TRREB: Housing market might not rebound for another year

Investor Insights
1 follower
10 Video Views·Oct 17, 2024
Jason Mercer, chief market analyst at Toronto Regional Real Estate Board, talks with Financial Post’s Larysa Harapyn about how the housing market might not rebound for another year.
Hi, Jason. Let's talk about Canada's real estate markets from your vantage point.
Let's talk about the status of what's happening in Toronto for the month of September,
that benchmark home price index down. New listings are up. Take us through the data.
Sure. So maybe a little bit of a turning point as we move from September into October,
in the sense that if you look at home sales, they are up on a year over year basis,
which bucked a bit of a trend, certainly compared to what we saw moving through
the summer months. But we saw new listings up as well. So by and large, if you look at it this year
compared to last, actually would-be homebuyers are benefiting from a little bit more choice in
the market. And if you add that to the fact that we've seen three consecutive rate cuts on the
part of the Bank of Canada, it's actually a more affordable situation in the market today compared
to where we were a year ago. And I think that that's only going to continue as we continue to
see rate cuts both this year and into the spring of 2025. And so you'll start to see an acceleration,
I think, in home sales over the next, say, six months to a year.
Let's just dive into that a little bit more. You mentioned the summer months,
and of course, those policy rate cuts, courtesy of the Bank of Canada, coming in
over the course of that end of spring and summer months. And I guess the expectation
was that we were going to see a market rebound then, as you are suggesting, probably not until
the next six months or so, six months to a year. Yeah, because it's interesting. I mean, we do
quite a bit of public polling, and certainly the last round that we did with Ipsos, one of the
things we were asking is, if you're going to be a first-time buyer in the GTA housing market over
the next year, how much would you need to see in terms of interest rate relief, interest rate cuts,
that you'd be comfortable moving into the market from an affordability perspective? And
people are talking about 200, even 300 basis points to see them moving off the sidelines and
into the housing market for the first time, or even looking at people that own an existing home
and might be looking to, say, upgrade, the same sort of calculus applies. And so obviously,
we've seen 75 basis points. If we look at that trajectory between now and, say, the spring of
next year, that's when we're really going to be hitting that target around 200, 250 basis points.
And that makes sense, because if you convert that into a monthly payment or think about what kind
of income qualifies for, say, a mortgage on a million-dollar home purchase, that's the kind
of number we need to hit in order to see the average household being able to comfortably afford
that monthly mortgage payment for that home. You think we'll see a dent with these new federal
policies? I think any mortgage lending guideline changes that inject the potential for more
affordability into the market for different types of buyers certainly helps. And to a certain degree,
it has a similar impact to, say, an interest rate cut. Let's talk about maybe some of the things
that you are watching. There were a lot of conversations around population growth, not just
in this city, but I guess cities in Canada as well. And is interprovincial migration still a thing?
Yeah, it's interesting. I mean, if you look over time on net what's driven population growth in
the greater Toronto area or even the surrounding greater Golden Horseshoe in southern Ontario,
it's immigration. This sort of urban region is Canada's single greatest beneficiary
of newcomers to Canada, and all these people require a place to live. And initially,
a lot of those households settle within Toronto and the immediate surrounding suburbs. What we
see over time, especially as we've moved out of the pandemic to where we are today, a lot of
households have moved further afield, branching out into the broader greater Golden Horseshoe.
And I think a lot of that has to do with housing affordability or lack thereof. Because even before
we started to see an increase in borrowing costs in 2022, we're seeing this trend where a greater
and greater share of deals reported through TREB's MLS system were outside of the greater
Toronto area proper. And that was people looking for affordable housing types.
Let's talk about maybe some of those affordable housing types,
an entry into the market, a point of entry, rather, I should say,
usually townhomes or the condo market, what are you seeing on that front?
Well, certainly, you know, as we see borrowing costs decline, and more and more, you know,
would be first time buyers actually move into the marketplace. Initially, they're going to benefit,
you know, from a lot of inventory, because, you know, we talked earlier on about,
you know, new listings being up year over year in general. But it's even more so,
when you look at the condo market, where, you know, that's the best supplied market segment
right now. And so, you know, it'll be the case that people will benefit not only from lower
borrowing costs compared to a year or two ago, they're also going to be benefiting from a lot
more negotiation power. And so that will, you know, serve to see not too much in the way of
price growth over the next year, even as sales pick up.
Any wild cards that you might be kind of mulling over that might affect your forecast?
Well, here's the thing, if you look beyond, say 2025, you know, we'll have absorbed a lot of that
standing inventory that we've that we've talked about, and the population is still going to be
growing at record or near record pace. And so we can't take our foot off the gas from a policy
perspective, or they're talking local governments, provincial, or even federally from a housing
supply perspective. Because, you know, ultimately, you know, we're not going to have a lot of
inventory in the resale market. And if we're not seeing new projects coming down the pipeline,
market conditions are going to tighten up again. And obviously,
that poses an affordability challenge over the longer term.
