Do Electric Shocks REALLY stop insect bites itching?? Expedition medication - Dr Gill
Dr James Gill
407 followers
Do Electric Shocks REALLY stop insect bites itching? Dr Gill
Every man and his dog has an approach to stopping the irritation or itching that comes from an insect or mosquito bite. Most of these options are chemical in nature with people commonly using antihistamines or steroid creams to reduce itching.
However there are companies which claim that the charge from a peizoelectric crystals is sufficient to reducing the itching from an insect bite.
Is that really the case? Can electricity affect an insect bite? and if so what might be the mechanism of action - let's take a look
#Drgill #insectbites #itching
Hello and welcome back to the channel. My name's Dr James Gill and I'm
somewhere hot again. So across a lot of the travels that I do for work I often end up in
hot places where mosquitoes are a big issue. Now I've spoken previously about using things like
DEET to try and reduce the risk of being bitten but once you've been bitten what are you going
to do? I mean there's all the chemicals, lotions and potions you can put on to try and reduce the
but there are devices that you can buy that claim to be able to help with the itching.
What's the science behind them? So this is a piezoelectric clicker. What that means is there
is a small piezoelectric crystal in here and when you activate it it generates a small current
and voltage across the two bits on the end. Now when you apply that to the skin that's going to
put electricity through you and the idea is that when you've been bitten when you're itching you
apply this thing and fire it between five and ten times and that should improve the itching.
Now this is not a sponsored video in any way. I get bitten enough. These things are quite cheap
and I thought I'll give it a go but I did have a look at the science first. So when these went
through the FDA in America there was a 100 person case control study done. So 50 people
had the real device and 50 using the sham. When you pressed it nothing happened. Now
interesting enough they did find about a 50% reduction in itching within about 10 minutes
of use of the device using let's say 10 up to 10 clicks on a person. Later on that difference
certainly disappeared but they also looked at the size of the wheel the area of redness
and that was shown to have about a 25% reduction several hours after. However there was one
considerable problem with the study for this thing. After the study they spoke to the people
involved in it and the testers were able with 97% accuracy to determine if they had the fake device
or not. Now that has a significant problem for any of the data. If you think you're using the
real device you're going to have a bias and even if there's a placebo bias you know we're still
going to see up to a 20% difference in the effect. So something to really keep in mind with that.
But let's assume there is a very small benefit. How could it work? Well there's a couple
hypotheses here. One is that these things actually overcome your nerves as in they over
stimulate it and result in that reduction in itching specifically the c-type fibres.
There's the hypothesis that the electrical stimuli stabilises the mast cells and reduces
the histamine release. Personally I'm not too convinced with that one because the idea being
that the histamine is already released and that's the thing causing the itching. So why
would you get a reduction in the first 10 minutes of use? So not convinced by that one myself.
There's the idea that these generate the release of endogenous opioids so the body's natural pain
relief pathways are engaged and that holds a little bit of evidence in the same way if you
bash your elbow on something you're going to rub your elbow to try and soothe it.
That's kind of what might be going on with this. The final hypothesis that I do rather like is that
the electricity stimulates heat within the skin denaturing the proteins in the mosquito saliva
that actually generate the itching in the first place. Now I find that a very elegant hypothesis
however I'm not entirely convinced because once you've denatured a protein it should stay that
way i.e. the effect should be maintained and we can see that from this evidence this is only a
couple of minutes of effect. So what's my take here? These are very cheap there's some evidence
although weak to suggest it's going to give you at least 10 minutes worth of benefit and personally
the complications I see from insect bites often come from people itching them. So actually in the
short term if this can reduce itching it's probably not a bad thing to take with you when traveling
because they're very cheap and they're probably not going to cause you any major problems
unless you have a pacemaker or any of the contraindications to using an electrical device.
Overall quite cheap not going to cause you any problems hopefully. I'd give it a go but
don't expect miracles from it. Take care and see you in the next one. Cheerio!
