There is no bond like that between sisters. A classic movie which celebrates this precious relationship is “Four Daughters” from 1938. This Warner Bros. classic starred three of the four real-life Lane sisters as the movie’s fictional Lemp sisters, with Gale Page playing the fourth sister. The rest of the cast features a delightful assembly of the studio’s standard players, including Claude Rains in an endearing performance as the family’s lovable father. This movie is most noteworthy for being the film debut of John Garfield, a future Warner Bros. star, who stole the show as a troubled young pianist and composer. This film started not only his career but a trilogy of films about the Lemp sisters. This film remains a story about classical music, familial love, and the joys of sisterhood. “Reel Thoughts with Tiffany and Rebekah” is a weekly film review show hosted by Tiffany and Rebekah. They dive into traditional and classic films, covering everything from mainstream blockbusters to indie gems. Each episode offers thoughtful analysis, diverse perspectives, and an engaging experience designed to connect with and entertain viewers. #movies#talk shows #classic films #American traditions #Hollywood#showbiz#theater#cinema#entertainment#celebrity#famous#actors#drama#motion picture
Emma? Yes, Anne?
Do you think she really loves him? She's going to marry him.
I mean, do you think she loves him as much as she loves us?
It's a different kind of love, Anne. You mean a perfect stranger could come in
here and mean more to me than father or Aunt Etta?
More than my own sisters? More than you? Oh, you're certainly not very worldly-wise.
Oh, Anne. Emma?
Don't let's get married, ever. Let D and K if they want to, but not us.
We'll grow old together, beautifully and gracefully.
Just wait and see, we'll both look just like Whistler's mother.
Well, if we don't get married, it'll be hard to look like anyone's mother.
Emma, you haven't met anyone. I mean, you're not holding out on me, are you?
No, not me. It looks like I'm pretty much headed for the shelf.
The love family is going to have one old maid.
Two. We'll have a cat, a tortoise shell one.
Wait and see, we'll both be the finest and happiest of all four daughters.
I'm Tiffany Brannan. I'm Rebecca Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Most classic films focus on a love story or a romance,
but there actually were many movies from the golden era of Hollywood
which focus on really touching family stories.
Warner Brothers Studio, and particularly in the late to mid-1930s,
seemed to have a real passion for making stories about sisters, particularly.
That's true. There are many examples of this,
but most notably is the film we're going to be discussing today,
Four Daughters from 1938.
This film follows Adam Lemp, a music professor, and his four daughters,
all of them musical talents, a singer, a violinist, a pianist, and a harpist.
Their quiet life is disrupted when a young composer shows up one day,
whom Adam doesn't entirely approve of because he doesn't like modern classical music,
but he likes the young man and welcomes him into his home as a boarder.
Soon all four girls are in love with him,
even though at least one of them already has a prospective suitor.
Then one day, Mickey Borden shows up.
He is a pianist and arranger of sorts who has come to help the young man, Felix,
orchestrate his composition, which he is going to enter in a contest.
Anne, the youngest daughter, is immediately fascinated by this strange,
down-on-his-luck young man, who soon develops feelings for her.
However, Anne and Felix are in love.
When Anne and Felix announce their engagement,
both Mickey and one of Anne's sisters, Emma, are crestfallen
as they think they've lost the loves of their lives.
Four daughters starred the Lane sisters, Priscilla Lane, Rosemary Lane, and Lola Lane,
with actress Gail Page as the fourth sister.
It was a Warner Brothers production, with executive producer Jack Warner, of course.
It was produced by Hal B. Wallace, with associate producer Henry Blank.
It was directed by Michael Curtiz.
Other noteworthy members of the cast were Claude Rains as the father,
Mae Robson as their aunt Etta,
John Garfield as Mickey, the down-on-his-luck arranger,
and Jeffrey Lynn as Felix Dietz, the young composer.
It's so interesting that this is a movie about four sisters,
and there actually were four Lane sisters who were actresses,
but that they didn't use the fourth sister.
Do you know why?
Yes, actually. Her name was Leota,
and she had had sort of a tempestuous career.
She never really had made it as a Hollywood actress.
None of them had that much up to this point.
Lola had been off and on as the oldest of the three,
but Leota at this point was in New York,
and this picture went through several different ideas.
