Impact Investing Movement – Insights and Stories

Invest Insight
9 followers
All right, looks like everyone's settling back in. What a wonderful morning. Just such a blessing.
Thank you, Dr. Jerry Wedigan. He's going to stay with us through noon and then he's off to disciple
someone else over lunch. So yeah, it shows a lot about how he manages his time and what he
prioritizes. So we wanted to start kind of this, the rest of the day with the big picture
of values-driven investing. And it's in headlines all the time. I mean, it's hard to miss. ESG,
it's often called. And more than ever, I think, in the history of investing, there's a lot of
discussion about values-driven investing. And people are now faced with decisions,
moral and ethical decisions about where they place their capital and how and why. And there's
options on either side of the spectrum. And there's more options than ever on the Christian
side of the spectrum. And we have some thought leaders with us today, which is just a huge
blessing. Many of you could have been up on stage. These are the three we chose. So thank you very
much. I'll introduce them in a minute. But please take a moment to look over the bio page that we
put in your folder, because we're not going to go through long introductions on bios. We're just
going to share a few highlights before each person goes. So please, please take a look at
that. So we have Greg Learnahan, Rachel McDonough, and DG Elmore here with us today. So where is
faith-driven impact investing in Talented? What's the context of the environment we're operating in?
And that's really what this is all about. So after this, the next session, we'll zone in deeply on
Talented. But we wanted to start kind of with the big picture. So we're going to start with Greg
Learnahan, and he's going to give a little presentation. He's the chairman of the Impact
Foundation and a growing national voice in this whole discussion, and deeply involved in the
faith-driven investing movement. After a successful career as Siemens as a senior VP for over 20 years
covering all of North America, he started Convergent. They have over 2,300 staff now.
And did you sell Convergent? Are you still involved? I'm still probably sold as well.
Okay, both. Great. Okay, awesome. And now he's kind of turning his attention to
really deploying personal capital, family capital for the kingdom in a variety of areas. So Greg,
why don't you go ahead and kick us off with your presentation? I assume we're hot here. Good
morning. Good morning. I'm going to stand. It's so much easier. I couldn't have followed a better
person. Jerry, thanks for everything you said, because I'm just going to echo many things that
you said. As John said, I was blessed with starting a company from scratch and actually
we're a lot larger than 2,000. Now we're actually 9,000 globally. And what Jerry said, I had
absolutely nothing to do with it. I just showed up and I have no idea why God blessed this company
other than we blessed others with shares and things like that. So my life changed very quickly
when I went to Haiti in 2012, two years after the earthquake, and I'd already read the book
Halftime, Success to Significance. So I left my job day-to-day of running this company,
and then I decided to dedicate my time, talent, and treasure to being the underserved,
the marginalized. And so for the last 10 years, I've been involved in impact investing full-time.
That's what I do with my son. We also have a granting arm as well. And that's money that
we've sold a few times. We sell a little bit and sell a little bit. I'm still involved with it,
but God has blessed us. So today we have investments in 140 investments today in 80
different companies. We do it full-time. We take it very seriously. And I had no idea what I was
doing 10 years ago when I started, but I just put that away. So what I'm hoping during my 10 minutes
is we're at the tip of the spear in this room. Anybody could be up here speaking, so I'm almost
embarrassed because many of you know everything as much as I do. So I'm just going to share from
my viewpoint. I don't think I have all the answers. In fact, I know I don't, but we need you to join
us. Now there's people in the room every time I speak, and they'll say, well, I can't really
solve this problem with nonprofit dollars. Well, if you look at this slide, you'll see a little
green square there, and that stands for $485 billion that have been donated for charitable
causes. And that's a really great number. The problem is it's been about the same for 40 years.
It's 2% of GDP, goes up a couple of percent one year. David would know this. Anybody in the
nonprofit space would know this. And we have 1.5 million people trying to get money from a square
that's not getting bigger. The rest of that gray area, I think Rachel may comment on this as well,
is investable assets across the world. This one's United States. It's either 20 trillion
or it's 200 trillion. It's a lot of money. And so here's two facts you may want to remember.
Number one, from 1970 to 2020, there were only 144 nonprofits that got larger
than $50 million. At the same time, there were 46,136 companies that built a for-profit company
greater than $50 million. There is nothing to debate in this room that we cannot solve our
social problems with grant dollars. Now we love grant dollars. You can't take them down.
They make a major contribution. But if we're going to solve the global issues,
we have to use capital from the marketplace. Second quote is from UN Sustainable Development
Goals. It talks about poverty, food, water. They estimate that we will leave $4 trillion
the next 15 years. So if we assume that to be the case, we were blessed with what they call
a wealth event. We didn't even know what that was. But one day we had money in our bank that
didn't have in the day before. And it wasn't a pleasant experience. It was a burden to us.
We were very uncomfortable with it. And we sat down and said, what are we supposed to do?
Let's look at the Bible. What do they tell you to do when you have resources? And we'll get lots
of problems because we have parable of talents, which you built a company on. And I'm going to
have a different opinion here in a second. And they say, of course, double your talents,
do everything possible. And then we have over here with Luke saying, sell all your possessions and
give it away. And then in Acts, they're sharing everything. And if you didn't share it, they
killed the God. Wife didn't even know. She comes a little late. She's dead. So we don't want to die.
