Three Smart Girls (1936) is a delightful musical comedy about three clever sisters determined to reunite their divorced parents before their father remarries. Filled with music, humor, and youthful energy, the film captures the warmth and optimism that made 1930s Hollywood musicals so beloved.
Starring Deanna Durbin in one of her breakthrough roles, the movie blends lively performances with heartfelt family themes. Rather than relying on cynicism, Three Smart Girls celebrates sincerity, loyalty, and the playful determination of young people trying to protect the people they love.
Subtitles and editing by QTSS
Where's Joan
She went to talk to Bill about the count
The count What's the idea
Bill got the idea from something Joan said
If we can get someone with more money to take an interest in her she'll be discarded like a hot potato
Does the count have money
Not a penny He's a drunkard and despises work
Oh I told you we couldn't trust that Bill But Bill's going to give
him some money—enough to make it convincing that
he's one of the richest men in Europe
Do you seriously think we can trick that gold-digging socialite with something
like that Believe me she hasn't got a chance against three clever girls
I'm Tiffany Brannan
I'm Rebecca Brannan
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema
Musical films centered on a lively young soprano were immensely popular during Hollywood's golden age
Some of the most memorable films in this genre emerged from the
post-World War II era yet the genre first thrived in the late 1930s
And it all began in 1936 with Three Smart Girls This film was produced by
Universal Pictures with Joe Pasternak as producer and Henry Koster as director
It starred Deanna Durbin Ray Milland Vinnie Barnes and Charles Wenninger
In Switzerland three charming young sisters—Joan Kay and Penny—live with their mother
a woman who is divorced but still deeply loves her father
Devastated to learn her ex-husband of ten years is remarrying a much younger New York socialite
The three sisters resolve to prevent their father's upcoming marriage
So accompanied by their loyal maid they flee to New York City
There they pounce on their unsuspecting father who initially appears to have little
interest in parenting But they swiftly win him over with their endearing charm
The three sisters each devise different plots to stop their father's disastrous impending marriage
The oldest daughter Joan conspires with their father's handsome young business associate Bill
o hire another man to pretend to be a wealthier suitor for Precious who is their father's fiancée
They hire a drunken count but little do they know that due to a case of mistaken identity
they actually end up mistaking him for a wealthy young man from England Michael Stewart
He quickly develops a crush on the middle sister Kay Meanwhile the youngest sister Penny wins
over her father's heart with her lovely singing voice and her charming youthful personality
Can the three sisters prevent their father from marrying Precious
Well it will take all the cleverness of these three sharp-witted girls
Looking back on the classic era I think the filmmakers weren't nearly as famous or influential as they are in modern Hollywood
Most of these highly influential filmmakers were no longer widely recognized by name
But that doesn’t mean they didn’t each have their own formula and a significant impact on the industry through their own production units
Joe Pasternak is an extraordinary producer because he pioneered this
kind of film—it was uniquely his and his production team's signature
Yes he was At MGM throughout most of the 1940s and into the 1950s headed the studio’s second-largest production unit just behind Arthur Freed’s
And although he didn’t produce the biggest musicals he usually focused on higher-caliber
ones many of which featured more classical music and renowned classical musicians
But long before these days of technicolor glory at MGM he had already pioneered this new genre and rescued Universal Pictures from bankruptcy
He and director Henry Koster whom he brought over from Europe were truly determined to create joyful uplifting films
Joe Pasternak said people aren't going to get sick and die in my films—it's not entertainment
And young star Diana Durbin was the ideal choice to help pioneer this genre of film
Yeah she definitely was I mean Pasternak had been in Europe since he was from Hungary
and worked as a Jewish Hungarian producer within Universal Films’ European division
But then largely due to the rise of Nazism he and his close friend Henry
Koster emigrated to the United States and it all began with Three Smart Girls
And Universal was on the brink of bankruptcy at the time but Diana Durbin was
an emerging star She was only 14 yet she was Canadian and a popular radio singer
And with this film she became a star and Universal was saved from bankruptcy Yes and
