Physical House, REITs, Or Real Estate Stocks: Where's The Value? | Your Money Matters #house #realestateinvesting #realestat

Investor Insights
1 follower
Jul 12, 2025
There are two age-old questions that Indians have always debated.
The first one is, should you buy a house or should you invest in equity?
I wanted to spin it a little bit.
And the second question, by the way, is should you buy gold as jewelry or should you buy
digital form of gold?
The spin that I'm adding is, should you buy real estate as a house?
Should you buy a REIT, which is a real estate investment trust?
Or should you buy a real estate company, that is a listed company that makes homes and other
forms of real estate?
And the second question that I want to twist is, should you buy jewelry or should you buy
a gold ETF or should you buy a jewelry company, something like a Titan or any other company
for that matter?
And to talk about this in more detail, I'm joined by Vishal Dhawan, who is a founder
and chief executive officer of Plan Ahead Wealth, as well as Santosh Joseph, who is
a founder of Germinate Investor Services.
Gentlemen, thanks so much for taking the time.
Vishal, I'll start with the first question.
And it's a slightly long question.
What are the pros and cons in the first case, when we're talking about real estate as a
house versus a stock versus REITs?
So I think fundamentally, they are very different forms of investing, even though they ultimately
give you exposure to an underlying asset class, which is the same, which is real estate.
So let's take them one by one.
If you look at physical real estate, typically, you'll find that the advantage of doing physical
real estate is that it feels very, very close to you because you actually own it.
You can walk into it, you can rent it out, you have a lot of control in terms of what
you can do with that asset.
But in order to get that control, you could end up having fairly significant costs associated
with buying it on one side.
Those could be stamp duties, typically 4% to 7% of the value of the asset.
You could have registration costs, very often about a percent of that cost.
And then there could be other costs all coming together, which could mean that your cost
of ownership increase between what is stated versus what you actually end up paying could
be in the region of about 10%.
So a lot of what you see on the price needs to be inflated to that extent to get to the
true price.
And if you add a loan on top of that, that cost goes even higher.
The other thing around real estate is that physical real estate is that liquidity in
that asset can be fairly challenging, especially when you go through a bit of a downturn.
And we've seen multiple cases where it can take months or even years to be able to liquidate
that asset if required.
And last but not the least, if you need to manage it because you choose to rent it out,
there could be a lot of work that you need to do from identifying a tenant to ensuring
that the property upkeep is maintained, you have maintenance costs which come in, etc.
So one needs to keep in mind that while the comfort of owning it is very high, there are
additional things which go along with it.
Now in contrast, if you look at real estate stocks, for example, they give you access
to specific real estate companies.
And those real estate companies in turn may be either diversified in terms of having access
to multiple geographies, or they may be in a specific geography.
And a lot of how they will perform will partly be driven by the change in property prices,
but also be driven by the balance sheet of that particular developer and the macroeconomic
cycle and everything else that that particular individual company is exposed to.
And therefore, for example, if you end up having a broad based stock market correction,
you could end up finding that even though real estate prices are not corrected, the
real estate stocks end up correcting in the process.
When you come to a REIT, in contrast, the REIT is normally not buying residential real
estate.
The listed REITs in India are either buying commercial real estate, or they're buying
retail spaces, or renting out retail spaces as a result.
And therefore, for you, your income there is largely going to come in the form of a
rental yield, which could take the form of a dividend, or it could come to you in the
form of capital appreciation.
Now, the advantage here is that you get the access to commercial real estate and the growth
in the economy without the headache of managing that space, because the REIT will manage that
space for you and just give you a particular rate of return.
It's also very convenient because you can sell it on the stock exchange, just like you
sell a stock.
The disadvantage, though, there is that very often it will not give you that sense of ownership
that you want when you buy real estate.
And especially if you're looking for residential sort of exposure, then a REIT doesn't really
give that to you.
It gives it to you in the form of commercial space.
So you've summed up the pros and cons quite well.
And I will circle back to you after I hear what Santosh has to say, whether he agrees
with everything that you've just now discussed, or are there any elements that he disagrees
with?
So that's the first question, Santosh.
And would you say at this point, given the kind of shift that you've seen in the tax
laws and a lot of people moving to the new tax regime, that that incentive to take a
home loan in order to buy a property and a very long home loan at that, and a sizable
one, is no longer there because you don't get the benefit of that interest payment in
the form of a deduction?
So Alex, hi.
Vishal really explained it very well.
So there's nothing to disagree.
I agree with almost everything, the way he broke it down, I think he did a great job.
But I think I'll just step back and say there are two reasons that we have to consider.
Now if there is a need or if there is a want.
Now for many of us, when we actually need a home, the pros and the cons actually don't
need to come up because you just need a home, you need for your family, you need for you
to stay in.
But when it comes to investment, all the stuff that Vishal explained becomes very important
and material facts to make the decision.
The second important decision that for many people, this swings the deal, is the difference
between the emotional benefit of owning physical real estate versus the rational benefit of
actually buying stock or REIT to get the benefit of real estate without actually using it.
Now the third part that you're talking about, does it make sense today when the new tax
regime is not so beneficial towards the interest that you pay towards home loan, because that's
also an additional cost to the home.