So in our case, my wife went back and got a degree, her master's in biblical studies.
So I am not a theologian. I'm a Christian businessman trying to apply biblical principles
in stewarding God's resources. So there may be some theologians in the room. These are theologians
I talk to. And so we take the parable of talents as the toughest one. We all know it doubles. We
all know we got it. But we don't see it quite that way after talking to theologians. And we see it
more as the master was upset because the one who buried his talents didn't even get bank interest.
He said, I would have been even happy if you had got me bank interest, which is the lowest possible
return. The other two, of course, he acknowledged they double their returns. Great job. But we
interpret this not as just a financial return, but at a risk reward. What did you do for the
kingdom, for the master? Did you risk my capital? He never said he'd be more happy with three times.
He left that to our imagination. So we, after interpreting it with theologians and pastors,
is we see this as God's resources, and we're directed to take risks with his resources.
They're not our resources. So we do take risks. And so from this in our family, we decided that
we're going to give money away. We're also going to invest money through what we call faith-driven
investing. When we first started, I was on the impact side, which to me is a secular term.
And so that was social and financial. I just got out of my business day-to-day. Literally,
the next day, I Google some people. And that Monday, I'm working. And I want to deploy some
capital. We'll go back to this. And so we had done some investments the first couple of years and
I'm doing social investing. I'm excited about it. Trying to change the world. And I sit next
to Pete Oaks at a dinner, and Pete's doing faith with it. I'm going, what do you mean you can do
faith with? I didn't even know that there was this. Well, we hadn't really started the movement.
And so that really changed the way we invested. And so when we've graphed our first investments,
you can't see along the bottom, but that's a financial return on the X and social and
the Y. So the perfect winning quadrant is up in that right corner. That's how every two-by-two
works. And we started graphing our investments. And we see up in the top left that we have
investments in areas that have low financial returns, but they could have gone to the right
and say, how did that happen? So we labeled these and talked about it for hours. And one
is buried talents. Obviously, no one wants to ever be in that quadrant. The next one is where
all the capital is in the world. Today, everywhere across the world, somebody's trying to make more
money, grow the IRR. They could care less. Christians, for sure. And that's where all
the capital is in the world. Then there's some minor amount of money in that top quadrant called
maximizing talents. And there's almost zero money in that upper left-hand quadrant. And what we
found is the only time you're in that upper left-hand quadrant is when the Spirit is moving
you. The Holy Spirit's doing it because you can't justify it financially. You wouldn't be in that
left quadrant. That's low returns. And so in our family, we started noticing that we were driven
by those investments. And the ones we talked to our friends about were always the upper left,
Spirit-led investments. The one that are, and I'll explain here in a second,
they're with the marginalized. So on the right-hand side, I'd like all the Christians in
this room, which are all, you're down 99% of your portfolio is probably in that capitalistic bucket.
And we have a lot of money there yet as well. We're moving it to try to go up to the maximizing
talent quadrant. There are funds. There's 75 funds according to Henry Kastner. And what you'll see,
the difference when we invest on the right-hand side, this is good. You want to be there. They're
looking for scale. On the left-hand side, those same people are looking for sustainability,
just trying to stay alive. On the right-hand side, you're going to see return on investments
driving those because you all put money in, you want them to maximize plus social and spiritual
returns. On the left-hand side, they're just looking for human flourishing. On the right-hand
side, they have abundant opportunities for jobs because they're mainly in the United States.
On the left-hand side, we're hiring the marginalized, the underserved, the returning
citizens, people that are hard to find. And on the right-hand side, they're in established markets.
On the left, they're in developing markets. So in our case, our family has decided we want half of
our investments in spirit-led quadrants and half of them in the maximizing talents. So talenting
in our model, which has a lot of subjectivity to it, is not at that midpoint. It's just to the left.
I was going to show you all of our investments because we have dots all over the place and
they're all 50-50 now. Talented is right about to the left of focus, human flourishing. They have an
8% return. We're going to do great. And we couldn't be doing a better job with the spiritual and the
social component. Here's where, and I have a couple more slides and I'm done. Here's where
it gets challenging. To be a redemptive investor, you have to, I sacrifice, we win, which goes
against everything we've been trained. It's win-win since we've been young kids. And it's easy to get
Christians to go from that capitalistic straight up for the exact same return, for the exact same
everything, I'm willing to do it. The second you start to go to the left a little bit, that's when
they start to get squirmish. They start to say, geez, that's terrible of talents. I'm supposed
to double everything and you're asking me to take less return. That's really hard. And so what I
would tell you is GIN stands for Global Impact Investing Network, collects data on impact
investing and 33% of the secular world said they would take lower returns all the way down to
return of capital for a cause they believed in. Faith-driven, 17%. So our faith-filled people,
where's Kathy? Somewhere in your tummy. It's one of my facts for you. Faith-filled people are less,
and I don't know where Don Simmons, I know he's here somewhere because I got a slide on him,
but Don Simmons will support this as well. The further you go left, Christians run. And I feel
terrible to say that to a group of Christian people that you're in the left quadrant here,
but we need you to evangelize from this conference to others, and you're going to find them very
uncomfortable in that space. And I would tell you now, after doing this for about eight years,
it is rewarding. It's not sacrificial for us to go to that upper left-hand quadrant. We seek it.