fascinatingly Joe Pasternak originally wanted Judy Garland who is now a much better-known name
But MGM wasn't willing to loan her
to them Interesting
And Diana Durbin had only appeared in one film before this a short featuring Judy Garland titled Every Sunday
That's right That was also Judy Garland's debut wasn't it I
believe so But after making that MGM actually dropped her contract
That's correct—she was initially signed by MGM but eventually rose to stardom at Universal
And although I'm certain she would have succeeded at MGM as well Universal
needed her more since MGM already had several successful musical stars
And since Universal didn’t have many major stars at the time it wasn’t one of the biggest studios
But they managed to transform Diana Durbin into a starlet who could genuinely rival not
only Judy Garland but even Shirley Temple who had been such a beloved young child actress
And whereas Shirley Temple relied on appearing genuinely young and irresistibly
cute Diana Durbin although occasionally made to look younger at age 14
She actually displayed genuine talent—real musical talent—because she was an outstanding
classically trained soprano Watching her perform as a classical singer is truly astounding
The voice that emerges from this teenage girl is
remarkable—so beautiful large and powerful especially considering she's so young
Yeah and I’m not saying there weren’t any classical singers before this Opera
singer Gracie Moore had already appeared in a few films around the same time
Jeanette McDonald at MGM was gradually being repositioned as an opera singer
as she was paired opposite Nelson Eddy who actually was an opera singer
But before that even though her voice had a more classical quality she wasn't truly operatic
No
And it was actually in 1936 with films like San Francisco and Rosemary
that she first began performing genuine classical music in her movies
But before that she had performed in more operettas and musicals
Yet here we have Diana Durbin this 14-year-old girl taking on the role
I'm not sure how old she's supposed to be in this movie—probably more
around 12 Definitely
But in this film she not only sang two original songs written for her by
studio composers Bronislaw Caper and Walter Uriman with lyrics by Gus Kahn
but she also performed a genuine classical aria this piece is "
Il Baccio" by Luigi Arniti which she sings again later in the film
She doesn't sing the entire piece but she performs excerpts
And that song is often known as The Kiss Waltz
a highly popular showstopping number for coloratura sopranos
And I think what really made this film stand out to people was the deeply touching and
heartfelt story of a family combined with the
presence of an exceptionally talented young girl
and the singing is almost random and she's just like oh she's singing
But it's really amazing and it adds a lot to the plot
because when she shows her father oh Precious wasn't singing the song properly
—this is how it should be sung—that's
the very first moment she breaks him down
He's amazed at how much his still very young daughter has grown into the talent she
possesses And it's not one of those movies
where characters suddenly burst into song
Most Pasternak films succeed and now this person is singing
They're meant to be singing—not just me talking about my feelings
It hadn’t really arrived yet Not at all no Not even on Broadway
at that time But because these songs are woven in so seamlessly
It's not overly focused on music—like I said there are really just these three
songs You get to see her talent while it also unfolds as a romantic comedy
It's a family drama blended with comedy
reminiscent of what the Hardy family
series might have been at MGM But if you consider the entire golden era
From the mid-30s to the mid-50s it seems
like oh it's a pretty standard family musical
But if you consider what came before this it was somewhat
groundbreaking I can't really name a film not even a non-musical one
at fits in this genre from before that
Because you could say maybe All Wilderness
which was the precursor to the Hardy series over at MGM in 1935
but there's a lot more drama in All Wilderness
It's not about the children It's more of a coming-of-age story
This one really is about these three daughters of varying ages
One is around 18 or 19 another is
17 and the youngest is 12 They 're
much younger girls It's about their relationship as sisters
It's about these daughters who believe
they can reunite their parents And they
kind of succeed It's that kind of film that would eventually become a formula
But this is where the formula was being developed
And due to the success of this film
Pasternak would stick with that formula
starring Deanna Durbin in a series of films in the late 1930s and
early 1940s And then he also used another younger soprano Gloria Jean
Also at Universal helped make her a
little star Then he left Universal and
