Ranking Member Jerry Nadler delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Jun 25, 2025
Hearing: The Proxy Advisor Duopoly's Anticompetitive Conduct
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you
to our witnesses for being here today.
Yet again, our Republican colleagues are
pushing baseless allegations of
antitrust violations at the expense of
American consumers. Today's hearing
alleges collusion between the two
largest proxy adviserss, consulting
firms that provide analysis and
recommendations to institutional
investors such as pension funds and
employee benefit plans on how to vote
their shares at company shareholder
meetings. The Republicans theory that
these two companies, institutional
shareholder services or ISS and Glass
Lewis, work together to push ideological
goals over financial reform. They they
allege that these proxy advisers advance
socially liberal policies at the expense
of their investors, their customers
return on investment, and their own
businesses. But like so many of the
flawed antitrust theories the
Republicans have brought before this
committee, it simply does not hold
water. Proxy advisers are a vital tool
for investors. While deep pocketed
companies or clients can do assessments
of proxy materials inhouse, retail
investors and mutual funds rely on
expert independent advice from large
proxy firms like ISS and Glass Lewis.
Proxy advisers inform their customers
about the hundreds and sometimes
thousands of complex proposals they may
be called upon to consider, helping them
to fully exercise their rights as
shareholders of publicly traded
companies. They do this by providing
independent assessments of company proxy
materials and shareholder proposals.
Anyone in the financial services
industry understands the value of
trusted information. Customers pay ISS
and Glass Lewis and sometimes both
companies or even a third service for
independent assessments of company proxy
materials and shareholder proposals. To
be clear, no one is forcing these
customers to pay for their services and
no investors bound by the subscription
to ISS or Glass Lewis to follow their
recommendations. The fact that companies
generally do follow their advice is a
reflection of the hard work proxy
advisers do to ensure that their
recommendations are in line with the
goals and values of their clients. They
do not leverage their market power over
their clients independent
determinations. If their customers do
not like their information or their
advice, they can stop subscribing to ISS
or Glass Lewis at any time. And we
should remember that it is the investor,
not the proxy adviser, that cast the
ultimate vote at shareholder meetings.
Proxy advisers can be particularly
beneficial to pension funds by allowing
them to maximize returns for their
beneficiaries by reallocating resources
that would otherwise go to analyzing the
vast quantity of shareholder proposals
they face. Take New York for example. As
of 2018, it was the third largest public
pension plan in the nation and held
207.4
billion dollars in assets. These assets
are overseen by the New York State
Controllers's Office and are held in on
behalf of more than 1 million members of
the New York State and local retirement
systems. The controllers's office, like
its counterparts in other states, takes
advantage of proxy advisory services to
be better informed about the companies
in which they have invested public
employees funds. The majority's basis
attacks on the proxy advisor market may
force New York's and other pension funds
to expend unnecessary resources
conducting their own shareholder
analyses, which could undermine their
ability to deliver strong returns for
their beneficiaries.
Once again, the majority has invented a
flawed antitrust theory to justify its
attacks on an industry it does not like.
Although the vast majority of investment
proposals are uncontroversial, such as
uncont uncontested board elections or
the approval of company company
nominated slates of electors. There are
tiny fraction of initiatives concerning
concerning social governance that the
majority labels DEI or proposes that
quite reasonably consider the risks of
climate change in making responsible
investment decisions. In each case,
proxy advisers conduct an independent
analysis and offer their best advice to
their clients who are free to make their
own independent judgment on how to vote.
But Republicans do not like some of the
recommendations that these two proxy
advisers have made. And therefore, as
has become commonplace in this
committee, they've launched another
unfounded antitrust investigation
designed purely to intimidate and harass
their opponents. During the last
Congress, the Republicans launched a
fatally flawed antitrust investigation
targeting investment groups that
consider environmental, social, and
governance or ESG strategies. Now the
majority is following the same playing
book and arguing that ISS and Glass
Lewis are conspiring to advance prog and
prodefree
investigation is all part of the
Republicans's larger goal of entrenching
corporate interests and conservative
political preferences. The Republicans
focus on alleged conclusion between ISS
and Glass Lewis not only furthers their
culture war campaign but also allows
them to target and dilute shareholder
rights that would otherwise threaten the
interests of their corporate allies. The
majority alleges collusion between ISS
and Glass Lewis because they often off
issue similar recommendations. But this
reflects incredibly shallow analysis. If
you go to multiple doctors and they each
diagnose you with cancer, that is not
evidence of collusion. In this case,
fair and impartial analyses of market
conditions and best practices are
yielding similar conclusions. There is
nothing nefarious about this. Proxy
advisory firms empower shareholders to
exercise their own judgment and
expertise. The market the market is
working as it should. Yet Republicans
are trying to meddle in it for political
purposes. I urge my colleagues to end
this fishing expedition and to focus on
the real issues our constituents face. I
look forward to hearing from the
witnesses.
