Ghost stories have been popular for generations, whether told around a campfire or flickering from a movie projector. If you’re not a fan of the grotesque and frightening in entertainment, you doubtless steer away from ghost movies. However, there is one classic ghost movie which can be enjoyed by those who don’t like scary films of any kind. “The Ghost and Mrs. Muir” from 1947 is more of a Gothic Victorian romance than a horror story. It’s the captivating tale of a beautiful young widow who rents a seaside cottage which has been empty for years because it’s rumored to be haunted by the ghost of the sea captain who built it. The widow is unafraid, but it isn’t long before she meets the ghost of the deceased owner on a stormy night. Her frank confidence charms the salty yet devastatingly handsome spirit, who is more man than spirit, and they soon find themselves caught up in an impossible romance. This film is brought to life by the powerful talents of the otherworldly Gene Tierney and the debonair Rex Harrison. “Reel Thoughts with Tiffany and Rebekah” is a weekly film review show hosted by Tiffany and Rebekah. They dive into traditional and classic films, covering everything from mainstream blockbusters to indie gems. Each episode offers thoughtful analysis, diverse perspectives, and an engaging experience designed to connect with and entertain viewers. #movies#talkshow#classicalmusic#Americantraditions#Hollywood#theater#cinema#entertainment#celebrity#famous#actors#drama#arts#performer#traditional
Alright, what should we watch?
Any suggestions?
I heard about this amazing movie starring Gene Tierney and Rex Harrison about a widow
who meets a ghost sea captain.
So, sort of like that movie from, I think, the 80s, Ghosts?
I don't want to watch that.
No, it's nothing like that.
It's romantic and spiritual and beautiful.
If you say so, but really, a ghost movie?
Are you sure I'll like it?
You know I scare kind of easily.
Trust me, I know you'll love it.
Well, if you say so, but if this keeps me up tonight, you have to sit up with me.
It's a deal.
But you've never seen anything like The Ghost and Mrs. Muir.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
There weren't many fantasy films made during the golden era of Hollywood.
It's true.
But of the ones that were, I think that most of them were sort of fanciful takes on the
afterlife.
That's a really good point.
I hadn't thought of that, but you're absolutely right.
There are quite a few of those.
Now specifically speaking about ghost movies, there are very few ghost stories.
But the classic films that are about ghosts are very different from what people would
consider now a ghost film.
Very true.
An excellent example of this is The Ghost and Mrs. Muir from 1947.
This story is about a beautiful young widow who decides to leave her overbearing mother-in-law
and sister-in-law to move to the seaside with her daughter and her beloved maid, Martha.
She's determined to rent a charming little cottage called Gull Cottage, although it supposedly
is haunted.
On the first night there, she meets the charming, handsome ghost, the deceased owner, Captain
Greg.
He tells her that he didn't commit suicide, as everyone thinks, but that he died through
a mysterious accident.
And he continues to haunt the house because he doesn't want it filled with renters.
He wanted it to be made into a home for old seamen.
They strike up an unlikely friendship, and he begins to trust her and care for her, as
he never cared for anyone when he was alive.
She in turn finds that he's one person who really understands her, even if he isn't a
living human being.
As her financial situation grows tense, her good friend the ghost helps her by dictating
a book all about his life as a sea captain, which he can sell so that she and her daughter
can always remain at Gull Cottage.
However, their friendly little arrangement is disrupted when a charming, dashing stranger
comes in and starts romancing Mrs. Muir.
This movie was made by 20th Century Fox.
It was produced by Fred Colmar and directed by Joseph Almenkiewicz.
It stars Gene Tierney, Rex Harrison, and George Sanders.
Now this movie began as a book of the same name, which was written by Josephine Leslie
under the pen name R.A. Dick.
But it had only been published in the United Kingdom at the time when 20th Century Fox
wanted to buy it.
I see.
So American readers were not familiar with this work.
It was eventually published after they'd bought the screen rights because then it became popular.
So they bought the rights in 1945, and there were several different ideas about who was
going to be in it.
At one point, Catherine Hepburn and Spencer Tracy were going to be in it.
That's right, I read that.
That's really interesting.
Yeah, but then he withdrew, so she did too.
And they also were considering Claudette Colbert, Olivia de Havilland, and even Norma Shearer,
who was retired at this point as having been a widow herself, and she hadn't made a movie
in five years, and they almost lured her out of retirement.
But she ended up deciding against it, so they cast Jeanne Tierney, who was, I would say,
a lot younger than some of those other actresses they were considering.
