This narration explores why a society lacks the rule of law, despite having a comprehensive legal system. It delves into the disconnect between laws and people, emphasizing that the rule of law requires laws to be society’s universal standard, ensuring fairness and justice. Drawing on Rudolph von Jhering’s purposive jurisprudence, it highlights the law as a manifestation of power and rights, born from struggle. Jhering’s concept of the “feeling of legal rights” underscores that spiritual pain from violated dignity drives legal defense. Without this, laws become obsolete, as seen in Roman legal tradition (desuetudo). Authoritarianism suppresses this feeling, undermining private rights. True lawmaking lies in practicing justice, not mere theory. The absence of struggle and emotional connection to laws renders them “dead,” highlighting the need for active engagement to foster a society governed by the rule of law.
0:00 Intro 0:26 The Puzzle of China’s Missing Rule of Law 0:49 Defining the Rule of Law’s Essence 1:38 Jhering’s Vision: Law as Dignity’s Guardian 2:36 The Roots of Legal Thought: Natural and Historical Schools 5:28 Law as Power: The Struggle for Rights 7:06 The Feeling of Legal Rights: Pain and Passion 11:12 Desuetudo: When Laws Expire Unused 13:00 Numbness and Authoritarianism: China’s Legal Tragedy 13:43 Misplacing Blame: Power vs. Law’s Decline 14:57 Authoritarianism’s Hidden Roots: Suppressing Rights 16:18 Dead Laws and Distant Hopes: China’s Legal Future
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dongsheng. Welcome to Digging into China, where we explore China in depth to review unique
perspectives. Today, let us explore why China lacks the rule of law, delving into this issue
from the foundational logic and core challenges of Chinese society. By understanding these
underlying principles, I believe we can gain a clear perspective on China and, indeed,
It is widely acknowledged that China is not a society governed by the rule of law.
Yet, a curious question arises. China has laws, and its legal framework is, in fact,
quite comprehensive. So why does the existence of laws do not translate into the rule of law?
This question is profoundly intriguing. The rule of law signifies that the law serves as
universal standard for society, superseding unwritten norms. Society operates under the
clear authority of the law, with fairness, justice, and transparency applied to all.
When disputes arise, they are resolved through legal channels. This is the essence of the rule
of law. The relationship between the law and individuals determines whether a society upholds
this principle. If this relationship is sound, the society is governed by the rule of law. However,
if the law and individuals are disconnected, the society falls short of this standard.
Thus, the critical question is, what defines the relationship between the law and the people?
This brings us to the work of a distinguished German jurist, Rudolf von Jaegen.
Jaegen eloquently articulated the connection between individuals and the law,
particularly the rights-based relationship that binds them. He argued that if the law
fails to uphold human dignity and protect human rights, it is as worthless as a discarded
sheet of paper. Let us begin by examining the nature of individuals, the law, and their relationships
through Jaegen's perspective. Rudolf von Jaegen was a prominent German jurist and a leading
authority on Roman law in the 19th century. As a legal scholar, Jaegen emphasized the purpose
of the law, giving rise to his philosophy known as purposive jurisprudence. This approach set
him apart from his predecessors. What is purposive jurisprudence? To understand this,
we must briefly review the history of legal theory. Prior to Jaegen, two major schools
of thought dominate the legal philosophy, the natural law school and the historical law school.
The natural law school emphasized the universality of law, asserting that the laws derive from
principles of justice inherent in nature. According to this view, the law's embodiment
of natural justice applies universally, resonating with the concept of inherent human rights.
The second school, the historical law school, represented by figures such as the renowned
jurist Severny, took a different stance. It emphasized the historical and specific nature
of law, arguing that laws do not reflect universal order or justice, but rather the unique spirit and
history of a nation. In essence, law is an expression of a distinct national identity.
For instance, Europeans revered Roman law, which they saw as embodying the unique spirit of Roman
citizens. Different nations with their distinct characteristics developed laws reflective of their
national identity. Jaegen, however, recognized the limitations of both schools. Neither, he argued,
constitute a true social science, nor could they directly advance the interests of society and its
people. Neither natural law or historical law empowered individuals with genuine agency or
effectively bridged the law with human experience. To clarify, let me simplify this. Natural law
suggests that laws are inherently bestowed by nature, implying that justice would naturally
emerge if people did nothing. This is clearly flawed. Can laws simply materialize without
effort? Can justice be achieved by remaining passive? Certainly not. Historical law, on the
other hand, attributes laws to a national spirit, as if claiming to inherit the legacy of Rome would
automatically yield the most noble and just laws. This notion is overly abstract and impractical.
