There are certain terms which are used and often misused so frequently that they begin to lose their meaning. In the classic film world, the best example of this is the term “film noir.” This catchphrase is bandied about by anyone who wants to sound knowledgeable about old movies, but it is such a widely used label that it often overshadows the individuality and nuance of individual films. One of the better-known films which is frequently labeled as noir is “Laura” from 1944. Starring Gene Tierney as the mysterious title character and Dana Andrews as a hardboiled private investigator who falls for her, this film is so much more than a detective story. This entrancing movie about a woman who is surrounded by selfish and possibly deadly so-called friends is truly the title character’s story. The magic which made this film an unexpected hit in the 1940s and an enduring classic is the captivating performance by Gene Tierney as the enigmatic Laura, coupled with the haunting theme song. You’ll be thrilled, chilled, and delighted by “Laura.”
I'm going to need to ask you some questions.
Yes?
It can't be.
You're alive.
Of course I'm alive.
Who are you?
This is impossible.
I've never seen you before.
You couldn't possibly know me.
I've seen your portrait.
All right, then.
If you know who I am, what's my name?
You're...
Laura.
I'm Tiffany Brannon.
I'm Rebecca Brannon.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
One of the film genres most frequently associated with the 1940s is the film noir genre.
And I know we've talked about this before, but I take issue with this label because it
wasn't actually used at that time in Hollywood when the films were being made.
So I feel like it's over-applied now.
Absolutely.
And what's even more frustrating is that it's used so loosely.
People call everything film noir.
This movie is slightly dark, and it's in black and white.
It must be a film noir.
Now, the movie we're going to discuss today is one of the most frequently cited films
when examples are being given of films noir.
And that is Laura from 1944.
This movie was made by Fox, and it was directed first by Ruben Mamoulian, and then he was
fired and Otto Preminger took over as both producer and director.
It stars Gene Tierney as Laura, Dana Andrews, Clifton Webb, and Vincent Price.
Laura starts out as a murder mystery.
The title character has recently mysteriously been murdered.
And the plot is narrated by the character of Waldo Lidecker, this intellect who's a
columnist and was one of her best friends.
He tells most of her story to this detective, whose job it is to find out who killed Laura.
As the handsome young detective finds out more about the beautiful young woman's story,
he begins to find himself falling in love with her mysterious portrait and the beautiful
young woman she was.
Nevertheless, the case takes a startling turn when one day, Laura walks into her apartment
and is amazed to find out that everyone thought she was dead.
Supposedly, she was gone for the weekend and had heard nothing about her supposed murder.
Who really was killed?
Did Laura know anything about it?
If she wasn't responsible for the death, who was the attempted killer?
And will he try to strike again?
I totally agree with what you've said about film noir as being too arbitrary.
But if there were such a thing as film noir, what makes you say that Laura isn't one?
Because I know you've expressed that.
I think that the idea of the film noir, it has a lot of stereotypes.
Definitely.
Those would be the bad cop, the femme fatale, the bitter former policeman or private eye-turned
bad guy, gangland activities, smoking gun.
There really aren't any of those things in Laura.
That's true.
The investigator's actually quite a sensitive romantic.
He's a good cop. He's a hero.
He acts tough, but he's not in any way embittered.
Laura, while very mysterious and alluring in her way, is definitely not a femme fatale.
She's never setting out to tempt anyone.
No, she's not a temptress.
She perhaps is tempting just because she's beautiful, but she's not trying to tempt anyone.
That's part of the mystique of the character, actually.
She never attempts to attract men. She just is so alluring to basically every man.
I think instead, some of the categories that should be given are murder mystery.
Definitely.
Definitely detective film.
At the time, Gene Tierney referred to it as a mystery classic.
How would you define that term, mystery classic?
I think that the term mystery is being used rather than murder, crime, detective, because
it really is a mystery.
It's more than just, somebody was killed, how was it done?
They know how it was done, and eventually they figure out it wasn't Laura, but somebody else was killed.
But then there's the mystery.
Why was this other woman killed, and they thought it was Laura?
Did Laura have anything to do with it?
Who are these people who are involved with her?
Each one of them is, I guess you could say morally ambiguous, but maybe not even that.
There are a lot of not-so-good characters who surround her.
They're all pretty bad.
The heart of this story really is Laura herself.
It's very much a story about a woman.
Definitely.
And I think that's very interesting to modern audiences, because people who don't like classic films
like to say that there weren't any strong female characters in classic movies,
and particularly in this era, 1934 to 1954, when it was under the production code.
So in pre-code films, you had these strong characters like Babyface, and I could go off on a tangent about that too.
But focusing on this, I just think this is such a great female, really strong character,
especially for modern young women to see, because especially in the 1940s,
they did such a wonderful job blending the sort of new position that women were taking in society,
particularly during World War II.