So I think Vishal again explained it.
The home loan, the home cost that you are, you know, told about or the list price that
is there, you have to add duty, you have to add interiors, you have to add other expenses
that make the home livable.
On top of that, you also had to add another layer of interest costs that actually add
up to the total cost of ownership.
Now when you look at the total cost of ownership, if it's for an investment, you're unnecessarily
increasing your own cost to buy something only for an investment return.
Therefore, with interest rates, with tax benefit and the total cost of ownership going up,
it is better today if you're looking from an investment perspective or diversification
perspective to buy it either in the form of equity or in REITs, depending on what suits
you best in terms of exposure to real estate.
Vishal, you want to drive home that point for us?
Because a lot of people say, hey, you know what?
I bought a house for one crore, it is worth 1.5 now and I made 50% gains.
But effectively, they'll be talking about it even while they're paying an EMI and they're
not accounting for the cost that they're paying and the overall cost that they're paying,
for example, for a flat screen television that they've set up or, you know, the furniture
that they've spent a couple of lakhs on.
So how do you drive home that point when you say, are you really looking for an investment
return?
And here I'm assuming that you're talking about buying a home as an investment, Vishal,
and not as something that you would live in.
Absolutely.
So I think it is quite common, just like we miss out those time duties and registrations
and all of that, we also tend to miss out the cost of the loan.
And that cost of the loan over long periods of time can be very significant.
And as, you know, virtually everyone would be aware, in an EMI model for a home loan,
the initial period is where you end up paying a lot more interest.
And towards the latter part, you end up paying more principal.
So what ends up happening for you is that when you start to look at your overall cost,
you could end up finding it significantly higher than what you imagined it to be.
Of course, leverage works very well if an asset moves up substantially.
Because let's say if you look at home loans today, home loan costs because of the rate
cuts by RBI are now, you know, in the 8% and below range very often.
And if you get returns, which are substantially higher than 8% on the real estate, then you
could say the leverage is actually working in your favor.
But that doesn't happen all the time.
The other thing that you need to keep in mind is that, you know, very often the tax breaks
on that end up becoming the talking point, especially when you rent out because you can
actually claim the interest as a deduction.
And even if you aren't able to rent it out, the budget this year actually made a change
whereby it went out and said that if you have two self-occupied properties, those now become
assessed to nil value and therefore you don't have to pay tax on a deemed rent.
So to that extent, physical real estate has become a little bit more attractive as compared
to what it may have been, you know, a few months ago before this change happened.
But in any case, the total cost of ownership, which both you and Santosh alluded to, is
ultimately what determines what's going to be your rate of return.
Because otherwise it's just giving a wrong outcome.
And therefore, even a simple mathematical calculation on rate of return won't work here.
You'll have to do an IRR to see how your inflows and outflows into the property actually work
to get the total rate of return that you made over a period of time.
So to conclude on this leg of our conversation, gentlemen, I'm going to throw it back to you.
So when you're talking about investments, of course, there are certain pockets where
real estate and physical real estate becomes extremely attractive, high growth areas, etc.,
etc.
But if we're talking about the metropolitan cities, if you have to shell out a couple
of crores and it's going to account for a very large portion of your portfolio, I would
assume that you would say that either a REIT or a real estate company, even as part of
an overarching investment portfolio, might make more sense.
Vishal, I don't want to – or Santosh, I don't want to put words in your mouth.
So I'm going to toss back to you to say, in the order of hierarchy, how would you rank
all three?
Vishal, first.
So typically, the way we look at it is that the hierarchy in our mind is REITs first for
the fact that they are probably the most predictable in terms of outcome.
The second is a diversified portfolio of real estate stocks, because you don't want to be
caught with just one of them and find that that particular stock gets caught in some
specific company-oriented issues.
And therefore, your exposure doesn't go.
And then third, physical real estate.
Santosh, do you concur or do you have a different order?
I'd go with possibly looking at stocks first, because we're going to be looking at returns.
REITs are stable, but I think stocks have the potential to outdo even REITs and we have
enough data to back that up.
So I think I'd go with stocks first, then for stable and rental income sort of kind
of yield, you look at REITs.
And then if you have to, beyond what you have, you look at physical real estate as ownership.
You have a very large corpus, for example, if you want to book capital gains and diversify
your portfolio, then perhaps that's something to look at.
Now, so that's one leg of the conversation.
Gentlemen, do you have any recommendations for, and not recommendation, I should amend
myself, any REITs?
Santosh, I know that you studied this carefully.
So if somebody is going out there and looking at the various REITs, there are more that
are coming through.
Micro REITs also is something that people have spoken about, not really taken off.
So which REITs are good, which REITs are not?
Do you have an opinion?
See, by and large, all of them have to give you a same structure in terms of how REITs
are structured.
And like what Vishal said, REITs large, you give you access to number one office space,
retail space, and at some level, the commercial real estate space.
So the payouts are quite stable.
We have a history of reasonable payouts.
So you have embassy, you have mind space, you have nexus, and you know, you have more
coming up.
But these three are already present and they have a track record.
So investors are, you know, comfortably, if they're comfortable, these are the three names
to go for.
