Understanding the Roman Antiquities Market

Ancient World
292 followers
Hi, everyone. I'm here at Harlan J. Burke Coins in Chicago with Aaron Burke, who has kindly agreed to talk about the antiquities market with us today.
So, Aaron, thanks for joining us.
Happy to be here.
So I wanted to lead off with the question that many of us ask about antiquities.
Where do they come from, first of all, onto the market?
And how can we be sure, if we're buying antiquities, that we're not buying looted artifacts, artifacts that come from other unofficial sources?
Right, right. Well, I can tell you that antiquities have been traded since the time they were actually made.
And so it's difficult to know when was something looted or not looted.
What we try to do is we try to maintain and buy things here in the U.S.
There's a lot of material that was brought here over the last hundred plus years.
And so there's tons of material here.
If I go to Europe these days, there's a chance, unless there's a known pedigree for the piece, that it could have been looted recently.
There's no way for you to know.
But things in the U.S. are pretty well documented, or I feel like they've been here long enough.
I don't have to worry about importing them in.
And they've been in families' collections for years and years, for many, many years.
So generally speaking, cheaper antiquities would never be in a known auction catalog going back before the 1970 date, which is the UNESCO treaty,
which says that museums and institutions can't purchase things that don't show that they've been outside the source country before that 1970 date.
But most items that are under $100 or $200 today would have never shown up in a catalog back then.
So it's really hard to get physical evidence to know whether a cheaper object has been out of the source country that long.
So a lot of it is just your gut feeling and also knowing who you're buying from.
If somebody tells you, I just found this in Italy or in Greece, I don't buy it.
And just using common sense, if you knowingly know that an item's been looted, then you are liable.
If you don't know and you do your due diligence, then you usually don't have a problem.
And most things that are not national treasures are not going to be an issue.
And it's the people that either make up pedigrees that aren't true or they are dealing directly with looters that are the ones that are the problem.
I see. And how do you detect forgeries in the antiquities market?
So we're coin dealers primarily, but we've been dealing with ancient artifacts our whole career.
I've been doing this for almost 32 years.
And so after looking at 32 years of fakes and real things, you develop an eye for what the items are supposed to look like,
what surfaces are supposed to look like, what the style is supposed to look like.
You get a general feeling from it.
And so your best defense is your gut, just like everything else.
And so it's no different than somebody looking at a painting to know if it's by Van Gogh or not.
Is the style right? Is the material proper for the period?
In certain cases, like with coins, is it the weight, the incrustation, the style?
All of those come into play.
And if any of those things raise a feeling with yourself, then you know it's bad.
Sometimes we'll also go to, depending on the type of piece, if it's Egyptian and has hieroglyphics,
we might go to an Egyptologist to see if it can be read.
If it can't be read, the glyphs are bad, then we know that it's probably bad.
If it's another language that's on a piece, we can do the same thing.
If it doesn't make sense, if it's done improperly, if the periods are mixed, which happens sometimes,
those things can also draw you to conclude that it must be bad.
I can walk into a room now and see a piece and know immediately, within seconds, if it's bad or not.
And then when I say it's bad because I haven't sat down and looked at it for more than 30 seconds,
people will question me, like, how do you know?
Well, I know because I've held a gazillion real things and a gazillion fake things.
Yeah, this experience tells.
Yeah.
So, moving on to what you actually find on the antiquities market,
on levels, say, sub-$1,000, people are actually buying for the most part, who aren't ultra-wealthy.
What are the most common antiquities you guys sell, say, at the $100, $200 price range?
Okay, so one of the most popular things that we sell during the holidays are these Roman nails.
These actual, we actually pair them, we put them in these suspension cases.
They actually open up very easily.
And these are Roman iron nails that were found in an excavation at Itched Hill in northern Scotland.
And they were found in 1961.
And the fort was dismantled in 71 AD.
And these were legally exported out of England at the time.
We actually bought about 100,000 of these.
There was a million nails found.
And most of them are in the National Museum in Scotland, except for the 100,000 that we bought in 1999.
We paired them with what's called a widow's mite, which are mentioned in the Bible.
And it has to do with Christ observing wealthy merchants putting gold coins into the donation bowl.
And then an old woman came and gave two widow's mites, which was the lowest currency at the time in Judea.
And he said that those were worth more than the gold coins.
So they call it the poor old widow's mite.
And so we pair it with a Roman nail that was made in the same century as the crucifixion by the Romans who crucified Christ.
And even though these couldn't crucify a mouse, they are good representations.
And we sell these for $65 in the case.
And so it's a nice price point for people.
Even the widow's mites we get out of Israel, legally exported from the Antiquity Authority with proper paperwork.
So whenever you're in this business, you always do the right thing.
And when you have to source outside of the country, you just make sure that all your Ts are crossed and Is are dotted.
So this is an excellent gift that a lot of people like, not just for the religious aspect, but also for the antiquity aspect as well.
Moving up, I would say then comes Roman glass.
So these are very common.
They're found all over the Middle East.
They call these teardrops because supposedly they would put a tear in it when someone passed away.
These date anywhere from the 1st to the 5th century A.D.
And these sell for about $100 or less in some cases a piece.
Very common, found all over, and a lot of people brought this stuff back over the last 100 years to the U.S.
So you can find mounds of this material here in the U.S.
And depending on the amount of iridescence on the piece or the shape, they can go up in value.
But I would say as a whole, Roman glass is down in value at the high level just because not as many people are collecting it right now as they used to.
