Should You Try a CGM (Continuous Glucose Monitor)? Dr James Gill
Should You Try a Continuous Glucose Monitor (CGM)? Dr James Gill
We know that continuous glucose monitors are everywhere comma but how important is this tech and who is really going to benefit from it? What does the CGM measure, and where are the pitfalls of its use??
What is the impact of the order of food consumption and exercise on glucose levels? We discuss this an more!
To enter the give away, like the video, add a comment and be sure to subscribe to the channel - the selection for UK residents only, will be done on monday 2nd of December, and international selection will be 3rd of December
For those considering a purchase during Black Friday, Sinocare are offering an extra 10% off code: 2ODVQWEH for this link:
[Music]
hello and welcome back to the channel my
name is Dr James Gill and you joined me
for what might be a controversial video
as I'm sure many of you are aware of
there are now these devices called
continuous glucose monitors that you can
get a hold of which can monitor your
blood sugars or sort of monitor your
blood sugars what these specifically do
is actually monitor the intertial fluid
um the sugar in the space between your
cells rather than actually in the blood
now don't get me wrong blood glucose
monitors are old Tech and they're great
Tech they're the the Cornerstone of our
diabetes care because whatever we can
measure we can
manage but then that also comes to the
question of whether or we should be
measuring something now there are you
know every Tom Dick and Harry on the
internet will tell you that cgms are the
next big thing and they've been saying
that for quite some time and Sino care
reached out and said would they be
interested or would I be interested in
sponsoring a video and I said yes on the
agreement that the sponsorship
involved 20 of these that I can then
hand out to you guys so the point being
is should you use a continuous glucose
monitor and the honest answer is
probably like the Bas lman sunscreen be
careful Whose advice you buy so probably
not unless maybe what do I mean by that
if you are a healthy individual with
nothing wrong with them this probably is
not going to change your life and in
fact could actually harm you because
you're perhaps going to end up fixating
on a number that doesn't matter to you
now the reason why I say it doesn't
matter because this is not measuring
your blood sugar but is measuring the
the sugar between the cells in your
tissues not finger Pricks um there's
quite a lag in terms of you doing
something and that's going to be a
crucial thing Andor eating something and
the effect on your blood
sugar hold on let me rephrase that
because that that is that's the Crux of
these devices
there's going to be a lag between you
doing or eating something and the
detection of that uh glucose Spike on
the continuous glucose monitor because
it is not a blood glucose monitor now
don't get me wrong there's still going
to be a bit of a lag with regard to
blood glucose monitoring but it's not
going to be you know in the hours that
we can see with these
things so why is that important
when um we get a new newly diagnosed
diabetic or perhaps somebody with a
slightly raised
hba1c so this is a marker of how much
sugar is stuck to our red blood cells
and the more sugar we have in the body
the more it sticks to our red blood
cells and it's an uh it's an indicator
of good glycemic control so in terms of
the numbers we need to be aware of
between um 42 and
48 um milles per liter puts us at
pre-diabetes these are the patients who
I really want to try and turn around
their trajectory because they're heading
for a very serious illness if you're
over 48 then you have diabetes and we
really need to be helping these people
manage the disease that they have and
potentially that word is doing an awful
lot of lifting try to find a way to turn
it around and reverse it so they are
biochemically not diabetic anymore
there's a debate to be said as to
whether or not you get your HBA 1C below
48 are you still diabetic or just an
incredibly well-controlled one but
that's not what we're discussing here
today so there two patients who might be
a benefit here but if you are General
Schmo who has no health problems as far
as you're aware this probably isn't
going to be helpful and might be harmful
now I say probably because in my opinion
you can do some really cool experiments
with these which can be useful for
healthy
people the one that I have done which
has changed how I live my life um is
with regard to how I eat not necessarily
what I eat so again going back to the
fact that there is a lag with these um
one of the things that you can do is eat
a unit of carbohydrate IE a bagel and
you'll see an hour or two later the um
the glucose level will increase you can
the following day eat some Greek yogurt
not Greek star yogurt cuz that's a
marketing Ploy but actual Greek yogurt
and a couple of hours later you'll see
much less of an increase you've got to
make sure that you're eating uh
equivalent
amounts the third day eat the bagel 20
minutes later and then have the yogurt
and again you'll see that Spike on the
monitor on the fourth day however if you
eat the Greek yogurt and then 20 minutes
later the bagel you do not get the same
Spike you get a much blunt uh blunting
into the curve now that sounds like this
whole blunt the curve hypothesis um that
blood sugar spikes are inherently evil
they're not okay they're a normal part
of life if you're particularly stressed
you go into fight or flight mode your
body needs sugar you're going to get a a
glucose Spike even if you haven't been
eating because your body will prepare
you for that if you're very stressed um
if you're not sleeping well all of those
things will lead to you know rises in
your blood glucose and that's why it's
important that we try to help a patient
look at their whole of their life not
just what goes into their mouth now I
hurly highlight that what goes into your
mouth is still crucially important and
when it comes to weight loss we say that
weight losses done in the um in the
kitchen not in the gym so that is
vitally important but how is this going