Yes.
How old was she?
I don't really know.
How old was she at the time this film was made?
I think she was in her late 20s.
That's what I thought.
And I was struck, in the book, she definitely seems older to begin with.
Because she says she's 32, and I believe in Martha, her maid is 34, so that character
is much younger in the book, they're more of sort of contemporaries instead of her being
sort of motherly toward Mrs. Muir.
Yes.
When they started filming the movie, on her first few days of filming, it said that Jeanne
Tierney was playing the role very playfully, almost comedically.
And then they had a meeting and decided that was the wrong path, so then they re-shot those
first few days, and she was much more serious, and that really led to this being a career-defining
role.
The cinematography, I think it's a lot of credit for the atmosphere, sort of the aesthetic
of this movie.
Right.
Because it's shot so beautifully, and the California coastline was standing in for England,
but all the footage of the ocean and beach and that house, it's...
So much is done with lighting and shadows, and I think in a fantasy film, that's so important.
And in order to sort of keep the budget down, they chose not to use any special effects
on Rex Harrison to make him look transparent or anything, so he just looks like a man.
He looks very much like he's there, but there's such a feeling of mystery and aura about the
whole film, that without actually making him look like a ghost, you just have that
ghostly feeling of his presence, even in scenes that he's not in.
And with the use of the portrait of him, the first moment you see it, just the moment with
the light shining on it for a second, you think he's standing there in the room, and
then, oh, it's just the painting.
Yeah, that's an amazing shot.
And the sea itself is almost a character.
It's so important, the sound of the gulls and the waves crashing, and that's worked
into it so much to kind of always have that presence of the sea.
Her name, Muir, is actually a Gaelic word for the ocean or the sea, so it's very much
tied into, she feels this call to the ocean, just like he did.
Even though she's never been to sea, she's led a very sheltered life, she feels that
call, and I think that's why their souls meet so much, they have this common ground.
It was nominated for Best Black and White Cinematography at the Academy Awards, no surprise,
but going back to how we were talking about that this is a ghost movie, it's right there
in the title, The Ghost and Mrs. Muir, but it's not what you'd think of for a ghost film.
Definitely not, because the first scene, the first time they meet, the first time you see
him, it's a bit scary, she keeps trying to light a match and it keeps going out, and
then all the lights go out.
And she hears his laugh echoing through the house beforehand.
Right, there's the storm blowing outside, but from the first moment that you see him,
he's never a frightening character, he's just almost more like a guardian angel in the way
that he's sort of this comforting presence with her, and then at times they just seem
like a man and a woman, the way they fight, there's a lot of tension between them, but
then also this sort of romance, but it's on such a spiritual level, as he says, he
has no body, he's just a spirit being, but it's really, the ultimate meeting of the minds
are soulmates, because it can't really be a true romance because he's not alive, but
just their spirits meet and are immediately bonded to each other.
I would say that I would recommend this movie for people who really love the sea, who love
Victorian Gothic stories, it's definitely that, not necessarily if you're really into
ghost movies, if you like really scary movies, I don't think you would dislike it, not in
a horror context, but I think that you definitely don't have to like ghost movies to like this.
I think if you really like that sort of supernatural romance idea, whether it be the ghost of
vampires, like Beauty and the Beast, it's more like that, it's almost more of a fairy
tale, than like a ghost movie, like scary, because it's not scary at all, it's a bit
eerie at first, but never frightening, a lot of times it's actually kind of funny, like
when he scares her relatives out of the house.
It's a testament to how it's not your typical ghost movie, and that our mother doesn't like
movies that are scary like that, but she loves this movie, so if she likes this movie,
I think you don't have to be into supernatural or scary movies to like this movie.
If you like really good stories, or you appreciate really well-crafted romances and deep characters,
you'll appreciate that in this movie.
It's such a unique love story, because it does have this limit to it, it's like the
ultimate, if only we'd met another time and place, because if only they'd met when he
was alive, it's so impossible, but that they still find this common bond, it just sort
of breaks that, the line between life and the afterlife, but in such a fanciful way,
so it's more like a fairy tale.
Jean Tierney ended up being really ideal for this role, because she always seemed to play
these characters who are somehow not completely connected to this world, whether it's her
Big Break film, Laura, where she's this, almost like a ghost herself, or now in this movie,
and when she made Laura, that was shortly after her daughter died, and her husband commented
that she was like a ghost at that point.