went over to MGM in 1942 And he did the same thing with Katherine Grayson
She then evolved into a more mature soprano yet continued performing
many of the same songs He did exactly the same with Jane Powell
who most resembled Deanna Durbin was that she even did many
similar things having started
around the age of 15 alongside him
She was also a teenager and because she was so short she appeared extremely young—far
younger than Katherine Grayson Yet with all
these singers you notice a similar pattern
This young girl often sharing a close bond with
her father sometimes experiences
the separation of one parent through divorce or widowhood And
that child who is willing to take some risks
perhaps a daughter who is bright or bold plenty
of lively coloratura pieces as well as opera arias
creatively reimagined right alongside these more
operetta-style numbers or even original compositions
And there's always a wonderfully engaging
blend of heartfelt
emotion and lighthearted
humor Being so groundbreaking the film
was nominated for three Academy Awards
Best Picture Best Original Story and Best Sound Recording
And Deanna Durbin received a special Juvenile Academy Award
for Best Actress for her performance in the film
Interestingly all three sisters are very important In some
ways I'd say Deanna Durbin's character is the least important
Among the three sisters she's the only one without a romantic interest simply because she's
the youngest The other two aren't particularly well-known actresses either
That's right Nan Gray and Barbara Reed
were both emerging in this film and even
though the movie was a big success neither
of their careers ever really took off
The other actor in this film who is most
famous aside from Deanna Durbin is Ray Moland
who portrays the young English nobleman entangled in the case of mistaken identity
Michael Stewart and he actually joined the production quite
late He was a last-minute replacement for Lewis Hayward
who was supposed to play the role but he developed pleurisy four days into filming
This young English actor is of course
best known for his work ten years later
In Billy Wilder's drama The Lost Weekend
And that was just one of many
highly popular films he directed But here this is
Early in his career he was just getting started so it's no surprise he's taking
on a more supporting role though I'd argue
his character is actually more important
an that of Bill the love interest of the older sister
Because it's kind of an important plot point
that they believe he's this drunken count
who in reality is this comical
character played by Mischa Auer
It's somewhat ironic considering you know Ray Milan from The Lost Weekend
how much they emphasize his character being drunk
Foreshadowing
And he's one of many actors who simply stumbled into the profession He never really cared
for it all that much He felt a bit embarrassed performing love scenes in front of the camera
But he gradually stepped back later in the
1950s only to grow restless and return to acting
And he did some work on stage He was simply one
of those people who never saw
himself as much of an actor
He had a few performances he was proud of but he remembered
that when he first started working in silent films he thought
I'm only in movies for my looks so he went and did
some stage work to try to train himself a bit more
But I think he just has a natural talent for it and a truly charismatic
presence He's not one of your favorite
actors in some of his later performances
but you seem to like him better in this movie
Yeah I thought this was a really good part for him
Yeah he plays it well but he doesn't draw too much attention
He's remarkably convincing in this role there's a certain refined quality
about him I can't quite decide whether it's that I simply don't care for him
Or maybe I just don't care for most of the movies
he's in—it could just be that I don't like the kind of material he chooses
Now Mischa Auer plays a brief but comic role as the real Drunken Count
and this film actually marked a
significant turning point in his career
That's correct He had mainly been a villain up to that point
and then afterward he was almost entirely cast in comedic roles
He's genuinely funny and has this slightly tall lanky look He played a wide
range of Eastern Europeans—Russians
Hungarians and all sorts—remarkably well
He went on a few years later to land a supporting
role in the original My Man Godfrey for which
he won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor So apparently stepping into comedic roles
It was the right choice for him It's interesting to see how this film
fits into the greater narrative of how
Hollywood was changing at this point
Because if this film or a film of
this nature had been made a few years
earlier it might not have become the hit it ultimately was Yeah I agree
But it was part of a broader shift in Hollywood at the time
closely tied to the Motion
Picture Production Code Beginning
