In late 1513, Michelangelo, Raphael and Leonardo da Vinci were all in Rome at the same time. Pope Julius II wanted to restore the Eternal City to its former splendor. What was the relationship between the three great painters? What rivalries existed between them?
Pope Pius commissioned Michelangelo (1475-1564) to decorate the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. The sculptor of ‘David’, who was at the height of his career, accepted this monumental task with reluctance. Behind the scenes, a young, aspiring painter spied on his older colleague and had no qualms about adopting his expressive style. He was not yet 30 years old and called Raphael (1483-1520). The child prodigy worked in the pontiff's public apartments. The death of Julius II and the election of his successor Leo X in February 1513 disrupted the rivalry. Then, a third competitor arrived in the capital: Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519), a close confidant of Giuliano de' Medici, the new Pope's brother. The 61-year-old master enjoyed special privileges that, among other things, made it possible for him to dissect corpses for anatomical research.
There are no sources proving that the three geniuses saw one another during their time in the city, but it’s unlikely that their paths didn’t cross. One thing is certain: the concurrent presence of Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo and Raphael in Rome was the highlight of the Italian High Renaissance.
In 1513, the paths of three brilliant artists crossed in Rome.
Raphael, Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo.
Their presence in the papal city at the same time
marked the high point of a period of exceptional artistic endeavour.
The Renaissance, the Golden Age,
when major papal commissions fuelled intense artistic competition.
Pope Julius II and after him, Leo X,
wanted to leave their mark on the eternal city.
By 1513, the lives and careers of Leonardo, Michelangelo and Raphael were in flux.
Leonardo had achieved everything, but was beginning to feel his age.
The younger Raphael was enjoying a meteoric rise to fame,
while Michelangelo was already an established sculptor.
Although in the prime of his life, his shy nature made him something of an outsider.
Did the three masters exchange ideas?
How did their rivalry shape their work?
And what did they create during this period?
Raphael had just finished one of his masterpieces, The School of Athens.
The fresco perfectly captures the humanist values of the Renaissance.
It also depicts the three greats meeting.
Michelangelo, Leonardo and Raphael.
By late 1512, the name Michelangelo Buonarroti was on everybody's lips.
He was born to a well-to-do Florentine family,
who at first rejected his artistic intentions.
But at 14, he was taken in by Lorenzo the Magnificent.
The Medici ruler recognized the young sculptor's talent
and offered him a place at his art school.
The Pietà, completed in Rome in 1499,
was early proof of his exceptional talent as a sculptor.
His monumental David, unveiled in Florence five years later,
made him famous in courts throughout Europe.
Michelangelo saw himself as a sculptor, not a painter.
He said he'd been born to be a sculptor
and had nurtured his calling since early childhood.
In the contemporary debate about whether painting or sculpture
was the nobler discipline, Michelangelo chose a side early on.
Sculptors considered sculpture to be superior
because it reproduces three-dimensionality.
Painters, on the other hand, saw painting as superior
because it uses colour.
At first, he clearly preferred sculpting to painting
because sculpture starts from stone
and finds its form and idea in it.
This idea comes from Greek philosophy,
which the artists of the Renaissance wanted to build on.
The artist's quest was no longer God,
as it had been in the Middle Ages, but life itself.
This philosophical thesis was first given voice by Plato.
Michelangelo's notes explicitly refer to Plato's theory of ideas.
Of all people, a sculptor obsessed with the idea
of breathing life into stone
was commissioned by Pope Julius II in 1508 to paint a fresco.
Although Michelangelo felt it almost a waste of his time,
he reluctantly accepted.
The project involved nothing less
than the vaulted ceiling of the Sistine Chapel.
The greatest artist of his time made his debut
as a painter here in the Sistine Chapel, in Rome,
with his sensational composition.
As a sculptor, it was a very special experience for him
because he succeeded in drawing the figures
out of the two-dimensional surface of the wall.
They emerge into the space.
He made them three-dimensional, palpable,
and at the same time expressed more strongly
and with more intense colors.