We desire it. We get motivated by Kentegra. We get motivated by Masaka Creamery. We get
motivated by Verdant, which some of you know. We get motivated by Talentant.
When we're in the field, it makes all the difference in the world. And the return,
that's up to God. At the end of the day, people say, what kind of return are you looking for?
We don't have a number on it. We just say, Lord, these are your resources. Our whole life changed
when we said, Lord, help us to understand that these are your resources, because we used to be
90-10. And then when you have a wealth event, 90-10 is nothing. And we said, we can't live like
that. There's no sacrificial giving here. And so we changed on that moment to say, these are
His resources. And it took us years. So a lot of you are way ahead of us, because 15 years ago,
I would have said 90-10, that's the gig I got going. But after that, we now are 100%. So that
every dollar are God's dollars. And so that means when you go to invest, risk isn't nearly as
important, because we don't believe Jesus will come back and say, you took too much risk there,
or not enough risk, and you were in Silicon Valley. I'll comment on that one more slide.
This is a slide I want Don Simmons to see, because this is hard as a Christian. But he wrote a book,
you should all read, The Servant Leader, Stuart Investor, he's a terrific guy, you'll see him
speak. And it says, it's easier to pry a steak bone from a hungry pit bull's mouth than it is
to persuade a wealthy Christian to reinvest resources for God's purposes. And that's really
harsh. That's really harsh, but it's true. We would say, I'd rather make a pitch to a secular
person, because when they're really positive about the experience that cash is not as important in
our case, we start with spiritual return first. Second, we start with social, and third is
financial, and then we trust the Lord. And this one here, I have this fear that one day I'm going
to wake up, and there's an email that says, from God to Greg, what did you do with the resources?
I haven't trust you, see in a couple months or years, eternity. And so you got to remember,
he has timeline is not the same as ours. So I know what's coming, and it sits there and say,
hey, by the way, let me know how those exits went that I helped you with. You like that? That was
good. What did you do with the marginalized? How many poor did you help? How many people did you
bring to Christ? And I'm going to sit there and say, we gave us a lot of money, and I was in the
upper right-hand quadrant, Jesus, the entire time. So I'll close with, Jerry helped us here. I
imagine the people on the panel say the same thing. After doing this for 10 years, which I didn't know
this 10 years ago, is the number one thing we can do is provide jobs, jobs, jobs, jobs, jobs, jobs.
I've been in clean water. I get it. Education, I get it. Healthcare, I get it. But when you give
a person the dignity of work, everything changes. They don't always want grant dollars. They want
jobs. And I was so proud of what Dave was talking about, 100 jobs here, 150 jobs there. We get
excited about 10, 20, 30. So the second thing is the only way we're going to get out, no one's
ever served their way out of poverty or served a community out of poverty. You can look at Haiti
for itself, $13 billion they got in grant capital, and it's as big a mess as it's ever been.
And then the last one is we need Christians to lead. So everyone in this room, which is unusual,
is already out in front here, because this is early. Our faith-driven investment movement
is early. So I thank you for being bold and courageous. Greg, thank you so much. A little
wonderful message to kick it off. And Rachel, before you go, I'll just say this.
I was always stunned with our early investors. We'd give them our story. David and I did a lot
of that. Harry and Iris, certainly, and Michelle. And when someone said yes, I almost said like,
really? Are you kidding me? We had hardly anything in our portfolio, hardly any AUM,
first-time fund managers. And I thought this is all about faith. And Greg was one of our
early investors, as was DG. And those folks really are our patrons alongside our board.
And we're going to introduce our board and investment committee here in a minute. So I
want to say thank you. And Rachel has her own amazing investment story. So Rachel,
you're up next. Rachel is a Certified Kingdom Advisor and a Certified Financial Planner.
She won the Kingdom Advisors National Organization, over 2,000 people at their
annual conference. Their Advisor of the Year Superstar Award, or MVP, what do they call it,
it's the Larry Burkett Award. And if you know Larry, you know how special and generous and
what a leader he was. Yeah, what an awesome thing for you to be associated with and to win.
And she's also a national voice now in this faith-driven investing movement. And it's just
wonderful to have you here. So yeah, go ahead and share a few slides, and then we'll turn it over
to you. Thank you, John. Well, I have to tell you, most of my clients, I'm a financial advisor,
if you didn't catch that. So most of my clients come to me and they're really interested in the
capitalistic quadrant. And I remember having a conversation with Henry Kastner a couple years
ago and said, I really am compelled by this deeper impact type of investing where you're
even accepting a concessionary rate of return. I said, you know, there is some little bit of
supply, some products that fit in that space. There's really no demand that I can tell. And he
said, Rach, no supply and no demand. Sounds like a tough business model. So I do, I think when new
investors come to me as a wealth manager, they pretty much are looking for a rate on return,
right? So my opportunity is to introduce them to something else, right? To whet their appetite.
For what could they want? And I think like Steve Jobs, when he was inventing, you know, for Apple,
he said, well, let's not give people what they want. Let's give them what they would want if
they knew to ask for it, right? And so we take kind of a head and heart approach to investing.
Some of the language that I'll use with investors is not overtly Christian-y, because I want them,
whatever position God sends them to us, if they're pre-Christian or they're disciples for many years,
we want to meet them wherever they're at in that journey, and then introduce them to heavenly
culture and heavenly values that whet their appetite to meet the King of Glory. Amen?
