The Salvage Job - Part 2

Classical Artwork Conservation
262 followers
1 Video View·Jun 27, 2025
Check out http://www.squarespace.com for a free trial or go to
http://squarespace.com/Baumgartner to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
--
There are paintings for which the future looks grim. A shift here or there and they could easily end up discarded. And while the state of these works is desperate all hope is not lost; something can be done. It may be unreasonable to expect that the painting would look new or as if no damage had occurred but it is perfectly sound to expect that it can be salvaged.
--
Support me on Patreon
/ baumgartnerrestoration
Official Baumgartner Merchandise
https://teespring.com/stores/bfars-store
Follow me on
Instagram - / baumgartnerrestoration
Facebook - / baumgartnerfineartrestoration
This video is brought to you by Squarespace.
From websites and online stores, to marketing tools and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one
platform to build a beautiful online presence and run your business.
While part one of this series was focused on removal and undoing, removal of the surface
removal of the old varnish, of the old retouching, of the old fill-in, of the other retouching,
of the other fill-in, of the other overpainting, of the linings, plural.
Part two is focused squarely on putting things back together.
A new interleaved lining, new fill-in, new retouching, new varnish.
And it all begins here with the Belgian linen canvas that gets marked to fit and cut to size.
The interleaf for this lining will negate any movement that the Belgian linen is wont to do
with humidity changes.
So with the painting all sandwiched together, it can go onto the large hot table.
The air extraction tubes can be set into place, the heat turned on, set to temperature,
and then the vacuum pump can be turned on and the air extraction can begin,
providing even distributed pressure on the whole painting.
This video largely glosses over all of the materials preparation,
because let's be honest, watching me cut canvas, glue, and film isn't all that exciting.
I mean, it's not even that exciting for me to do that work.
But spending time and energy on the preparation of the materials,
all of the structural behind-the-scenes stuff, is absolutely critical to ensuring
that the final outcome, what we see, is just so.
You know, it's kind of like when you're building your website,
and you don't want to code CSS, JavaScript, or HTML.
You just want Squarespace to do it for you.
Squarespace's platform uses the latest and greatest web technologies.
Their templates are mobile-friendly and work on any device, anywhere.
And their library of plugins, everything from online image galleries,
to contact forms, online scheduling, and even e-commerce solutions,
are as simple as point and click.
You don't have to spend any of your precious time learning how to code,
or figuring out how to make the whole website work.
Squarespace takes care of everything for you,
so that you can focus on your website, your passion, your business.
And one of the coolest things is how modular the whole platform is.
If you want to change your template, click, it's done.
If you want to add a marketplace, click, that's done too.
If you want to move your gallery around, change anything, click, it's done.
Squarespace has made it so simple,
there really isn't any good reason not to go with them.
So head over to squarespace.com for a free trial,
and when you're ready to launch,
go to squarespace.com slash Baumgartner
to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
So you plus Squarespace plus the interwebs equals world domination.
Cool. Back to the painting.
I left the stretcher as is,
because it really wasn't important to focus on right away.
But now I do have to start preparing it to receive the painting.
There are so many rounds of tacks and nails in this support,
that I questioned whether or not it was even worth saving.
Ultimately, however, it is worth saving.
It's a pretty good support,
and unless there was something catastrophically wrong with it,
I wouldn't throw it away.
Now it is missing several keys,
so I'm going to go over to my shop,
and I'm going to start preparing some new ones
by tracing out one of the original ones.
I can ensure that they're going to be identical,
and that will fit properly doing this way.
I have learned my lesson and bundled up this stack of keys
with some painter's tape,
just to make sure that they aren't sliding around.
And I am being careful with my fingers.
I do like them and need them.
But using a sharp bandsaw blade is the best way to ensure
that I get a clean, nice cut.
And with one cut, there we go.
Keys.
I'll sand them up just to make them look a little bit nicer,
but also so that they slide in the mortises a little bit better.
Rough wood seems to bind.
While I was dealing with the stretcher,
the painting was allowed to cool,
and now that it is room temperature,
I can turn off the vacuum pump,
remove it from the sleeve,
and bring it over to my large table,
where I will start to fill in all of the voids.
And voids there are.
Lots of them.
So I'm using a fairly large palette knife here,
and I'm not being all that delicate.
I'm just going to try to cover up all of the areas as much as I can.
I can always remove what I apply now,
so there really isn't any benefit to trying to be really reserved.
I need to make sure that all of the areas of loss are filled in and smoothed out,
because I don't want any waves, bubbles, wrinkles,
divots, or other planar distortions to catch the light once I've applied a varnish.