The whole of Rome flocked to the chapel to admire his work.
He achieved superhuman status.
People began to call him the Divine Michelangelo.
He was a great artist,
The Herculean task took him four years.
The artist worked day and night, mostly alone.
Work that left its mark on him.
Michelangelo also depicted himself in drawings
and even in a poem, with his back bent,
his head up, wielding the brush and saying,
Oh God, what am I doing here?
It must have been an incredible physical effort for him.
In a poem, he complained,
My haunches are grinding into my guts.
My buttocks strained to work as a counterweight.
I'm not in the right place.
Michelangelo could not refuse the commission,
as there was merciless artistic competition
for the favor of Julius II.
He was also worried by a new rival,
Raffaello Sanzio.
The young painter had just been commissioned
to design the papal apartments.
Michelangelo distrusted him deeply
and knew that Raffaello was spying on him.
Raffaello was working in the building
right next to the Sistine Chapel,
in the papal apartments.
He once managed to climb the scaffolding
in the Sistine Chapel before the official unveiling.
The fact that Raffaello had snuck this preview
in the artist's absence
made Michelangelo very angry.
Angry, to put it mildly.
Michelangelo was enraged
because the frescoes that Raffaello later painted
in the Chapel of Santa Maria della Pace
were clearly modeled after his style.
Raffaello changed his style considerably
and began to paint like Michelangelo.
His figures show a striking anatomy,
pronounced musculature,
and contorted poses.
At this point,
tensions began brewing between the two.
Michelangelo was irritated
because Raffaello had painted the sybils
in a style very similar to his own.
Michelangelo claimed that Raffaello
had copied everything from him.
He probably wanted to downplay
the younger artist's originality,
but he ended up paying him
the greatest possible compliment.
The talented young painter's success
drew a great deal of envy.
Raffaello was still very young,
barely 26,
when he arrived in Rome in 1508.
Pope Julius II
had assembled a group of high-ranking artists
like Baldassare Peruzzi,
Giovanni Antonio Bazzi,
Pietro Perugino.
But Raffaello outdid them all.
He was given free reign
to change everything
they had already completed.
Within a few months,
the Pope thought so highly of him
that he appointed him
head of the papal building site
for St. Peter's Basilica
and of a team that had to implement
his ideas and drawings.
Raffaello was inundated with commissions.
Besides the rooms in the Vatican Palace,
he also took on the decoration
of the magnificent Villa Farnesina,
owned by Agostino Chigi,
the Pope's powerful banker.
In the 15th century,
the Medici were the Pope's bankers.
In the 16th century,
the Chigi and Farnese families
owned the banks that financed
the Vatican's major projects.
Agostino Chigi
had a magnificent residence
built for himself on the banks of the Tiber.
He wanted it to reflect his social status
and his patronage of the arts,
of which he was very proud.
Agostino Chigi
threw lavish parties in this villa.
It developed into a cultural center,
but at the same time,
into a center of power
where he orchestrated his success.
At Villa Farnesina,
Raffaello was able to display
all his talents.
His creativity was freed
from the confines of the Christian faith.
The logias of Amor, Psyche,
and Triumph of Galatea
bear witness to a turning point in his art,
which was turning ever more decisively
towards the modern.
Raffaello reconciled tradition with modernity,
antiquity with Christian morality.
He combined the strengths
of all the great masters he had admired
and developed a painterly style
that reached an unprecedented level of perfection.
Raffaello also owed his artistic maturity
to his origins.
Unlike Michelangelo,
he grew up in privileged surroundings
and enjoyed a humanist upbringing.
The Duce of Urbino,
in the Marquet region,
was one of the most enlightened
royal courts of the time.
Raffaello's hometown
had been conceived as an ideal city,
an island of the blessed,
far removed from the rest of the world.
Raffaello was the son of Giovanni Santi,
the court poet and painter of Urbino.
So he was born into a courtly environment.
Giovanni Santi let Raffaello work in the studio,
sometimes even using him as a model.
