Ranking Member Jamie Raskin delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Sep 19, 2025
Hearing: AI at a Crossroads: A Nationwide Strategy or Californication?
I I'm very grateful to you for putting
together this really important hearing
and uh thanks to the witnesses for your
statements. When commercially available
AI debuted three years ago, the
consequences were breathtaking from the
start. Generative AI spurred scientific
research and provided astonishing new
tools to creators. the massive jumpstart
to American innovation swept uh from
social and economic domain to social and
economic domain from pharmaceutical
research and quantum computing to sound
recording and film editing. But
generative AI has also raised profound
legal, practical, even philosophical
problems such as whether individuals
have a right to their name, their image,
their likeness, and their voice when
they're used in other people's deep
fakes. If government um has unlimited
power to engage in AI enabled
surveillance of our citizens, and what
are the appropriate standards of care,
if any, for AI platforms to protect
users against harmful consequences?
While Congress takes the time to absorb
the shock of these changes and these
problems and examines the technology,
the states have already begun to enact
the first regulations on AI. We often
talk about creation of rules for the
road when crafting legislation to govern
new technology. But I think this way of
talking about consumer safety and
technological ethics suggests that a
road without speed limits would get us
to where we're going faster. For
generative AI, it's not about creating
speed and safety laws and building
highway guard rails, but rather building
a road system in the first place. Some
of my colleagues would argue that the
construction of local roads is
unnecessary. They say that without broad
preeemption, without clearing the field
of all state-based legal encumbrances,
um AI companies and fledging startups
will have trouble complying with state
laws and will be put to a disadvantage.
and then wither on the vine. I've heard
little to suggest that broad preeemption
is in fact the appropriate solution to
this problem. Proponents of preeemption
present Americans with a series of false
choices, telling us we must choose
choose a side between AI innovation or
state powers and federalism, between
business and consumers or national
security and safe innovation. In 1816,
Jefferson wrote, "Laws and institutions
must go handinhand with the progress of
the human mind. As that becomes more
developed, more enlightened, as new
discoveries are made, new truths
discovered, and manners and opinions
change with the change of circumstances,
institutions must advance also to keep
pace with the times." What we're seeing
across America is individual states
looking at these amazing technological
developments and asking whether and how
their laws need to change to protect
their citizens and advance the common
good. Um today you might think that the
issue has some kind of necessary
partisan veance to it. Republicans on
one side, Democrats on the other, but
opposition to an AI moratorum I think is
broad and bipartisan. In fact, when some
of my Republican colleagues tried to
pass a moratorum through our last
spending bill, attorneys general from
across the states, red, white, and blue,
sent a letter to Congress saying,
"Please don't do this to our state
laws." In another letter, 17 Republican
governors wrote to Majority Leader Thun
and Speaker Johnson praising their quote
big beautiful bill, but explaining that
the moratorium provision stripping the
right of any state to regulate this
technology in any way without a
thoughtful public debate was quote the
antithesis of what our founders
envisioned. I surely disagree with these
governors on many things, but I think
that they are right and should indeed be
free to create what they call quote
smart regulations of the AI industry
that simultaneously protect consumers
while also encouraging this
everdeveloping and critical sector. In a
statement submitted for this hearing, AI
startup Bria wrote that a moratorum on
state laws would create a giant vacuum
and strip away the rules needed to quote
raise capital, foreign partnerships, and
build safely in order to win consumer
trust. Without a road on which to travel
forward, startups are cut out of the
market in favor of large companies with
the legal and fundraising teams
necessary to deal with a barren legal
landscape. Finally, some argue we need
unrestrained AI development to properly
compete with China. The subcommittee has
held many bipartisan hearings on the
threat to innovation, AI supremacy, and
IP from China. It would be amazing, I
think, even dangerous to posit that we
need to become more like China to
compete with China. In fact, it seems
more plausible to me that to believe
that stronger, better products developed
in America while protecting Americans
and their data through American
political processes and the passage of
American laws will ensure that AI is
both more advanced, more durable, and
more internationally competitive.
Protecting American innovation,
investing in American research,
developing American laws to deal with
problems like deep fakes, political deep
fakes. um discrimination through AI and
so on and investing in our workforce I
believe is the right way to win the
so-called AI arms race. American safety
is not at odds with AI innovation. That
should be the baseline for any
conversation we have about the best way
moving forward. Um and I very much look
forward to this conversation and have
already learned a lot from it. Yield
back to you, Mr.
