This Should NEVER Happen to the Housing Market

Global Finance News
11 followers
Ken McElroy, you are one of the biggest real estate investors in the country, so you're the
perfect person to ask this question to. I just saw this chart this morning that was showing that the
price of a home in the U.S. versus the average income is kind of at an all-time high. When I
spoke to you six months ago, you said you were looking for buying opportunities, so I'm curious
what you're seeing now and kind of where we're at. I love that chart, and I'll tell you why,
because it depends on what side of the equation you're on. If you're on the single family
side, you're not cash flowing. You're not buying any of those for cash flow, right? Because the
price of homes are high, and the price of the mortgage is high, and the rent just doesn't pay
for all of that. So what that's really doing is it's pushing people over to the apartments
and the multi-family side, so we have an affordability issue, right? Because most people
that are investing in single-family homes are trying to get my renters to rent them, right?
Same thing with a home builder. Home builder's trying to get them to buy a house. So when the
single-family market is frothy, let's say, that actually bodes well for a rental side of the
house. And so we've seen a little bit of softness on single-family, but it's still so far off.
The average rent's, let's say, $2,000. The average mortgage plus all the expenses are in the force,
right? There's a big gap still, so we're still pretty good. So we're buying multi-family.
You are buying multi-family?
Yeah, a lot of it.
And so are you buying now because you just want to make sure you lock in those properties and
somebody else doesn't get them, or are you buying them because you think this is the bottom and
bird?
I don't know if it's quite the bottom. It could slide a little bit more, but here's what happens
when big money, Wall Street comes in, they start pushing prices up. When there's a lot of money
chasing few deals. So I'm trying to be like the speed boat. They're the cruise ship. They move
slow, but really strategically, where I see it all coming, but they never are the first to the
dance ever, right? So they need guys like us to go do stuff and prove the market out, and then
they come in, and then it's going to be really hard to compete against them, right? And so we've
done four recaps so far. We'll do two more recapitalizations of our own deal with a big,
big equity group. We bought 250 million so far of existing, and we're breaking ground on another
200 million on multi-family. That will open in 2027. So we have a bunch of strategies going.
We're real, real busy.
Well, so obviously interest rates play a huge deal in real estate, right? And you know more
about real estate than I ever will, but I follow interest rates pretty closely. I'm going to tell
you what I think of interest rates, but I'd love to get your take because again, I think it
influences everything, but the reason I'm not quite comfortable with real estate, and I'm not saying
I'm bearish, but I also just not sure I'm bullish. And the reason I struggle with it is my view on
interest rates is that they're probably staying here or going higher unless they crash lower
in some kind of a deflationary scenario. And in that deflationary scenario, then I would imagine
that real estate prices get a little bit softer as well. If that doesn't happen and interest rates
stay here or go higher, then it doesn't necessarily mean that we're going to have a fall in real
estate prices. So, you know-
Right. Yep. So, okay. So I don't know where real estate interest rates are going,
but I will tell you what we've just been doing. So on our last deal, we did a rate buy-down agency,
so Fannie and Freddie, at 5.18. At that rate, we're in the money, like we're cash flowing.
And we bought, so every deal we bought this year, we like to buy fixed if we can. Doesn't always
work, but that's what we like to do. You can't do that on construction, but so we're seeing rates
in the low to mid fives. And if it cash flows today and we're buying under replacement costs,
we think that's a good deal for a few reasons. One, again, I don't know if rates are going to
go down below that or not, but the cash flow today for me and I'm buying below replacement
costs and I see the affordability issues still coming. And I think we're moving toward a renter
nation. Personally, I don't think there's a lot of people that can afford houses.
So that's going to continue to pour people over into my sector. That will push things up. The
other thing is when the big money comes in the institutions, that'll create a little bit of a
bubble. And so what I'm anticipating is if nothing changes, I'm good. I just got to keep the things
at 90, 92% occupied and I can clip away at a very fine coupon. If things change, if rates go up,
I'm still good because I'm fixed. If they go down, then I can refinance. As the inflation
starts to kick in from the tariff, somebody's got to pay for those tariffs. We don't know how much
or anything like that. I do believe that real estate prices will go up as a result of that
replacement costs. And so I got, but it will really affect the supply that would typically
hit. Like there's no supply, like people pulled back when rates went up. So what I'm anticipating
is the frothiness of the real estate market, the rental market is going to kind of be over by the
end of 26. And then 27, it'll start to settle out and we'll start to see gradual rent growth.
And then we should see really exponential rent growth. So 27, 28, 29, all the tenants are going
to be up in arms, all the politicians, rent control, all that stuff will start to kick in.