In mid-1934 the Production Code Administration took over from the former
unsuccessful Studio Relations Committee to
enforce the Motion Picture Production Code
Code commonly known as the Hays Code
and under the leadership of Joseph
I Breen was properly enforced for the first time demonstrating tha
Hollywood could actually regulate itself
to include strong moral content without
every film needing to be religious or end with a happily-ever-after conclusion
ot just good triumphing over evil but it
couldn't be excessively violent inappropriate
contain much or any foul language
indecent costumes or lurid subject matter
or dismantle the institution of marriage an issue that has always been somewhat
controversial Divorce and remarriage were
never explicitly prohibited under the code
but many censors still opposed it and the Catholic National Legion
of Decency also condemned films
that glorified divorce and remarriage
As a result the code couldn't specifically say oh you can't make this movie because
somebody's divorced and remarried but there'
s a general trend toward encouraging divorced
or estranged couples reuniting because the
code did state that the institution of marriage
must be upheld So there are a few rare instances
of films depicting divorce and remarriage bu
Usually you don't actually see the
original spouse—I've noticed that's a fairly
common detail—and especially when children are involved they typically show wha
Every child's dream is for their parents to reunite especially if it wasn 't
a truly terrible situation—mostly it was just an inability to get along
And this film is truly moving in that direction
as you can see just how much their mother
still loves her ex-husband and how this other woman cares about nothing except his money
And there are pictures of their father
scattered throughout the house and they still
affectionately call him daddy and you can tell even though he abandoned their family
Ten years ago they still loved him And so at the beginning of this film you can'
t help but wonder— are they really going to bring these characters back together
Because as soon as you see Charles
Winninger's character and his father it's
clear he's not winning any Father of the Year awards—he's a terrible father
He doesn't even recognize them—he calls his daughters by the wrong
names has no idea how old they are and doesn't recognize them at all
and he doesn't care about them he just wants to send them back to Europe and get them out of the way
His hair He doesn't care that he hasn't seen them in ten years He's
perfectly content to move past them
I'm sure he's paying child support bu
He doesn't care He just doesn't care And
even though he barely knew his youngest
daughter because she was so young his older
daughter was you know around eight years old
or nine Well yes and the image he holds of them in his mind is likely how they appeared the
last time he saw them so he hasn't really
been interested in learning more about them
who they've become as young women and he had
no idea that Penny was a singer and he's like
Where did you learn to sing Oh didn’t Mother write you She probably did
but he never read it And in contrast
we see Binnie Barnes who is an actress
you see her throughout the Golden Era from the 1930s through
the 1960s—she was a British actress with very strong opinions
She’s thinking about the kind of parts she’d
be drawn to—she doesn’t want to be a good girl
not even a sweet little one like that And she’s got a serious nature that suits her well
She's quite the haughty self-centered
socialite—yet it's an intriguing aspect for
her given how emphatically they emphasize that she's this international beauty
and she was usually not cast in roles that emphasize how attractive
she is But she appears younger here than in many of her later films
So she's incredibly glamorous—she has this 1930s Cleopatra
vibe and her hair is particularly striking in this film
And then her mother is even more like
the manipulative gold-digging mother
who's trying to win over her daughter who isn't much younger than she is
o make an influential marriage She's just completely excessive with
her outfits and her 1930s obsession
Very much a cliché this character
And you see this throughout the
Golden Era and beyond of this
gold-digging mother who is even more brazen than her daughter
because her daughter tries to act sweet but she's so over the top
And ironically this actress was only 11 years older
than Benny Barnes but it doesn't
She strikes me as somewhat young
yet there's a certain
maturity about her It's amusing how the father always calls his fiancée Precious
So the daughters jokingly call her Precious
instead of her name Donna and they refer to their mother as the Pelican
And it's fascinating to see how all the
servants ultimately unite with the daughters in
opposing their father's absurd remarriage
The butler who remembers the girls very well
