Shifting dullness and fluid thrill for ascites is often one of the last parts of the abdominal examination, but it is often something students can become confused over when they first start clinical skills at medical school
In this video, we will look at what ascites is, how it is clinically relevant, what ascites means for the body, how to assess ascites, what causes ascites and crucially what steps we can implement to treat it
Watch further abdominal examinations for your OSCE revision:
Please note that there is no ABSOLUTE way to perform a clinical examination. Different institutions and even clinicians will have differing degrees of variations - the aim is the effectively identify medically relevant signs.
However during OSCE assessments. Different medical schools, nursing colleges and other health professional courses will have their own preferred approach to a clinical assessment - you should concentrate on THEIR marks schemes for your assessments.
The examination demonstrated here is derived from Macleods Clinical Examination - a recognised standard textbook for clinical skills.
00:00 - Overview of Ascites 01:04 - Ascites Fluid Composition 02:00 - Serum Ascites Albumin Gradient (SAAG) Explanation 02:28 - High vs. Low SAAG 04:12 - Paracentesis for Ascites 05:05 - Clinical Examination for Ascites 05:54 - Shifting Dullness Technique Demonstration 07:59 - Fluid Thrill Technique Demonstration 09:40 - Additional Investigations for Ascites 10:48 - Treatment Approaches for Ascites 14:54 - Recap and Final Thoughts
[Music]
hello and welcome back to the channel my
name is dr james gill and you've joined
me for another clinical skills video
today we're going to be looking at a
specific part of the abdominal
examination
that of how to assess for a cities using
two particular examination techniques
that being
shifting dullness and also the fluid
thrill
now before we get much further into it i
will highlight that i'm not the biggest
fan of the fluid thrill as you may see
later on it's a reasonable test but i
don't like how it's performed on the
patient
so with that in mind we're talking about
ascites what what do we actually mean by
societies
so a patient is said to have ascites
when they have more than 25 ml of fluid
in the peritoneal cavity now we say
technically 25 mils but it won't be
until 500 milliliters in the peritoneal
cavity that would be able to detect that
clinically on examination
so when we talk about societies in the
peritoneal cavity we need to keep in
mind
what this fluid actually is it's not as
if somebody's just you know managed to
sweat a little bit into this peritoneal
cavity ascites is comprised of protein
albumin
bile
white blood cells and a little bit of
lipid or fats as well
so it's very important we understand the
makeup of an acidic fluid because we
need to be able to categorize that
necessities and we do that by
calculating the serum ascites album and
gradient and that's relatively
straightforward working out the serum
acidic albumin gradient we're going to
take the serum albumin concentration and
we're going to minus that from the
ascites albumin concentration and that
will then give us a number
so in terms of the stag number we have
an important cutoff
if the
concentration is greater than 1.1
milligrams per deciliter then it's
determined to be a
high sag rating whereas if it's below
1.1 it's a low sag rating
so once we've calculated our sag and we
can determine if it's a high or low sag
why why is that matter well if we have a
high sag concentration then that
indicates that the acidic fluid has
formed due to a increased hydrostatic
pressure i.e fluid has been forced out
of the tissues into the peritoneal
cavity
conversely if we have a low sac then
we're looking at an increased oncotic
pressure and this is much more serious
this means that for some reason the
bowel and
membranes around it have become more
permeable and allowed albumin as well as
fluid to pass into the peritoneal cavity
so to really sort of
crystallize that home a high sag from
our societies will be due to
for example increased portal
hypertension so that might be the
commonest form that you'll be aware of
liver cirrhosis it may be due to blood
chiari syndromes quite rare there and it
can also be due to heart failure
so if we've got a low sag then we're
going to be looking at
an you know an increased oncotic
pressure and that tends to have more
worrying features
not that
heart failure and cirrhosis aren't
worrying but
with the race oncotic pressure to
generate the societies we're looking at
things like infections such as tb
malignancies particularly if we're
talking
particularly with peritoneal meds
we can also have pancreatitis and
nephrotic syndrome where people are
going to be losing a large amount of
protein anyway
so that really sort of brings home how
important it is to a
identify um
the societies and then b work out what
type of vascities we've got in terms to