First, it was going to be an Errol Flynn picture.
Some reports said that he turned it down because of illness,
but it was actually because it wasn't a big enough role for him.
He would have played the Mickey Borden character.
And then at one point, they were considering Bette Davis for it.
So it's no wonder that Flynn and Davis ended up making The Sisters,
also Warner Brothers, the same year.
They put them in that.
When we watched that, I was like,
this is a lot like Florida.
It's the same formula.
But Lola Lane was playing sort of bit parts
around Warner Brothers at this time,
and she got the idea,
what if I did this with my sisters?
And it was actually her idea.
She pitched that, so they screen tested all the sisters,
they sent for Leota,
but they found her to not be good enough from her screen test.
So they cast Gail Page as the fourth sister,
and she ended up being basically known as the fourth Lane sister
for the rest of her career,
because they would be re-teamed for three more movies.
But it is so interesting to see these real siblings
and how a lot of their own lives and backgrounds got put into this.
Like the musical element, for instance.
Right.
They all had musical training,
as they were very young children.
They learned how to play the piano, the violin, the harp.
The three of them actually were a singing trio at one point.
So all the musical talents that they're portraying in the film,
they actually were proficient in.
So it's very charming, and it's so real.
And I think one of the things that's most endearing about this movie
is that you see the real relationships of these sisters,
and then the other actors gather together in it so well.
So it's no wonder that this was a huge hit,
an unexpected hit, I might add,
because Michael Curtiz ended up doing this
just as he was waiting for Robin Hood,
The Adventures of Robin Hood, to be ready to start production,
which an Errol Flynn picture he ended up directing.
But he just, oh, just do this, do it quickly,
don't spend too much money.
And then it was this big hit.
It's interesting.
You can kind of feel it's not major, big-budget production.
It is kind of a simple little movie,
but it's so heartfelt and so real.
I think, like you said, with having the real sisters in it,
the family relationship is so much stronger because of that element.
And there's something about the youth of the cast.
They all, the younger generation,
they all seem very young and bright and ambitious,
and so it really has that sort of small-town, nice youngsters feel,
and it's just a very homey sort of picture.
Yes, it is.
Like you said about seeing that it's not a biggest-budget production,
you can see that from the fact that there really were no name stars in it.
You wouldn't consider Claude Reigns a name star?
I would consider him a very important supporting actor.
I guess that's true.
And it's not even his biggest role.
You're right.
It's interesting to see him playing the father this early in his career
because even like five years later, he'd be like,
no, I don't want to play that part, I don't want to be a father yet.
But he had played this role, and it's a little bit off-type for him.
He has that kind of charming, almost sinister quality.
And he's just a lovable, loving father in this.
But I would say he's playing a strong supporting role,
and besides John Garfield, the other three suitors are more bit-part actors.
Dick Farran was often the other man.
Geoffrey Lin often the other man.
Frank McHugh.
Frank McHugh was just a total supporting actor.
It's unusual actually for him to be playing that much of sort of a leading man.
As being the love interest of one of the girls,
he's usually more of kind of a funny side character.
He's usually a sidekick.
And then with not having someone like Errol Flynn or Burgess Meredith,
who were up for the part of Mickey,
that role was given to a total newcomer.
That's right, this was John Garfield's first movie.
Yes, he was very young.
I don't know how well-known he is now,
but to people who know about classic films,
he made a lot of crime movies, and he was very well-known.
Yeah, he ended up being a big star.
Although he had a very short life.
Yes.
Like his character.
Yes, and he died at 39, right?
I'd kind of forgotten that until I read it again.
This is his first movie, because he just comes in with such ease as an actor.
Yes, he does.
Just so natural.
Now, he did go to drama school, so he was a trained actor.
But interestingly, a lot of people note this
as the first mainstream method acting performance.
That's right, because he was a student of Lee Strasberg,
who had that method acting.
And people, although they didn't really talk about method acting at that time,
some reviewers at the time said he's so natural in his bitter brilliance
that it's hard to figure out whether it's the character
or Mr. Garfield himself, who's like that.
I would say more reacting than acting.
Yeah, that's why it's considered method acting.
Even in places, sometimes the way a line is delivered,
it's almost like you didn't expect him to deliver a line that way,
but there's something about him that makes this person seem very real.