While laws may carry a spiritual dimension, if that dimension is not grounded in reality, it remains
an empty ideal devoid of substance. Recognizing these shortcomings, Jaegen introduced
purposive jurisprudence. His aim was to illuminate the practical significance and purpose of the law,
grounding legal theory in real-world application. Two of his works, Structure for Law and The Law
as a Means to an End, directly expounded the principles of purposive jurisprudence.
In essence, Jaegen defined the law as the tangible manifestation of power, with human rights
representing a highly abstract form of the law. Put simply, law is power, and power is law.
How should we interpret this? Consider the English word bill, commonly understood as an
invoice. Its original meaning is a list. The bills we pay are, in fact, lists of payments.
Similarly, the historical document known as the Bill of Rights, found in both British and American
history, serves as the foundation of their constitutions. The term bill here denotes a list,
making the Bill of Rights fundamentally a list of powers. In other words, the law's purpose is to
delineate a list of powers. Only when these specific rights are documented and enforced,
does a true law come into being. From this perspective, the law is not an abstract or
intangible concept, but a concrete, resonant reality. Jaegen further contended that merely
listing these powers is insufficient. Why? Because there will always be those who disregard
or violate others' rights, trampling on this list of powers. In such cases, those whose rights are
infringed must take action to defend their legal list, fighting resolutely to uphold it. Thus,
Jaegen concluded that the law emerges from struggle, a struggle to secure this list of powers.
A list that has not been fought for is not a true law. It remains a hollow, false law.
In the opening of the third chapter of Law as a Mean to an End, Jaegen writes that, for humanity,
a person is not merely a physical entity. Their spiritual existence is equally essential.
One of the conditions for the survival of the human spirit is the assertion of rights. Only
within the framework of rights does a person possess the condition for spiritual existence.
Without rights, a person is akin to livestock. This explains why in Roman times, slaves and
livestock are treated equivalently. Under the law, a perspective that, from a legal standpoint,
was entirely consistent. Jaegen employs an analogy. Just as there is no harvest without labor,
there is no law without struggle. The law is something that must be fought for. It does not
simply materialize. Just as crops do not grow without effort. Reflect for a moment, when have
the Chinese people fought for the law? When have they struggled for their rights? Never. Without
the struggle, one does not earn the benefits of the law. Of course, struggles have occurred among
the Chinese, but these are often characterized as infighting or mutual harm, brutal conflicts
driven by selfish motives and personal desires. Such struggles lack nobility or moral grounding
and are fundamentally distinct from the struggle for the law. Under what condition, then, will
people actively fight for the law? Jaegen posits that people will only do so when they experience
pain, not physical pain, but spiritual pain. This spiritual pain arises when a person's dignity and
rights are violated or disregarded, compelling them to act. Conversely, those who feel no pain,
who are numb or indifferent, will never fight for the law or their rights. This is what separates
individuals. Jaegen terms this emotion, the drive to fight through pain, the feeling of legal rights.
This concept, a central theme in law as a means to an end, originates from the fundamental dignity
of humanity. When a person's dignity and rights are violated, their heart aches. This so deep pain
is the feeling of legal rights. Jaegen elaborates that when the feeling of legal rights is robust,
individuals will actively uphold the law and fight for it. But when this feeling weakens and
becomes numb, people lose their sense of pain, ignoring the violation of their rights and,
consequently, failing to fight for the law. Historically, in early ancient Rome, the Romans
possessed a strong feeling of legal rights and were willing to fight for the law. By the time
of the Byzantine Empire, with the promulgation of Justinian's Code, legal texts appeared more
refined. Yet, the people had gradually lost their feeling of legal rights, becoming
apathetic. Paradoxically, the less polished legal system of early Rome was, in practice,
more reflective of a society governed by the rule of law, while the ostensibly more advanced
Byzantine Empire was less so. True lawmaking, therefore, resides not in written text but in
emotions and souls of individuals. As the adage goes, nothing is sadder than a dead heart. When
the heart dies, so does the law. Jaegen believed that the rise and fall of the feeling of legal
rights throughout history determines whether a society upholds the rule of law. When this feeling
reaches its nadir, a phenomenon emerges as people cease to use the law or seek justice through it.
The law effectively becomes obsolete. This principle derives from a Roman legal tradition
called desuatudo, a Latin term meaning disuse. In legal terms, disuse equates to abolition.
