine.
Before that, we launched our value research online.
Which virtually did, you know, that we were among the first few.
Website to democratize mutual fund information for Indian public.
You know, we were known among investors.
We were known for our mutual funds.
You know, the rigor of our information management or opinion or information on mutual fund.
Then the great boom happened since 2003.
The market started galloping.
And then I realized a very funny thing.
That we rarely came across a person who invested for a couple of years in mutual fund and lost money.
But we rarely came across a person who was investing in stocks directly and made money.
Okay.
We were only coming across, you know, all kinds of horrible stories.
People investing in IPOs.
People investing in risky stocks.
People buying at 20 rupees, selling it at 21 and feeling very happy about it.
It was very difficult to find long-term investors in equity.
And what happened was, the early 2000, the gamification of the market.
What happened was, you know, ET Now, CNBC, Z Business.
All these people, they went about giving the running commentary on the market.
And everybody thought that this is the biggest game in the town.
And you have to get cracking in the morning.
And I realized that, you know, here is the sure shot way of losing money.
The only way is, you know, when people understand that it is a great thing to be buying stock.
It is a great thing to be buying stock thoughtfully.
It is a great thing to be buying stock thoughtfully and holding it for a period.
And it is just as important to sell the stock when it's no longer good.
But nobody used to think of stock like that.
And everybody thought that this is something, you know, where you go and bet your way to,
you know, riches.
And effectively, you know, it was actually betting your way to poverty.
Right.
So 2006 was when you launched the magazine.
And you say that there were so many platforms out there
that were creating the noise around stock investing.
How was Wealth Insight different then?
Wealth Insight has nothing short term in its content.
Wealth Insight only talked about how to invest.
Why think long term?
Why think fundamental?
Why not to speculate?
Because everybody, you know, when you come across this large number of people in dabbling in stock,
they are not investors.
They're really dabbling.
They're speculating in stock.
They're doing something for a couple of hours, a couple of days, maybe a day, maybe overnight.
These are the terminologies.
Buy today, sell tomorrow is one of the product of the brokers.
So I think, you know, we brought about a degree of thoughtfulness for all our subscribers.
And, you know, soon after we launched, the market has not, you know, touched its peak.
It was middle of 2000 or close to 2007.
Actually, the market started tanking since January 22nd, 2008.
And before that, we had hit a peak circulation of 1,10,000.
And people used to, you know, wait for our magazine.
Wealth Insight, in the peak of the bull run, our office will start getting phone calls
that where is Wealth Insight today's second, today's third.
And we did not have a digital copy then.
So it was quite remarkable.
People were, you know, there was an appetite.
People were craving for fundamental ideas, thoughtful ideas, credible things.
And not that, you know, we did a good job.
When the whole market went up and when it came down,
many of the things that we said also turned out to be bad or wrong or not so good.
But we were able to bring about awareness about long-term thinking, fundamentally guided,
fact-led investment rather than speculation or, you know, just based on tip.
So you mentioned 1,10,000, close to that, subscribers.
How did the magazine reach that, you know, that level of success at that time?
No, we were very lucky.
What happened was, you know, value research is known as the mutual fund guys,
the ratings, the data and information.
So we have, we are the vendors.
We are the information provider to ICICI Direct since its beginning.
ICICI started in, you know, it got, you know, they started putting it together in 1999.
And we were an eight, nine-year-old company.
And they came to us for the data and our data is embedded in ICICI Direct.
So when this stock market boom happened,
they had this idea that they should come out with a publication, an independent research.
And they came to us that, you, why don't you create a magazine for us?
And we thought that, okay, this is a great opportunity.
So it was their idea.
It was, no, they wanted us to underwrite the customer base.
They want, they, ICICI even then, in 2000, they had close to a million customers.
And they wanted to please their premium customers, that they were about a lakh of them.
So one-tenth of their customers, they wanted to give them something fanciful.
And they were very successful.