assist uh treating it
we're going to work out that type as i
say by doing the um
paracentesis getting some of that fluid
out and honestly i can tell you from
when you've done when i've done
parasynthesis in the hospital
the first time we do it it's frankly a
quite
frightening procedure as essentially
you're getting this long needle putting
it into the patient
at the transition zone where you're
getting that dullness hoping not to
injure
any of the floating contents of the
abdomen um no none of the bowel that's
floating on that acidic fluid
so we've covered what ascites is now i
think we should probably do the clinical
examination to
show the differences between
the shifting dullness and also the fluid
thrill
[Music]
so we've just talked about some of the
background with the side to ascites but
we did highlight that whilst ascites
is technically present when you've got
more than 25 mils of fluid in the
abdomen
we wouldn't be able to detect it
clinically until we've got 500 ml of
fluid in there and the two approaches
that we'll use to determine ascites in
our patient will be first off shifting
dullness
and secondarily a fluid thrill which
we're going to demonstrate both of those
now so we're going once again joined by
other so if you'd like to lie back for
me take off your shirt please
so in terms of assessing for ascites we
observe the patient and we see if we can
see any obvious
swelling or distension to the abdomen
increasing our probability that we have
ascites here
we're going to place our left hand flat
on the center of the patient's abdomen
and i'm going to precurse directly over
the distal interphalangeal joint we're
going to percuss around the patient's
flank
thinking that we've got the bowel
sitting here floating over the fluid so
we should have a resonant note over the
central area and as we move down towards
where the fluid will be that note will
change from resonant to dull
once we've found that dull area we'll
move the patient we'll wait and
hopefully
in the case of ascites
we'll find that the bowel floats up and
the fluid
trickles away meaning that that area of
dullness will now become resonant
so in terms of recessing for shifting
dullness i'm placing my hand flat on the
patient's abdomen and i'm striking
directly over the distal interphalangeal
joint
i'm going to percuss all the way around
the side where i'd expect dullness to be
around about here if there was any
acidic fluid
now we've got a change in note here
anyway because other doesn't have any
obvious societies and his bowel is still
going to be resonant with air so if you
roll over towards me
okay and i wait for 10 seconds for the
fluid to percolate down and the bowel to
float up after 10 seconds i'm going to
percuss again
and if we have ascites that percussion
would have changed to resonant thus we
have shown the dullness from the flank
has now shifted
if you could roll back for me if we've
got a patient with very tense societies
we can also check for a fluid thrill
so in terms of checking for a fluid
thrill that involves me placing my hand
on the patient's abdomen and flicking uh
their side to propagate a wave through
that acidic fluid
i'll be honest personally i'm not a big
fan of this
test because
you're physically flicking the patient
there is a chance you could hurt them
but it is still a relevant valid test if
we are unsure about the presence of the
sitees if it's exceptionally tense in
the abdomen
so in terms of the fluid through i'm
going to place my hand on the left side
of the abdomen and we're then going to
flick
to the side to see if i can feel that
wave propagating through
now if we've got fluid in the abdomen
that wave will be transmitted through
that fluid
however so it can also be propagated
across the skin and abdominal fat
so because i can feel
that fluid thrill coming through we'll
take the patient's left hand and place
it in the center of their abdomen
pushing down
i'm once again going to place my left
hand on the side of the patient and
again
check the fluid through
if i can once again feel the fluid
thrill coming through the fluid then
we've confirmed that we have ascites
however if that thrill is no longer
propagated with the patient placing
their hand there we know that that
through was actually being propagated
through the abdominal wall and fatty
tissues thus there's no evidence of
societies there
okay so you've seen how we go about
performing the shifting dullness and the
fluid thrill now so perhaps it's
worthwhile we look at a few of the other
investigations that we do if we have
ascites so we'd also want to do a few
blood tests on a patient with ascites
looking at their liver function
looking at their full blood count and
the coagulation screen the coagulation
screen is quite important as that's one
of the earliest things we'll see start
to become deranged
in severe liver failure
conversely we're also going to need to
