The Reformation in England witnessed the destruction of the most brilliant art of the medieval age. Church paintings and stained glass - even sculpture - were destroyed throughout England in the name of religion. And yet one art survived against the odds - the art of medieval embroidery.
Portable and easily squirrelled away, English embroidery was spirited out of the country in the 16th century and many brilliant examples survive today - if slightly unappreciated and forgotten in Italian churches and museums, even the Vatican. And yet it is an art form that rivalled the very finest in medieval painting or stained glass and for 200 years was the finest embroidery in the western world. Known simply as Opus Anglicanum (English work), the work of English embroiders was desired by kings and popes throughout Christendom.
Dan Jones, Plantagenet expert and medievalist, goes in search of these fragile yet stunning survivors from the great age of embroidery - encountering a world of finery, bejewelled luxury and sacred beauty on an undreamt-of scale.
For much of the Middle Ages, England excelled at ecclesiastical art.
Our religious wall paintings, stained glass, church sculpture and carving
were amongst the finest in Europe.
But there's a forgotten art,
of which we were the very best in the Western world,
the art of embroidery.
For almost 300 years,
the work of English embroiderers was sought all over Christendom.
The extraordinary Bayer tapestry showed what we were capable of,
but it was just a hint of the glories to come.
And when the fanaticism of the Reformation engulfed England
and so much of our religious art was destroyed,
it was the sumptuous embroidered vestments of the church
which were easily rolled up and spirited away.
Now the best medieval English embroidery is abroad,
or has only been brought back to the UK in modern times.
This is the unsung story of English embroidery of a golden age,
and how, against all the odds,
some of the greatest masterpieces survived.
It's almost as if this whole piece has been signed with a needle.
This is from England.
You always want to stroke it to touch it, but absolutely forbidden.
The English elevated the craft of embroidery
into an art of stunning realism and emotion.
This is deliberate.
This is designed to shock, to scare, to intimidate.
Fragile and faded,
English embroidery gives us an extraordinary glimpse
into the medieval world.
These days, everyone's well-dressed,
particularly, it seems, here in Rome.
But 700 or 800 years ago, fine clothing was a rarity
afforded only to the rich.
Medieval English embroidery was nothing short of pure luxury,
famed and desired across Europe.
In the inventories of castles, palaces and cathedrals,
it was referred to as opus anglicanum,
simply put, English work.
The greatest patron of opus anglicanum was the Catholic Church.
For more than 200 years, from the early 1100s
until the middle of the 14th century,
English embroiderers were as highly sought after
as the best architects, sculptors and painters
that Europe had to offer.
In the medieval period, most people couldn't read,
so the look of the liturgy was paramount.
Religious vestments, especially the cope, a bishop's outer cloak,
needed to evoke the majesty of Christ.
But over the centuries, the cope evolved
into an illuminated manuscript and fabric
depicting scenes from the life of Christ and the lives of the saints,
a visual sermon in stitchwork.
In the Archbasilica of St John Lateran in Rome,
fragile and faded, kept in gloomy conditions behind protective glass,
is a masterpiece of embroidery dating back almost 700 years.
It's the Lateran cope. It's the first time I've seen it.
And I've got to say, it's absolutely astonishing.
It's almost bewildering.
And it's not just the fineness of the detail, the craftsmanship,
this combination of taste and piety and ostentation.
It's actually the scale of the thing.
What we've got to remember is this isn't just a piece of art.
It's designed to be worn.
It's a processional cape of the church's top brass.
I'm reasonably tall, and I'm going to stretch up tiptoes
just to reach the top of it.
What we can see here, this is the offering at the top,
and this would have sort of hung down here,
while the rest of the piece just enveloped whoever was wearing it.
In fact, if you come in closely here, you can see there's some wear,
and that would have come from the right shoulder.
A man lucky enough to be enveloped by this piece.
There's some fantastically rich imagery here,
and we have... It's hard to know almost where to start.
OK, down the back here, this would have been broad of the shoulders,
trailing all the way down behind whoever's wearing it.
The centrepiece, obviously, the crucifixion here.
And down here, we've got this lovely...
It's almost like a cartoon strip, some of it.
We have the Annunciation, the Nativity, the Adoration of Kings.
It's kind of telling a story as it sweeps past.
All the wear and tear on the piece is here,
along the fringe at the bottom.
And so we can imagine that's where it's worn away,
as it's just flowed behind whoever was wearing it, dragging on the ground.
This was something that was used, it was processional.
You can imagine the gold glinting in the light,
candlelight or out in the street.
Over here, what catches my eye, we have these griffins.
These little griffins just here, I really like those.
Over here, we've got angels as we go.
Here, we have lives of the saints.
We have St Andrew martyred on his cross here.
But this is what's really interesting.
This is St Edmund of Bury.
He's being martyred.
He's been killed in 869 by the great Viking heathen army.