I'll make multiple passes of thin fill-in material,
one after the other,
until I have built up enough of the material
that I'm confident the divots are all filled.
And then, after it has had some time to dry,
a day or two,
I can begin removing the excess.
There are many ways to remove the excess fill-in material,
and I can start by using a cotton swab,
dipped in water,
and slowly working around the excess fill-in material.
It is water-based,
so it receives that water,
swells, and dissolves.
The swab can then remove the excess,
and I can check it with my fingers.
It is important that I remove all of the excess material.
I don't want to simply cover up and smooth out,
or feather,
any of the existing paint.
Now, on this large area,
I'm going to be using some very fine sandpaper.
I know it seems really weird to use sandpaper on a painting,
but you can see that I'm not actually sanding the paint,
just the large area of fill-in.
Once all of the excess is removed,
I can take a little bit of water on a shop towel,
and just clean up the surface of the painting,
removing any of the dust,
and any of the residues.
I'll make several passes to ensure that I've got all of this up,
as it can contaminate the varnish,
the retouching,
or the isolation resin that I'm going to be applying later on.
With the painting largely cleaned,
I'm not so concerned that it's 100% clean yet.
I'm still going to be handling it,
and I'll go over it once or twice more
before I apply the isolation layer.
I can transfer it over to the stretcher,
and begin fitting it onto the support.
Now, this is a replacement stretcher.
The original is long gone,
and while it fits approximately,
it's not precise.
There's a little bit of a gap,
say a quarter of an inch,
around the entire painting.
So I'll center the painting on the stretcher,
and then hope that when the painting is ultimately framed,
the framer will create a rabbit that is large enough to cover that gap.
As usual, I start my retouching in the center of each side.
But this is mostly out of force of habit,
because this painting has an interleaf.
So unlike another painting,
without an interleaf lining,
this canvas is immobilized against any movement,
any distortions.
When the humidity changes, this canvas won't get slack.
In addition, no matter how hard I pull on this canvas,
it's not going to get any more taut.
So I don't have to worry about any distortions in the center,
or on the edges.
So starting in the middle,
and working my way to the edges,
is mostly just because I've been doing it that way forever,
and I'm too old to learn any new tricks.
I'll continue stretching with the painting on the floor,
resting on some foam pads to protect it from the concrete.
Again, I'll work from the center out,
just making sure that the tacks are evenly placed,
and all the way into the canvas.
It's riveting work.
And once I'm done, I will flip the painting on its face,
and then start trimming up the excess canvas from the lining.
There's really no critical need to save any of this canvas,
but I like to keep some of it so that I can fold it back on itself,
and then use tacks to secure it in place.
I think it looks nice,
and it's a sign of craftsmanship that I think my clients appreciate.
So using very small tacks,
and folding the canvas in,
I'll go ahead on the back,
and just secure it into place.
These tacks don't provide any real structural stability,
or any benefit to the stretching itself.
They're just here to keep the canvas in place,
and to make everything look nice and tidy.
After years and years of doing this,
there is actually one side of my magnetic steel tacking hammer
that has been ground down to a rounded edge from a square one,
just from running it along the back of the canvas.
It's pretty amazing, actually, when you think about it.
And now with all of the stretching work done,
and all of the canvas tidied up,
I can take these beautiful new keys that I have made,
and insert them into the stretcher.
Now on a normal painting that isn't lined with an interleaf,
these keys are absolutely critical to adding tension to the canvas.
But here, because we have an interleaf, that's not really necessary.
The function of the keys is mostly to keep the stretcher together.
These joints that were made by the stretcher maker aren't exactly precise.
There's a little bit of play.
And the keys help compensate for that play,
and help keep the stretcher square, and from getting all wonky.
Once the keys are installed, I'll take a little bit of fishing line,
and another tack, and I'll secure them into place.
I do this because I don't want these keys to fall out.
I'm not concerned that they're really going to get lost.
They can always be replaced.
I'm mostly concerned that they're going to fall in between the stretcher and the canvas,
and create a bulge or a dent over time.
And now, I can do a final wipe down of this canvas,
to get rid of all the residues before the next step.
Which actually isn't applying an isolation layer, or doing any retouching.
I'm heading over to the easel, because I want to do something before I do retouching.
There is so much loss here, and the fill-in medium is so bright white,
that my concern is that any areas that I don't hit perfectly,
are going to shine through as white, or just too bright.
And since much of the painting has an abraded look,
particularly in the coat and the background,
I need to set up a situation whereby I can mimic that look.