and their maid and companion and of course
Bill his associate is the one who comes up with
the scheme involving the count And you remarked
after watching this again how interesting
The tone of 1930s movies is sometimes exaggerated—yes there's a lot of
laughing and screaming which sounds
funny but it's just part of the style
High-pitched shouting They're incredibly energetic Especially with these three
rather young exuberant girls around they 're
extremely loud The rhythm of the 30s
Movies were faster-paced than those of the 40s or 50s
even in editing Yes fade-outs
are more abrupt and quicker
There's just a quick pace which is typical of the 1930s
style This one is slightly slowed down because it's a musical
Whenever you insert music into a film that slows down pause for a
moment—stop for the song—but it
still maintains that seamless flow
As you mentioned the music simply begins
and that's just one element of the broader portrayal
of mid-1930s culture you experience
The background music the cinematography and of course the fashion
My outfit is inspired by the dress
you see Penny wearing It features
puffy sleeves and a slightly fuller skirt typical of a young girl
in the 1930s as well as flat shoes
And throughout the film she wears
Several distinct unique hats that are highly characteristic of the era
My outfit draws inspiration from one that
Kay wears during a stroll through the park with Michael Stewart
It features a distinctly 1930s
silhouette complete with a small
jacket a scarf at the neck and an unusual hat Some people mig
consider a movie like this a bit fluffy or somewhat routine
but if you view it through the lens of a film historian
It was truly groundbreaking marking the start of a
style that would become the backbone for numerous
motion picture studios over the next few decades and
it was also pure heartwarming family entertainment
at people of all ages can enjoy It
just makes you feel good and it brought
European culture to Americans in a big way That was something about whic
Joe Pasternak was deeply passionate
and you can see that in the opera
the ballet the classical instrumental music and the operetta style
which you see in many Pasternak films And
it all began right here with Three Smart
Girls which intriguingly starts in Switzerland before moving to the United States
and New York highlighting both
Pasternak's and Koster's own journeys—
from the old world to the new world—
and in a sense preserving that culture
as Nazism threatened to destroy it in Europe
These creatives had to bring their old world style
and sensibility to the new world and blend it
with the strong new principles of American decency
which were being overseen by Joseph Breen
and the PCA Since they couldn't produce
the sensational films that had been popular during the pre-Code era instead
They had to do something else and new styles emerged during the Code era flourishing
throughout that period It's no surprise that
Joe Pasternak was a close personal friend
of Joseph Breen since they seemed to share the same vision that people of all ages
should be able to enjoy every film and
whereas other filmmakers sometimes would argue
with Mr Breen or attempt to sneak in more
suggestive or daring content Joe Pasternak was also
a professional ally because he genuinely shared
the same values when it came to filmmaking
and both gentlemen had a strong European
background as Joseph Breen had spent much of his
time international diplomacy and travel as
a newspaperman and they shared that passion
for old world culture combined with
Americana values For those of us who aren't
film historians I just think this movie
will probably surprise you if you go into
It's kind of a light-hearted musical comedy and there
are moments so moving they
can bring tears to your eyes
especially the ending is truly beautiful
and I believe that is a genuine
hallmark of the Golden Year as a whole I think there's a certain quality
o 30s films which I'm particularly drawn
to there's just this really amazing balance
— it can be incredibly light and genuinely funny at times yet also deeply moving
It becomes deeply emotional and profoundly
moving exceeding expectations in a
way that truly sets it apart within the
genre which is likely why it's so popular
This movie has been beautifully remastered
and is available to rent or purchase
on Amazon Prime Video Hulu and other
streaming platforms such as YouTube
and you can also purchase it on DVD through
Amazon Barnes & Noble or Walmart either as an
individual DVD or as part of a larger Deanna
Durbin film collection Throughout literature
film opera and all kinds of stories
revolve around the love triangle—especially two
friends torn apart by their love for the same woman
Join us next time as we discuss a film that follows
s very plot about two wildcatters
who become oil tycoons but have their
friendship threatened by love for the same woman Thank you
for watching Goodbye