He was killed for refusing to renounce Christianity.
And they're firing arrows into him.
We've got one, two, three, four, five arrows here.
And they also cut his head off, just to be sure.
But his presence here is important
because it's a clue about the origins of the cope.
St Edmund wasn't very well known outside England,
so the fact that he's here tells us that this is English work.
English embroiderers had immense technical prowess.
They gave the human body a naturalism
that brought stories of Christ and the saints to life.
And the human face, so often inscrutable in Gothic art,
acquired a new emotional realism in the hands of English embroiderers.
Round the corner, at the Vatican Museum,
is another survival of Opus Anglicanum,
where the human drama of the crucifixion is at its most moving.
Sometimes today we think of embroidery as a craft or a hobby,
something that's done by ladies of leisure.
But this is art.
The intricacy of the design, the faces we can see,
the colours throughout, we've got gold thread and silver thread.
It's like painting with a needle.
Back in Britain, near Westminster Abbey,
I'm on my way to one of London's oldest ecclesiastical outfitters.
The cope was a part of a whole liturgical wardrobe
that I need to understand.
Modern religious vestments may no longer be covered in dense embroidery,
but they still seek to transform the wearer
and send a message to the faithful.
The religious vestments of Opus Anglicanum are too delicate even to touch,
so this is the closest I'm going to get.
So the first thing that goes on is this, which is called an amiss,
and it was basically a neck cloth.
But it goes over your head to start with.
Well, let's get it on then.
All right.
OK.
I feel slightly like Little Bo Peep.
I won't say you look like Little Bo Peep.
Thank you very much. Not my confidence, no.
Next thing is the alb.
This is this all-enveloping white garment, which we've got here.
In you go.
I'm just diving in?
Just diving in, yeah. Come on.
All right.
Oh, it's big.
I told you, it's all-enveloping.
It really is.
The next thing that goes on is rope tie, girdle or cincture.
And...
I mean, do bishops these days have buckles, or is it still ropes?
No, no, no, they still use this, I mean, to a very large extent.
This is still the full kit which they would put on.
OK, so I really feel I'm beginning to transform.
That's absolutely what it's all about.
It's all about transformation.
It's taking you from being an ordinary person
walking around the street to become, in a sense,
a special person that's going to perform
the great miracle of transubstantiation,
which is, in a sense, the ultimate transformation.
So, in a sense, the transformation of the robes
mirrors the transubstantiation...
You see, you can't do that.
You can't do that unless you are a completely different person.
Right, well, I'm starting to feel like a completely different person.
Well, you're starting to look like it.
Next thing on, stole.
And you see, all of that would have been accompanied
by a whole series of prayers.
You don't just sort of sling it on and going out.
No, no, no.
You're really thinking about what you're doing.
Really thinking about it. With the girdle, for example,
the prayer that goes with putting that on is,
gird me about, O Lord, with the cincture of purity...
Pretty pure, yeah.
..and quench in my heart the fire of concupiscency
and the virtue of constancy and chastity may abide in me.
Next, this is very much a medieval thing, which is the Dalmatic.
It's a coloured version of the alb, really.
I presume you get more elegant as you get more experienced.
You do, yeah. I don't feel particularly...
OK. Last thing's last.
This is the chasuble.
This is the maniple. OK.
This finally comes off.
And that forms a collar.
Well, I've no idea what I look like, but I feel quite smart.
You look terribly medieval.
I do? Yes! I feel good about that.
But there's something missing.
There's something missing.
The mitre. OK, are you ready for this?
I've been waiting all my life, I think, yeah. OK, fine.
There you go. Wow. OK, are you ready?
I think so.
Oh, my God!
I am almost speechless.
This is quite incredible.
I mean, I honestly feel like a different person.
I've never worn anything quite like this, I think it's fair to say.
So when would I have worn this?
As a bishop, you would have worn that when you were celebrating Mass.
But then again, as a bishop,
you wouldn't necessarily always be celebrating Mass.
And when you didn't, you'd wear the coat.
Ah. Well, can I try it on?
OK. Let's have a go at that.
Off with the hat. My favourite bit.
OK.
Oh, goodness, that's a lot heavier.
What's this made of?
This one's made of velvet.
It really feels... It's a lot heavier than the Chosebol.
Mustn't forget that mitre.
That's it.
And tell me, what's it made up of?
OK, what you've got here is, in origin, a rain cloak.
And what we've got on the back is what's left of the hood
that would have originally gone over your head.
And on the front, these panels here are called the orpheries.
Mm-hm.
And they would have been used, again, for embroidery,
and they would be images of saints or scenes from the life of Christ.
So as well as looking rather grand,
I suppose I'm telling people about the history and the stories of the church.
Absolutely. Yes, you'd be a bit like a stained-glass window.
Well, David, thank you very much.
It's a real insight into how Opus Anglicanum
and all the rest of these vestments would have been used.