And it's just a fascinating character study.
I mean, almost everybody in this movie
is just such sort of a study in different types of characters.
And it's often very difficult,
especially in a small film like this, it's not that long,
that there are so many plot lines going on
with having these four different sisters,
and they each have kind of their own separate little storyline,
and then there's the father and the aunt, so many characters.
And they're all so well fleshed out and separate but intertwining beautifully.
So it doesn't feel long, it doesn't feel overcomplicated.
But it's not very long, it's like just around an hour and a half.
Yeah, it just really feels like you're just right in there
and getting a look at this family,
and the way that their lives are sort of turned upside down
by these two young men entering it.
Yes, and there's some typical things, I think,
if you're familiar with movies of this era,
you can start to recognize the different studios and their styles.
Very much Warner Brothers.
I feel like even just recently, within the last few months,
we've really started to study just how much of a style there is to Warner Brothers.
They have this sort of method,
which you can see exemplified in some of the most famous movies,
like Casablanca.
Yeah.
Warner is really not afraid to get into really complex human emotions.
Yeah, I'd say probably the two biggest studios of this time were MGM and Warner.
MGM was huge on the spectacle.
Nobody could beat them when it comes to musicals,
flashy Technicolor, giant productions.
Warner Brothers delved more into really a complex,
intricate, sometimes even troubling human emotion.
And Mr. Mayer...
They didn't have to have happy endings.
Right.
Mr. Mayer, as the head of MGM,
was always insistent on having happy endings to his movies.
And Warner kind of counteracted by that.
But there are a lot of, not even necessarily tragedies,
but they go through a lot.
It's a little tough.
It might end up in a way that it still feels satisfying,
but it's not just happiness and light all the way through, definitely.
And one thing I've noted about Warner Brothers is
they tend to have more random, funny little comedic moments,
little goofy little touches they throw in that kind of lighten it up,
even if it's a really serious subject.
I think I saw a Warner Brothers movie for Einstein referred to as
a sad film with funny moments or something like that.
And that really describes it perfectly.
Yeah, and I think this film was described as
a comedy with tragic moments, I guess.
And in general, the tone of it is like a romantic comedy.
It's very true.
It's bright, it's cute, it's cheerful.
Especially the first, say, half.
It's going along, it's sort of bright.
And it's amazing,
the entrance of Mickey Borden's character into the film
just changes the tone.
Yes, it does.
And there's something about both the character
and the actor, John Garfield,
he's very different from anyone else you've seen in the film.
Frank McHugh is this slightly older, sort of the wealthy man.
So Thea wants to go with him
because she wants to be the wealthy Mrs. Crowley.
And then there's Felix, the composer.
He's just that sort of charming, not exactly a rascal,
but he's really got that charm.
Yeah, but he's also really sincere.
He doesn't seem like a troublemaker.
No, not at all.
He's playful, he's fun.
Yes, he lights up a room because he likes to laugh.
You can count on him.
And then Dick Ferran, who's interested in Emma,
plays this young florist,
and she's not sure if she wants more romance than him,
but he's always bringing her flowers.
So they're just very much small-town types.
They're very much these sort of standard,
the fellow you'll meet on the street,
even though they're from different classes
and different walks of life.
And then enter this character of Mickey who,
I feel like there are a lot more people like this character now,
maybe than then,
or at least than you'd see in films that much.
But he's a relatable character to that era
because he represents the Depression era.
That's a good point.
This film doesn't touch on that that much.
Yeah, it's not necessarily the Depression that got him there.
He's an orphan.
He's poor.
These are things that he experienced
long before the Great Depression struck,
but the idea of being this down-on-your-luck person
was something to which people could relate in the Great Depression.
That's a good point.
Although I feel there was so much desire during the Depression.
It's like people didn't want to hand out.
They just wanted work.
And most people who were struck by the Depression
were very hard-working.
And this character just seems like,
no matter what time period he's in,
he's just one of those people.
He's just so convinced that the world is against him.
Yeah, he's so cynical.
And even when people try to help him,
sometimes there's not that much you can do for a person like that.
Yeah, and it's interesting to see a character
who was so young being depicted as so cynical,
which isn't unrealistic.