So I take a head and heart approach to investing, and most of it's focused on public markets
investing. So we do some impact investing, some private market stuff, but different for most of
you in the room, our focus is on managing the stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs.
Okay? So I would say investing has become, with the invention of the stock market, has become very
accessible to a large number of people. Anyone can participate. Even just the smallest investor
with $100 a month can become an investor, and that's powerful. But with the invention of the
stock market has also come a huge amount of complexity. There are now thousands of different
mutual funds and ETFs to choose from, thousands of managed products to choose from, thousands of
stocks and bonds to choose from. And what that's led to is really just the need to have a lot of
databases and companies that can help sort that information out and help an investor choose what
they ought to own and why. But what's gotten lost in all that complexity is that between the
investor and the company in which they invest, there are now many layers and much complexity.
So we have the financial advisor, we have the portfolio managers and the products that they use,
the analysts who support the portfolio managers to help them choose which stocks they're going
to invest in. We have the firms at which those managers and advisors work, and they may allow
or disallow certain types of investing. And we have the market itself with this fear and greed
governance mechanism that mostly results in a highly transactional experience in investing.
But the reality is, the hidden reality is that there are people, humans, image bearers on the
other side of each transaction. And if we show up to the investment decision with only our heads,
only our analytical skills in play, then we miss out on the nature in which God intended for us
to live, which is from the head and the heart, and to be led by his spirit. So at a minimum,
even if a Christian is not a Christian, or even if an investor is not a Christian investor,
we at least want to encourage them to pursue a parallel goal with their investing.
Now, everyone comes for the financial goal, let's call that productivity. This is the creation of
wealth, or the protection of wealth. And that's why people come to a financial advisor. We understand
that that's important to our clients, and it's our duty to help them meet their financial goals.
But we want to introduce them to the parallel goal. And I would think that a great way to
describe that parallel goal, I've heard it described different ways, biblically responsible
investing, or faith-based investing, or faith-driven investing. It's actually right-relatedness
is the parallel goal. And so we use flowers in that image to get us thinking back to the Garden
of Eden before the fall, when man was in right relationship with God, the creator, who would
come and walk with him in the cool of the day. And there was right relationship between people
laterally as well. We want to give back to that and use the vehicle and the mechanism of investing
to pull down heavenly culture and values back into the earth. The Word of God says that all
of creation groans and longs with eager expectation for the sons and daughters of God to be revealed.
We can't do that if we're not even in the game. We have to get in the game and have our voices be
heard, not just in sweet places like this. This is a sweet place. Are you feeling refreshed being
here? I'm feeling refreshed being here. We drove in yesterday and my husband said,
that guy's smiling at us. I wonder why he's smiling. I'm like, he's a Christian.
It's refreshing to be with the body of Christ and to just understand that the spirit of unity
and the bond of peace that we all long for, someday we're going to experience it every day
in heaven, but we're not there yet. We can't withdraw from the marketplace. I use a spectrum
as well. I don't want to give you too much. You've already gotten great frameworks from Greg,
but I just want to give you this in terms of that parallel goal. This is too small for you to see.
On the one end, we have pursuing only profit, which leads to a negative impact.
What Greg didn't dive into in his capitalistic quadrant is the reality
that much of the capitalistic quadrant is overtly exploitative. It's not just capitalistic.
We're Americans. We think capitalism is good, right? We don't actually think socialism is
all that attractive. One of us would cringe at that thought. Capitalism without love is
exploitation. There are humans on the other side of every investment transaction.
We don't want to pursue blind profit. On the other end of the spectrum, if we were only pursuing the
parallel, I've told you the parallel goals. If we were only pursuing the goal of positive impact,
those would be our charitable dollars. There's all this different opportunity in between where
we can pursue two goals at the same time. At a minimum, we want to accomplish our financial
goals without being exploitative. We want to have an ethical approach to investing at a minimum,
even if that's the bucket of capital that's more capitalistic. Then where we have opportunity,
we want to push the envelope and actually be seeking impact and deep impact through
investments like talent. I want to give you the three-bucket approach here.
Most of us, especially those who have a significant amount of wealth, there's really
more than one kind of mental category that we put it in. First, there's the provision for our
families and our lifestyle. This is biblical. It's good for you to think about how to provide
for your family. That's not wrong. There's also our charitable capital that we feel free and
empowered to release and sow into the kingdom. I think that bucket has the best rate of return.
If you've read Randy Alcorn's The Treasure Principle, then you know what I'm talking about.
It's kind of like we're all playing with this monopoly money, and someday the only thing that's
left is going to be whatever we sowed into the kingdom, right? Then there's this to-be-determined
bucket. It's a potential excess. You've done your financial plan, and it shows that there's enough
capital in the provision bucket. Then there's some that maybe you just don't feel released
to give away yet. Different approaches are going to work well with different types of capital.
I really see that as the primary job of a skilled financial advisor is to help
an investor work through in which buckets of capital can I be free to pursue impact over
profit? In which buckets of capital do I have a responsibility and an obligation
to invest for the benefit of my family, but also to invest ethically? When you don't need liquidity
like that middle bucket or maybe some parts of the provision bucket, then you can go deeper on
impact because you're not relying on the liquidity of public markets. There's a lot of really
innovative stuff happening in public markets investing. Anybody who wants to hear some
teasers on that or a deeper dive, our breakout session will cover that. Let's go back to the
parable of talents one more time because this is talented, and you can never talk about it enough.
