'Hercules' (c. 1500–1510) by Pier Jacopo Alari Bonacolsi (Antico)

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
31 Video Views·Jun 22, 2025
In this premiere episode, the Frick’s Assistant Curator of Sculpture, Giulio Dalvit, discusses Hercules by Pier Jacopo Alari Bonacolsi (Antico), one of the museum’s important bronze statuettes. Known for his exceptional technical skill, Antico worked for the powerful Gonzaga family in Mantua during the late 15th and early 16th centuries.
Hello, I'm Giulio Dalvit. I'm the new Assistant Curator of Sculpture at The Frick Collection in New York.
Welcome to a new episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
Tonight, we will be talking about this small statuette of Hercules by the Italian 15th and 16th century sculptor Antico.
So who's Antico and who's Hercules?
Hercules, as many of you may know, is one of the protagonists of ancient Greek and Latin mythology.
He was said to be so strong that he could defeat any kind of enemies.
And as he did through his so-called twelve labors, one of which, for example, was the killing of the Nemean lion,
whose pelt you see wrapped around his waist in this statuette.
But who's Antico? Antico is a nickname for an artist whose real name was Pier Jacopo Alari de Bonacolzi.
This is a very high flown name, but Antico was, in fact, just the son, quite simply, of a butcher who amazingly managed to become
one of the most celebrated artists of his time in humanist circles of his own town, Mantua.
Mantua is a small town, a fabulous place.
I urge you all to go there and visit it as soon as coronavirus will be over.
It's wonderfully preserved. It's in a town in northern Italy, halfway in between Venice and Milan.
It's surrounded by water, by three lakes and the river.
And Mantua, from the 14th to the 18th century, was ruled by a very prominent Italian family, the Gonzaga.
The Gonzaga had many peculiarities, and among them was an appreciation of wine.
One of them in particular, whom we will encounter later in the episode today, Isabella d'Este,
was so fond of a particular kind of white wine, Malvasia, kind of a Swedish white wine, that she would drink it at breakfast.
So I thought that today we could make an exception to our cocktail schedule and go for a simple glass of white Malvasia wine.
In the 15th century, Mantua and the Gonzaga were known also for their antiquarian taste.
They were somewhat obsessed with another city, which is going to loom very large in today's episode, Rome.
We don't know how many times Antico went to Rome, but probably many.
But at least once he left a mark there.
He signed a sculpture group that is known as the Horse Tamers of the Quirinal Hill.
They are still now visible in Rome, you see them on the left.
He signed this sculpture group because he restored it, probably sometime around the 1470s or 1880s.
And this tells us that Antico at least once went to Rome.
The fact that he went to Rome does not come as a surprise.
In Mantua, people were absolutely obsessed, as I said, about this antiquarian culture.
And you can see it here, for example, in this canvas by the famous painter who worked in Mantua throughout his life, Andrea Mantegna.
This is one of the Nine Triumphs of Julius Caesar,
nine large canvases that are now at Hampton Court in London by Andrea Mantegna.
And you see here, these canvases are studded with a number of artifacts from ancient times,
temples, tablets, helmets, statues, and so on.
And you see here in this comparison with this bust, this bronze bust by Antico, which you see on the right,
that is now at the MFA in Boston, that Antico and Mantegna,
although they were very different from so many points of view, they worked in different media,
still they shared this visual agenda that pivoted on the ancient classical past.
And you can see that here in this replica by Antico in bronze on the right of an ancient marble statue,
the so-called Apollo del Belvedere, one of the most celebrated sculptures from antiquity.
And here, I mean, we really need to think that at the time, ancient sculpture and ancient civilization was the hype of the day.
It was the coolest thing.
Now, we tend to think after neoclassicism and all that, that these are sort of always the same replicas of the classical past,
which we know inside out.
But back in the 15th century, this was brand new.
These statues had just been unearthed.
For example, the Apollo had just been unearthed a few years before Antico went to Rome,
and he could see it and appreciate it.
So we really need to think that ancient civilizations were very much the coolest thing in the 15th century.
And also that copying was, to an extent, a creative process.
As you see, Antico adds the bow to Apollo's arm.
And that's because these statues were often found in a fragmentary state.
And as we've seen, he restored the horse tamers of the Quirinal Hill,
just because these statues were often missing limbs or attributes,
and artists had to recreate them and refashion the antique in a way.