to potentially help or harm well by
showing how the order in which I eat
Foods adjusts the effect on my glucose
levels I have found it means that I do
not get quite as ravenously hungry now I
want to be really clear I'm not changing
the food that I'm eating I'm changing
the order so for example you go to a
restaurant have a starter that's
potentially more fibrous it's got more
fats to it and then I'm going to have my
you know um my main meal that's got
planted chips to it you know all the
stuff that I like I've not changed what
I'm eating I've changed how I'm eating
so that is how I have used this
and I think that's reasonable to you
know use one of these for 2 weeks have a
play with it and see what information
you
get should you be buying one of these as
a normal person and using it day in day
out to rule your life absolutely not not
only is it going to end up with somebody
who's fixated on a number that as I say
is hugely affected by the environment as
much as anything else these things
aren't cheap and they're not going to be
giving you anywhere near the level of
benefit that you would think that you
get for the price and also for what
people are going to tell you on social
media so if you're a normal person ah
it's fun to mess around with one for a
week or two bear in mind each of them
has a 14-day battery life if you've got
no other health problems don't go
anywhere anyway now then we get to the
gray zones of people who I think these
could be useful for um personally I try
to ride my uh diabetic patients quite
hard I really want to help them I
basically have an open door policy and
say come in we'll talk about these
things you know let me try to help you
let's get a good monitoring on your
hba1c now there's a crucial thing with
monitoring
hba1c it's slow which these kind of go
against the concept for you can only
repeat the HBA A1C so a marker of how
your diet has been been a marker of how
your exercise has been a marker of how
your health has been a marker of how
your diabetes has been every 3 months
because that's how long it takes a red
blood cell to be created from the bone
marrow come out do its thing in the body
and then be die off and
cleared it'll be three months that
sugars will stick to that red blood cell
so if you have a patient who's diabetic
and I magically cured their Di diabetes
absolutely perfectly cured their
diabetes their
hba1c would
not significantly change until 3 months
had passed and we had replaced their
existing red blood cells that were
crammed on the surface full of sugar so
again this is you know a two-e thing I'm
looking at it hourly daily no actually
our big diabetic numbers are long-term
trends
and this might help with that trend for
you so if you're very concerned that
you're in a pre-diabetic Zone trying to
reduce the spikes of uh blood sugar that
you are um how to put it that you
are I don't want to say responsible for
because that sounds like we blame people
for their um their conditions perhaps
that you are able to adjust is a best
phrasing um then this can be worthwhile
again I go back to thinking about diet
go back to thinking about exercise go
back to thinking about
stress if you find that when you are
pre-diabetic that you're able to get
something like this from your GP you
wear the the glucose
monitor using this may be able to give
you an idea about how your sleep how
good quality sleep getting enough sleep
has an impact on your glucose in the
preceding few days similarly how your
stress levels might
improve and you might see an improvement
in your glucose levels you know with
meditation with trying to adjust life
trying to reduce stresses at work by
maybe sort of planning differently maybe
engaging in walks on the way to work
there's lots of little health things
that we can do but ultim Ely bringing
down your stress levels you may see has
an improvement in your glucose level now
with our patients who have
diabetes these things come into a very
different uh field and I'm not going to
discuss that quite so much here because
that's a different video in its own
right but ultimately these are going to
give us a really important metric for
our diabetic patients of time in range
where how long have we managed to
maintain a patient's blood sugars in the
range that we want it where they haven't
had high pose which let's crank it to
the max can be deadly all the way
through to our hypers which will be
causing damage so on that side of things
these can be really really
useful now we talked about um using
these with regard to exercise and I
think that's going to be a really
interesting point because what I'm going
to do shortly I'm going to stick this on
my arm and you're going to join me in
the garage and we're going to go on the
exercise bike now if I absolutely Peg it
on the exercise bike for let's go for 45
minutes what do you think is going to
happen to my blood sugar as I ride and
I'm going to do it first thing in the
morning and I will have got out of bed I
will be in a fasted State I'll have
water on it so I'm not going to be
taking anything what do you expect is
going to happen to my blood sugar levels
as I go on the bike let's have a look
okay I'm SW now as we know from medical
school we go from the
inside out and then going to turn over
go in and out again and I'm actually
going to leave that to
dry at this point I'm going
to
remove the click part and then we've got
the sticky bit
underneath I'm going to stick that on
the side I'm waiting for that to
dry
okay here we go 3 two
1 3 two
one
oh you know
what I think it made and probably me
made more noise than it actually did
going in but there we go all
finished okay so the sensor's on now and
actually this works out quite well I've
now got 2 hours before it's ready to go
ready to give me data or something like
that and actually I forgot I was doing
this so I had lunch a little bit too
soon ago so what I'm going to do I'm
going to let this run get it all set up
make sure things are good and then when
I wake up in the morning the first thing
I'm going to do is get on the bike and
I'm going to do that as a fasted ride so
I should see as mentioned a glucose
Spike as I'm going along okay in that