Yeah, this is during the war.
This is 1944, this is during the war, that a lot of women were in the business world, more than they had been.
And Laura is a career woman.
She's in advertising, right?
Yeah, she's actually an executive.
And all the men in her life are just sort of people that she chooses to allow into her life.
None of them are – they direct the course of her life, but not in a way that almost she's even aware of.
I feel like in a lot of ways she's not aware of how much they're kind of shaping this course,
because she is very much her own person.
But at the same time, what makes her so powerful is that she's so feminine still.
Yeah, she always has beautiful clothes.
She still has those really traditional feminine traits, while also being in this sort of man's world.
Yeah, and the way she has so much power over men, particularly the two main characters,
Waldo Lidecker and the detective, is her feminine charm.
And that aura of Laura is all about that mystique of that painting.
Right.
Which is a focal point of the film.
It's over her mantle, and you just keep seeing it.
Now, when the film process started, Ruben Mullien was the director,
and his wife was working as the set designer,
and she painted a portrait of Jean Tierney to be this portrait of Laura.
But when Otto Preminger took over as the director, he threw out all of that, including the painting,
and he felt that paintings didn't always photograph well in film, particularly in black and white.
So what they did was they took a photograph of Jean Tierney and put paint over it to make it look like a portrait.
Kind of soften the edges.
So it's almost like putting a filter on it, like you would do with a modern computer program.
It's really beautiful.
I was really struck by it last time I think that kind of legend researcher,
because I was saying, I wonder if that painting still exists,
and who did that because it's such a good likeness, and that explains why it was actually a photograph.
But I think he had a very good point.
Obviously, he was a great director.
He knew what he was saying, and that you really need that to look exactly like her.
And well, of course, there are wonderfully talented artists who can do a perfect likeness of someone.
I think being a photograph makes it seem more like you're seeing her,
and I think that's definitely what they wanted.
They wanted that painting to almost seem alive.
There's a lot of flashback work in this film because the protagonist is dead when it starts, or so you think.
Right.
So you see a lot as Waldo is narrating it.
I remember kind of an interesting story.
When we first watched this, we actually had it on a VHS tape, right?
And the case had this artwork from some original poster that showed Dana Andrews as a detective embracing gene tyranny.
And I thought, either this artist is being, you know,
just being how Hollywood publicity shots were honestly a lot like that.
Sometimes they weren't always accurate.
Either they're just kind of, oh, they want this nice romantic shot,
or there's something kind of different that's going to happen in here.
And it's really interesting to think about the song.
Yes.
Talking about the theme music of this movie is so important.
It is.
Originally, they wanted to have Alfred Newman to do the score or Bernard Herrmann.
They both were busy, so they ended up using a relatively unknown composer, David Rackson.
And he wrote this theme, which is played so many times throughout the film,
which is over and over, more than you usually have a theme in a movie.
That's true.
There aren't a whole lot of other melodies used.
It's just that theme.
It keeps coming back.
And it became so popular that a bunch of different bands recorded it.
And it was snubbed at the Academy Awards.
They didn't even nominate it.
Interesting.
Yet everyone involved, from Gene Tierney to Otto Preminger and all the critics,
felt that it was that song which elevated this film above other murder mysteries or detective stories
and made it a mystery classic.
When she really isn't on screen all that much for being the title character,
the painting shows us what she looks like.
The song shows us her spirit.
You know what she's like before you see her.
And I think the melody has a lot to do with that.
It's refined, mysterious, beautiful, otherworldly.
And it was then made into a popular song the next year.
Right.
And Johnny Mercer was hired to write some lyrics for it.
Otto Preminger wasn't a big fan of the lyrics.
But because of that, Dick Hames, Frank Sinatra, all the popular singers of the day
were able to record it.
I can see why, because it's funny.
I'd heard the song before seeing the movie.
And the last lyric of the song is,
She's only a dream.
So when Laura first appeared on screen alive, I thought,
Is he dreaming this?
The detective?
Like, she's not actually alive?
They had me going for a while.
I was expecting them to pull a swerve.
Jenny was like, she's actually dead.
But I was glad that they didn't.
So I guess Johnny Mercer was just, I don't know.
Just being creative.
He was just being creative.
That's why Otto Preminger didn't like it.
I think he wanted to capture the way that the detective feels,
his name is Mark, before she comes back.
Yes.
The first time he sees that portrait.
He's immediately.
The theme song plays.
Yeah.
He's so smitten with her, but he thinks,
I'll never even be able to meet this woman.
Because she's dead.
That's such a fascinating idea.
Yeah.
To come into someone's story so shortly after,
so you think the person's death.
