When the CHINESE invented the LONGSWORD: Roaring Dragon Jian from LK Chen REVIEW

Rune Slicer
2 followers
Jun 4, 2025
The Chu two-handed sword (jian) was probably the first steel-bladed 'longsword' that the world had seen and it was closely modeled on bronze examples that had gone before. Here we look at the historically accurate replica, the 'roaring dragon' jian, by LK Chen, with some historical background and cutting tests. Full review by Matt Easton of Schola Gladiatoria.
Hey folks, Matt Eaton here, Scholar Guide Editorial, and I've got a real treat for you today.
We're looking at LK Chen's Roaring Dragon two-handed Jian.
So I guess a lot of you watching this video will have seen my previous video looking at
the Magnificent Chu Jian, which is essentially a one-handed sword, which I reviewed very
highly.
I love it.
A beautiful, beautiful sword.
This is from the same period, so it's a replica of types of sword that are found archaeologically
and in museums and private collections from around 2,200 years ago.
So we're talking about 200 BC.
And it is essentially the big two-handed version of the previous Jian we're looking at from
the Chu kingdom.
And this is a very specialized weapon.
And yes, the real headline here is that the Chinese invented the longsword.
Is this a longsword?
Well, I think to all intents and purposes, yes, it is a longsword.
So let's have a little look at the blade.
The blade, as we saw with the Magnificent Chu Jian, this Roaring Dragon Jian from LK
Chen has the same blade section.
I'll just put the scabbard down for a second.
So you can hopefully see there that it is double fullered, and then coming down to the
edge bevel, nice edge on here.
I'll talk a bit more about the edge, and we will look at some cutting, and we'll look
at the way that this sword tracks and moves in the air as well.
But it is essentially a scaled up, in terms of the blade, it's a scaled up version of
the standard one-handed Chu Jian, which was used with a shield.
This obviously was not used with a shield.
Now you might be thinking, before we go into the specifics of this actual sword, why were
they able to use, or why in this period did they decide to use longswords?
Now it's interesting, because there's a parallel here with medieval European history.
So in the medieval world, when we see longswords, longswords start to appear when armour, plate
armour, starts to reach almost its conclusion in terms of its protectiveness.
And so shields, at least for the knightly classes, shields start to be used less, and
therefore two-handed weapons become more useful, and the two-handed sword, or the longsword,
starts to predominate from about 1360, 1370 in Europe.
But rewind about 1500 years in China, when the longsword was essentially invented, the
steel longsword, and there had been bronze versions as well, and this is modelled on
the bronze swords that went before, with the new technology of new steel blades.
And this longsword was made possible by the fact that the Chinese at this time, particularly
in the Chu-controlled areas, were using essentially plate armour.
They were using a type of armour made of, well, various types in fact, but amongst other
types there was rhino-hide used and all sorts of other things, which meant that they were
very comprehensively armoured and protected, and that to some extent probably enabled the
use of these two-handed swords.
And just like in medieval Europe, these swords became a symbol of, I suppose, prestige and
power as well.
So these started to be carried to some degree by people who weren't wearing armour, particularly
in generals and things like that, perhaps in civilian life, as a kind of badge of office.
Now the proportions of this are quite impressive.
What you're seeing here is it compared to the Albion Ring-Eck.
Now the Albion Ring-Eck is a fairly typically sized European longsword of the 15th century,
and this, as you can see, is a big sword.
This is a longsword, although it's not particularly big in terms of its proportions, as you'll
see, it's actually got a very slender blade, and I'll talk about that in a second as well.
And it is essentially a lengthened version of the one-handed Chu Jian that went before
and at the same time as it, used with a shield, and they simply lengthened it.
Now this blade is a whopping 39 and a half inches long, that is a seriously long blade,
even by medieval Renaissance European standards.
The fact that they were making steel blades 200 years before Christ, so 200 BC, 2200 years
ago they were making steel blades, of these slender proportions and this length, is quite
frankly stunning.
Now some people have questioned what characteristics these blades had, obviously bronze has very
different characteristics and bronze tends to bend and stay bent, steel has the ability
of course to be tempered so that it is a spring, and we know that at least some of the originals
were like this, because some of the originals have actually been tested in private collections
and have been shown to be flexible.