And it was the largest brokerage in the country.
Even today, it may not be the largest, but it will be the most profitable one.
And so they came to us that produce something high quality for our customers.
And we thought that this is a great opportunity.
That is how Wealth Inside got created.
And that is how we got a captive market of interested customers.
Not only interested in, you know, stock investor, but premium stock investor in 2000.
And that turned out to be a boom for us.
And how long did the partnership last?
It lasted for not very long.
What happened was, you know, it started in 2006 middle.
And 2008 beginning, the market cracked.
Right.
And market cracked and went on, you know, the whole global financial crisis,
the Indian market debacle, and, you know, another seven, eight months.
And then ICICI just gave up on that.
So that I had a choice of, you know, closing down the Wealth Inside magazine.
And ICICI wanted me to close down the magazine and pay me some money that,
OK, we took the risk and it did not work out.
We were not expecting ICICI direct to back out.
But, you know, that was the context.
We were very committed to run Wealth Inside because I had a very passionate team.
We had some thought process and it was getting refined.
Every month we will struggle that what should be the cover story.
Because, you know, mutual fund, we had mastered mutual fund over the last 18 years.
There was also thought that, you know, mutual fund is very important.
Mutual fund is very useful.
Mutual fund is very, you know, critical to investors financial success,
for naive investors financial success.
It has a lot of good things embedded into its design.
But it's not that interesting.
It's not.
It's boring.
Stocks give the thrill.
No, that thrill is of a different kind.
I'll just come back to it.
You know, in case of mutual fund, we have always at value research,
we have been telling creating awareness that keep it boring, keep it simple.
Buy few funds.
Be at it.
Keep doing your SIP.
Increase your SIP as your income rises.
And that is all there to it.
And that is a great recipe to financial success.
But when it comes to building wealth,
there is much more to stocks than just, you know, the thrill.
The thrill is of a different kind.
The most investors, most people who are actually pretending to be investors,
the speculators who are this 9 to 5, you know, 9 to 330 gang.
These people, they are having fun.
They are having fun.
And it is nearly impossible.
We have deep belief that, you know,
it is impossible to guess the market on a day to day basis.
It is nearly impossible to get the market on a short term basis.
And it is reasonably OK to, you know,
it is reasonably predictable in the medium term, in the long term.
And we thought that, you know, this overlay of understanding,
overlay of fact led investment equity research, filtering it.
So, you know, one of the feature in Wealth Insight to begin with was stock ideas,
which was nothing but a stock filter, filtering stocks based on six, seven parameters.
And that remains the most popular thing even today.
In fact, it is available live on our website.
In fact, I had a very funny conversation with a CIO of a leading fund company.
What happened was he was we were doing the money masters about two months back.
And he said that he has stopped getting wealth insight and he's finding,
you know, he's missing out on those stock ideas,
the stock filters, which is at the last 20 pages of the magazine.
So, you know, we brought him back to the maybe during COVID times,
you know, we discontinued that physical copy for a couple of months.
And that that is how it remained.
So we went about doing very simple things in Wealth Insight.
And it is a magazine of stock ideas.
It is a magazine of validating your stock ideas.
It is a magazine of giving you framework for choosing stocks.
It is a magazine of giving reinforcement to the long term thinking.
Because what happens is, you know, COVID happened and everybody panicked.
Wealth Insight came and said that why you should not panic
if the world is not coming to an end.
Why, you know, bringing this very simple perspective that, you know,
here is a company.
It's not the stock.
Stock is like, you know, something moving up and down.
But there are, you know, when it comes to, you know,
it's a representation of ownership of a company.
Every day market moves dramatically.
And people quickly invent a reason to justify it.
I find it quite, I would like to, you know,
write a satire and a humorous column on value research online and in Wealth Insight too.
Because I find that, you know, a lot of people are faking it.
And Wealth Insight actually does a very simple job of
getting the context of what are you investing in.
Right.