What would the master say upon return from his journey if he found his steward
had in fact doubled or tripled or quadrupled the assets under management, but did so
by investing in the campaigns of the master's enemy while he was away? Campaigns which kill,
steal, and destroy. We're all on the same team here. I know that you are all leaders
in impact investing, but if you left your S&P 500 mutual fund in your public markets portfolio,
does it make any sense to lean in on deep impact with talent and then go ahead and give
a big chunk of your capitalistic bucket to the enemy to play with? Let's be thoughtful about each
bucket and how we have it deployed and seek to bless and serve and bring joy to the master.
This last slide, I don't know if you can see it or not. This is actually from Praxis. It's not mine.
I just made it pretty. We want to move from exploitative investing at least to ethical
investing. As we have opportunity, we want to make the most of every opportunity to press in
as the tip of the spear and be redemptive and bring about the culture of heaven on earth
through our investing. Thank you. Rachel, thank you so much. I want everyone to be thinking of
one or two questions. We'll have time for a few of those at the end in a bit of a panel discussion,
just to call out. DG, over to you. I know you don't have a presentation, but DG Elmore,
chairman of the board of The Navigator, so this is his home turf as well.
Been here many times. He told me about eight times a year, so isn't he lucky?
Owner of multiple businesses. Do you own the Colorado Springs minor league baseball team?
We do.
Okay. Yeah. It's been fun to have his daughter deeply involved at our investment committee.
She also is CEO of two or three family businesses. DG, any immediate response to what you just heard?
If not, then I'd love for you to share more about how you're integrating your faith
into your investment decisions as a family holding company.
John, the one thing that struck me as I was listening was the need to have our hearts
connected and what God's calling us into with our business mindsets and our business abilities.
I think it was a little bit concerning, but when I was listening, I was reflecting on
in many cases, the secular world is ahead of the followers of Christ, of how they're going to
reach in and accomplish those non-heavy capitalistic profit-oriented things,
whether it's in the area of climate change or all sorts of ESG sorts of things.
I don't mean those are bad, but they seem to be leading, and that's what I was hearing.
And as I reflected, I think that that was in many cases, in my reflections, I think that's
true and somewhat discouraging, I guess, that we need to be out there, I think, really leading
in that area of doing business in a way that is creating jobs, breaking down the cycle of poverty
and advancing the gospel of Jesus and his kingdom. And I think we just need to be much more conscious
about that. That's what I was hearing and certainly reflecting on that.
You know, as I think about the journey our family's been on, the parable that we have
thought a lot about is the one of the sower of the seed. And obviously that's speaking about
sowing the word, but I also think about it just in the pragmatic sense of the farmer who is out
sowing seed. And if we think about that as being our financial resources and our business resources,
to some extent, we heard a little bit about this, is that everything that we put our seed out in,
not everything we put our financial resources into, it's an entrepreneurial adventure out there,
is going to produce huge returns. Some of it is going to fall on rocky soil,
and it's just not going to take root, but we have to be willing to take that risk.
But the thing that we obviously love is when it starts coming up. And one of the things that has
driven our family is this idea that as we sow seeds, there's going to be a bountiful return of
30-fold, 60-fold, 100-fold. And that's what we want to do as individuals within our businesses
in investing in those companies that are going to produce returns that will continue to generate
returns. Not for me, I don't need more return. It's easy for me to be in that upper left because
for us, it's always been about charitable giving. So actually, it's sort of a weird mindset that,
oh, you're going to get a return on this money that you put at Talents. And it's like,
I don't need that return. I want those businesses to have that return that they generate more
revenue, more employment. I want the return up there in that upper left side because I want the
100-fold to be going to those entrepreneurs and going to those employees of those businesses.
So that's what has been part of our journey, and that's what gets I get fired up.
It's great to get fired up. We got a few people fired up here on stage, so that's been
really fun. And a lot of references to kind of the real heroes of this whole story, which is
the entrepreneurs, and we're going to hear from them all afternoon, so you can look forward to that.
And there's a breakout session with Rachel and Don Simmons on being a steward adventure,
and we'll spread around a bit and have more of a smaller group discussion. So that's coming.
I'm going to ask just a couple of questions, and I'll open it up to the audience. Rachel,
you made a very interesting comment. If you're invested in the S&P 500, you might want to
question that. Why? Yeah, so it's more fun to talk about positive investing than it is to talk
about the bad investing that happens that we all are sort of complicit in at one point or another
in our lives. And no one likes to talk about, oh, let's talk about what we're for and not what we're
against. But can I just say, investing in the S&P 500 gives you significant exposure to things
that violate your conscience. And it is inconvenient, and it is complicated to try
to work through that. It's messy, and it's imperfect. Like the portfolios we manage are
still imperfect portfolios. There aren't any perfect companies. But I think there is a holiness
and a righteous desire to be on this discipleship journey to say, we don't want to put our dollars
into investments blindly and abdicate our authority. If God put the talents that belong
to him into your account, they're for you to manage according to his values. And his values
don't align well with the S&P 500. For example, companies that profit from abortion, pornography,
gambling, tobacco that literally seeks another generation of victims to get as its customers.