Now this particular blade obviously is made of modern steel but it is pattern-welded,
which is representative of the fact that the original steel blades that were being used
for these were probably of a laminate construction.
These are pattern-welded, I believe between 1065 steel and T8 if I remember correctly,
so it's quite a modern combination of steels, but it does give the look of the original
sort of blades in the terms of you can see the complex structure and grain in the actual
blade itself, and it's not just a mono-steel, you know, basic, shiny, modern kind of flat
blade, and we do see structure in the original blades that have been polished and re-etched,
but additionally it is pretty much exactly the same proportions as the original blades
and therefore, you know, it is this slender type of blade, it is more slender than most
European longswords and it's more akin actually to some sort of, shall we call them sidesword
or slightly later period European blades.
That means it is for its length quite a slim sword, it does also mean therefore, if we
start to look at the characteristics of this actual model, that it is relatively flexible
and bendy, and that does mean that with such a long grip, for example, if I smack the pommel
you can see how much the blade does wibble.
Now we do find this with other sorts of swords, both European and Indian and certain African
swords, where they're relatively narrow and thin for their length, and you have to be
wary of that when you're cutting, which we're going to do a bit of in a minute, you have
to be wary of that with your edge alignment, because they're fairly unforgiving blades,
the advantage is they're light.
Incidentally, just off the cuff you do find a comparable situation with, for example,
Highland Claymores, the two-handed swords used in the Highlands of Scotland, and they're
very often, although they're quite broad, they're quite thin blades and they're quite
flexible.
And these are quite unforgiving in the cut, if your edge alignment is off, you don't have
stiffness in the blade to kind of drag the edge through, it's going to over-accentuate
the fact that your edge alignment is off and it's going to flex and it won't cut.
So these blades are unforgiving in that sense, but they are very light, so as a result of
this slenderness and this relative, although it starts off 7mm here and goes down to about
2.5mm down here, so it has got a good distal taper, but because it is a relatively slender
blade and therefore fairly flexible, it does mean it's light.
So you've got pros and cons there, you've got advantages and disadvantages.
The advantage is that this whole sword, despite its massive size, and if I just put the tip
on the ground, I'm 6'1", if I put the tip about 184cm or something, if I put the tip
on the ground you can see it comes up the centre of my chest, so this is the length
of a long 15th century longsword from Europe.
But despite its size, or length at least, it is only about 1150g, it's remarkably light
for its size.
That being said, it's not ludicrously light, it is heavier than most one-handed swords
for example, as you would expect for its size.
So it doesn't feel shockingly light or it doesn't feel disconcertingly light, it still
feels like it has authority in the blow, whether you hold it with the hands far apart or you
hold them together, it still feels like it packs quite a lot of punch to it, but for
its size it is a very nimble and light sword, and of course part of that as well is because
of the minimalness of the hilt.
Unlike European swords we don't have a heavy pommel, we don't have a heavy guard, we don't
have a complex guard, and it should be stated as well that these hilts are not really designed
with protectiveness in mind, think more along hilts that you'd find on polearms, this is
purely something to hold the blade by, so it's essentially like a short-handled glaive
or something like that.
That guard is really there, although it provides some degree of protection to bashing your
hands on things, particularly shields and stuff like this, it won't provide an awful
lot of protection against other swords, but you have to bear in mind in this period these
swords probably weren't being used that often against others of these swords, they were
predominantly being used against people with spears, people with swords and shields and
stuff like this.
So it's really all about the blade and the hilt is really just there, that's to stop
your hand riding up principally, and the hilt is really there to provide a secure grip
and a way to use it.
Now in terms of the build quality of this specific sword, so moving away from the history
for a minute, and LK Chen yet again have done an outstanding job, it is very finely made,
starting with the materials, we've got bronze used in the pommel cap and the guard, we've
got a pattern-welded blade of good quality steel, heat-treated to about 58 Rockwell,
so it's hard, it's got a fine edge, the fullers are perfectly straight, looking along the
blade it has some rippling, but that's fine, it's nothing drastic, it is straight, there
are no bends, and the edge is perfectly straight and doesn't have any twists or bends in it
like this, so the edges on both sides are good, the fullers as mentioned are perfectly
straight, the ridges are perfectly straight, the edge bevels are perfectly straight, the
point is very nicely formed and very slightly I would say reinforced at the tip which is
always nice, the pattern in the steel is absolutely beautiful, stunning in fact, and the polish
is tasteful, it's not a high polish but it's not a satin polish, it's somewhere in between
the two, it's a very good and I would say quite historical looking polish.