So I'm really thinking of four, three, four years out. And so that's why I'm buying today
at these below replacement costs at fixed, make sure that cash flow. And then to your point,
whatever happens, happens. I'm hedged on the up and I'll take advantage on the down.
But I would imagine that, you know, someone who invests in multifamily home or single family home,
you as a rental property, you're competing with the home builders who are trying to sell them,
right? So what are some of the tricks that each side tries to do to lure the customer
to that side versus the other? So the home builder, Lenar just came out with their filings
last week and it's not good. Like, you know, their net, call it their net, which means their
price of their home plus all the sales costs. So they've been putting inside of their marketing and
sales costs, the rate buy downs. So let's say you want to buy a home from Lenar and you, you know,
you put a huge chunk of money in because really what's going to make you not buy a home,
the monthly payment, right? And so the, you call it the six, 7%, you know, money that's out there
for a single family. They've got to buy that down so that they can compete. So it's, you know,
it's showing up in their filing. So it's very interesting to see, you know, home prices haven't
really jacked down too much. So if you own a home next to a Lenar community, you're at a huge
disadvantage. Especially if you're trying to sell yours right around the same price because they've
got, you know, the big marketing dollars to buy down rates. Now you could do that too, but it's,
that's what's happening. So there is a bit of an adjustment going on and I think there's not
enough buyers for the amount of sellers. And so we're starting to see that now, which is actually
good, Brett. Like this actually is what the market needs. I mean, most people think I want everything
to go like this or home, but that's not good. It's not healthy. It doesn't, it doesn't provide
that entry level house for that person. Like my kids, your kids, you know, when your son
gets out of school, he's going to want to buy something. And you know, frustrates me that the
price point is 400, $500,000 at 7%. So not like us. I mean, you know, so, so I think that now
does that disrupt my business? It does, right? Because now it's starting to be, you can have a
choice. And so I, but that's not where we are today. You know, the home of the price of a home
has to come way down. The interest rate also has to come down. Don't know if it will. But meanwhile,
rents are way below mortgage plus costs. So I think right now we have this little window
for a while under this administration and Trump's a real estate guy, whether you like them or you
don't like them. Right. That's he's cut his teeth on that the whole time. So, you know, we're going
to see bonus depreciation come back. It looks like he's going to preserve all the carried interest
and the depreciation stuff that, you know, real estate investors get. So I would imagine, plus
he's doing stuff with opportunity zones and he's talking about opening up some of that federal land
that all has lag. Right. So all that stuff's like, so let's say he does open up some of that federal
land and people start to build on it. You're not going to see that for years. Right. Right. So
whatever I'm doing today, I'm exiting, you know, as it starts to get, you know, so it's just like
anything else, but I'm playing a probably a three to five year window on this stuff right now. And
that's, that's essentially what I'm trying to do is get into the game now before the institutions.
And then who knows what's going to happen with all this other stuff.
Gold is near all time highs, but appreciation isn't the only way to benefit monetary metals.
You could potentially earn a yield on your gold paid in physical gold without selling it. Here's
how it works. When you lease your gold through their platform, pre-qualified companies pay to
use it under strict guidelines, like renting out real estate, but with gold, instead of paying to
store your metal, you may earn up to 4% annually in gold. You stay in control and you can choose
which leases to participate in. Monetary metals handles the due diligence, lease terms, and all
the administration. Thousands of investors use this approach to grow their gold, not just sit
on it. Visit monetary-metals.com forward slash Ken to learn more. Leasing gold involves risk and
returns are not guaranteed. This is not an offer to buy or sell securities. Please review all risk
disclosures at monetary-metals.com. Visit monetary-metals.com forward slash Ken to learn
more. So I've got one other question. This is the one I'm really interested in. So when we were
speaking one time, I can't remember if it was six months ago, a year ago, you mentioned to me that
your international buyers will typically come in and invest with you when the dollar is weaker
because their currency is stronger, right? Well, so now we have, the dollar's gotten weaker this
year, but it's part of the reason that it's gotten weaker is because the theory is that people
are pulling capital away from the United States. So I'm curious if you are seeing any international
buyers coming in or what's your view on this? It's very different today. So you're right. So in 07,
2007, I was raising money out of Canada and the dollar was almost equal. I think it was September
of 2007, the US dollar and the Canadian dollar were almost pair, you know, equal, which is,
you know, doesn't happen very often. Right. And that's because of our weak dollar,
not necessarily because they're strong dollars, you know. So today it's very different where
they're like, we don't trust the US dollar. Right. And they're like, you know, with all
the stuff happening here. So there's a pullback. So we're not seeing the international inflow
like we were certainly back in 07, 08, 09. And that's, I got a tremendous amount of money that
came from out of the country during that time, trying to chase goods and services and hard assets
and stuff because also, because they were not happy with their, you know, with their situation.