In one of his works,
an angel has Raffaello's face.
He became familiar with everyday life
in a studio at an early age.
At eight years old,
Raffaello lost his mother.
Her death may have inspired
the tenderness characteristic
of all his Madonnas.
Raffaello's early artistic maturity
was impressive
and also explained his meteoric rise in Rome.
Pope Julius II wanted to restore the city
to its former glory
and make it the new capital of the world,
in true Renaissance style, of course.
In the 15th century,
Rome had not yet established itself
as a political and artistic center
to rival Florence or Venice.
It was Julius who laid the foundations
for Rome to become the art capital of Italy.
Entire art schools relocated
from Florence to the Eternal City.
The patronage of Julius II
offered artists many promising opportunities.
It was during this period
that both Michelangelo and Raffaello
arrived in Rome at the request of the Pope,
who wanted to attract the best artists
for his grand project.
Julius II has been called the Warrior Pope.
He saw himself as a successor to Caesar
and as part of the great tradition
of Roman antiquity.
The Pope ordered the demolition
of Constantine's St. Peter's Basilica
to make way for a new building
in the shape of a Greek cross.
The area around the Apostolic Palace,
which had been neglected
since the Pope moved to Avignon,
was also redesigned.
Huge palaces shot up all over the city,
decorated with ancient statues
that had been found during construction work.
The revival of interest
in the art treasures of antiquity
began in the Florentine Renaissance
but reached its peak in Rome,
where these pieces originated.
The Laocoon,
the Belvedere Torso,
the Sleeping Ariadne,
and other works like the Statue of Apollo
came to light again.
They were an inexhaustible source of inspiration
for the artists working there.
Michelangelo and Raffaello
were utterly fascinated by this antique heritage
because it represented an ideal
that had been lost in medieval art.
This ideal would be reborn in all its forms.
Raffaello and Michelangelo
vied in their respective disciplines
to do it justice.
Pope Julius II commissioned two works
that would showcase their respective talents
but pose enormous challenges for both artists.
Raffaello rose to the occasion
with his School of Athens fresco,
painted between 1508 and 1510
in the Stanza della Signatura
in the papal apartments.
He appealed to the Pope's political
and spiritual orientation
by placing him in the painting
alongside the great Greek and Roman scholars.
It was meant to symbolise
the new vision of papal power
and the desire to bridge faith and science.
Julius commissioned Michelangelo
to create a tomb in his honour
even before the sculptor was summoned
to the Sistine Chapel.
The monumental project
comprised 30 gigantic sculptures
all inspired by models from the antique.
Michelangelo considered this his life's work
and was irritated to have to interrupt
the project for four years.
In late 1512
Michelangelo hoped to devote himself
to this task once more
but the death of his patron
Pope Julius II on February 21, 1513
dampened his eagerness.
A conclave was convened
to determine the successor
while artists wondered
if the new Pope would continue
the generous patronage of his predecessor.
The cardinals met amid the tensions
of the Italian wars.
Under Pope Julius della Rovere
the papal states had become a warring power.
His attacks on Venice and France
stoked fears of the worst for Rome.
The della Rovere family
was unable to install
one of their candidates.
Instead, the majority of the cardinals
favoured the challenger
from the rival Medici family.
The candidacy of a cardinal
from the powerful Medici family
was advantageous
in that the papal states
could count on support
from them and the Grand Duchy of Tuscany.
Giovanni de' Medici
was the first son
of the powerful Florentine dynasty
to ascend the papal throne.
For a family of bankers,
patrons and princes
it was the highest honour.
In March 1513
he was named Pope Leo X.
Ensuring the stability of the papacy
was vitally important
so it was helpful
to be able to fall back
on outside forces
that would defend Rome
and the Pope in an emergency.
Michelangelo had already met
the new Pope
during his youth in Florence
when he had worked for his father
Lorenzo the Magnificent.
He had reason to hope
that this would work to his advantage.