Alcohol where, I mean, I may enjoy a glass of wine, I shouldn't say that I'm at the
Navigator's tier thing. But I also don't want to be an investor and an owner of a business where
maybe 90% of the profits come from 10% of the customers because it's clearly feeding off of
addiction. So our responsibility and our opportunity is to think which of these companies need to be
eliminated from my investment portfolio. And with the companies that remain in my investment
portfolio, maybe they're doing some things I don't love, but I don't think they're a bad
company altogether. Then let me engage and have the faith driven voice be heard in the marketplace.
Right now it's almost all the way silent. Even just not even faith-based, but even just a
conservative voice is almost all the way silent. We need to get better at engaging with the
marketplace. And there are some really exciting things, people that are developing services where
they can advocate and vote proxies on your behalf in alignment with your kingdom values.
Okay. Wow. Everyone go back and look at your portfolios, I guess.
Yeah. Yeah. Thanks for the challenge, Rachel. It's just so important. Keeping in mind 1 Chronicles
29, that all resources are God's. It's really based in scripture that what you're saying,
and we have more transparency now to actually do our homework and be held accountable to that.
So I think that's a great call out. Greg, you also said something super interesting.
How many hundred some investments you've made?
We have 140.
Yeah, 140. You choose one and hit in two or three minutes and say why you're particularly
excited about it. Maybe a story of a live transformed or something that you say,
because I know you guys do a lot of strategy and digging. I work a lot with Greg's son, Tom,
like DG. Both have deeply involved their families in everything they do, which is really, really
cool. And I love working with your son. So what's the one you'd call out and say, this is an example
of just a fantastic impact? Yes, plenty, but I'll start with one because it's an African-based
crowd. That's what we're thinking about in Uganda. The company's name is PureFlow. I think
we have an investor over there. And what they do, it was started by two people from America that
were in East Africa trying to solve problems. And they saw all these motorcycles. If you've never
been to a developing country, they're called Bota-Bota drivers. And you'll see five people
on it, three people, eight people. It's like a little cab. They take you from here to there.
They get paid. And 80% of them did not own their bicycles or motorcycles. And they were charged
relatively high rates. So this young man said, this is what I'm going to do. I'm going to help
them own their bikes, motorcycles. And so we had 6,000 to his name. The video is four minutes if
you want to go to PureFlow. He really does a wonderful job doing it. And he said, all my life
savings was 6,000 bucks out the door, drove six motorcycles. And he said, I didn't think they were
going to come back. And sure enough, the next day they came back. And he's created a business
where we loan them money at 8%, a number that we seem to think we can raise capital off of.
And over 12, 18, or 24 months, they own their own motorcycle. That increases their take-home
pay by 50%. It's okay. That's really good, right? The nice thing is if you got $20 million,
you could do this over a million motorcycles in East Africa. None of these are, they're all at
the bottom of the pyramid where we're working. But you're saying, well, where's the spiritual side?
They come in once a week. He pours into them, reads the Bible, shares stories,
talks to them about community. It's incredible. So in our bullseye, it's led by faith,
pouring into individuals, 8% return we'll take. There's no collateral behind it. The whole thing
could go out of business tomorrow. So I don't want to make Africa sound like it's easy,
but we can't wait to invest again. And I would tell other Christians, just look at it. I'm not
an investment advisor. My risk tolerance may be higher, but what they're doing is pure.
And the people that are helping, like Rachel said, we get excited. We have a wealth advisor
and it's down in the right capitalistic side. And I can hardly stay awake, no offense,
in that business because I'm not moved by that unknown stock went up 4%. I'm literally going,
I got to get it out of there. I got to get it out of there. And then I go in the upper left-hand
quadrant. I get super excited about PureFlow. And if it goes under, I don't need the money.
We're going to redeploy that money. That's all we're going to do. And I have more if you want.
That's great, Greg. Well, thank you. And Greg will be helping to facilitate one of the breakout
sessions. So more time with him if you choose his group. DG, question, then we'll go to the
floor here for a couple of questions. I've always been intrigued as to your perspective with your
family businesses about how you make decisions and how you integrate faith into due diligence,
into how you then post-investment support. Maybe you could share a story too, rather than just kind
of high level. But if there's one that comes to mind where you've seen a breakthrough or a
transform life. So it's a broad question, but I'll leave it to you to answer it how you like.
Thanks, John. So the businesses we own, they're just normal companies that do different things,
staffing, food manufacturing, things like that. And we like to have operating partners who own
part of the company. And we don't have a requirement that they're Christian. And so
I've got many stories I could tell. I'll tell one about a good friend, Todd, who grew up Catholic,
walked away from the faith, didn't really have much of a faith journey going on. And so we're
working together. And I just personally take a view that I'm going to share about Jesus with
people just in the midst of life. Because we're going to be together. Todd's running one of the
companies. We're going to be together for years. And so there's this one time that we'd spent all
day together at a business, and we're now getting ready to take the red eye from Los Angeles back
to Chicago. And it's 11 o'clock at night, and we're sitting at gate 72, getting ready to get
on United Airlines. And he says to me, he says, I've figured it out. I said, you figured it out?