The fit and finish of the blade in the guard is very very good, as you can hopefully see
the aperture cut through the bronze or probably cast and then filed afterwards through the
bronze fits the blade perfectly even though you've got this complex cross-sectional shape
to the blade, the grip is this sort of same type of silk looking, I don't know what the
composition is on wrap, and it's all very tightly done, there's no movement, there's
nothing coming loose, I don't know if there's chagrin underneath this like there is with
the Magnificent Chew, I can't see so I can't comment on that, the pommel is very artistically
cast with the concentric rings, cast in bronze, so slight constructional comments, so I would
say some of the edges on some of the brass fittings, the guard is not too bad actually
but the pommel is a little bit rough around the edge there and I will probably smooth
that with a bit of wet and dry sandpaper or something similar to that, it would be nice
just to see these fittings just polished off a little bit smoother and making them just
a little bit nicer to handle especially with the pommel because the hand might be coming
up around here to do things, I believe Sword Sage mentioned something about bracing this
type of pommel with the palm of the hand, I don't know whether that's historically accurate
but it's plausible and it's something we see in European treatises, if you look at Fiore
de Liberi's longsword section for example you do see him bracing the pommel and we see
it in other treatises as well, Codex Wallerstein and things like this, so it's completely plausible
that the hand was sometimes placed on the butt of there so you want it to be nice smoothed
edged and this is just a little bit rough so I'll smooth that off myself, the grip is
very nice and I like the look of it and I particularly like the fact that it is oval
which aids with edge alignment, great, we only know a certain amount about the original
grips because obviously they're the first things to go archaeologically, we're left
with the blades and the guard pieces but the grip's not so much, and I like the fact that
it's got ridges to stop the hand sliding up and down when you don't want it to, it aids
in the kind of grip, your hands grip on the grip so to speak, on the handle, the only
slight thing that I've noticed cutting with this and the Magnificent Chew since I did
the previous video, is these can be a bit slippery, if your hands are sweaty or if
you're tired, if you've done a lot of cutting, if you've done a lot of forms, you might find
that this very shiny material starts to get a little bit slippery under your grip, now
you could fix that with beeswax and I often use beeswax on leather grips to make them
more grippy for actual fencing, for sparring, that would be a shame to do on this because
the beeswax would potentially mess up what it looks like, it would make the grip look
a bit grubby and messy I think, so a possible constructional criticism might be that the
weave of this cord might want to be done in a way that gives it a little bit more friction
to the grip, so I'm finding it a little bit too slippy at the moment, in terms of the
blade now, this is a complicated bit because I haven't studied many of the original Chew
double-handed, two-handed Jian and we don't have an awful lot of statistics shared online
for them, but my impressions based on handling lots of long swords and lots of large swords
in my life in general, is that I personally would want the blades to be a little bit thicker
at the base, it's currently 7mm, I actually think that it might for a sword of this size
with a 39.5 inch blade, it might be better if it was more about 10mm, now I understand
that would take the weight up, although what you often find with distal taper on historical
swords, and again I don't know if the Chew Jian fit into this, but with a lot of distal
taper on a lot of other, whether it's European, Indian, African swords that I have studied,
is that the distal taper is non-linear, that is it doesn't go from say 7mm to 2.5mm in
a straight gradient, often what you'll find is it starts at maybe 10mm and quite quickly
goes down to about 7mm, and then it only gradually distally tapers for a bit, and then
maybe it suddenly distally tapers in the last 12 inches again, so if you draw it on a graph
it would be something like this, then this, then this, so it's in other words non-linear
distal taper, and certainly in terms of military swords of the 18th and 19th centuries, that
is normal, non-linear distal taper is normal, and linear distal taper is very unusual, so
I would say, and the reason, the important part here, the reason why I would say that
this blade preferentially would be a bit thicker at the base is to add to stiffness, as I mentioned
these types of blades which have quite a lot of movement in them, because they tend to
flex more down here than you necessarily like, they feel a bit wobbly in the hand and a little
bit less stable, and they're less forgiving in the cut. The final constructional comment