This has been absolutely terrific. Thank you.
It's been a great pleasure.
The medieval English church was an enormous power in the land,
richer and often more influential than the king.
It could afford to commission the best painters,
the best embroiderers, the finest materials.
But not all embroidery was about the lives of the saints.
Some celebrated the power of the sword,
the age of chivalry.
In the town of Marseille, on the German-Belgian border,
the earliest examples of English embroidery survive.
Over 1,000 years old, these fragments are a mystery.
No-one knows whether they were secular or religious,
what they were part of, or, indeed, what they were for.
We need to move forward 200 years
to encounter a piece of English embroidery
whose message is unmistakable.
The Bayer tapestry commemorates the most significant moment
in English medieval history,
but if its narrative is clear,
it has still given rise to the biggest misunderstanding
in the history of embroidery.
First things first.
The Bayer tapestry isn't a tapestry, it's an embroidery.
A tapestry is woven on a loom.
An embroidery is stitched, you need a needle and thread.
And it's not even French.
You might celebrate the Norman invasion,
but academics think that it was made in England,
and specifically in Kent.
Incredibly fragile, the 1,000-year-old Bayer tapestry
is entombed in a high-tech case with low-level lighting to match.
It's 230 feet long
and commemorates the Battle of Hastings in 1066
and the invasion of England by William of Normandy.
Made of dyed woolen yarn on linen,
it's thought to have taken seven years to complete.
It's an astonishing piece of work that tells a dramatic story.
From the details of feeding an army
and transporting horses across the English Channel,
the makers of this embroidery
wanted to preach a particular version of history.
The brilliant victory of William,
climaxing in the death of King Harold and the conquest of England.
The Bayer tapestry may look naive in places, even unsophisticated,
but it's set in English fashion
for using embroidery to communicate a powerful message.
Now, we'll probably never know who designed the Bayer tapestry,
but we're almost certain that it was women who embroidered it.
And that's because around the time of 1066 and all that,
embroidery was a pious and acceptable occupation for women.
Even very well-off ladies did it.
So we know that Canute the Great's wife embroidered altar cloths.
Edward the Confessor's wife embroidered his clothes.
The English already had a reputation.
One French writer wrote, shortly after the conquest,
that women of England are very skilled with the needle.
So around the 11th and early 12th centuries,
women were devoting a considerable amount of their time to this art,
but it was men who were paying for it.
And they could afford to do this
because parts of England were awash with money.
And nowhere was richer than Canterbury, the mother church of England.
Here, by the 12th century,
the archbishop was dressing in the very finest clothing money could buy.
And that, of course, meant English embroidery.
The proof can be found in some extraordinary ecclesiastical slippers and boots.
Hidden away in the cathedral archives, rarely seen or exposed to daylight,
today they're coming out of their protective wrappings.
Wow. Wow.
Now, this is a very early example of opus anglicanum on a religious vestment.
These are buskins, so they're a bishop's footwear.
And what's remarkable about them is they're actually worn by a bishop,
and we know which bishop. In fact, it was an archbishop,
Hubert Walter, Archbishop of Canterbury,
who was around in 1200,
about the time of Richard the Lionheart and Bad King John.
Now, these may be religious vestments,
but what's really striking about them is the subject matter.
I mean, it's very much secular.
So here on the buskins, we have crosses, but we also have these eagles here,
we have stars, we have dots here, and more crosses on the feet.
But on the slippers, they're a little fleur-de-lis here.
We have these garnets running around the top.
These dragons here.
I really love the lions on the side, just here.
But what's also interesting about these is they were made
only a century or so after the Bay of Tapestry,
but already we can see the style evolving,
so we have much finer needlework.
There's silk used here instead of wool.
We've got gilt here on the eagle, which you can still see glinting.
And what's extraordinary to think, as we sit here looking at these,
is just how much more money was spent on Opus Anglicanum in years to come.
The creation of ever more fantastic religious clothing in the 13th century
happened during a boom time for England.
The city of London had never known such an energetic age of trade and commerce.
The boom was based on the export of wool,
and English sheep were reputed to produce the best wool.
Selling wool to the continent allowed England to trade in gold,
silk and precious jewels.
Key ingredients to make the finest embroidery.
In 1271, an autofront for Westminster Abbey
took four women nearly four years to embroider.
The bill back then was £36, but based on average earnings,
that's a staggering half a million pounds today,
and that's before paying for the gold, silk, pearls, garnets and enamels.
So producing embroidery was big, big money,
and consequently there was profit to be made.
The best embroiderers worked here in the city of London,
where all aspects of trade were regulated by the guilds.
They imposed quality control and a monopoly grip
to ensure the best trading terms.
So the fishmongers were down by the river near London Bridge.
The merchant tailors, obviously, were on Threadneedle Street.
Just off Cheapside, the goldsmiths and silversmiths,
and cheek-by-jowl with them, the broderers.