And especially, he's trying to find out everything he can about her first,
to try to find the killer.
But then it becomes this sort of, almost an obsession.
And it's just such an unusual idea for a love story.
It is.
But it's never weird.
Like, it could be weird.
Yeah.
The idea of that.
But it's handled so well.
I think it's really beautiful.
Jean Tierney herself downplayed her importance in this film.
Although she happily cited it as her biggest claim to fame.
She said she was glad and grateful that she was remembered for anything.
But she felt it was the story, it was the score,
it wasn't anything she did.
Yet people around her said,
one of the reasons she embodied that character so much was that
shortly before this, her child had died.
And it traumatized her.
She was so grief-stricken that her husband said she withdrew at that point.
She went completely inward.
And she brought that to the character where she doesn't seem completely there.
She's not completely human.
She's like this other-worldly character because
Jean Tierney was like a ghost of her former self at this point
because she was so grief-stricken.
And she brought that to the character.
I see a little of that in all of her performances.
She has this kind of fragile quality.
She was very fragile.
She had some mental health issues.
While at the same time seeming to have this really intense inner strength.
And that's just such a fascinating juxtaposition to see in a performer.
And I think we see a bit in Laura,
if you know more about Jean Tierney's story,
how she did have some mental health issues
and ended up being in an institution for a while
where she even underwent some shock treatment.
And then afterwards she was a very vocal opponent of that
and even helped to end the use of that
because it did hurt her memory a bit.
And then she became a very strong advocate for herself.
So I think you see that in Laura,
how there are people around her who are trying to use her
or take advantage of her.
That's such an important thing.
But she ends up standing up for herself.
Particularly as we're talking about in this,
you're speaking about female empowerment,
which is such a big deal in the media now,
to really see how, particularly with the character Waldo,
she looks up to as this mentor.
And that's something that, and not just for a woman, anyone,
we all have to be so careful of people that we look up to
and just who you let into your life
and let someone be sort of a guiding influence in your life.
The moment when it takes her a long time, a year,
she finally realizes that he's basically manipulating her
and becomes so possessive of her
that he's kind of trying to push everyone else out of her life.
And she has to finally kind of take control of her emotional life
and her professional life.
She's very much in control.
She acts only under her own volition,
but her emotions are being sort of swayed this way,
and not even her directly, but that he's just,
like anyone who's going to step into their special space,
he kind of gets rid of them, pushes them out.
So she has to basically tell him to step out.
So this came from a novel of the same name in 1943,
and then the author, who was a woman,
then made it into a play called Ring Twice for Laura.
Then it was Otto Preminger who had the idea of making it into a movie.
And he approached Daryl F. Zanuck,
who was in charge of 20th Century Fox,
about making it into a movie.
And Preminger was not on good terms with Hollywood at this point.
He was one of those controversial directors.
He was always up to no good.
He'd had some films which weren't very successful, too.
So people weren't ready for him with so many unusual ideas.
But he thought this one would be a really good movie,
and he sold everybody on the idea,
and he ended up being the producer.
But Zanuck said, but you're not going to direct it.
He put his foot down.
So Ruben Mamoulian, a very well-known director,
ended up being the director.
And Zanuck was not in Hollywood at this point.
He was away dealing with World War II and things like that.
But Ruben Mamoulian made a mistake,
because he said, nobody likes Otto Preminger.
He's the bad guy right now.
I can do anything I want, and nobody's going to side with him.
But he made a mistake with that, because Preminger was the producer,
and he ended up making some decisions,
and even doing some things with filming, his cinematographer,
said Preminger was not happy.
And then he showed some of the rushes to Daryl Zanuck,
and he had to agree he's not doing a good job.
So then he was fired,
and he finally let Preminger take over as the director.
And Preminger hired a great cinematographer
who just used so much mystery and the great camera angles,
and ended up winning the Academy Award
for Best Black and White Cinematography,
which was among several nominations.
It's filmed so well, the angles, the use of mirrors.
And one of the things they had to consider when first doing it
was who would be the narrator?
Because in the book, it kind of goes back and forth.
They're like, Laura's narrating, Mark's narrating, Waldo's narrating.
I always find books like that very interesting.
But in the movie, they tried it several ways.
They had Mark narrating it, they had Laura narrating it,
and finally they said, no, we have to have Waldo.
Well, he's a writer.
Yes, exactly.
So it almost seems like he's writing his column.
That's what the narration is.
That was always kind of my impression.
And there was a lot of discussion about who should play all the main roles.
Of course, many actresses were offered the role of Laura.
One of them was Hedy Lamarr.
And later, when she was asked, why did you turn it down?
She said, they sent me the script.
They didn't send me the score.
And then they weren't sure who to cast
for that important role of Waldo Lydekker.