So I think she brought that into all these characters she played after that, including
Mrs. Muir, as this woman who has lost her husband, but is trying to find herself in
a way that she's never been able to before, first with, you know, living her father's
life, or her husband's, her mother-in-law and sister-in-law's, but now she's trying
to find her own way, and Jean Tierney captures that beautifully.
It was difficult for filming, because she actually had a broken foot at some point during
the production, so that delayed filming a little, but she did most of it with a cast
on her foot, but you couldn't see it under the long skirts.
Something useful about Victorian or older style costumes.
And Rex Harrison, of course, was a veteran stage actor.
Yes.
He's definitely most known for being in this stage, and then the film adaptation of My
Fair Lady.
Right.
But before that, back in the 40s, he made a lot of Hollywood movies.
He worked with 20th Century Fox.
Right.
And he was noted for being a real lady killer, a real dasher, even to the point of having
a rather scandalous reputation around Hollywood.
And that really reflects Captain Greg.
He talks about how, I lived a man's life, and a lot of women cried over him.
So that's why you see the contrast when he finally truly cares about Lucy Muir, or Lucia,
as he calls her.
He cares for her in a way that he never cared for any of the other girls who were in his
life when he was alive.
They're a perfect counterpart to each other, because she's so prim and reserved, and such
a proper lady, and he's the blustery sea dog who's had all these experiences in all these
different exotic ports, and she sort of tames his wild spirit a bit, but he helps her so
much to really take over her own life, as she said she wanted to do.
Right.
Jane Tierney does have such a quiet strength about her in any role that she plays, and
that I think, beyond any kind of differences in plot, because there were a lot of differences
in plot from the novel to the film, is that Lucy Muir is this, everyone says she's this
little, like dear little Lucy, poor little Lucy, she's just a small, kind of frail woman,
and it takes her a long time to really be a strong force in her own life.
When she's alone, she can be strong, but then when she's influenced by her sister-in-law
and other people come in, she sort of goes back to being the shrinking violet, and Mrs.
Muir in the film, even though she said it's never been my life, you know she has this
strength in her, and he helps her bring it out, but she always has more strength than
I think the character in the book does.
What are some other big differences, you'd say, in the adaptation from the book?
A lot of it is the order in which events take place.
For example, one of the biggest things would be in the film, quite early on, she, in her
time at Gold Cottage, I think it's been just a little over a year, she's facing financial
straits, she can't afford to pay the rent any longer, so that's when he helps her write
the book, Blood and Swash, and it's at the publisher's office that she meets the character
of Miles Fairley, played by George Sanders, who then is romancing her.
That character is in the book, and she also writes the book in the book, but she meets
him much earlier on, she's out walking her dog.
Yeah, he's just there at the seaside.
And Captain Gregg had previously said that you're such a naive little fool, you'd marry
the first man who romanced you, so he actually arranges for her to meet this man, just sort
of teach her a lesson, and then when ultimately she has her heart broken by him, then he feels
bad.
But the book, her writing of the book, comes much later in the novel, and rather than those
two events happening around the same time, and it's more of a secret that she wrote it.
In the novel, she actually has two children, the elder being a son, and he is very much
her husband's son, or her sister-in-law's son, and she's sort of prudish, very stuffy,
and he has the Muir trait of always wanting everything his own way, and she's never very
close to him.
She's much closer to her daughter, who's sort of a rebel, a bit like Lucy, but with even
more of a free spirit, and when they're grown, he is apprenticed by a bishop, and ends up
marrying his daughter, and his sister wants to become a ballerina, which he very much
disapproves of, so she has to change her name, so she won't be connected to him.
The book, Blood and Swash, is very definitely under a pen name, so no one knows that Mrs.
Muir wrote it, because that would be a scandal.
And one of the things that's most, I want to say, moving in the film, interestingly
is not in the book, which is, he ultimately decides, Captain Greg, that she needs to live
among the living, and this man, Miles Fairley, even though he thoroughly disapproves of him
from the beginning, says he wants to marry her, and he thinks that will make her happy,
so he disappears, leaves her life until the very end of it.
But in the book, he's there with her her whole life.
There will be intervals, like they quarreled, and then years pass, and then all of a sudden
he popped up again.
But for the most part, he's always there with her.
She buys the house very early on, with some gold that he had hidden there.
That is interesting, how those changes they made.
And I think that they really, because it only takes place, the majority of the plot takes
place within the first year.
Then there are two or three isolated incidents after that, but it's all about that first
year in the cottage.