These were the streets where England's finest
and most desirable luxury goods were painstakingly crafted.
And it was the Broderers' Guild that ensured English embroidery was the best.
Apprentices served seven years to learn their craft.
Pieces like this could only be produced by embroiderers working in daylight,
and with the highest grade silk and gold thread.
And central to the quality of English work
was the precision of the stitch work and the density,
covering every inch of the fabric
and yet allowing a flexibility to the finished garment.
It was all down to two extraordinary stitches
that became the signature of Opus Anglicanum
and set English embroiderers apart from the rest of Europe.
I'm on my way to the Royal School of Embroidery at Hampton Court Palace
to see how it's done.
First, the split stitch, where the needle turns back on itself,
coming back up through the previous stitch and splitting the thread.
It gives the stitching absolute precision.
It's quite a basic principle.
So I'm doing a stitch, really tiny,
bringing my needle up through that stitch and splitting it in half.
So you just have to make sure you split it each time
so you've got a continuous line then.
And what's the point of split stitch? Why do it?
It just makes it a very, very solid and dense area.
Everything is joined together.
And is there something you can do with split stitch
that other stitches simply can't achieve?
Because of the way the stitches are worked,
it actually looks like it's shaded
because it's tight in the middle.
It goes round and round so it looks like it's got shading to it
and that's purely just the stitch.
So there's no colour.
So these round stitches here on the cheek, that's what's giving us that effect?
Yeah.
Would you like to have a little go with this one here?
Well, absolutely, yeah. I'm sure I'm going to be a master at this.
So what am I doing?
Right hand underneath.
Right hand underneath?
Yep. Left hand on top, that's it.
So you want to do a tiny little stitch.
Just here?
Yeah.
And then using your right hand, pull the needle through.
Oh, so it's two-handed, I see.
Let go now on this hand.
Try and split that stitch.
I've sort of lost where my initial stitch was.
Because it's so tiny.
It's so tiny.
I've got pretty good eyesight but this is difficult.
Ah, there we go.
That's it, pull through.
Bit wonky but...
It's alright.
Do you think I've got promise?
It's alright, yeah, definitely.
Yeah?
Yep.
Just a matter of practice, right?
Yeah, a lot of practice.
A lot of practice, okay.
So that's taken me about 20 seconds to do my first stitch.
How long did it take you to do what we've got so far on this face?
I've got about six hours' work so far on here.
Six hours just to do this cheek?
Yep.
Do you ever get really frustrated and just throw it all up in the air?
No.
You must be a very even-tempered person.
I'm already feeling like...
The split stitch is the secret behind the subtle three-dimensional impression
on human faces in Opus Sanglicanum.
As the cheek work spirals to its centre,
almost a painterly light and shade is the result.
But it was the second technique, underside couching,
that allowed a thick surface intensity of gold thread
together with a flexibility suitable for clothing.
The heavy gold thread is held in place on the fabric surface
by a second thread made of linen.
This is underside couching.
So this is gold.
Gold?
Yes.
Wow.
Okay, so what's the difference?
Well, two parts, so they would have had silk embroidery
and also they would have had gold on the same piece.
So we're using thread which has got real gold in it.
So this is real gold?
It's got real gold in there.
And what is it, solid gold thread?
I just break a bit from the end.
It's actually gold around the outside
and you can see it's got a silk or cotton core in the middle there
and it's wrapped around.
And that just makes it a bit more flexible.
It's actually quite a flexible thread.
Okay, and why do you need it to be so flexible?
Because we're going to take a little bit of the gold
through to the back
and that's what is special about underside couching.
If you just had your gold on the top,
it makes it very solid and flexible.
And because these things were used as vestments,
so they were worn,
you wanted it to be a little bit more flowing.
Let me get my hands on it then.
Right, so I'm going to bring up the needle
in the right position for you.
Okay, thank you.
So needle it in your right hand.
Right hand, okay.
And with your left hand,
you want to have a bit of tension on there, that's it.
I see.
What you're doing now is you're creating a hole
by holding that quite taut.
Yes, I do that.
And you should be able to just about see a little space
where the thread's coming out,
so you want your needle down.
We're going back the way we came.
That's it.
Is that about right?
Yeah.
I feel like I'm a natural.
So right hand now is pulling the needle through.
Yes.
You can let go of your left hand.
Okay.
This is quite hard.
It's very hard.
Doesn't it hurt your fingers?
Yeah.
As this linen thread comes through,
it will take a bit of the gold with it
and you should be able to hear it.
And what happens if...
That's it.
Did you hear it now?
I heard it.
I heard it pop.
That's it.
What happens if I were to break this thread now?
If you broke the gold thread,
we'd have to take out the entire row.
That would be incredibly frustrating.
That would be, so let's not do that.