So I'm creating a palette with some gouache,
and I'm going to simply tone and tint all of the areas of fill-in.
And I'm going to do this with a color that tries to mimic what is on the canvas already.
This kind of iron oxide, burnt umber, black, gray, purplish, this color.
And I'm doing this because I want to make sure that any areas that I don't cover
with the retouching paint aren't bright white.
But also, because the bright white of the fill-in medium is a little distracting here.
And it's hard to see through the forest, if that makes any sense.
It's hard to see what I am going to retouch with all of this bright white here.
It also changes the aperture of my eye, so to speak.
A lot of bright white causes me to see colors a little differently.
So by toning and tinting some of this retouching, particularly on a dark painting,
it's going to help me see past this fill-in material a little bit better.
So I'm going to work my way through, moderating the color a little bit,
because it's not a uniform color on the entire painting.
There are areas that are more blue, areas that are more pink, areas that are a little bit more gray.
And particularly on this area, I need to make sure that I've got all of the white gone,
so that when I do add my retouching paint,
I can be a little bit looser and not have to worry about this fill-in medium shining through.
And so with all of this completed, now I am ready to apply the isolation layer.
The resin that I'm applying is going to serve two purposes,
and you've heard me talk about this before.
One is to simulate what the colors are going to look like when the varnish is applied,
but also to compensate for any undulations, very tiny ones, that are in this canvas.
This painting has been worked over many times, and so the surface is not perfectly smooth.
And this resin will sit in all of those tiny little craters and even them out,
so that I do have a more unified surface.
This doesn't necessarily help the retouching, but it helps when I apply the final varnish,
so that I don't see all of those little divots or uneven areas that I otherwise would.
This is an ultraviolet stable synthetic resin,
and so it does double duty to protect the painting not only from the physical world,
but from UV light.
The final varnish also does that, so I guess you could say this painting has double protection.
And now, on to retouching.
And there is a lot of retouching on this painting.
And anytime I start a painting with a lot of retouching,
I like to choose some low-hanging fruit first.
Give myself something that I know I can achieve fairly easily,
so I feel good about this experience.
If I started off with an incredibly difficult area, and it didn't go smoothly,
well, it's just going to make the rest of the painting feel that much more impossible.
So, by notching an easy win,
it allows me to trick myself into thinking that the rest of the painting is going to be as cooperative.
And so I started with the hand.
It gives me an idea for what the flesh tones are going to look like,
and for how the paint is going to react on the canvas.
There are lots of little abrasions here,
and unlike the last retouching,
which just saw fit to glaze them all in with one fell swoop of a large brush,
here I'm just adding little dots.
Now, as you notice, I apply these dots,
they actually lighten up once the paint dries.
When the varnish is applied, they'll darken up.
So if they look a little light now,
that just means that they're going to look right when the varnish is applied.
Now, with the easy stuff done,
there is nothing left but the hard stuff.
The face.
And the first thing that I need to do here is,
well, just kind of tone it to match.
Get the skin color right.
Kind of do some general color blocking,
so that, again, I can start to see the face,
and not just the areas of retouching that need to be applied.
This is fairly easy, and it's relatively mindless.
It's just a matter of mixing color,
and letting the contours of the face that exists guide me.
It still is important that I'm very reserved here,
because I don't want to add paint where there is paint.
I just want to add color where the color's been lost.
It is in this step that I can start to build out
what I think the face is going to look like,
where the bones are, the structure of the sitter's face is.
Of course, there's a lot of refinement that needs to be done,
but this is the natural first step.
Broad brush strokes.
Now, in some of my early conversations with the client
about how to treat this painting's conservation and retouching,
we spoke about leaving much of the coat as is,
not trying to recreate it.
But the client did have the desire to see the face put back together,
to see it rebuilt.
And so I agreed, at least to try to put the face back together,
to try to recreate what I thought this person might have looked like.
I always have trepidation about doing this,
because there is so much editorial process
whenever a conservator tries to fill in the blanks of a missing area.
And on a landscape or a still life with fruit, perhaps,
it's a little bit less consequential,
because we know what fruit looks like,
we know what a landscape looks like,
and we are forgiving.
But on a face, it's really difficult.
And here, I have nothing to work from.
I have looked at the original by Van Dyck,
and this painting does not look like the original.
So I cannot use the original as a template,
because, well, that would be recreating something that perhaps wasn't here.
And so, as I start to fill in the gaps,
this is the easy part.
Making the cheeks and the chin,
making all of that go away,
making the forehead unified,
this is the easy stuff.