do some imaging particularly
an ultrasound
that will allow us to assess the
patient's organs and quantify any
ascites that is actually too small for
us to detect with clinical examination
and as mentioned previously portal vein
hypertension can be a cause of
increased hydrostatic pressure causing a
high sag ascites
so
our ultrasound would also let us assess
that portal vein
when it comes to treatments essentially
we need to treat the cause so for
example if a patient is having liver
failure treating what has
triggered the liver failure if possible
but in some cases that may indicate that
the patient needs a liver transplant in
order to treat the ascites and any other
features that they're presenting with
but societies itself is a very
uncomfortable thing to have you know you
literally stretched to the amount of
fluid that you have within you so we're
going to need to make sure that we're
trying to treat that ascites by doing a
therapeutic tap a therapeutic
paracentesis to try and get that fluid
out
so if we're doing a therapeutic draining
of the ascites we need to keep our eyes
out for two very important changes
first being sudden onset bacterial
peritonitis so where that acidic fluid
can become colonized by bacteria which
can be life-threatening
similarly we also need to keep regular
checks on a patient's liver and renal
function making sure they don't develop
a hepato-renal syndrome
so when it comes to a high sac we can
try and help the patient lose some of
the fluid through diuresis so we can
treat them with medications such as
spironolactone
now it's very important if we do this
that we keep a close watch on the
patient's weight
in terms of treating the ascites itself
we want to be aiming to lose about half
a kilo a day
however if the patient has peripheral
edema as well then we're going to push a
little bit further and we're going to
aim to lose one kilo of fluid a day but
hence the comment about hepato renal
syndrome we need to make sure we're
monitoring their fluid balance very
carefully one of the other things that
we can do for a patient with a high sag
a raised hydrostatic pressure induced
societies is to
give them a reduced salt diet so they're
worth helping and try to reduce
their holding on to water now i
highlight that that is what we'll do for
our high sag
societies
unfortunately low sagitte is with that
increased oncotic pressure due to
infections due to pancreatitis
due to malignancy and
metastasis
those don't respond to
diarrhea as well so diuretics like
spironolactone aren't going to be
effective
there we've only got the option to treat
the underlying cause and provide
therapeutic paracentesis
so hopefully you can see how that feeds
back to what i said earlier
that the um
the low sag the raised oncotic pressure
induced societies is much more serious
because well it's much more difficult to
treat
so when it comes to a diagnosis of
ascites it's very important that we
highlight to the patient how important
this diagnosis is and how serious it is
part of that is going to be helping
support the patient with the underlying
issues that may be in a case of say for
example cirrhosis helping them make sure
that they are reducing risk factors to
their liver so for example making sure
they're cutting out alcohol
if it's that we're considering the
ascites due to
malignancy or meta metastatic spread
making sure the patient has access to
appropriate counseling because that can
be a very serious diagnosis
similarly if the patient societies is
due to pancreatitis making sure that
we've highlighted all the potential risk
factors for pancreatitis and helping
modify anything that we can so for
example if they have gallstone
pancreatitis helping them get the
appropriate consultation with the
surgeon to review potentially removing
those stones or perhaps removing the
gallbladder overall
just as a brief recap for that we've got
the mnemonic get smashed when it comes
to pancreatitis so these are potential
causes so we could have gallstones
ethanol
trauma
scorpion venom although i wouldn't
recommend you talking about that in your
finals unless you're very confident to
discuss the particular types such as the
trinidadian scorpion and why that venom
causes pancreatitis
mumps
autoimmune pancreatitis
steroids are three h's that being
hyperparathyroidism
hyperlipidemia
and hypothermia
e for ercp
d for drugs that being
azothiaprine
sodium vaporic acid and potentially
laraglotide
you can also have i if you want to put
at the front of i get smashed for
idiopathic
so hopefully that's been a good overview
of the societies you've got a working
understanding now as to what causes
societies the two different types of
societies and crucially how you'd assess
it
if the video's been useful to yourself
please consider liking the video because
that tells youtube we're here and
subscribe for more clinical skills take
care we'll see you in the next one
[Music]
you