At the Victoria and Albert Museum in London,
there's a small piece of ecclesiastical embroidery
that has some of the finest stitch work to survive.
All the trademarks of the best of opus anglicanum.
Split stitching in the fine details of the faces.
Underside couching for the rich gold thread background.
This is an ecclesiastical berse.
Originally, it would have been folded down the middle
to form the bag that held the corporal,
the cloth that the chalice is placed on during mass.
The quality of the embroidery on this is just unbelievable.
It looks impressive by the naked eye,
but when you get under the magnifying glass,
what you can see is that each stitch is absolutely perfect.
If you look at the Virgin here,
she has really feminine features.
And then if you move over to Christ on the cross here,
the hair is what impresses me.
The hair has been done, it really has the texture of hair.
It's astonishing this has been done with a needle.
When we get to his abdomen, he has six-pack abs.
This is anatomically correct.
The stitching is circular and very tight.
I'm amazed to see this on something
that's from the early 14th century.
Then we move across to this scene here,
and this is the coronation of the Virgin in heaven.
And originally, I wasn't sure
whether this was God the Father or God the Son
who was crowning her, but if we look really closely here,
his hands and his feet,
we can actually see the stigmata, the wounds.
There's been red...
There are red stitches coming through
each of his hands and his feet
Just within this little outline,
the quality and the depth and the fineness of the work on this piece
is just phenomenal.
Trade with Italy took many of the finest examples
of English embroidery abroad,
and today it's where most opus anglicanum survives.
To the best-dressed Italian clerics,
owning vestments made in England
is a mark of piety and sophistication.
I'm heading for the romantic setting of Ascoli Puccino,
a fine Renaissance town built out of the local marble.
Many vestments, copes and chosibors
were commissioned specifically by the popes,
but others were made as gifts to curry political favour.
In fact, by 1295, the Vatican inventory lists
no fewer than 80 separate pieces of opus anglicanum.
And here, in Ascoli Puccino, on Italy's east coast,
is a particularly splendid example,
which oddly was used to fund part of this fantastic cathedral.
For centuries, the cope here was kept at the local cathedral,
but these days it enjoys a safer home at the town's civic museum,
because even here in Italy,
many English copes did not enjoy a trouble-free history.
It's not just the ravages of decay that have taken their toll,
but the extravagance of the work that was an everlasting temptation.
Unmistakably English. How do we know?
Well, if we look at the technical details,
all over there's a huge amount of gilt thread surviving,
and it's the underside couching that's very typical of English work.
We also have split-stitch on the clothes
and where it survives on the faces.
The faces themselves, the details and expressions feel very English.
But if that's not enough,
what we also have on the clothes of the characters all over this cope,
and particularly down here, the Virgin Mary,
we have these lions passing guard on,
and that's the English royal symbol.
It's almost as if this whole piece has been signed with a needle.
This is from England.
What we don't have along the offer at the top here
are the hundreds of pearls which were once attached.
They were sold in 1798 to fund the building
which we've just seen round the corner, the Capella del Sacramento.
But what I find really interesting here
is that each of these circles shows a scene from the life of a different pope.
I like to call it the Pope Cope.
They're quite carefully arranged.
So along the top we have early popes,
all of whom have been martyred.
On the middle row, the subject matter changes.
These are all popes who are famed for their interpretation of scriptures.
Down the bottom is where it gets really interesting.
These are all popes who were alive
at around the time this piece was made.
It's mid-13th century,
and the really intriguing one is down here.
This is Clement IV,
and he gives us a clue
to the whole provenance of this piece of English work.
We think this cape was commissioned by Ottobono Fieschi,
who was a cardinal legate sent to England by Clement IV.
He was sent to make peace between Henry III
and his rebellious barons and bishops.
And it's likely that Ottobono commissioned this
as a political gift for his master.
It seems like it worked, because a few years later,
Ottobono was pope himself, as Hadrian V.
But the story of this cope doesn't end there.
If copes were extremely valuable in the Middle Ages,
by the 20th century, they were worth a small fortune.
Easily wrapped up and spirited away,
the Ascoli Piceno Cope mysteriously disappeared
from the local cathedral in 1902.
Two years later, in 1904,
the cope was spotted on display in London at the V&A,
where it had been loaned by its owner,
or so he thought, the American banker J.P. Morgan.
There was a huge public outcry, scandal, ruined reputations,
even reports that the guy who'd fenced it
had killed himself in prison.
Happily, in 1907, J.P. Morgan bequeathed it and it came home.
But you'll notice it's here in the Civic Museum
and not across the road in the cathedral.
You almost get the feeling the locals
didn't quite trust the priests anymore.
The joy of a life lived according to Christian principles
inspired many of the English copemakers
to depict images of beauty,
scenes of redemption to lift people's religious imagination.
But in the lives of the saints,
there were also dire warnings
that a Christian life could mean suffering and pain.