There are many young people who are very cynical,
but he does a great job getting into that character.
And by creating this character,
John Garfield created a character he would end up playing
for basically the rest of his career.
It's not necessarily exactly what he was like,
because, again, he was a method actor,
but he created this character,
and so he would continue playing versions of that character
in different settings.
Speaking about the complexity of the story,
there are certain elements of it
that could be considered sort of problematic,
especially during this era,
because this was between 1934 and 1954
when the Production Code Administration
was enforcing the Motion Picture Production Code,
commonly misnomered the Hays Code,
and Joseph I. Breen was the head of the PCA
from 1934 to 1954.
So this is right in the somewhat earlier years of that, 1938,
and this has the idea of a love triangle
which extends past marriage.
That's right.
Where you have the character of Anne,
spoilers sort of here,
but she ends up marrying Mickey,
even though she's in love with Felix
because she thinks her sister is in love with him
and also because she has so much empathy for Mickey
and he loves her so much,
it seems like she was the one thing
that was going to give him sort of a new lease on life.
Yes.
And it really just delves into that concept
of it's never in a way that she's unfaithful to him,
but just that there's still...
Felix is a man she was in love with,
but that she makes every effort to make a good life for Mickey
and to be a good wife to him.
You can tell she cares for him very deeply.
There was a connection between them right from the beginning,
but Felix is the one that she really loves,
and that's a very complex issue.
Also, her sister Thea marries this man basically for his money,
and you get the idea that they don't have the best relationship
because she really has no feelings for him,
really in a romantic way,
but that later in the film,
she finally realizes how much he means to her.
Yeah.
And you see that overarching wholesomeness of the code era
while dealing with some of these more complex,
challenging issues that you've mentioned,
something which you do not find in any other era.
Now, this is an interesting film in the fact that two things.
It inspired two sequels, sequel and triple,
and it inspired a popular, successful remake.
So after this, they made, just the next year,
Four Wives, bringing together the same cast,
and then Four Mothers shortly after that.
And then, like 15 years later, Young at Heart.
They remade it, Warner Brothers again, as a musical.
Now, you could say this film has musical elements,
but it was the inclusion of classical music.
There are a couple of pieces by Schubert,
like you hear her, the main sister, who's a singer,
Kay, you hear her singing Stehenchen,
also known as Serenade, while they're all playing.
That's how the movie starts.
They're all playing their instruments,
and then she sings on Wings of Song,
she sings Hiding the Rose Line.
This is really more of an appreciation of music
than being a musical.
But it's not popular songs of the day or bursting into song,
whereas the remake was a complete musical
starring two of the biggest musical stars of the day.
Doris Day as that main sister, Anne,
who was Priscilla Lane in the original,
and Frank Sinatra, of all people,
as the John Garfield character,
whose name is Barney Sloan in the remake.
And then they had other characters like Gig Young
as supporting actors, but those two were the main couple.
And it featured the very popular title song, Young at Heart.
Right.
And of course, it's a whole different topic
to talk about that movie,
but it's interesting to see how the story
was vibrant enough to inspire this successful remake.
Right, and we had seen Young at Heart years ago.
Right.
Old family favorite, but I feel like that's not a movie
that we've watched as much as, say,
some of Doris Day's other movies.
Perhaps because it does have some parts of it
that are a little bit harder to watch.
I would say that movie is harder to watch than the original.
Which is kind of odd considering the ending.
Yeah.
Which is one of the biggest differences.
Plus the fact that they cut out one of the sisters.
Right, I didn't remember Young at Heart that well
when we watched Four Daughters, but I was aware of,
oh, this is the original.
But some of the dialogue is verbatim.
Right, I said, this is the original of that movie.
I didn't remember Young at Heart well enough
to at first recognize, like, oh, this is the same dialogue.
When we watched Young at Heart again,
I was like, wow, this is very similar.
Like you said, sometimes dialogue is verbatim
and in other places it's very different.
Like you noted the, well, for one thing,
the characters all seem a lot older.
Yes, they do.
The actors are older, and his being,
he's sort of like a nightclub singer and pianist
instead of being this more classical musician.
And all the composers, both the composers
are like Tin Pan Alley songwriters
instead of classical composers.