Right. So there's obviously a lot that goes into this, but this is a very different time. We're
seeing a flight to like gold and Bitcoin and stuff like that instead of US real estate. Right. So,
yeah. So not like before. It would be interesting to see how it goes from here. There's just so
many variables up in here right now. It's probably the most uncertain time that I've seen in doing
this for 25 years. And so we'll see where it goes from here. It's wild. Yeah. It's fun too.
Well, I've used 2022 as my analog for 2025. When we came into 2022, it was a wholesale regime change
based on interest rates. You know, people had been in business for 40 years and had never seen
interest rates, you know, go up significantly. Yeah. I mean, they were going down. Right. Yeah.
And so it took six to nine months for the market to kind of come to grips with interest rates
ratcheting higher rather than lower. And during that first six to nine months, it was very volatile.
And so I thought 2025 would be similar. And so far it has been because I feel like we're having
a regime change now, but now it's based on how the US does business with the rest of the world.
And it's based on tariffs rather than interest rates. The fundamentally interesting thing to me
is that both interest rate hikes and tariffs kind of have the same effect on the economy.
It's costing more. Right. And so we had the big sell off in April. We've seen a big rebound.
It's a rebound. I thought it would rebound. I didn't think it would rebound quite this high,
but I would expect in Q3 we have more volatility similar to what we saw at the end of Q1.
I think what you're going to see is the second half of this year is going to see
the single family market come down. Prices come down. What you're going to have is,
it's really about normal. And by the way, my whole career was built on what interest
rates are today. Like my whole career. I just had this little window that everyone kind of came in
at. They thought, oh, this is the way it's supposed to be. That was a gift for a while.
Now, it could go back there, but if you can't make a real estate deal at 5% to 6%,
it's probably the wrong deal. Historically, they're really not that high, right?
Right. That's the thing that a lot of people, and so everybody's like hanging on these quarter
point or half point adjustments and they're important. Don't get me wrong. But the real
issue we have in the single family market is we have, I think over 60% of the people
are sitting on trapped equity with low interest rates. And if they even move laterally,
it's a bad decision, right? They can't even move to their neighbor next door
at the same price because their payments can be a couple thousand more per month.
Well, that's what's kind of interesting to me. I feel like the prices are kind of back to where
they were pre-global financial crisis, right? But then it was because people were buying multiple
homes and there was tons of liquidity. Now, it's kind of the same thing, but people are trapped in
their one home and they have tons of equity, but they're kind of trapped because they can't move
and they can't refinance. Right. I would suspect that you're going to start to see financial
products that says, okay, Brent, you got 300 or 400 grand in your home. You can keep your mortgage
and we're going to give you this opportunity to pull that out and be a second or a third or
whatever it might be. That would, because everybody's looking at that. That's trillions
of dollars. And when that actually needs to open up and flow, the problem is that's all
sitting in 4% or less, right? Like my wife, Danielle has a condo that she wants to sell
and it's actually doing fine, but she wants to move it into a single family home. It's at 2.85%
interest rates. And she's like, she's got hundreds of thousands of dollars in equity in it. And she
wants to turn it, but she's like, I just can't leave the loan. And I think a lot of people are
in that scenario where their payments are low. She cash flows because the rents are, actually
rents aren't really going up a lot, but her rate is so low that she cash flows quite a bit every
month on that property. So she can't move it because of the rate. So the rate today is really
an asset, right? If you have a loan in the 2, 3, 4%, it's an asset and you don't want to move off
of that. And so there's a lot of that happening. And so if rates do come down, it'll unleash all
that equity and that actually would be good. It will create another bubble, but if they stay the
same, what you'll see is a lot of people will stay put for a long time. And what will happen
is this happened before I've seen this. Let's say you live in a house and you've been there now
eight or nine years. And now all of a sudden you go to Home Depot, you go to Lowe's and you start
to see their stocks go up because they're like, we need a new refrigerator and we need cabinets.
And so they start to do these home equity HELOC stuff, kind of harvesting the money inside of
equity, but they don't move because they have such a good low mortgage. And so really that
kind of renovation platform starts to really, really make sense for a lot of folks. So it'll
be interesting to see how long they stay. Do you have an opinion on Fannie and Freddie,
about the government potentially bringing them out?
Yeah, I know. Not a strong one. They've been fantastic for us. I don't know the inner workings,
but for us, it's really, really good debt. It's however, under 60% loan to value today.
But we've had a phenomenal history with both Fannie and Freddie. So for me, it's not broken.
Don't touch it. But it doesn't mean that they won't.