There were no newspapers in the Middle Ages,
so the best way to get across any political, social or religious message
was through public spectacle.
For the church, the most important message was the life of Christ.
So in religious art from the period,
we see the nativity, the crucifixion, the resurrection.
But there were other stories too, particularly the lives of the saints.
And it's when we start to understand these,
we realise what the people who wore and saw all this finery
were really thinking.
Bologna in northern Italy.
In the City Museum,
it's one of the best-preserved pieces of opus anglicanum.
But to save its delicate colours,
it hangs in a basement in sepulchral gloom.
This is the Bologna Cope.
And I could stand in front of it all day
because what this Cope does
is take us directly into the medieval religious mindset.
It's constructed very carefully.
There are two almost strips, almost like comic strips here,
and they're telling us particular stories,
both from the life of Christ
and the two most important stories from the life of Christ.
We start on this outer semicircle here
with the story of Christ's birth.
And it goes chronologically.
So up here we have the archangel Gabriel
appearing to the Virgin Mary.
He's holding something that says Ave Maria.
And here we have the second really big story
in the Christian calendar, and it's Christ's death.
His passion, his crucifixion.
I want to pick out a few details here.
If we come down,
this is the shepherds.
They're being spoken to by the angel.
He's pointing at the star. Everything is in fine detail.
But what we can see is there are two sheep beneath them.
One of the shepherds is playing an instrument
that looks like a bagpipe.
The artist has been very, very careful about what he's done here.
I think you can imagine people seeing this,
feeling like it related to their own lives.
That is what medieval religion and spectacle is all about.
There's something else that I find fascinating.
Oh, these angels are absolutely delightful.
Each of them is playing a different instrument.
So one of them is playing a harp,
one of them is playing a pipe here.
Anyone who'd ever heard music, played music,
would have been able almost to hear the music of the angels playing.
It's so specifically, deliberately, beautifully done.
But the Bologna Cope has a dark side.
An embroidered vision designed not just to inspire,
but to instil fear.
This is one of the most horrible images
on this whole Cope.
It's the massacre of the innocents.
And we have this awful image of a soldier
with his spear thrust through a child, waving it aloft.
And here, I mean, a truly horrific image.
It's a woman holding the severed head of her child.
And that chimes up here,
when we have the story of Christ's passion.
We have this hell mouth,
and this beastly mouth roars open,
and within it, you have these sinners pleading towards Christ,
desperate for release.
This is deliberate.
This is designed to shock, to scare, to intimidate,
to fill people with the horror and the majesty of God.
To medievalise the jaws of hell would have been unmistakable.
A life of sin, guaranteeing an afterlife of eternal torment
in the sulphurous fires of hell.
And, of course, as ever,
the embroiderers haven't been able to resist,
leaving an English signature.
Now, this Cope tells us principally about the life of Christ.
But here we have St Thomas, or to us, Thomas Becket.
Here he is, on what would have been the right front of the Cope.
And his story follows on from that of Christ's birth
right through to the epiphany.
And yet, here's Becket.
There's nothing to do with the rest of the story.
This is the story from 1170.
Becket was killed in his own cathedral by four knights acting,
or acting so they thought, on the orders of King Henry II.
Becket's presence on this Cope tells us something important
about the place of martyrdom.
Martyrdom is something great. Martyrdom is something holy.
Martyrdom is something that is almost the pinnacle of religious nobility.
So what do we have?
Well, we have the liturgical seasons, the life of Christ,
we have music, we have colour, we have redemption,
we have hell, we have pain, we have gold.
I think everything you need to know about Christian belief
in the Middle Ages is here, in this Cope.
Back at the Victoria and Albert Museum in London
is one of the few pieces in Britain to rival the finest in Italy.
Even so, what you see today has had to be patched together.
Because in spite of its vibrant colour,
this Cope has had a particularly rough ride through history.
This beautiful Cope was made sometime between 1330 and 1350
at the absolute zenith of Opus Anglicanum.
And I've been lucky enough to be allowed inside the display case
to take a closer look.
But obviously, this thing is priceless.
So once I'm inside, I've been told I mustn't move around.
Sometime during its long history,
this Cope was sliced up to create various ecclesiastical vestments,
even an altar frontal.
But it has been painstakingly stitched back together
with inserts of darker red velvet, filling in the missing sections.
I've got to say, it's a very strange sensation
to be here inside the display case.
But it's also mesmerising to be this close.
You almost want to stroke it to touch it, but absolutely forbidden.
The Butler Bowden Cope is one of the most ornate, complex and ambitious
to survive in anything like its original state.
Underside couching and split stitching
define the bishops and kings in glorious colour and detail.
There are also brilliant depictions of the natural world.
Exotic parakeets.
And most remarkably, leopard heads
that still retain the seed pearls sewn onto their faces.
This Cope gives just a hint of how jewels and precious stones
were once a vibrant part of ecclesiastical embroidery.