case I'll see you in the
morning right good morning so we're
going to put this to the test what we're
expecting to happen given it is now 10:
to 8 in the morning is I'm going to get
on the bike I'm going to have to work
for quite a while maybe an hour or so
that should result in me using the
glucose in my leg
because I haven't eaten since 8:00 last
night so I've got a 12-hour fast and my
glucose at the moment is 8 mm per liter
as my glucose levels in my legs go down
because I've used them we're going to
expect glucagon to be released from the
pancreas to affect glycogen in the liver
to allow my sugar levels to increase
back up that's what we're looking for
let's see if it happens oh and on an
entirely separate note if you're going
to wear one of these blasted CGM things
have to think about where your clothes
could get in the way now I've placed
mine well above the belt but
unfortunately it's rubbing on my cycling
shorts just think is there anything that
might um rub before you stick it there
cuz I've got this stuck there for the
next 14 days just a thought right with
that in mind let's head to the garage oh
actually on that point it is currently 4
degrees outside so that might add a
small complicating Factor the reason
being is when the temperatures are very
low and it's first thing in the morning
you can have a higher level of cortisol
level which could mean that we get a um
a reduction in insulin release which
could mean that um you know we don't see
the effect in the sugars we're looking
at so we'll we'll see whether or not it
works but I'm hoping that once I've
warmed up on the bike that should be
taken out of the equation we'll see
right
well as you can see there's been a brief
costume change because it's Jolly cold
in here but I've got the bike set up and
currently I'm doing steady 150 watts um
I'm going to need to get to that much
higher in order to um burn through um
the glucose that's in my blood at the
moment so let's actually have a look on
the phone where we are so currently I'm
sitting there at 8.2 mm m per liter and
what we're expecting to happen as the
clock goes on and I use up the sugar in
my in my blood literally turning the W
bike here um the pancreas is going to
see that reduction in glucose and all
the while your body wants to
maintain uh homeostasis so it wants to
keep my sugar levels nice and normal so
what we'd expect to see is a bit of a
dip
and then the pancreas will see that dip
and will release
glucagon now glucagon from the pancreas
is going to then affect the liver and
that's going to
allow the liver to break down
glycogen which is going to put more
sugar back in my blood to allow me to
keep on pushing so we're expecting to
see ideally everything stay completely
stable but but in reality we'll probably
see a bit of a dip because I'm literally
burning sugar and then that to come up
again even though I've only got water in
this bottle and I won't be taking
anything during the ride and we'll be
able to look
at the work that I've done later in
terms of the calories burned because
I've got a heart rate monitor on so I
know I'm sitting there
at 143 beats a minute but you can see
I'm climatizing so I'm holding 210 Watts
at that
143 so certainly in the warm-up period
it's been and gone I can tell that cuz
it's now getting rather warm for me
anyway all
right so do that
right so I'm going to get on with this
and I
will come back and talk to you guys if
we see nothing of news actually on a
mild thing since you're here that's
interesting so up here my wattage is a
little bit lower but when I come
forwards onto the hoods my wattage
increases just a um a small thing for
you this is because I'm recrui
recruiting different muscles when I'm
cycling in different positions so when
you're out on a big bike ride and you're
needing a break change positions it's
not going to be huge but it is going to
help ever so slightly I'm putting that
in perspective doing
240 and my heart rate has dropped down
to
125 so I'm in a much more efficient
position with regard to my musculature
although given the nature of the
experiment we're doing and I want to
generate work perhaps it will be better
for me to go back to this position where
it's harder for me generate the power y
I'm down to 220
now and expecting that to push my heart
rate
up it's not going to affect the uh
experiment but it's just an interesting
thing
about training a muscle position and
things like
that right I'll see you later well that
was perhaps a little bit more than I
expected right so uh camera's died which
is why we're doing it on the phone now
over that ride I've just done 784
calories
burned my blood glucose peaked at about
8.8 is dropped down as low as 6.8
and finished at
7.8 so two things take away from this
one not only what was expected happened
so blood sugar went up to feed my legs
blood sugar went down as I'm using my
legs and blood sugars came back up again
but because I don't have diabetes or
other medical problems I've gone back to
that homeostasis the body has tried to
keep everything in balance and I think
that's really the key if you are
well these blood glucose monitors
probably aren't going to do much for you
if you are pre-diabetic they can be very
useful at helping you determine whether
or not you're spiking with certain foods
and look at how you're changing your
lifestyle if you're diabetic they are
massively important but for people who
don't have medical problems they're
interesting experiments certainly and
you know I love science you know krack
on you know use these devices as a point
of Interest with regard to looking at
your own body but don't have these as
the be all and end all so I hope that's
been interesting I hope that's given you
a bit of context for how these may or
may not be useful and more importantly
if you make a comment like the video and
then in the next uh 48 hours I'll
randomly select group of people to send
continuous glucose monitors to you from
sinare and perhaps afterwards as a say
we can get together and maybe have a um
a large Zoom call that we film and put
on the channel to see how people have
done with uh these blood glucose
monitors to that end Cheerio we'll see
you in the next one