KLEIN vs KOMELON - Whose Best At Multitasking (2-in-1) - Scraper _ Utility Knife Combos

Tools plus
2 followers
Do you like utility knives? Ok, now do you like utility blade scrapers? If so then would you be interested in a tool that incorporates both functions in 1? If that sounds like you then this video dives into the details of how each of these function and if they are worth the consideration.
#machine #tools #powertools
We got a video here today of something a little interesting. I've seen these in the marketplace
just for a short time and I like what they've done here. Now there's been other manufacturers
who have accomplished this, but this is the first time I've seen Klein go ahead and they call it a
flick blade utility knife and scraper on one. And basically what you get here is a regular utility
knife on one end, but then you also get a scraper blade action on the other end. And Camelon's got
one as well. This is their version, but it has a rotating head. And well, let's take a look at it.
We're going to jump into this video, take a look at the differences between these. We'll go through
them one by one and then we'll kind of show you a little bit of in use practice of why it might
be advantageous to have either one or maybe one over the other, because they both implement a
different style of making the scraper function work along with utility. All right, let's take
a look at it. This is their UDS-N6 folding knife and scraper. As you can see here in this
illustration, the idea is in one position you have the folding knife and then the other position you
have the scraper. So you don't have to switch around from side to side. It's all on the same
end. They have a safety lock button here on the side as well. Adjustable locking position. Looks
like you lock it at 90 and 45 as well as a full 180 degrees. And then it has some blade storage.
We'll check that out. Overall length from head to tail is going to be 19 millimeters and they
do offer three extra blades. Here's how the rotation works between the two positions,
utility and the scraper. We'll go through this and then you're able to remove and replace the
blade with this thumb action. We'll take a look at that as well. And then here's the storage.
Now Camelon, this was made in China and I believe Camelon's always been a Korean company,
they've been traded several times. But a lot of you guys have seen this name a lot over the years
and Camelon has a pretty good reputation. So I'm looking forward to see how this looks.
All right, so we have it here in hand. She's a little bit beefy for sure.
Just have a pocket clip, folds with the blade down. So a thumb lock here. It does a lot of
when you flick it. So it feels much like the Milwaukee's, although there's just much more
weight on the end of that as it flicks open. And you can also lock it as it goes into that 45
degree and in that 90 degree. So this should be nice. Maybe you're doing some drywall cutting
and you just want to go in there and cut at it. That might be nice. And then 45, I think this
would be advantageous for you guys that maybe do some carpet work, right? Or maybe some tile work
too. If you're going in and you need to cut and hold and pull at an angle, that would work out
actually quite nice. Now the body is going to be, it feels like a cast aluminum in there.
Look there, you can see your detents for all three positions. So they're full detents
as you lock them in. This is going to be plastic. The yellow piece here kind of feels like ABS.
We'll go ahead and close, let you guys see what it is closed. A little bulky on the tail end here.
So a little squeeze there allows you to open that up, look inside,
and there are going to be some blades. I don't know, these are interesting. These
have some cutouts here. I wonder if these are going to be special only to come along.
So those might be proprietary guys. We'll double check. We'll find out as we pop it open.
But yeah, you can store the blade inside there. All right, let's crack this open again.
Now this function, I think, is what allows you to rotate it. Yes, you take it and you rotate
it with your finger to get to the position that you like. Now the head has a little bit of wobble
in it, but that's actually nice. I mean, it's not too bad as far as the wobble. The idea of it is
nice because you can take it and start scraping on whatever it is you need to scrape.
Ideally wood's not the thing that you're going to use it on. I think for scraping,
each industry is going to do its own. For me, I tend to use scrapers a lot for
head gaskets, head gasket cleaning, removal, even other gaskets as well. But head gaskets,
this is a great way to do it. Scrape this way, or say on your windows, if you're cleaning off
anything that might have spilled, overspray, or if you've got window tint you're trying to take
off, this works as well to scrape up underneath. It's not a bad design. I actually kind of like it.
It's not super, it doesn't scream quality per se. Let's check out the blade. I think you push
this side. Ah yes, it comes out. So I'm betting this is a proprietary blade.