But they ended up casting Clifton Webb
after seeing him in a stage play.
He hadn't made a movie since the 1920s.
He'd only made one film.
And they lured him back.
He made a screen test.
And the first time he saw The Rushes,
it was of the opening scene where he's sitting in the bathtub
with his typewriter, looking as skinny as he possibly could look.
And he said when he first watched it, he was absolutely horrified.
He was just sickened to see how skinny he looked.
He said, I look like Mahatma Gandhi.
And Dana Andrews had to revive him with whiskey.
And he said it was a great shock to him
because people didn't see photos and videos of themselves back then
like we do now.
Didn't he have a bathroom mirror?
I mean, surely he'd seen himself.
There's something about a mirror versus film.
360.
You can see an angle that you never can see in real life.
And he said, I finally came to the realization
that I wasn't a handsome juvenile anymore.
I guess I'd been going around with the idea for the past 20 years
when I was on stage that I was still this handsome leading man.
And I realized I wasn't anymore.
I feel like this stage is more forgiving.
They're less careful about age.
You can play younger on the stage.
And that realization he had, I think, is also
a lot like what Waldo is facing.
Although he doesn't really make a bold romantic advance toward Laura,
you realize that he goes from being this absolute cynic
to when this 17-year-old girl approaches him,
wanting him to endorse a pen.
At first, she annoys him.
Everybody annoys him.
He hates people.
But then her sensitivity, her beauty, her courage, her intelligence
captivates him.
And so then she becomes his project, sort of a Pygmalion situation.
Yes.
And he falls in love with her, being too proud to ask
for something definite in return beyond friendship.
Yet he wants to be that handsome young man that he thinks he wants.
He wants to think that she could be above that
and just enjoy this kind of spiritual bond that they have.
Yeah.
We're too lofty for that kind of romance for young people.
So he has disdain for the handsome, strapping, muscular young man
whom he thinks attract her.
Yes.
I read, really interestingly, that the scene, it's in a flashback.
He's telling Mark about when he met Laura,
about when he was introducing her to high society
and kind of reinventing her, that that scene was actually cut
in the original theatrical release because they thought
this focus on a kind of decadent lifestyle would be offensive
to soldiers serving overseas.
Which I think is kind of strange.
It is strange.
I mean, there's more.
There's opulence you see throughout the film.
Obviously, they have money.
I wonder if there's more to that story than that.
Yeah.
Anyway, it was put back in in the 1991 re-release.
I thought that sequence was very good.
It is an interesting sequence, yeah.
And it shows how throughout the film, Laura has 27 different costumes
and she looks beautiful in each one
and showing different sides of her personality.
My outfit is based on my favourite costume that Laura wears.
She wears it at a cocktail party when she first meets the character
of Vincent Price, who ends up becoming her fiancé.
It's a beautiful white, almost Grecian-style gown
with a V-neckline and gold jewellery.
Hers is a long dress, whereas I'm wearing the shorter style,
which was also popular in the 1940s.
And in the typical 1940s style, it has the hourglass curves
but in a more delicate way than in the 1950s.
My outfit is inspired by one worn by Laura around the house
with the signature tailored style of the 1940s
and pants which were not worn out by women at the time
but were acceptable boudoir fashion.
A scarf tied around the head was also very popular for around-the-house wear.
Two terms which you hear bandied about all the time on social media now
is vibe and aesthetic.
So I think young people could really relate to this film
because it passes the vibe check and it has a great aesthetic.
If you like the idea of film noir, you'll like this film
because it does have that moody, mysterious, darker cinematography.
It's in black and white, beautiful fashion, a strong female character,
so I think girls could really like it.
And going along with a trend that was popular a few months ago,
she's very demure and very mindful.
Yes.
But boys could like it, and young men,
because it has some really interesting male characters as well.
You've got the detective who has a silver plate in his knee
because he went up against some gangsters.
You've got this kind of mysterious intellectual, Waldo.
You've got Vincent Price, who is still a pretty well-known name
because of his work in horror films, but this was actually his favorite film.
And it's not very long. It's only an hour and 30 minutes,
yet so much story is packed into it.
So I think it's a really enjoyable one and a good first classic film
for people who are interested in a mystery classic,
a detective film, a murder drama, or a film noir.
Now, it's available to buy or rent on Amazon Prime Video,
YouTube, all the streaming platforms,
and it's also available in a lot of good copies on DVD.
One of the greatest forces for preserving or destroying
the American way of life is the newspaper.
The glamour and grit of this industry has fascinated Hollywood for years,
creating countless stories focused on journalism.
Join us next time as we talk about an obscure film
with a star-studded cast all about one newspaper's fight
against a vicious gangster.
Thank you for watching. Goodbye.