Raphael, on the other hand,
owed his position to the deceased Pope
and stood to lose favour under Leo.
The cards had been redealt.
Both Raphael and his mentor
wanted to keep their positions
in the Vatican.
Agostino Chigi
influenced the conclave.
Chigi offered the Cardinal's bribes
to help Giovanni de' Medici win
and thereby gain his trust.
But would his lobbying efforts
be enough to keep Raphael at court
under the new Pope?
No sooner was the conclave over
than a rumour concerning
both Michelangelo and Raphael
started circulating.
The arrival of a third genius in Rome,
Leonardo da Vinci,
could further fuel
their artistic rivalry.
His arrival in Rome was confirmed
in late October 1513.
Leonardo was born in 1452 in Vinci,
a town near Florence.
Despite being stigmatised in his youth
for being an illegitimate child,
he nonetheless made a name for himself.
By 1513, he was well known as an artist
and enjoyed a reputation
that none of his contemporaries
ever achieved.
It was said that no other painter
could reproduce reality so accurately.
Of course, he brought his masterpieces with him.
There weren't many,
but he was still working on
The Virgin and Child with Saint Anne,
Saint John the Baptist,
and The Mona Lisa.
They remained unfinished until his death.
He especially wanted to develop
his sfumato technique,
where several layers of transparent glaze
are applied over each other.
This made the painting
even more vibrant and vital.
His contemporaries claimed
his works were truly alive,
that they had a soul.
At 61 years old,
history's most famous master
was forced to leave the Duchy of Milan
when his French patrons were expelled.
But Leonardo had a network at his disposal,
including the brother of the new Pope,
Giuliano de' Medici.
Leonardo was like a brother
to Giuliano de' Medici.
Thanks to his connection,
he was able to settle in Rome
for nearly three years.
He was fascinating and very interesting.
He knew a great deal about mathematics,
geometry, botany, and bird flight.
Leonardo must have enjoyed interacting
with the other artists
in these wonderful surroundings.
Raphael was working on the stanze,
and Michelangelo had nearly completed
the Sistine Chapel.
Under Pope Leo,
who continued his predecessor's patronage,
Leonardo and Raphael
were in a better position
than Michelangelo
in vying for the pontiff's goodwill.
Their approachable nature
proved an advantage.
Leo X became Pope at 37
and cultivated a luxurious lifestyle.
Renaissance celebrations
were part of the cultural expression of the time.
They lasted for days,
sometimes up to a week.
The Pope usually attended
the festivities for a day.
Leonardo was invited
to these festivities as a guest,
but also helped stage them.
This was part of his role
at the Papal Palace.
The man with the long beard
was also a real joker
who knew how to make people laugh.
He designed costumes,
organized parties,
and always knew how to surprise.
For example,
he made wings for a lizard he had caught
using the skin of other lizards,
transforming it into a miniature dragon.
Raphael, too,
was present at all the festivals,
often accompanied by attractive women
including his lover Margarita Lutti,
a baker's daughter from the Trastevere,
and presumably the model
for his painting La Forna Rina.
The young genius
possessed the necessary sprezzatura
for nonchalance
that according to Baldassare Castiglione
in his Book of the Courtier,
should characterize a nobleman.
Michelangelo's lifestyle,
on the other hand,
was the exact opposite.
In his letters,
he often mentioned
having to live poorly
because Christ had lived poorly.
It seems paradoxical
that Michelangelo lived so austerely
while the cardinals and the pope
were throwing money around.
Michelangelo's lifestyle and seclusion
began to make people uneasy.
Michelangelo irritated Leo X.
Perhaps they were too different in character.
Leo preferred Raphael
because his personality
suited the society of the time.
This gave Raphael better inroads
to papal commissions.
In August 1514,
Leo appointed Raphael
as master builder
of the future St. Peter's Basilica.
Raphael was entrusted with a commission
that Michelangelo may have wanted himself.
Michelangelo preferred to work alone.
This was perhaps one of the reasons
why the pope chose Raphael.