He said, what do you mean? He said, it's all about faith and grace and the grace of Jesus
and putting my faith in him. And I was like, holy cow, this is amazing. So yeah, right there. I'm
still getting emotional, as you can tell about it. Because he said, we're still together. We've been
now partners for 20 plus years. And he's got a really good walk with God. He's been through some
tough stuff. But it is just being with people in business. And that's a dynamic. I think that's
the thing many of us can appreciate is being in business with people and sharing life on your life
in the midst of that business takes us to places with those people that we would not get with
anybody else. We would not have that opportunity. You know, my neighbor that I see,
you know, maybe once a week, and maybe have a meal with them once a month. I mean,
that takes it. But here, what day after day, year after year of us just living and life together
in the home, in the business, on the phone, in the emails, that is so significant. That's what I love
about what Talenton does, in terms of taking business and using it as a pathway to introduce
people to Jesus and living like Jesus with them. TG, thank you so much. You know, we have time for
just one or two quick questions. But I will say this, one of the key learnings at Talenton,
and you know, post-investment support is one of the key parts of our strategy for impact,
obviously, because we have that long-term relationship with all of our investments.
So we tried outsourcing to a mentoring organization, really good organization,
faith-driven. We had a little bit of uptake. We worked with the Navigators, fantastic organization.
And what we've learned is that it's really us on the Talenton team. You know, we're the ones who
build deep relationships and due diligence. We're the ones who call them every quarter looking for
financial results. We're the ones who, you know, have the opportunity for life on life.
So we thought, well, we're too busy doing due diligence, raising capital,
let's outsource some of this. And it was a mistake we made. We learned, we're learning,
I should say, that it's really us. And it doesn't have to be some big structured program. It's more,
this is African investing. Investing in the world, quite honestly, there's going to be ups and downs.
And when there's those downs in particular, you can step in, and we've done this two or three
times, restructure loans, help them get through a very difficult stretch, not gone to use our
security, getting the same return in the long run, and doing that sort of thing. And we've done quite
a bit of that. So it's been a blessing. So a couple of quick questions, and then a couple of
short answers. We have a lot more time together this afternoon and breakout, so don't worry if
there's not enough Q&A. Eric's got a roving mic, it looks like. So anybody got a question? Here we
go. Brian, it looks like you raised your hand. Yeah. Oh, okay. We'll go to you a second,
Brian. I guess I'll kick it off. Would love your insight, all three of you, any and all,
of what do you perceive as the obstacles that are causing the Christian communities at large to lack
the imagination both to, well, first of all, to understand that all resources, they have our gods,
we have our gods, but also to take the risk and kind of move forward with this. And so not only
what are the blocks, but how have each of you been able to kind of disarm or disable those
blocks that kind of move somebody forward, if there are examples of that? I do this all day.
I would say the big block is really the worship of Mammon. Because Mammon wants, there was a
wonderful Andy Crouch teaching through FDI. If any of you have not heard it, I encourage you to just
Google it. It's really fantastic. Yeah, it's amazing. But Mammon desires our worship. And the
more of it there is, the more gravity it has. So the more wealth, I think you mentioned feeling
the sense of burden, right? Like when there's a huge amount in the bank account, it comes with
this burden to it. And the more of it there is, the more gravity it's trying to pull on us, right?
And it's pulling and desiring for us to put our trust in it, rather than to put our trust in the
living God. Yeah, I mean, that's a good question, but I'm not sure why it seems to impact Christians
more strongly specifically, but that is the number one obstacle that I would say is just
helping people move past. They're even worried about market rate investments, like what if it
returns a half a percent less because I apply my ethical filter? And really, it's surprising.
I had the pleasure to serve a wonderful investor, $10 million investor in his late 70s,
cancer survivor, $10 million, late 70s. This does not take a lot of financial planning.
Let's give it away. Probably going to be okay. But he was so distraught over the losses in the
markets. And of course, I'm trying to think, well, this is a person who has a significant
opportunity for impact investing. But it's just the pace at which we're willing to allow
change to come. It's how much are we putting our trust in, even sometimes finding our identity
in what's on our balance sheets instead of in the living God. So I'd say, as you probably have
observed, one of the things I like to do is to persuade people. I love to just turn on that
persuasive, let me see if whoever has ears to hear, let them hear. Let me just give the message.
But it's really through prayer is the times when I've seen the Lord is really the only one who can
change hearts. So we do our faithful duty and do the part that God's given us to do and then pray
that God changes the heart. And sometimes he does. Let me make a couple comments, Kathy. Number
one, I saw a curve years ago and I have not been able to find it again. And it's a U. So picture
going like this. And it has income on the Y and has anxiety on the X. And with a low amount of
income, you have a high anxiety. And then the anxiety tends to drift down once you make more
income. Then there comes another point where you're making too much income and the anxiety
comes back. Because I'm friends with a person who's very wealthy and he's like, I just, I'm
afraid I'm going to lose it. And I'm afraid I'm going to lose it. And I think that's overwhelming
to some people. The other is, and I can't wait for this to happen, men, you know,
barroom chat or whatever, yeah, you should see the return I got on that investment. We killed
22%. You don't hear anybody saying, I got a 4% investment in South Africa and you should hear
about it. No one talks about it. And so that's unfortunate, but here's the good news. Rachel can
talk more on as well is the world's going to change very soon. All the money's going to the
women and the women are better purposeful care. Don't joke. It's going from 10 to 30 trillion
over the next, I think it's seven years by 2030 and women invest differently. They're going to
be much more impact oriented and all the young generation is coming. They're totally into brands
that are making a difference. So the good news is if we can get the Christians to help lead in this,
it's coming regardless. Women are going to do it and the kids. Hey man, that's the whole values
driven sweeping everything. You have to choose sides a bit. We have time for one more quick
question. Uh, if it's, uh, you raised your hand. So, and uh, yeah. Oh, two, there's two.