Another one that's very common are oil lamps.
So these are even more common than the glass because back in the day when we didn't have electricity or even candles, these were the candles.
So they would put the oil here, the wick here, and these would light your home.
So basically you needed to have lamps in all periods, starting in Greek period all the way through to the Byzantines and beyond.
And so depending on how much money you had, you had different workshops in different regions making lamps.
These are probably the most common that you'd find all over the Middle East, dating anywhere from the late 3rd to 5th century A.D. and later.
These sell for, I think right now we're selling them for about $85 a piece.
They used to sell back 30 years ago about $40 a piece, but they're harder to get now and there's a lot of reproductions out there.
And so I only want to sell real things, and so I have to make sure what I have is real so you pay more.
And then you can go up to pieces like this, which is a scene with a gladiator fighting scene.
So depending on how much iconography is on the piece, you'll get higher values.
And these can go, like this one probably is going to sell anywhere between $500 and $800 and up depending on how nice it is.
So it all comes down to the iconography and how nice the piece is.
But again, something that's pretty prevalent and all over the place.
People love Egyptian, so Egyptian figurines, amulets, and things like that.
A thing that we sell pretty commonly is Egyptian faience necklaces.
These are from the late period, about 715 to 30 B.C.
These are modernly restrung because the string wouldn't last anymore.
But faience, I like to call like the cheap plastic of the Egyptian culture.
Because if you didn't have money for any valuable materials, these were pressed out in molds and then glazed.
And depending on how much blue or iron was in the glazing process, you'd get greens to deep blues.
And they made their amulets, their ushaptis, and their beads out of it.
So very, very common.
So people like to buy these.
We sell these for about $250 for a strand of those.
Weapons.
You don't generally get Greek and Roman weapons because they were made out of iron and iron erodes away.
But the loristans, which was a culture, it was pre-Persian between the Iraq and Iran borders.
And they did a lot of their weapons in bronze and it all, because of the climate, it all survived.
And it also saw that they put a lot of these things in their tombs, hundreds of them.
So they weren't necessarily used as weapons all the time.
And so you have tons of swords and daggers and spear points that exist.
So these are some of the more common ones that you'll see.
And these date anywhere from 12 to 800 B.C.
And a piece like this might run $150 or less, sometimes down to like $50.
And then you get a nicer one like this that we mounted up that might run around $1,000.
Just depending on how nice it is, the patina on it, how large it is.
I've had swords, full swords that are probably three feet long that have sold for $5,000 to $8,000.
So again, it just depends on the quality of the pieces.
Another thing that people really love are Greek vases.
And so you can get basically very common blackware, 4th to 3rd centuries B.C. in Magna Graecia.
And people will say, oh, you're touching these things with your hands.
Well, I can tell you these things all come out of the earth.
They're all covered in sediment.
And I've been handling these things for over 30 years.
I've never had a problem with anything.
Bronze, you can get what's called green disease.
If you had moisture on your hands and it got into the surfaces, that can be a problem.
But in general, ceramics and terracotta, not a problem.
As long as you're not eating peanut butter and then touching these things with peanut butter, you're going to be okay.
So in fact, I think people hold these things with gloves will have a better chance of dropping them, honestly.
So these date anywhere 4th, 3rd century B.C.
And they might run anywhere, depending on, again, the glaze, the type, anywhere from $200 up to $500.
And then you might get ones like this.
This is Attic 5th century. Attic is more popular.
It's got a design on top. A piece like this might be $800, $1,200.
And then you have an earlier geometric.
So this is an early geometric period around 8th century B.C. with the bird on it.
A piece like this might be $1,200, which is actually pretty inexpensive for what it is.
In auction, these things can go for about $2,000 or more.
And then some of the most amazing things, if you really want to get crazy, is going to be high-end pieces.
I talk about cheaper lamps. Well, this is an amazing ship lamp.
It actually has got an oceanic scene here, kind of like a Neptune figure down here, the three spouts.
This is Roman period with a ship or galley on it.
Probably almost a one-of-a-kind type of piece.
This actually came out of a collection that was formed before 1970.
And a piece like this sells for about anywhere from $80,000 to $100,000.
This was actually bought out legally out of an auction in Germany a number of years ago.
And we're happy to have it on consignment with a client right now.
And so, again, it just depends on, like anything else, antiquities, like anything else, is supply and demand.
And how much demand is, how beautiful it is, and how much demand that there is.
And then finally, we have what's called a Phrygian helmet.
So this is Greek. This is going to be 4th to 3rd century BC.
Philip II, the father of Alexander the Great, would have used these for his calvary.
And then after Alexander took over, he didn't like them for the calvary.
But there were some hoplite soldiers that would still wear them during the time of Alexander the Great.
This is made out of bronze.
And it's very iconic.
And in fact, the Liberty cap was probably copied from this that you see on old U.S. coins.
And it's just an iconic piece.
One piece that we've, I've never had one of these.
It came out of a collection here in the U.S.
And a piece like this is going to sell anywhere between $25,000 and $30,000.
Oh, great. Thank you for that survey of the antiquities market.
You're welcome.
Some fascinating stuff.
Thanks.
It must be affordable, considering what it is and how old it is and the history attached to it.
Correct.
So anyway, Aaron, thanks so much.
If you're interested in this stuff, check out Han J. Burke Coins, based here in Chicago, but shipping everywhere.
And for watching, thank you very much.
And we'll be back very soon.
Thanks.