And there's the familiar figure
of the martyred St Edmund of Bury, pierced by arrows.
The contemplative St Catherine,
with the wheel she miraculously broke during her martyrdom.
And the English king and founder of Westminster Abbey,
St Edward the Confessor.
What I really like are these multifoil ogee arches,
which seem almost to grow limbs
and bind everything together in a tableau of storytelling.
That taken together with just the sheer quality of the stitching
and the craftsmanship,
this is the absolute peak
of what English artists were able to achieve.
It's astonishing.
But if this Cope represents the peak of achievement,
it's also a last gasp for Opus Anglicanum.
Just after the Butler Bowden Cope was completed in the 1340s,
people in southern England started to die in huge numbers.
And by 1348, death stalked the city of London,
the centre of England's embroidery industry.
First, painful lumps developed on the underarms and thighs.
Then, internal bleeding caused dark blotches under the skin.
Certain death followed in a few days.
One of the worst pandemics in history had arrived in England.
The Black Death.
And it sounded the death knell for Opus Anglicanum.
Across Europe, population declined by around 40%.
But in urban centres like London, it was much worse.
More than half the people living here died.
The Black Death was cataclysmic.
Society had to completely readjust.
By the end of the century, the world was a very different place.
The London embroidery industry had been destroyed.
And by the time it recovered,
the initiative had been seized by Dutch embroiderers,
who worked more quickly and more cheaply.
The English followed suit.
Today, the dramatic shift in style and technique
can be seen in Threadneedle Street in the city of London,
still home to one of London's medieval guilds.
This is the funerary pool of the Merchant Tailors' Company.
This was a piece of rich material
that was placed over the coffin of the deceased member
for funerals and for their anniversary services.
The Merchant Tailors.
Is there anything identifying the Merchant Tailors here?
Well, you can see the scissors at the end here.
Ah, yes.
And also, the Merchant Tailors' Company
grew out of the fraternity of St John the Baptist.
And so you see John the Baptist featured prominently along the sides.
And here is St John the Baptist baptising Christ.
And then here, in a rather gruesome detail,
is the head of St John the Baptist on a plate
with an unnecessary inscription, it seems to me,
saying, Behold the head of the Baptist on a plate.
Yes, and we can see there's blood coming out of his severed neck.
Absolutely.
And he's quite gruesome, isn't he? Yes.
I'm looking at John the Baptist's face here
and there's definitely something technically different
to the opus anglicanum I've seen before.
In earlier opus anglicanum embroidery,
these stitches carefully follow the contours of the face.
Here, they're simply arranged in parallel lines on the face.
So there's much less of the sort of vivid, realistic human features
that we've seen when things are stitched in a rounder form.
What you're seeing is actually a change
in which the English are adopting continental techniques.
Unfortunately, by this stage,
England had become a follower rather than a leader.
Were standards being kept as high as had previously been?
I think not.
I think that in the early 15th century,
you'll find the Commons petitioning Henry VI in 1423
because they complained that people had...
..certainly embroiderers, were mixing in bad work with good
and that they were producing these things outside of London
to avoid the scrutiny of the king's wardens.
So by the time this is made,
is it fair to say that England is no longer the leader?
The heyday of opus anglicanum has come to its end.
I'm afraid opus anglicanum had definitely seen its heyday
by this date, and this is a very far cry from the earlier pieces.
What a shame.
With the fine techniques of English medieval embroidery abandoned
in favour of quicker, more profitable production methods
copied from mainland Europe,
the practice of opus anglicanum was dead.
And another event, no less cataclysmic than the Black Death,
would threaten even the evidence of England's great age of embroidery.
English life, its faith, its philosophies,
was about to experience a revolution.
A religious storm was brewing that would sweep away old certainties
and great works of art.
The early 16th century had seen a growing anti-Catholic feeling
spreading across Europe.
It was provoked by corruption,
the sale of church offices and indulgences.
But the sight of churchmen parading around in expensive vestments,
embroidered with gold and hundreds of jewels,
can't exactly have helped.
In the 1530s, the church in England broke with Rome.
The authority of the pope was overturned
and replaced by that of the king.
New theological arguments outlawed the traditional use of religious imagery.
It was the start of the Protestant Reformation in England.
Here at St Andrew's in North Birlingham, Norfolk,
the level of fanaticism is clear to see from the rude screen,
where images of the saints have been systematically vandalised.
I've never seen this before and it's genuinely shocking.
These images have literally been defaced,
all because they represented what was called the profane beast of Rome.
What you can feel from all of these images is the visceral hatred,
the violence and the fury of the men who did this.
Almost overnight, the treasures of one age became the heresy of the next.
And Opus Anglicanum's love of depicting the lives of the saints in Stichwo
and of the popes, too, made it a prime target.
And, sadly, an art so delicate and fragile,
so tempting for its removable gold thread and jewels,
was the easiest thing to vandalise or destroy.