I bought, I had to grab it out of the air.
Um, I guess I'm wondering Greg DG, I heard you both say something along the lines of,
I don't need the return. I I'm, I'm playing for a different return. I don't need the return to feed
my family. I wonder what your older self would have said to your younger self if you were
considering how you were investing about investing dollars that you do need. When you're thinking
about your experience here and in light of this, it does all belong to God. And for some reason,
the story that came to my mind as I was processing, processing that as the story of the,
the widow, you know, Christ watching people giving in the widow's mind, she gave what she needed.
I just wonder if you, how would you reflect on that at all? Part of the burden that Rachel
mentioned that I brought up, I would never profess that we have done sacrificial giving yet.
Um, and I'm, I struggle with that. We are going to give all our money away in the next 10 years.
We're sunsetting it and we're still, so our goal, we're going to get zero. And now what we struggle
with is what's the number that you keep just to stay alive. One of the smarter things we did was
we, um, will to our kids that are young adults now that have had children and are very established.
We gave them a small percentage and that's a fixed number now. So my son is on investing,
doesn't care per se. He's following the kingdom. If not, I think the devil would be in his ear
saying, go to this one for 22%. When they die, you're going to make all that money.
And now it doesn't matter. He's not gonna make any money. It's all going to the kingdom.
But my younger self was capitalistic and tithing. That was it. No question about it.
And then once you have a wealth event and I can't afford not to have the money come back,
I realized everybody has a different economic status, but it still comes back to
what number can you live on? Is it my dad in the small town, Michigan city, Indiana,
never made more than $20,000 in his life and $30,000. He could live like a king,
Washington DC, San Francisco, maybe a little more. And so we still struggle with that.
And what we've done where I said it originally was a burden. Literally, my wife and I were
sitting there saying, I don't want to ruin our kids. I don't want to ruin our kids. I don't
want them wishing for us to die. I don't want to ruin our kids. And then after a handful of years
of doing it, we said, this is a responsibility. We're going to steward this for God. And we
finally got to the point this is God's resources. But now in the last year, I would say that wealth
has been a blessing, which if you'd asked me 10 years ago, I couldn't have even in a thousand
years come up with a blessing. The reason I say a blessing, our son got involved, our daughter's
involved, our daughter-in-law's involved, and we offered nothing to any of them. We didn't ask them
to come to work with us. And they're around Christ-centered people every day of the week.
And what happened to them is they become more Christ-centered. They have empathy for Africa.
And I couldn't pay for that. And if we did not get this wealth event that I think we are stewarding,
God has blessed us for some reason, because we're trying not to hold on to it. But it's hard.
It's hard. I hope that helped a little, Brian. So I don't want to stand up here and anybody
think we're doing anything special. We're not. Everybody has a different level of time, talent,
and treasure. Our treasure is more than we need. And we're doing everything we can to help the
kingdom with it. That's all I can say. Somebody else's treasure may be less than their talent's
more. Awesome. Or even if their treasure—I'm nowhere near the widow's might. I'm humiliated
compared. I'm that other guy that's giving money from the excess right now. But we will come to a
time when my wife and I are sitting there going, okay, we're down because we're going to give it away.
Can I just add one quick comment? I can be very concise. I would say where profit really matters
and the returns really matter, there's still a type of profit that we don't want. And that's
where that discernment comes in to say, yeah, we're still going to seek unapologetically. This
is money that's for provision for our family. We have that biblical responsibility. But we're going
to invest in such a way that doesn't profit off the backs of the poor or through slave labor or
things that are naturally just more exploitative and don't align with the heart of God.
I think we're ready. I know, DJ, I know you have a whole story on this. And I think we'll
stay on schedule and take, I think, a 10-minute break. If you have time to connect with any of
these three with any questions you have, I'm sure they're readily available.
I want to say one more word to Jerry. I'm sorry, it'll take me 10 seconds. I did not realize
the ministry world, what you were talking about, how it has to go. I've heard Billy Graham and
others, but it is 100% true that working is where we're going to have the ministry work done.
We need to provide jobs for those people.
You can feel it. You can feel that talent, and that's one joy we have.
Ninety-nine percent of the world has to care about commerce Monday through Saturday,
and it's where they connect with other people and where they get meaning,
where they use their giftedness. So amen, Greg. I mean, it's the opportunity to show
Life on Life the stuff DJ talked about on a daily basis and just look for those opportunities to
share Christ and come alongside people. A round of applause for this wonderful panel.
Thank you so much for taking the time and sharing vulnerably from your hearts.
Yeah, we'll gather again here at 1045. A couple of things I heard as you're writing notes,
Greg said, we cannot solve global issues with grand dollars.
Rachel, there are people on either side of every transaction.
That guy's smiling at me. Why is he smiling at me? He's a Christian.
I want the 100-field full return to go to the business making an impact.
Thank you, DG.
So, all right, 10-minute break. We'll be back at 1045.