So imitation was, to an extent, a very creative process at the time.
So most of Antico's statuettes are made after ancient sculptures.
We don't really know if that's the case for our Hercules at the Frick.
There's a bronze statuette, which you see on the right, which is at the Louvre now,
which was sometimes believed to be the prototype for Antico's Hercules.
But in fact, many scholars believe that this is a later cast after Antico's own statuette.
Regardless of the relationship between these two objects,
Antico would have found so many different sources of inspiration for his Hercules.
For example, you see this small bronze statuette at the Met.
They share the same kind of body type, the same facial type, the hair, the beard,
the position of the hand holding probably the apples of the Hesperides,
another of Hercules's labors, the lion pelt.
So statuettes like this could have provided Antico with a source of inspiration for his Hercules.
But also you see here this much larger scale Hercules of the Forum Boarium, as it's known,
which is now in Rome in the Mosaic Capitolini.
This is more than two meters high.
And this as well could have provided Antico with a source of inspiration for his Hercules.
So we now start to understand what Antico's works are really about.
They bring the monumentality of ancient sculpture into the hands of the viewer.
And unlike ancient little statuettes, they are so refined that they are almost jewel-like.
So they combine the monumentality of ancient sculpture with jewel-like qualities of things
that you can hold in your hands and appreciate in close viewing.
So that's what made these statuettes so appealing to the rulers of the day.
And if you look at the side views of the Hercules, you realize how astonishing this statuette is.
Antico managed to create a full round statuette that could be seen 360 degrees round.
So you can look at this from so many different angles, and it's always rewarding.
He managed to model a statuette that could be seen from all angles.
And that's implicit, in a way, in the small round vase on which Hercules stands.
That small vase is one of Antico's most clever inventions,
because it tells us that this really needs to be appreciated as a full-size statue,
as if it were a public sculpture.
And you can turn it in your hands.
You can follow the shape of this round vase and turn it in your hands
and appreciate it from all different angles.
And if you do that, you realize, as you see here, that the refinement of the lion pelt,
where you can see each single hair of the pelt,
and these wonderful gilded locks of hair on the top of his head,
and the beard, and the silvering of the eyes,
in this lost, somehow, in this dreamlike expression.
And also, compare this to the little bronze statuette from the Met,
which I showed you before, which is greenish.
And this is dark black.
It's in a dark black tone,
which tells us that Antico managed to find a chemical formula
that would stabilize the appearance of this dark bronze over time.
And the fact that this has survived 500 years of history
is just amazing, if you think about it.
So, are there any other sculptors who tried to do something like Antico was doing?
The answer is yes.
For example, Filarete on the left, or Bertoldo di Giovanni on the right.
You might have seen the Bertoldo statuette in a recent exhibition at the Frick,
a wonderful exhibition on Bertoldo di Giovanni.
Both of them tried to grapple with ancient statues.
For example, the inspiration for both these works
is the equestrian monument of Marcus Aurelius on the Capitol Hill in Rome.
But you see here that they never quite managed to get to the same level
of philological accuracy in the replication of the details of ancient statuary,
also because many works hadn't been unearthed yet
by the time Bertoldo and Filarete were working on these statuettes.
But also, so it's a more free, let's say,
interpretation of what antique works would look like.
But also, they are technically much more deficient
and they are definitely not as refined as Antico's statuettes.
They don't have that jewel-like quality we were talking about before.
So technical virtuosity is also something that,
it's definitely something that characterizes Antico's works.
And here you see five different versions of the Frick Hercules.
The Frick exemplar is, in a way, the most accomplished,
the most refined, the most precious.
But other four Hercules exist in the world,
which probably were cast by Antico.
The fact that this was possible,
that he could cast five different versions of the same statue,
is astonishing, is an incredible innovation.
Normally, back then when you had to cast the statuette,
you would, the wax model after which you cast it
would go lost in the process because it would get melted.
But Antico comes up with new innovative technique
that allows him to preserve the wax model and replicate it over time.
And here, again, we need to shift our way of thinking about copies
because after the Industrial Revolution,
we tend to think that copies are worthless,
that things that can be copied are not original
and so are devoid of artistic significance.
But back then, actually, the fact that something could be copied
was a way to attest to something's importance.
So replicability went hand in hand with appreciation.
So the more something was copied, the more important it was.
It's not like it is today.
Definitely, this is something completely different.
But we also know that Antico's patrons
would guard very safely the replication of their works.