Let's just try this guy inside here and see if he holds together or not. No, he won't. And that
makes sense too because I think it needs this to hold it in place from falling out. Yeah,
it needs it to hold it in, otherwise it just falls out the front. And I get that because
there's nothing on the front side of the blade giving it any retention. It has to use that system.
Not bad, really easy to switch between the two. And it stays together nice. Let's do overall
width on it for you guys. So frame overall up here is 17.75. And then if you wonder how wide
this gets to, 9.27 there. And then the width down here is 4.8 millimeters. 28.5, that measurement,
and 36.11. So definitely a little bit on the bulky side. But I mean, if you're a tradesman,
this is actually not that bad for bulky. I think this would be perfectly fine. I'll let this stick
up a little bit right there. Although once it's locked, it stays locked. This isn't going to open
up. So the push button lock is nice. It's fancy. It's quick and easy. I like it. I think it's a
good setup. And pricing for this one is, I'll give you guys a link to Amazon down below. But it's
$20, or sub $20. I think it's like 19 bucks. So good price. And yeah, I think it's priced
attractively well for that price point. Almost a deep carry. But yeah, nice long and decent spring
to it. All right, next up, we'll check out our Klein tools. And we'll run through here to let
you guys read it real quick. Part number is 44306 is their flick blade utility knife scraper with
blade storage. So it's a two in one, and they go 180 to 135 degrees. So it doesn't have the 90.
So it's got three blades included, much the same as the come along. That's your scraper side on
there. Carbon, high carbon blades. That's good, I guess. Quick release button. We'll check that
out. Smooth open and close out action. We'll check that out as well. Storage compartment that pulls
out, which is nice, a little convenient. And durable cast aluminum, so much the same as that
cast aluminum. It's got a little safety cover for the two in one. And again, made in China.
So let's get this open. All right, guys, here she is. Nice little orange paint to this cast
aluminum. The head here looks much like a lot of the traditional fastback. That's very smooth,
even smoother than the come along. Doesn't smack anything when it goes down in there.
So you have your little paracord or seatbelt cutter position there. Blade out the front.
So there's a stamped steel retention on the side here. Push button, I believe, release.
Yeah, so that's a standard utility blade out the front. So that's nice. You can still use
your standard blade. Now this should be, this is all plastic here, this should be your extra blade
retention. There's your second blade, I think it'll hold two. And it definitely has a magnet
in there. Oh, there it is. There's a magnet that holds the blades. Magnetic retention holds it in.
We'll try this guy inside there. You only carry one extra blade. So one extra blade,
which is probably fine for most people. We'll go ahead and close this back up. Close is really
nice. Does it stay locked? Yes, the push button stays locked when it's closed. Here's the cover.
This is, I believe, to allow the safety for the rotation of this. Oh wow, that comes right out.
It's a very quick, it's a very quick function. Hey, don't get your finger in the middle of that.
That'll mess you up. And then when you close that, that looks like it locks it
in place so it can't go back. Okay. And when it's out, you can see it's a little bit offset,
not perfectly straight on. Yeah, don't use with both blades open. I think that's a safe bet.
Don't use it with both blades open. I feel like they put the part number on the side here
in case you ever have any issues down the line. But yeah, that holds just fine on the end. I want
to see if these are proprietary blade. I have a feeling that they don't. And if that's the truth,
then that's a really good advantage that you're going to get. Oh, perfect. Standard blades on
this one. So it uses the frame to hold it in place via this compression fitting.
So no easy quick release, but it will, it will tightly hold your blade inside there
via this compression fitting. And then it just mounts back into that housing.
So that is a good trick set up there. Now in the closed position, overall length is going to come
in about 13 centimeters head to tail. So short, let's see, we can put them side by side so you
guys could see. Closed, the Klein is going to be longer, substantially longer. Because the come
along closed is going to be 11 and a half centimeters in length. And then open, we already
know this one's going to be 19 millimeters. And then opened this way on this one as well,
just over 19 millimeters, 19.2, 19.2 millimeters in overall length this way. You open up even
further, it'd be more, but you're not supposed to have both open at the same time. So I won't
measure it fully open that way. Overall weight, the come along is heavier. Let's go ahead and
weigh them. 186 grams versus 172 grams. So definitely more, more metal to this one,
as opposed to the Klein. Now you may have a preference of how heavy this is in your pockets,
or maybe you wanted the extra weight, but for being smaller, this is definitely a denser tool.