One of the greatest arts of the medieval age was almost extinguished.
The flamboyant excess of English embroidery was simply too dangerous to own
because wherever it was found, like this rude screen,
like stained-glass windows, like carved images of saints,
like crosses in churchyards, it was destroyed.
Opus Anglicanum was simply too grand, too ostentatious,
too popish for the Reformation.
Around 30 major pieces of medieval English embroidery are all that survive.
Every piece, every fragment, an incredible rarity.
And we know next to nothing about the men and women
who designed and made these great vestments.
But in a gallery just off the main entrance of the Victoria and Albert Museum,
there's a cope that provokes the specialists
into a frenzy of speculation and excitement.
A cope with more clues to the taste and character of its creator than any other.
Today, the Zion Cope is having a rare outing from its display case,
under the watchful gaze of the V&A curator, Glyn Davis.
Mystery surrounds the origins of the cope.
It takes its name from Zion Abbey in Middlesex,
which owned it from the 15th century.
The cope survives today only because it was spirited abroad
by the intrepid nuns of Zion,
who fled Reformation England, taking it with them.
So it's amazing, Glyn, to have this out of its case.
How often do you take it out?
Very, very rarely.
We installed it in these new galleries in 2009.
I haven't seen it out of its case since.
So it's not taken out to be worn?
No, no, no, and that was the first time I'd seen it outside its case
in my entire time here at the museum.
So this is a rare, rare opportunity. It's wonderful to see.
So one thing that I'm fascinated by is round here.
And this I think you can tell us a bit more about.
We know, don't we, who made this?
Well, we have some idea about the man that it was made for,
and this is very unusual.
Unfortunately, it's still quite tantalising.
We don't know everything that we would like to.
But here he is.
Who's this?
He's this chap who's kneeling down here
beneath this scene of Christ appearing to Mary Magdalene.
This is the Noli me Tangere.
Christ is resurrected, he appears to Mary Magdalene,
and she wants to touch him, and he says,
No, you can't touch me.
I'd rather like this coat.
Absolutely.
And so kneeling in prayer beneath that,
you have this figure who's wearing the robe of a monk.
He's tortured, so again, we know he's a monk.
And he's holding a scroll in his hands,
and it has some lettering on it.
What does it say?
Well, it says, Dawn, Pears, Day.
And just to explain that, Dawn is like Don,
like Don Giovanni or Don John in Much Ado About Nothing.
It's a term for a gentleman.
OK.
And Pears is Pears or Peter, and Day just means of,
and normally you would then say where he was from.
And where was he from?
Whether he was from Gloucester or wherever.
Unfortunately, it doesn't go on to tell us.
So we know that he's a monk.
We know that he's a wealthy monk, and of course he was.
He could pay for this.
And we know that his name was Peter,
but we don't know an awful lot else about where he was from
or where this was made for.
But we know something about his tastes as a religious man.
OK, what do we know?
Well, we know that he was particularly devoted
to St Thomas the Apostle, or Doubting Thomas,
because here he is again kneeling beneath this scene
where Thomas is being asked to thrust his hand
into Christ's side wound.
And this is very funny.
I mean, there's a lot of gold thread on this particular scene.
Yeah, it's very beautiful.
And I think there's a deliberate contrast as well
with Mary Magdalene, who's not allowed to touch Christ,
and Thomas, who is.
And you see Thomas then appears again in the next frame around,
and he's standing there with his lance that he's martyred by.
But I think particularly interestingly,
Thomas appears a third time.
And it's up here in this scene,
which is really unique in medieval art,
because it's a combination of two scenes.
You've got the funeral of the Virgin Mary,
but at the back you can see the Virgin's soul
is going up into heaven,
and there's this kind of snake-like object
being passed down to this chap standing at the back.
And that man is Thomas,
and what he's being given is the Virgin's belt, her girdle,
which is one of the key relics of the Virgin,
which was kept in Pisa.
So this is a truly amazing object,
and it's one of so few that survive.
How many of these do you think might originally have been in existence?
Well, it's impossible to say, of course,
but if you look at the inventories of some of the great churches
and monasteries in England at the time,
it wouldn't be unusual to find 15 or 20 copes,
15 or 20 chasubles.
Sometimes many more than that.
So hundreds, if not thousands, of these objects
must originally have existed.
We must have lost over 90%.
Wow.
Today we recognise the artistic greatness of the medieval age
in its stained glass, its effigies and religious sculpture
and its architecture.
We should also proclaim it as the Age of Embroidery.
It's just that so little of it has survived.
A tantalising hint of one of the greatest artistic industries
England has ever produced.
But there remains the attractive possibility
that an old Catholic family unknowingly possesses
some ancient vestments,
tucked away inside a dusty chest or hidden behind a secret panel.
An embroidered treasure that survived history,
just waiting to come into the light.