Now let's try and shift gears a bit.
There are a lot of people who ask who should be investing in stocks
and who shouldn't invest in stocks.
So what is the advice that you would give to someone who's now ready to take the plunge?
One is that somebody should invest in equity market
who has at least five plus year time frame in mind.
Let me just, you know, give you one example.
I was actually referring to it while writing a column
that a lot of people get up in the morning,
the market opens, buy something at 10 rupees, sell it at 11.
Then buy the same stock at 20, six months later, and sell it at 21.
Then buy it again at 30 after it has gone up and sell it at 31.
And then they feel happy about it, that every time they bought it gained a rupee.
And it's meaningful for a couple of days.
But the real point is somebody who misses the whole point
of something more from 10 to 31 is actually should not be investing in stock.
He's doing something else.
He's actually having fun.
The one is that, you know, you have to invest in stocks.
Only if you have five plus years in your mind, anything less than five years,
don't think of investing in even an equity fund.
Forget about stocks directly.
Then comes, you know, investing in stocks.
You need three things for this.
You need time.
You must be interested.
And then, you know, you should have a little bit of understanding
of how to look at companies, how to look at numbers, how to read the balance sheet
and ability to absorb that in your mind, that what happens here.
You are not buying a stock.
You are buying a proportionate ownership of a company.
And then the most important thing is if you don't have the temperament,
if you are actually investing to have fun, if you are investing to actually have quick money,
if you are not interested, so you have the time,
you have the inclination, you can understand companies, but you won't thrill out of it.
It's not meant for them because it requires being thoughtful about it,
being able to hold through a company when it's going through a lean patch,
when the market is going through a lean phase.
And that, I think, is one of the biggest differentiators
of a great investor or a successful investor.
And if you don't have that, choose a good fund,
choose two, three good funds and value search will help you with those.
And then a little bit of mechanics, diversification in your portfolio,
assuming that you choose to invest in stock.
But then you can also go wrong with many of your
judgment about those companies, despite all the information.
Information is not going to reduce risk.
Information will help you judge better or be thoughtful about it.
It will give you a premise to think.
And you will have to bring in your risk controls yourself.
You will have to buy 10 stocks because if you buy one stock,
because you have done a great research,
that does not guarantee that that company will actually only succeed.
You will go wrong, how to spread your risk, how much where not to.
And those things of temperament, framework, all these things are very useful.
And if you don't have these, don't invest in stocks.
And if you are, read Wealth Insight,
and you could well be on your way to be a thoughtful investor.
So you think someone who has time, temperament, inclination,
only they should be, you know, they should be investing in stocks.
Only those people, because Wealth Insight cannot help you.
You know, we will give you a great analysis of a company.
That these are the companies, you know, look at this current issue.
100 baggers look like a clickbait, but, you know, we are giving you a framework.
We are giving you a framework that what makes a 100 bagger.
We have looked at, you know, last 40 years of market history in India.
And which are the companies which have proved to be 100 baggers?
What were their symptoms?
What were their characters?
What was driving them?
And if you have to look for similar symptoms, which are the companies that you find here?
But we are not saying that by these 10 companies that they will be 100 baggers.
They are not.
They will not be 100 baggers.
You have to apply your judgment because all these 100 baggers,
they will go through phases when they will struggle.
And if you don't understand it, if you don't have the temperament,
if you don't have that belief, but try and read it.
We are giving you a framework.
We are giving you ideas.
We are giving you thought, you know, very high quality food for thought.
And so they look at it as a very high quality curated,
honest, you know, food for thought by people who are very passionate about it.
And it could be a great catalyst to your,
you know, in your journey to build a great equity portfolio, stock portfolio.
All right.
So markets will swing, but conviction comes from understanding,
understanding the companies worth owning.
And that's why Wealth Insight and Stock Advisor service is there.
To wrap up, let's take a quick look at the team that makes Wealth Insight what it is today.
Thank you.