The hard stuff comes with the nose, the eyes, and the lips.
Particularly the eyes,
because, I mean, there's almost nothing there.
The bottom half of both eyes is missing.
And I have to figure out what to do,
because right now,
well, he looks like he's wearing a mask.
And I don't think anybody would be satisfied if I called it quits here.
Now, I mentioned my trepidation about retouching these eyes.
And what you're about to see is a prime example
of what I do not want to have happen when I start retouching.
I got carried away here.
I started working on these eyes,
and started letting my instinct to make them better get a hold of me.
I started to see the eyes,
and started to work to recreate them,
to give them a shape,
to add folds and shadows where there weren't,
to add highlights.
I started to paint.
And I wasn't aware that I was doing this,
because, of course, I couldn't see the forest for the trees.
I was trapped in the moment.
I was listening to some great music,
and the retouching was going beautifully.
And to some degree, the eyes were coming along really nicely.
Unfortunately, when I took a step back,
I realized my mistake.
And I wrestled with it.
Because, on one hand,
the painting looked much better.
It looked much more complete.
The face was unified.
His nose, his mouth, his eyes.
It looked like a full painting.
But it was not the painting that arrived at my studio.
So it had to go.
All of it.
Hours upon hours of retouching.
Just like that, I had to remove it.
And while it may seem like this would pain me,
it was actually quite liberating.
Taking the onus of narrative
for retouching off of the conservator's plate
is absolutely critical.
Leaving it to just technical recreation
is where we like to live.
And what I had done before was a bridge too far.
And so removing it was the only thing that was acceptable.
And whatever feelings I had about wasted time
or wasted energy,
I have to swallow those.
In fact, I have to ignore those.
Because I should never have those in the first place.
So, with a clean palette
and a more acute sense of what I actually needed to do,
I began retouching for the second time.
And here, I was committed to only retouching
what was missing.
The majority of the face went along
just as it did the first time.
Just retouching the dots,
removing the small areas of damage,
really keeping my brush controlled and restrained.
This wasn't all that difficult.
I did it once.
I could do it again.
And mixing skin tones is really a pleasure.
It's fun to see the different shades of
greens and blacks and yellows and pinks and reds
that compose a face.
But of course, all this while,
I was thinking about the elephant in the room.
Thinking about how I was going to address that nose
and those eyes.
And it's pretty clear that I started at the bottom of the face for a reason.
I suppose subconsciously, I was avoiding going back to them.
Because I was nervous that I was going to do the same thing.
That despite my reservation,
despite my control,
that some part of me was going to get carried away
or romanced by the retouching that I was doing.
And so even though I was cognizant of that,
I was still nervous that it was going to happen
because it happened once.
And so of course, it could happen again.
So I spent as much time as I could avoiding the area that I was nervous about.
I guess it's akin to delaying homework that you have to do.
No matter how much you procrastinate,
it will never go away.
And to a certain degree,
procrastination just builds it up into a bigger beast.
So perhaps next time,
as I'm narrating this video,
I am considering
that maybe I should start with the part that's the hardest.
Ignore the low-hanging fruit.
Jump right into the part that I am most nervous about.
Get it out of the way.
Don't build it up into something bigger.
Jump right into the deep end.
Anyhow, I say this now,
and it's easy to say in hindsight,
but all the while,
I was still nervous about this retouching.
And it took more time.
It was a slower process,
because I was really holding my breath.
As I came to the nose,
it became clear that just retouching the areas of loss still wouldn't suffice,
because there were large chunks of the features that were missing.
The top half of the nostril,
and the bridge,
the cheekbone,
all missing.
And if I just left them toned and tinted,
well, that may work for a sky,
but it certainly won't work for a face,
because we would look right at it,
and instead of seeing past the damage,
we would be drawn to it.
It's that uncanny valley effect.
And that's something I didn't want.
So on to the eyes.
As I began retouching these eyes,
I realized that,
again, there was just so much missing.
The bottom section of this eye on the left,
and the majority of the eye on the right,
were just gone,
and simply toning and tinting them would not cut it.
But there has to be a middle ground
between leaving them as they are now,
which looks horrendous,
and the excessive work that I did on the first attempt at retouching.
There must be some middle ground there.
There must be some way of completing the image
without doing too much,
or without making too large of an editorial decision.
Leaving them just raw enough that they look,
well, like they belong.
But not so raw,
not so empty,
and abused, and damaged,
that we jump right to them and say,
well, that doesn't look right.
Why aren't their eyes there?
And it's really a hard thing to retouch something imperfectly.