He could fit in well with a group
and lead a team just as well.
It had worked well in the stanzas,
so why not at the building site?
Raphael was quick and prolific,
an unbeatable advantage
in the eyes of Pope Leo,
who soon entrusted him
with an even more prestigious office.
The Medici pope made Raphael
overseer of the Roman antiquities,
responsible for the inventory
and preservation of Rome's
ancient civic heritage.
Raphael's unstoppable rise
fanned Michelangelo's resentment.
He was struggling with great personal
and professional difficulties.
A downward spiral began,
taking with it the tomb project
for Julius II.
After the death of his patron,
Michelangelo threw himself into the work,
even though the new situation
was extremely unfavorable.
The matter of the Julius tomb was difficult.
Leo didn't want to put a giant open tomb
in the new quire.
His predecessor's huge funerary monument
didn't sit well with Leo.
In spring 1513,
Michelangelo signed a new contract
with the family heirs of Julius
for a smaller version of the tomb.
Only one facade instead of four
and far fewer statues.
But the artist was under pressure.
Marble continued to arrive from Carrara,
which he had ordered and paid for
while Julius was on military campaign.
He had to try to recoup the money.
He considered it a terrible failure.
In his letters,
he wrote about the tragedy of the tomb,
not only because he was unable to realize
his original project,
but also because of the way the Pope
and his heirs treated him.
He often wrote to them,
I haven't been paid enough.
In truth, he was very well paid.
It was just that he found
working on this project very stressful.
Creating the tomb proved to be artistic
and emotional martyrdom for the artist,
even more agonizing than the ceiling fresco
in the Sistine Chapel.
In the end,
only his Moses remained in the monument.
The two slaves are now in the Louvre
and four other models are in Florence.
And yet Michelangelo devoted
35 years of his life to this project.
The artist lived in poverty
and was harassed by his father and brothers
who demanded ever more money from him.
Michelangelo never managed to free himself
from these family bonds.
His studio reflects his personality
and his entire lifestyle
focused solely on his work.
Raphael depicted the divine sculptor
in his fresco,
the School of Athens,
as withdrawn and inappropriately dressed
for a Renaissance artist.
He added Michelangelo,
but not in a very flattering way.
He's crouching there in the foreground
in his boots,
not very elegantly dressed.
He looks completely isolated
when you compare him to the others
who are conversing
and hugging and winking at each other.
He obviously tended to be a loner.
Leonardo, meanwhile,
was lodging in the Belvedere
of the Vatican Palace.
The centre of papal power.
He seemed to be staying out of the rivalry
more and more.
But a full-scale feud broke out
between Raphael and Michelangelo
which reached its climax
when the Pope sent Michelangelo to Florence
to help beautify his home city.
Leonardo remained outside the fray
and tirelessly continued his research
assisted by his pupil, Francesco Melzi.
Earning a steady income
was important to Leonardo.
That gave him the freedom
to devote himself
to the projects that interested him.
He was secretive
about some of these projects,
one of which was the dissection of corpses.
The Church had forbidden studying cadavers,
but his anatomical drawings
held such scientific value,
the great Leonardo was allowed to continue.
Still, his work at the Santo Spirito Hospital,
not far from the Vatican,
soon got him into trouble.
A certain Giovanni degli Spechi
apparently rifled through Leonardo's documents,
presumably looking for secret plans,
and then denounced him.
Leonardo then complained
to Giuliano de' Medici
and said he deserved better
and demanded to be left alone.
Leonardo's patron
managed to sweep the matter under the rug,
but tongues continued to wag
and his protected status began to crumble.
The old master likely suffered his first stroke
between 1513 and 1516.
He then retired
and devoted himself
to compiling his manuscripts.
The culmination of decades
of interdisciplinary study.
Just imagine him with his notebooks
trying to order his thoughts
and at the same time
constantly making new observations.
This led to his treatise on painting,
which is kept in the Vatican Library.
His knowledge of an entire lifetime
put down on paper in sketches and notes.