Antico worked mainly for the Gonzaga family,
only basically for the Gonzaga family,
and the Gonzagas managed to curb the possibilities
of copying these works over time.
So these could only be enjoyed by themselves for their private pleasures
or they could be replicated as gifts to be given
to prominent visitors coming to the court.
So it's very hard to tell for whom Antico cast our Hercules,
but we do know that Antico only worked for members of the Gonzaga family.
In particular, he started his career working for these two members,
Giovanni Francesco Gonzaga di Rodigo and Antonia del Valzo,
who are represented here in two wonderful medals by Antico,
which are at the Frick Collection as a gift from Stephen and Janie, who share.
And you see here the first main patrons of Antico.
Later on, he went on working for Bishop-elect Ludovico Gonzaga,
another member of the family, another cadet branch.
And then he went on, although he was still working throughout his life for Antonia,
Antonia del Valzo, who you see here,
he started working for another prominent woman, Isabella d'Este.
Isabella came from Ferrara, from the Este court in Ferrara,
as the wife of Francesco II Gonzaga, Marquess of Mantua.
After her husband's death, she became the, she was the Marquess of Mantua,
and she effectively ruled the city for a number of years.
And she is so celebrated because she could,
she entertained the most highly educated and cultivated court.
She was a patron of the arts.
She could fearlessly talk on the same level with popes, emperors.
She was one of the key figures in Italian politics at the time,
European politics, really, at the time.
She was so immensely important, despite the fact that she was a woman,
which back then was definitely, wouldn't have made her life very easy at the time.
And if you want to sort of navigate the psychology of this extraordinary woman,
I recommend to you this wonderful book, Private Renaissance by Maria Bellucci,
which is now available in a wonderful English translation.
And it's a riveting book. It's really a page turner.
And you can really manage to see the world of 15th and 16th century Italy
through the eyes of this unbelievable woman.
You see her here, by the way, in a portrait by Titian,
which she asked him to paint when she was much older than she looks here.
She asked Titian to paint it sort of retrospectively,
as she would have looked like many years before as a young, attractive woman.
And we never know for whom Antico cast his statuettes,
except in this particular case of this Hercules and Antaeus,
which is now in Vienna in the Kunsthistorisches Museum,
which is inscribed with an inscription which tells us that this belonged to Isabella d'Este.
It's very hard to tell among the different Gonzaga inventories
which list statuettes of Hercules, which is which.
So it's almost impossible.
But if you think about it, the fact that Antico never inscribed his works,
except in this case, or the fact also that he didn't sign them.
So we don't ever really know,
except that if we look at the technical achievements of them,
we don't really know how to ascribe them to Antico.
But the fact that he didn't sign them is very clever.
In a way, the game, the pretend game here was that these statuettes were, in fact, antiques.
So had he signed them with his name, Antique,
he would have declared that, in fact, they were not.
So he would have sort of destroyed this pretend game of antiquity for these works.
So the works of art themselves become the signature of Antico, of Antique.
So we don't really know much about the history of the Hercules by Antico at the Frick.
But we do know that it was at the beginning of the 20th century in J.P. Morgan's collection,
and that it was acquired by Henry Clay Frick in 1916.
It was acquired for the incredibly low amount of $165.
It was obviously a lot of money at the time,
but still we know that other statuettes, bronze statuettes, were valued at $100,000, for example.
So we don't know how Henry Clay Frick got away with this statuette for just $165.
We don't know if that's because nobody actually realized how important this was.
But he might have realized that because he kept the statuette for his private collection,
and it was only donated to the Frick by his daughter, Helen Clay Frick, in 1970.
So as some of you may know, Antico's statuette will join some others at the Frick's new temporary home, Frick Madison.
We are really thrilled to be able to welcome visitors back to the Frick very soon at our new home, Frick Madison,
which is open to the public on the 18th of March, 2021.
Frick Madison is located just five blocks north at the Breuer Designed Building at 945 Madison Avenue and 75th Street.
Frick Madison will provide visitors with the exciting opportunity to see rarely seen and favorite works of art from the collection in a new way,
outside of the domestic setting of the Frick's gilded age mansion.
So for more information about the opening and on how to purchase advance tickets, please click the link below in the pinned comment.
Thank you for joining me tonight. And I'm looking forward to a new episode of Cocktails with a Curator with you very soon.
Goodbye. Thanks.
