Ranking Member Jerry Nadler delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 16, 2025
Subcommittee on the Administrative State, Regulatory Reform, and Antitrust
Hearing: Bankruptcy Law: Overview and Legislative Reforms
Thank you Mr. Chairman and thank you for holding this bipartisan hearing.
Thank you as well to our distinguished panel of witnesses who are contributing their time
and expertise to assist the committee in its efforts to streamline and improve our bankruptcy
system. I'm pleased that we've come together in a bipartisan fashion today to consider a variety of
proposals to make our bankruptcy system more accessible to individuals and businesses in
financial distress. These reforms can ensure that the bankruptcy code is more efficient
and beneficial for debtors and creditors alike and will help businesses, especially small
businesses, restructure in the face of potential financial disaster. One important issue that our
hearings will touch on is increasing the debt limit under subchapter 5 of chapter 11 of the
bankruptcy code. In 2020, eligibility for subchapter 5 bankruptcy treatment was temporarily
increased to seven and a half million dollars from approximately three million dollars,
allowing a significantly greater number of businesses to access relief under this part
of the code, which generally provides debtors an efficient and successful restructuring plan.
Unfortunately, this provision was allowed to lapse in June of last year. Data shows that
the debt limit increase was a clear success while it was in effect subchapter 5 cases
at double the plan confirmation rate and a 20 percent lower dismissal rate in relation to
non-subchapter 5 chapter 11 cases. This means that small businesses were able to keep their
doors open and their employees on staff while ensuring that their creditors were fairly
compensated. I hope we can work together to reinstate this important provision. Congress
similarly passed a temporary debt limit increase for chapter 13 filings, allowing for combined
unsecured and secured debt of 2.75 million dollars. Chapter 13 bankruptcy is the best path
for many filers because it's less expensive and more efficient than pursuing relief under
chapter 11. Unfortunately, although this provision proved to be successful, it also expired last year
and has not been renewed. Now debtors must meet significantly lower levels of both unsecured
and secured debt, leaving many people without access to the courts and needed relief.
Resurrecting the higher chapter 13 debt limit would serve individuals and families
with regular income who are facing higher housing prices, medical costs,
and other debts that present significant financial hardship yet put them over the current debt limit.
In addition to facing higher prices, Americans are also facing mountains of student loan debt.
Under the bankruptcy code, however, unlike nearly every other unsecured debt such as
credit cards or auto loans, it is nearly impossible to discharge student loans,
leaving millions of Americans deeply in debt with little hope of ever regaining financial security.
Nearly 43 million Americans have federal student loan debt, with the total federal student loan
portfolio exceeding 1.6 billion dollars. Under current law, educational debt can only be
discharged in bankruptcy if the borrower demonstrates a continued repayment of the debt
would impose an, quote, undue hardship on the debtor and the debtor's dependents. In practice,
this standard has proven a nearly impossible hurdle to overcome in the courts. There is no
reason that this one category of debt should be singled out for special treatment that makes
relief under the bankruptcy code virtually impossible. It is long past time to repeal
the current limitation on educational debt and to place it on the same footing as other similar debt.
While the picture of student loan debtors is traditionally of young recent college graduates,
the reality is that a significant population of student loan debtors are older Americans
whose wages and social security checks are being garnished toward loans that they will never be
able to repay. Student loan bankruptcy reform, therefore, would benefit a wide swath of Americans,
including the most vulnerable borrowers in our society who have no prospect of being able to
repay their debts incurred decades ago. Finally, we will consider reforms to compensation of
attorneys and trustees in Chapter 7 cases, which would expand access to justice for low-income
debtors. Chapter 7 is a critical lifeline for low-income individuals in the most severe
financial distress, offering the most direct and immediate path to a fresh start. It eliminates
unsecured debts without the burden of a multi-year repayment plan, and its streamlined structure
makes it the only viable option for many households facing wage garnishment, utility shutoffs,
or eviction. Yet the current framework makes it exceedingly difficult for those same individuals
to access legal counsel. Chapter 7 debtors with attorneys are nine times more likely to obtain a
discharge than those without representation. As a result of a clerical error in the law, however,
attorneys representing Chapter 7 debtors are generally ineligible for compensation from the
bankruptcy estate unless formally retained by the trustee. Therefore, most debtors seeking a Chapter
7 pathway have to pay for their representation up front and in full despite their being insolvent,
which either pushes them to the less efficient Chapter 13 or forces them to continue without
representation. I hope that our witnesses will help us examine solutions to this problem. A similar
access to justice issue arises with respect to trustee compensation. Under current law,
trustees appointed by the courts to administer a Chapter 7 bankruptcy are paid just $60 per case.
Additional compensation comes only when the case involves liquidation of assets,
which happens only rarely in Chapter 7 cases. A fee of just $60 is clearly inadequate to compensate
trustees for a role that requires them to review filings, conduct meetings with creditors,
and identify potential circumstances of abuse or fraud. This results in experienced trustees not
being able to afford to take on no-asset cases or being unwilling to invest their time in complex
cases that would require their knowledge and expertise. We must work to increase this fee
to ensure that debtors have the assistance they need to navigate the complicated world of bankruptcy
proceedings. Today's hearing is an opportunity to discuss bipartisan paths forward to increasing
access and opportunity provided to Americans under the bankruptcy system. I thank the Chairman for
holding this important hearing. I look forward to the testimony from our distinguished panel of
attorneys.