His pupil Francesco Melzi
compiled it into a book after his death.
This is the famous treatise on painting
by master Leonardo da Vinci,
Florentine painter and sculptor.
He separated the book clearly
into theory and practice.
Men in battle, clothing, animals.
The hump in the middle,
meaning the hump on the nose,
the drooping nose.
Here is the position of the arms.
Here with a stick.
Here turning.
These are the bones of the arm
and two figures moving a column.
Both as a writer and a painter,
Leonardo often tended
to leave his works unfinished.
He never considered anything complete
and not one of his words
was published in his lifetime.
His experimental nature
drove him to this eternal incompleteness.
He evolved without pause
and the unfinished was part of his gesture.
During Leonardo,
Michelangelo and Raphael's stay in Rome
between 1513 and 1516,
all three artists had to use
the only bridge that connected the Vatican
with the city centre at the time.
No official sources survived
to confirm that they met in person.
The painter Giorgio Vasari
mentions nothing of the sort
in his biography published in 1550.
He said that the city centre
but although there is no evidence,
it seems inevitable that they met.
They had to have met there in the Vatican.
Rome was small at the time.
They could hardly have avoided
bumping into each other.
Given his solitary nature,
Michelangelo may have tried
to avoid his two rivals
but Raphael and Leonardo
respected each other.
It is entirely conceivable
that the two artists met
in Leonardo's chambers in the Belvedere.
They may have exchanged ideas
about the Mona Lisa, for example,
or Leonardo's most recent creations.
They may even have compared their work.
Leonardo had a virtuoso painting technique
but it was very laborious.
Raphael had a faster brush stroke
that achieved comparable effects
but much more rapidly.
The three brilliant artists met
at least on an artistic level.
In the school of Athens,
Raphael on the far right of the picture
crept into the composition,
securing a place alongside
Michelangelo and Leonardo
in this venerable assembly.
You can see him on the right-hand side
of the painting.
It is a self-portrait of the artist
standing next to Bramante
and surrounded by mathematicians
and astronomers.
This reveals something
about his self-image.
He considered himself on equal stature
with those involved in the liberal arts
which at that time
did not include painting.
Plaster analysis reveals that Raphael
only added Michelangelo later
as he was not originally depicted
in the fresco.
Perhaps a sign that the painter
overcame his rivalry
to honour this unique artist.
Michelangelo's immense creative power
was sometimes problematic
when dealing with other people
face to face.
But it also made him
an extraordinary artist.
The school of Athens
is a hymn to philosophical peace,
the prerequisite for all peace.
But this peace was short-lived.
The golden age of the Renaissance
burned out like a shooting star.
Then the project failed.
After this glorious era
in the early 16th century,
the sky darkened.
Martin Luther,
who was on pilgrimage to Rome
at the time,
was deeply shocked
by the church's extravagant spending.
He initiated the reformation
and the church split,
giving rise to Protestantism.
The Pope and his cardinals
were caught off guard.
In 1516, Leonardo left Rome
and settled in France
at the invitation of François I.
Three years later,
he died in Amboise,
probably as a result of a final stroke.
In 1520, Raphael also died
at the age of just 37,
at the height of fame
within his lifetime.
When Raphael died in 1520,
the Renaissance slowed considerably.
In a way,
it came to a standstill.
The sack of Rome in 1527
dealt a severe blow
to the Eternal City,
its popes,
and all the artists who worked for it.
The massacres committed
by the mercenaries
of Charles V in May of that year
were followed by devastating plagues.
Michelangelo lived on
more than 30 years.
When he returned to Rome in 1541,
after a long stay in Florence,
he completed the Sistine Chapel
with the fresco of the Last Judgment.
He then finally took over
supervising the building site
at St. Peter's Basilica.
He died at 88,
with no descendants,
just like Raphael and Leonardo.
The few years
that the three greatest masters
of the Renaissance
spent in Rome
were like an unprecedented
and ingenious confluence
of three stars
and left an indelible mark
on European art history.