And as a result, her daughter, Anna, is very young for most of it, played by a very young
Natalie Wood.
The same year as her breakout film, which was Miracle on 34th Street.
At one point, I think they were going to have the older daughter be more important.
They were going to cast June Lockhart, and have her be a more prominent role when she's
older.
But it ended up being just that one scene, and she comes and tells her she's going to
get married, which does happen in the book, but after a lot of other more interesting,
not more interesting, but a lot more developed plot points involving Anna, all about her
becoming a dancer.
And then she decides to give up her career, and just go back to her traditional life,
and marry this young man.
But the young man's name is the same.
And originally, Richard Ney, who was a much younger actor, was cast in the role of Miles
Fairley.
Instead of George Sanders.
Yes.
And he was fired for being inadequate.
And I honestly think they probably changed the character when they cast George Sanders,
because I can imagine Richard Ney, who is best known for being the son in Mrs. Miniver,
being more like in the book.
Definitely.
He's this sort of...
He seems a lot younger in the book.
Young...
Yes.
He's a bit of a bounder, but just this young fellow kind of going where he says, just go
about looking for things to entertain him, basically he's letting this little cottage
at the moment, and just sort of bored, and then he meets Lucy, and begins romancing her.
Instead of...
He's just...
You kind of wonder in the movie why she's interested in him at all, because he's just
such a wolf from the get-go.
He's a terrible masher, so you're not at all surprised when he ends up actually being married.
Yeah, he's quite a scoundrel.
The circumstances under which she finds that out are also very different.
Yes.
That Captain Gregg actually finds it out and tells her in the book, rather than her going
to see his wife by accident and learning about his marriage.
When considering films from the 1940s, it's impossible to look at them without talking
about the Motion Picture Production Code, and the huge impact that had on Hollywood
at the time.
Because between 1934 and 1954, the Production Code Administration was such a guiding force
in Hollywood, enforcing the code and saying what was and was not suitable content.
So whenever a story was taken from a book, or a play, that there had to be a lot of discussion
before they started to roll film on how it could be made into a code film.
Would you say that any changes were definitely made to make it a code film?
The biggest thing overall would be the pervasive use by Captain Gregg of some sailor language.
It's quite mild, but still, it is swearing, and the code is very strict about no profanity,
so it's just so creatively blasted.
Now, I think in the time period in which it's set, blasted would sort of be considered swearing.
And it is funny, at one point she says, I wish you wouldn't swear, it's so ugly.
He wasn't really swearing nearly as much as in the book, but for instance, when she's
writing his book, at one point she stops, she's like, I won't write that word, and
he says, it's a perfectly good word, it means what it says, and then she very decidedly
types four letters on the typewriter.
It's so interesting to see how code films would acknowledge that profanity existed,
dealing with the issue of swearing without actually...
And either use mild words, like saying, oh darn, oh, don't swear, or oh blast, words
that were okay, they weren't on the actual swear word list, and other characters reacting
like it's profanity, or referring to the idea of profanity.
I feel like that little detail there is sort of the code itself, the principle of self-regulation
in a nutshell, is that you could discuss an issue or feature kind of a problematic element,
but usually not just out and out show it.
It shouldn't be explicit.
Right.
And the other thing would be, I feel part of the reason, one thing is probably just
to cut down on screen time and extra story, but her son, the character of her son and
his apprenticeship to the bishop, it's a bit, it could be seen as mocking religion a bit,
so I think they were probably shying away from that.
And they probably thought, a ghost movie is one thing, and Christianity is another.
Let's not mix them up in one story.
More discussion of the elements of the afterlife in the book.
It's a bit more spiritual in getting into that, so they just don't really talk about
that side of it.
I think we, most people don't believe in this is how the afterlife is, but we're just having
some fun with a little ghost movie, so let's not be too serious about it.
Right, and I think that's really the best way to do it.
Also, something interesting that I forgot, probably the biggest change in the book, from
the book rather, is she doesn't actually see him.
He's just like a voice in her head.
Yeah, I remember that.
And that, of course, would have not been nearly as impacting in a film, but in some ways,
by having him be like, he's there, and then when he's not there, he's gone, it feels more
appropriate.
Yeah.
Something about the way he's just like, hanging around her mind all the time, like in her
sort of part of her spirit, I feel like that could seem a bit odd.
Yeah.
And one scene, she, well he says, you keep the best bedroom, and she says, well if I
keep the best bedroom, where will you be?