I would say, and I do like this sword a lot, but I want this review to be as useful for you
and as useful for LK Chen as possible, is the issue of sharpness again, now this is a very good
edge and I wouldn't want to grab this hard and pull the blade out because it would cut my hand
open, but I can run my fingers along the edge like that without any fear of it cutting, if I
pushed a bit harder and did that I think it might cut, so I would feel that there is just lacking
a little bit of bite to the edge, but I will caveat that this criticism with the fact that
most production swords that I ever see and have ever bought and ever been sent to review,
that is also true of them, it is true of some of the most well-known makers, one example being
Albion, and everybody knows that that's a common criticism I make of Albion swords, is that out of
the box they're not really as sharp as I think they should be, and in this case I think this is
almost the same, this is almost the same criticism, it's similar to Albion sharps,
so in other words it's not blunt, don't go away going Matt Easton says that LK Chen swords are
blunt and they're not, this has got a very nicely formed edge on it, very nice edge geometry and
very fine at the edge, but it's just lacking that final bit of bite that I would like to see of a
sword for cutting purposes, and therefore I will use my DC4 stone, my Falconeven DC4 which is what
I swear by and sharpen everything with, that I will use that on this and the Magnificent Chu Jian
that I reviewed before, however for the purposes of this review and for purposes of this cutting
I decided this time I'm not going to sharpen it up, I'm going to try and cut with it as it is,
as it is out of the box, because for you watching if you buy one of these, and if you're tempted
buy one you won't be disappointed, these are really nice swords, if you buy one of these
then I don't, I want you to have an accurate representation in this video of what this will
do to water bottles which I'm what I'm using here. Right, final thing I'm going to say before I go
into some cutting and that is quite simply that I don't have access to tatami mats at the moment
and I don't have access to green bamboo, so I am going to be cutting water bottles which are a very
specific type of target and different swords like or dislike different types of targets, there are
some swords which cut well on all targets, katanas cut well on most targets, but there are certain
types of swords which do very well on x but don't do very well on y. Water bottles are a very specific
thing, they are actually quite hard on the outer side but obviously have no structure on their
inside it's just water, the water is just the mass to keep them where they are, so it is what it is,
this is just cutting water bottles but it is a measure by which at least some of you will be
familiar and you're able to replicate if you have a sharp sword, anybody can get hold of plastic
water bottles and cut them quite easily and almost for free. Okay so let's have a little look at how
hit the wood there on one of those cuts but no damage done. Right so cutting is done, what are my
thoughts? Well actually there's a few interesting things that came out of that, first of all my
slight criticism of the edges of some of the bronze work on the hilt stand true and are emphasised I
think by that experience, they need to be smoothed just a little bit, they're a little bit rough
against the hand, I didn't do any damage to my hands but I could feel that perhaps with a lot
of cutting and certainly if I was fighting with this, if I wasn't wearing gloves I think those
would start to chafe on my hands a little bit, funnily enough not so much the pommel as I mentioned
before but more the guard. In terms of the grip, I did once my back hand did slip off the
grip so the slippiness of the grip I think is a slight issue but it was only an issue with one cut
not with the others, interestingly when I hit the cutting stand or the wood one time I hit right
with the tip up here, obviously it didn't do any damage to the sword at all but I did feel quite a
lot of shock in the hand but I think you would with any sword frankly hitting with the tip on a
massive great log like that, those are quite heavy those logs, so to be honest I think that performed
quite well considering it hit a large chunk of wood. In terms of the edge sharpness, I would
stand by what I said previously, I have to say actually this sword cut better than I expected it
to, partly to do with tip speed because having such a long grip and a long blade you've got a
amount of acceleration but I feel that it would perform even better and more effortlessly if it
had a slightly sharper blade on it. The edge geometry is fantastic but this edge does require
a little bit of attention, fine polishing and honing with a stone, wet stone or dc4 or whatever
in order to really bring it up to what I would class as top level cutting. In terms of the
wobbliness of the blade, funnily enough I didn't find it an issue cutting this target,
it might be a different issue if you're maybe cutting bamboo or tatami mat, I don't know.