If a law inscribed in legal text remains unused for an extended period, with people's rights
unexercised through it, then, per Roman legal custom, that law is effectively nullified.
Even if the text persists, it is a dead law, devoid of vitality. To put it plainly, the law
is akin to perishable food in a supermarket. It has an expiration date. If left uneaten,
it spoils and becomes useless. Similarly, if a law is not utilized within a certain time frame,
it too becomes obsolete, reduced to meaningless words. This framework illuminates the anomalies
in Chinese law, where the law is entirely disconnected from reality.
Consider the Constitution of the People's Republic of China. Chapter 2, Article 35,
explicitly grants Chinese citizens freedom of speech, assembly, publication, and demonstration.
Yet in practice, these freedoms are absent. Why does such a stark contradiction exist between
the written law and the reality? Many have pondered this question. Through the lens of
Yehen's purposive jurisprudence, the answer is clear. The Chinese people have never exercised
these laws or fought for the rights they confer. When laws granting freedoms remain unused and
undefended, they are effectively nullified under Roman legal principles. In practice,
China lacks true law. Its laws are dead, not living. This reality is widely recognized,
but its underlying cause is even more troubling. The Chinese people's feeling of legal rights is
profoundly weak, nearly non-existent. To echo Yehen, the Chinese are numb, devoid of pain,
and feel no profound anguish when their rights are violated. When an individual's soul feels
no pain in the face of trampled rights, they are unfit to be human. They are relegated to
the status of livestock or slaves, entities devoid of such sensitivity. From the perspective of
purposive jurisprudence, the legal status of the Chinese people is akin to that of animals.
Many attribute China's lack of rule of law to the dominance of power over law or the
precedence of human rule over legal rule. This view is misleading, as it implies that excessive
power has suppressed the law. Yet, Yehen's arguments reveal that the law's decline stems
from the erosion of the feeling of legal rights, from a diminishing capacity to feel pain, and from
a growing numbness and a reluctance to fight. The root cause is not an excess of power but a
deficiency of law. This can be likened to a mathematical analogy. If the Chinese people's
feeling of legal rights is zero, their willingness to uphold and defend the law is also zero.
No matter how large a number is multiplied by zero, the result remains zero. Conversely,
power or the privilege to violate the law is always a positive value. However small,
as long as it exceeds zero, it will always surpass a law backed by no feeling. The crux
of the issue lies in the absence of the feeling of legal rights, not the magnitude of power.
What then suppresses the feeling of legal rights? Primarily, it is authoritarianism
masquerading as equality. In Law as a Means to an End, Yehen writes that authoritarianism
understands precisely how to fell a tree, not by attacking its crown but by undermining its roots.
Authoritarianism begins by violating private rights and mistreating individuals.
Once this stage succeeds, the tree collapses of its own accord. Conversely, how can we cultivate
a sensitivity to rights and foster the feeling of legal rights? Yehen asserts that the strength of
a nation and the strength of its feeling of legal rights are synonymous. Cultivating this feeling
is tantamount to nurturing the health and vigor of a nation. This is not achieved through
theoretical instruction in classrooms but by embedding principles of justice in all facets
of life and applying them in practice. Ultimately, this discussion returns to the principle of
practice. Conversations about the rule of law and legal theory must extend beyond the books
and theories manifesting in real-world struggle and action. Without practice, all theory is
meaningless. Yehen concludes his book with a poignant statement. One must relentlessly carve
out a life and freedom each day to be worthy of enjoying them. In China, a peculiar concept exists
the rights-defending lawyer. This term is odd because a lawyer's duty is to use the law to
protect rights. The emergence of rights-defending lawyers implies that most Chinese lawyers do not
defend the rights and the laws they employ fail to safeguard them. This phenomenon underscores
the disconnect between law and human rights in China. The Chinese people's emotional connection
to the law is profoundly detached. From the outset, their feelings of legal rights has been
frail, compounded by the authoritarian regime of the Chinese Communist Party,
which has adeptly suppressed this feeling. The result is a complete erosion of the feeling
of legal rights. When this feeling is absent, a society cannot be governed by the rule of law,
and the law in China remains a dead law, not a living one. Given China's current environment,
is it possible to envision a future society governed by the rule of law? I believe it is
not. Unless a force emerges to radically transform China's system, culture, and populace,
such a force, I suspect, does not exist. Even if it did, it would likely require a century
to come to fruition. Thank you so much for watching. If you find this video helpful,
please like it, drop a comment below, and hit the subscribe button right here. It really helps
YouTube suggest my videos to others. I'll be back with more content soon. Until then, be well.