And he says, the best bedroom, and she's shocked by that, of course, he's like, confounded
madam, I'm a spirit.
And that night, she brings his painting into her room, as he requested, but then first
she gets undressed, she covers it up, and then right as she's going to sleep, he says,
my dear, I'll never let anyone tell you to be ashamed of your figure, and she's shocked.
But there's a scene like that in the book, but it's a bit more pointed.
So I think it was an excellent, did an excellent job there, just sort of skirting around that.
Yeah, I've definitely, I've read part of the book, and I like the movie so much more.
Yes.
But the name, The Ghost and Mrs. Muir, is still kind of recognizable to a lot of people,
but not from the movie.
From the television series in the 60s, right?
Yes, 1968 to 1970, there was a television series that ran two seasons, and the really
funny thing is, the actor who played the ghost, Captain Greg, in the television series, was
Rex Harrison's understudy for Henry Higgins on Broadway.
And Hope Lange played Mrs. Muir.
It's, she has two children in that, again.
And it's more of like a sitcom, but I think, in some ways, it's more like the book, in
that there are more events that happen over longer periods of time.
Yeah, I would say that was more comedic.
The Ghost and Mrs. Muir is almost like her father was sort of a tearjerker, especially
the ending, which is so beautiful.
Yeah, there were some playful, funny moments, but yeah, there were also some sad moments,
and some really tender moments.
Classic films are, most classic films are just so good at balancing the sad with the
happy, the funny with the tragic, and that's what makes them so lifelike, because life
isn't just all happiness or all sadness.
Especially a film like this, it's covering so much of someone's life, and then even going
into the afterlife a bit, it's just really encapsulating all the trials and joys and
the ups and downs of this woman's experience.
And it captures that Victorian setting as well, with the architecture, of course.
You've got the old cars, and of course, the costumes.
My outfit is inspired by some of the mourning attire worn by Mrs. Muir, or simple black
dresses, in cases with a white collar, and a large black hat with a black veil, as was
appropriate for a lady whose husband had died.
My outfit is inspired by the costumes which Lucy wears after she stops being in mourning.
In a few different scenes, she wears a shirt waist of a various color, with a brooch, which
is from her mother-in-law, which she ends up pawning eventually, so she can continue
renting Gull Cottage.
Then with a simple black skirt, and a large picture hat, such as she wears most notably
in one scene where she goes to visit her publisher.
Interestingly, discussing the idea of the mourning clothes, she, partway through the
film, as you noted, stops wearing them, and the captain fully approves of her not being
draped in all that ugly black crepe anymore.
I believe in the book she remains dressed in mourning for the rest of her life.
That's interesting.
They probably, from a costume standpoint, wanted to brighten it up a little.
Maybe the best thing about the movie is the score, or at least a really important part
of it.
Bernard Herrmann, so well known for scoring several of Hitchcock's films, thought this
was his finest work.
He loved his main theme so much that when he wrote his only opera, of the story of Wuthering
Heights, he used that as the main love theme.
It's just so beautiful.
He puts the ocean into this music.
You can hear the waves crashing in it.
I think that is what elevates the film to being this beautiful, tear-jerking love story.
So much of it is the music, and the way it's woven in.
It's a character in itself.
The dramatic strings as they show the waves crashing, and then the beautiful harp.
It conveys the idea of the afterlife, the spiritual heaven harp.
It's timeless and transcendent.
It's so beautiful and so dramatic, but it perfectly highlights the different moods of
the story.
You've got the sea shanty with a little horn pipe, the dramatic strings, the tense moments
when it's the dark house.
It's the perfect complement and background to the great acting.
I think a really cohesive score, and there were so many great film composers from the
classic era, is if it can be a thread that strings the whole film together.
This score really does that beautifully.
Like you said, it complements everything else about the film, and it really adds to
giving it an atmosphere.
If you listen to that suite, if you hear this music, it immediately brings you into the
place of this film.
Yes.
I think some works and some films more than others are almost like their own little universe,
like a place where you can go, and this film is definitely one of those.
Yes, it is.
You can buy or rent this movie on Amazon Prime Video.
It's also available for purchase on many other streaming services like YouTube and
Google Play.
In all these copies, it's beautifully crisp and very well-restored black and white, so
you can see the cinematography in all its beauty.
We've talked about so many great films from the golden era of Hollywood, which uplifted
the principles of the Motion Picture Production Code and what made it great.
Join us next time for something completely different, a study in contrast.
As we discuss a 1960s classic which challenged the traditional morals of the code.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.