My experience incidentally with tatami mats is that edge sharpness is less important with tatami
mats than it is with water bottles, with water bottles if your sword's blunt you often just
can't get through them, not with a clean cut obviously, whereas with tatami mat you can put
really almost a semi-sharp sword through a tatami mat if your edge alignment is good. So different
targets test different things as well as they test the person in different ways, they test the sword
in different ways. So this performed very very well, I did have issues with the upwards cuts
and with the zwerchhau type cut, the zwerchhau type cut is not something I do very much so that's
partly to do probably with user error shall we say, let's put it let's be charitable and say
it's my fault. The upwards cuts I don't know, I'm usually quite good at upwards cuts with long swords
I can't really say why I wasn't working well with this, I would put it down partially to sharpness
and I do think as I say look I can run my hand along the edge there, the fact that I can do that
shows that this isn't a really really sharp blade, sharp enough to do water bottles so if you get one
of these out of the box with this level of sharpness you will be able to cut water bottles
but it's not really as sharp as you would like it to be and you will be able to make more difficult
cuts and cuts more easily and with smaller movements if the blade is sharper. In terms of
how it stood up, nothing happened to the edges, there's no you know chipping or curling
or anything like that but you wouldn't expect that with water bottles alone, everything's perfectly
straight and true, there's no bends even though it hit the cutting stand at one point,
it's all in great condition, there's no there's no rattles, nothing's come loose inside, I must say
I do know that LK Chen use I believe epoxy inside their hilts so I suspect all of this is glued on
as well as being riveted through the kind of bits that go up the side of the pommel and that kind of
stuff so it's a solid construction traditional but I think they've put epoxy in there to just
keep everything together as well which I don't have an issue with actually at all and most
modern or a lot of modern sword makers do that so everything's solid and tight nothing to criticize
very briefly we're going to have a look at the scabbard before I sort of wrap things up now a
lot of what I said about the scabbards for the Magnificent Chu will stand for this because it's
the same scabbard just made bigger for the bigger sword it's got the same kind of shape at the end
it's got it's made of the same kind of wood of a nice thin diamond flattened diamond section
shape it's very nicely shaped I wish I could have all my scabbards for all my swords made this well
it's got the bronze fitting that I showed in the previous video that wears on this
side I won't put this because it's got a wet blade I won't put this in there
but obviously when you wear these big two-handed ones they do stick out somewhat more than the
one-handed ones and then it changes cross-sectional shape of sort of for the bottom third of the
scabbard and I will say once again these are modeled on originals this isn't one of so LK
Chen do at least three swords which are modeled one for one exactly modeled on one surviving
original this isn't one of those this is an amalgam it's a sort of an average modeled on
several surviving examples as the Magnificent Chu is as well but there are a lot of these
surviving well relatively speaking and this is really modeled closely on those original ones
there is there are even scabbards surviving obviously not in as good condition as this
but this is what that's what these are modeled on these are middle modeled on original swords
so really once again fantastic work from LK Chen I'm super super impressed I will be using
this for cutting lots more no doubt I love the pattern in the steel their blades I mean not to
say anything bad about their hilts because their hilts are good but their blades are absolutely
superlative really really beautiful and my only possible criticism of this particularly long type
of Jian and I don't know how this measures up against the originals because I haven't studied
them firsthand because they're in China and haven't been there is I am not certain that this
is thick enough at the base of the blade compared to what I suspect the originals are I suspect the
originals are thicker than seven millimeters at the base of the blade but I might be wrong
and as the cutting showed it doesn't need to be thicker in order to still be a very effective
weapon it's just that I'm used to weapons feeling a little bit stiffer in the hand than this does
but the advantage is that this is lighter therefore and quicker and it is a very quick and
nimble sword another beautiful product the roaring dragon Jian two-handed Jian from LK Chen
thanks for watching give us a like and a subscribe please and you can see other reviews in my review
playlist I've got a bunch of playlists I've got one on Chinese weapons now now that I'm looking at
these more so have a look at my playlists as well have a look at LK Chen's website obviously
the links are all below to this sword and I can only speak very very highly of what LK Chen is
achieving over there in China at the moment well done and I will see you really again for another
video on scholar gladiatorial channel cheers folks thanks for watching we've got extra videos on
patreon please give our facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