Now I wanted to show you guys this real quick, kind of what I typically use this stuff for.
So let's say you have the back of something, say it's a decal like this.
These work great because you can evenly clean off the surface. This one doesn't have the best
approach to it. This would be the better side, I think. You see how I just kind of clean that
all off at one swipe? Gives you a nice clean and uniform, just a nice uniform cut across whatever
you're working on. Sometimes even until you have a little bit of sticker residue left on something.
When I get it in one shot, I don't have to do a ton of work. Using this will
typically make quick work of that. So it works great for that. And then what I typically want
to use it for is going to be head gaskets. Now this will usually be on the block or on
the head side. This is just for demonstration purposes. But you'll run this along here,
like if, say if it's on the head of your engine, you just slowly scrape off all those high spots
where say gasket material or say maybe you got a little bit of rust there.
This is the best way to remove gasket material without adding additional debris to your engine.
Especially if you're just doing a head gasket job, you're not tearing apart the lower part.
These work great. There's all different types of scraper like this, but this is a great one.
And I wanted something that was easy to carry and throw in my toolbox or throw in my bag.
And this, this fits the bill. Either one of these, these both will do it.
I think it just comes down to price wise. Well, before we hit price, let's just do a
quick measurement on this one too. So we could see what the overall dimensions are.
Okay. So overall depth, 38.34. That's how deep that's going to be or how wide. And then
overall thickness, we're coming at 19.19.
So still even thicker. I guess this is a little bit thicker on this far side of the handle.
So we're pretty close in thickness. And then overall head, this keeps it nice and thin,
4.96 all the way through. As you remember to come along, it's a little bit fatter because
it has that rotating bit here on the end. So it gets up to nine, almost 10 millimeters on
thickness there. 28 on that overall. Now this one doesn't have a pocket clip. I'll say that's
one downside to it. If you want to be able to carry this on you, you're going to throw this
in your pocket and carry it that way. There's no real easy way to throw one on here either.
Maybe you can get a little lucky and put something there, but yeah, that is a misstep. I think on
Klein's part, you cannot carry this in your pocket on a belt or on your pocket itself. It has to go
in. Whereas Come Along nailed it with the clip on the side. It's a super easy. It has more positions,
but the only downside to this Come Along is the proprietary blades that have to go with it.
So that's going to be my only gripe with Come Along. It's heavier, you get more for your money.
They're both going to come in at $19. $19 and some change roughly. So great prices on both.
I do, this one feels a little bit better in the hand. It feels just a little bit better quality
control too, but I wish I had a clip on the side and I do wish this was a little bit shorter,
but you know, this is your hand. I mean, you're going to get a good amount of grip on this.
It's not terrible. It is a little offset too with the blade. I wish it was a little bit straighter
like this one. This one does a good job keeping it centered. So as you're working with it,
you can put pressure on the back to scrape. Whereas this one's going to be just a little bit
off canter. It is a little bit more flatter too. So you probably get a little bit better.
I mean, if you have to whack that, if you do like a rubber mallet, you could as well.
So I think, oh, it's tough guys. They're both going to do a good job of what you need them
to do. It's just going to come down to preference of what style you need or what extra attribute
you need more, more compact, more bulky, better blade situation you're stuck with come along.
Or maybe there's several that make that. I did notice that this kind of seems to be like a
generic style. I've seen several other manufacturers or that I've never heard of
out of China that make this as well. So you could probably use one of their blades as well,
but I don't know how good their blades are. If you have a flavor of blade that you like the most,
then you're not going to be able to use it in this because it's just not set up for it.
So you're stuck with their blades. And where's this one? You get to get what you want.
You can put it in there. So definitely advantageous for Klein. So I'd love to hear
your guys' thoughts. Is there something else, one of these I've missed, or is this something
you guys would use? Tell me what application you guys think it worked best in. I'd love to hear it.
Because these utility blade tools are becoming pretty dang popular, and I totally get why.
They're nice. They do a lot in a small package. So tell me your guys' thoughts down below.
Would you guys pick up one? Alright guys, thanks for watching. We'll talk to you soon.