Our natural inclination is to make things perfect,
to fill them in.
Crisp, clean edges,
solid areas of color.
But that's not this painting.
There are no crisp edges here.
Even where there should have been,
they are worn and abraded.
And so, as I start to define parts of the eye,
I have to keep my lines looser,
a little bit rougher,
a little bit less defined,
which is a way of thinking that is unnatural.
It's much like asking a house painter
to just kind of sloppily paint the house
so that it matches the old hundred-year-old paint job.
I'm sure a master painter can do it,
but it'll take a rethinking,
a new approach,
and a conscious effort to do that work.
But I think that if one can shift their mindset,
change how they go about things,
deviate from their norm,
get out of the routine or rut,
and be a little bit more creative,
that it's totally possible.
It is completely plausible
to add something to a painting, retouching,
that actually looks old and weathered and worn,
maybe even a little damaged,
so that it fits in with the rest of the piece.
At least, that's what I hope happens when I'm done.
Well, that was a long week.
Lots of ups and downs,
lots of time spent in the chair,
lots of music,
and lots of podcasts.
But I'm done,
and I'm ready to apply the varnish.
For this painting, I have chosen not to brush on the varnish,
but instead to spray it on.
I think that this is going to be a better method for this painting.
It's going to give me a very even layer of varnish,
and it's going to also allow me to control it
in ways that I don't think I can achieve with the brush.
So, respirator on, gloves on,
just because I hate the way the varnish gets sticky on my fingers
and then sticks to everything.
And then, over to the painting,
and a couple of passes,
overlapping each time I cross the painting.
This is not terribly difficult.
Once the HVLP system is set up,
one very rarely has to adjust it.
Yes, it takes a little time in the beginning,
but once it's perfect,
it's almost always perfect.
So, back and forth,
and then, as the varnish is starting to dry,
well, I'm not 100% satisfied with it.
There are some uneven areas that I want to adjust for.
So, I'm taking a piece of felt,
and I'm just lightly abrading the surface.
And this is going to give a more even,
unified sheen to which the next layer of varnish can stick.
Sometimes the varnish goes on,
and while you expect it to react one way,
it reacts another way.
So, this microtexture,
this evening out of the surface,
will create a nice sub-layer
for the next layer of varnish to go on.
And keep in mind,
these are incredibly thin layers of varnish.
This is not building up a thick, thick coating.
It's so thin.
And that's one of the benefits of spraying varnish,
is that you can add layer upon layer.
You can't do that with a brush,
because the varnish reactivates the previous layer,
and the brush would then drag it,
and would create lines,
or it would get goopy,
or all sorts of bad things would happen.
Now, while that layer of varnish is setting up,
I'm switching to a different varnish,
a different sheen,
a gloss,
pure gloss.
And I'm spraying from a little bit higher up.
And I'm allowing some of this varnish
to dry in the air as it's atomized,
and fall as a crystal
to the surface of that tacky first layer.
These little crystals of glossy varnish
will land and stick to the tacky varnish.
And then, once dry,
they'll be incredibly glittery.
Really beautiful.
Again, this is an effect that can't be achieved with brushing.
And now I am done,
both literally with the work,
and figuratively,
in that I cannot bear to do anything more.
To say that this was a salvage job
really is an underestimation of how dire
of a condition this painting was when it arrived.
The damage was clear,
but as I worked to undo all of the old work,
the damage just seemed to compound.
This was a tricky project.
It required threading a needle,
doing enough, but not too much.
I totally missed the mark on the first retouching
and had to go back in and correct it.
But ultimately, I settled on a compromise
that I'm satisfied with,
and I think my client will be too.
At least the painting can go back up on the wall
and be enjoyed.
It's been salvaged.
There's so much left.
There's so...
You're right, there is.
There's so much left.
You haven't even finished the little dots.
I know.
Why?
Because it's slow.
Just scribble.
No, I can't.
You can just do lines and then perfect.
I wish.
I have to go slowly,
and I have to use this tiny little brush.
What if you just get a big brush and then...
Well, I can't do that.
That's against the rules for me.
And then it'll just be done.
Yeah, but that's not how it works in this job.
I can't do that.
I have to go very slow.
But what if you could just use a machine
that would paint for you?
Oh, I would love that,
but nobody made that machine.
But what if you could buy one?
Well, I can't.
Nobody sells one.
I hope you've enjoyed this video.
If you have questions
or would like to learn more about this
or any of my other projects,
head over to Patreon,
where members get ad-free videos
and get to ask questions that are answered
in follow-up epilogue videos.