But yes, the thing that shocked me most
when we watched Four Daughters was the ending
because it's very different,
and I don't know if we should spoil the ending now, but.
But it's interesting to see how this is one of the few films
where there are two Breen-era versions of the same story.
That's right.
1938 and 1954, right at the end,
but it's technically before Mr. Breen retired,
so you've got, you see how times have changed,
but not enough that decency was still the order of the day.
And there were different approaches.
You could do it in a different way,
and they're both great movies.
But in terms of a movie that's really about sisterhood
and just if you really want a great sister family movie,
I recommend Four Daughters because there are more sisters,
and I think it's even more about them
because Frank Sinatra was a much bigger star
than John Garfield or any of those other characters,
so it's really about the sisters.
It really is kind of a startling
when you really just sort of clock it,
like how little screen time
the Mickey Borden character actually has in this,
especially after having watched Young at Heart
because I remembered he was, like, you know,
he's the main guy, and he's,
it's more of a toss-up between he and Felix.
That character was played by Gig Young in the remake,
and he was always kind of the other guy,
so he's even more decidedly the other guy.
Gig Young is never going to beat out Frank Sinatra for The Girl.
But I also love, in introducing people to classic films,
for them to get a taste of different eras,
which they might not know,
and the late 30s were such a charming time.
They had adorable fashion,
and it's really nice to see how people were dressing
and behaving at this time,
and there's lots of fashion on display
in a very relatable, I think, realistic way
because they're just sort of average girls,
since you have all the four daughters.
My outfit is based on the first costume,
which the character of Emma wears, Gail Page.
It's a simple striped blouse with short sleeves
and a skirt which was very typical of the 1930s
in that it was mid-calf length and straighter,
with a belt, heavier black shoes,
a little watch and a little bracelet,
and she doesn't wear a hat in this scene,
but this is the sort of hat that a lady might wear
at that time period.
My outfit is inspired by the one worn by Anne
when she goes to see Mickey on her wedding day.
It's a simple dress with buttons up the front
and a belt in the mid-calf 30s length
with heavier heeled shoes and a little cardigan over it.
She's wearing a charm bracelet given to her by Felix,
and while she does not wear a hat in this scene,
later on in the film, she wears a black beret like this one
worn in the signature 30s style.
This movie is a great introduction
to this Warner Brothers style we've been discussing,
the family movies of the golden era.
It shows you a bunch of classic actors
whom I know you'll want to see more of their work.
These Lane sisters, young John Garfield,
all these supporting actors, Claude Rains, of course.
That was the reason why I watched this movie
because we really like Claude Rains.
And after watching this,
you're going to want to see the other two
and Young at Heart and more movies with all these actors,
and I think it could be a really good way to...
It's not too long, short and fun,
but also dramatic and romantic and all those things.
You can get a taste of that and say,
oh, maybe I'd like to see more classic films.
There's a brilliance to classic films
in the way that they could blend comedy and drama and romance
in so many different genres,
but in a way that never feels out of place
because it feels truly like a slice of life.
Yeah.
Sort of like one kind of thing you'd see in sitcoms later on,
like in the 50s and 60s,
in the way that life isn't just romance
and it's not just happiness and it's not just sadness.
There's so much, all the different emotions that go into life,
so you really are seeing a bit of these people's lives.
It's touched by happiness and laughter and surprise and tragedy
because tragedy enters everyone's life.
And just the human relationships are so realistically presented
in a way that I think could relate to almost anyone.
You're probably going to relate to at least one character in this movie
or something that each character goes through.
This movie is available to rent or buy on Amazon Prime Video.
It's not available on any other streaming service for some reason,
but it can be purchased on DVD.
It's much harder to find the sequel and the triquel.
I'm not even sure if they're available on DVD, are they?
I believe they are, yes.
Okay, they're available on DVD,
but you can only find them on some very obscure websites other than that.
But you can definitely start with Four Daughters
right there on Amazon Prime for a good price,
so it's a great way to be introduced to this genre of the late 30s.
As we've discussed a great deal,
this film features very realistic characters.
However, they are products of fiction.
Many Golden Age films were biopics of real-life people, however.
Join us next time as we talk about a movie
based on the dramatic life story of a female athlete
who changed her field forever,
portrayed by another female athlete
who was a legend in her own right in the same field.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.