Gothic Ivories: A ‘Greatest Hits’ of Medieval Myths on a Casket

Antique Collection
23 followers
Jun 3, 2025
Last time, curator Naomi Speakman explored the meaning and myths behind medieval bestiaries. Before that, she revealed the symbolism found in medieval jewels and jewelry.
In this episode, Naomi turns her attention to the intricately carved Gothic ivory caskets that once held those very manuscripts and treasures. These ornate boxes are more than decorative containers—they’re rich with stories, legends, and layered symbolism from the medieval imagination.
While some characters may be unfamiliar, a few well-known names make surprising appearances—including Aristotle, in a scene you’re unlikely to forget.
CONTENT WARNING:
Aristotle will, at one point, be saddled and ridden like a horse.
Hi, I'm Naomi Speakman, Curator of Late Medieval Europe and welcome to my corner.
Today we are going to explore some playful objects from the collection.
These two caskets were designed to entertain and they epitomise the medieval art of storytelling.
Something we can't do obviously in the galleries is turn objects around and look at them on all
their sides but that's exactly what these caskets invite us to do. They're made of elephant ivory
which was a particularly popular material for luxury carvings in medieval Europe from the 13th
to the 15th centuries. Over 5,000 carvings in this material survive today and we know them as
gothic ivories. Paris was one of the centres, if not the major centre, for carving in this material.
Those workshops flourished during the late 1200s and the 1300s. A whole host of objects were made
in this material from statuettes of the Virgin and Child to multi-panelled plaques decorated
with religious scenes to more secular objects such as mirror cases and combs. Many were and
are very detailed such as these two caskets and these both draw their imagery from contemporary
literature. What did they actually hold? Well we don't know for certain. Some people say jewellery.
For the larger ones it's also been argued that they may have held documents.
What were they given for? Well it's also been argued that they were perhaps love gifts or
to mark a marriage. Of the caskets that survive the largest number are known as composite caskets
and they're like the one I have here and they show a range of different scenes. This one measures
about 21 centimetres in width and it dates from the second quarter of the 14th century.
By that I mean from about 1325 to 1350. Let's start on the lid where a lot of activity is taking place.
At the centre two knights are in the middle of a joust. You can see they are sitting on their
horses. They are fully armoured, their male shirts are visible, they have their leg guards on and their
horses are thundering towards each other. They are mere millimetres away from impact. Both are holding
their lances aloft and the tips of them are about to strike both knights helmets. These knights also
have crests on top of their helmets. For the one on the left there's a very distinct bird and for
the one on the right there's either a fanned plant or a coxcomb. This central image presents us
with the idea of a cacophony of sound and it's quite easy to see why. The horses are galloping
on uneven ground. There are two quite precariously placed heralds seated in the trees and they are
blowing their trumpets. Above there is a balcony and there are six people standing on it. Their
gestures and the way that their bodies move show us that they are all talking animatedly.
Perhaps they're even debating about whose knight is going to win. On the edges of this scene
something else is taking place. One knight is loading up a crossbow, another is filling up and
preparing a catapult. On the other side a knight kneels before a lady holding a large key and
another knight is climbing this almost twisted rope-like ladder. But look again and everything
is not as it seems. That knight with the crossbow is not about to shoot an arrow but a bunch of
flowers. The catapult is about to send a basket of roses flying through the air and the people all
at the top are holding missiles and they're not about to throw stones down on their attackers
but they also are holding flowers and in this top corner there's a curious figure who is crowned,
he's winged and he's holding a bow and arrow. So what's going on here? Well this is a scene known
as the assault or the attack on the castle of love. This was a chivalric allegory which was
very popular at the time and it was meant to be humorous. So here knights are storming the castle
of romance. Moving down onto the front of the casket there are two different stories shown in
four scenes. We begin on the left and the characters here have some names that might
be familiar to you. Aristotle that great classical scholar, Alexander the Great and Alexander's love
who in the medieval stories is known as Phyllis. It begins in this panel on the end. Aristotle is
seated in front of his crowned pupil and he's telling Alexander to focus on his studies and
not be distracted by women because Alexander is besotted with Phyllis. But Phyllis decides to get
her own back and that's what happens in the second scene. Aristotle sees her and is overcome
with lust so she convinces him to let her put a horse's saddle and a bridle on him and to ride him
and that's what's happening. Here Aristotle is on all fours and you can clearly see that he's
wearing reins. Phyllis is sitting on his back and you can just make out underneath the lock that
she's also holding a whip in her other hand. Looking on is Alexander the Great and he is this
little head peeping out of the tower. Here he sees that his great tutor has completely humiliated
himself. There are lots of different themes at play here. Age versus youth, hypocrisy, the world
turned upside down and quite simply a venerable scholar made to look ridiculous. That theme of
age continues on the rest of the front of the casket. The other tale is that of the fountain
of youth. Here a queue of elderly people are lining up and they're eager to get into the
curative waters of the fountain. At the end of the casket we see several bathing youths
rejuvenated and they're sitting in the waters and the fountain almost looks like a hamburger.
Moving to the side this panel shows two different stories alongside each other. On the left is the
tragic love story of Tristan and Isolde. You might be familiar with it but if you're not I'll tell
you briefly. Tristan was a knight in the court of King Mark of Cornwall and Isolde was the Irish
princess who married Mark. The two strike up an idolatrous relationship. What's taking place here
is in a wood. You can see that with the tree. Tristan and Isolde are talking but they're watched
over by Mark. He's spying down on them from the top of the tree. You can make out his face at the top.
Conveniently they are seated in front of this pool of water so they see Mark's reflection
and because of that they talk innocently so as to convince Mark that there is nothing untoward
going on. One of my favourite things about this object is the way that Mark's reflection is
depicted because his head is shown as if it's literally coming out of the water in 3D. On the
other side of this panel is the death of the unicorn. As medieval texts tell us the only person
who can capture a unicorn is a virgin maiden because she's the only person who is pure enough
and a unicorn will lie down in her lap. Here that's just what's happening. The unicorn is
lying down in the maiden's lap and it has been killed by a man who is standing and stabbing it
with a spear. For the medieval viewer they would also have understood the sexual connotations of
this allegory. The rest of the panels all tell stories of knights from Arthurian legends.
These are the knights of the round table from King Arthur's court and various knights are shown here
performing different elements of their stories. We begin on the left with Gawain and he's fighting
a lion. The next scene shows Lancelot. He's crawling on all fours across this gigantic sword
which is a bridge and he's walking over the rushing water which you can see rippling beneath him.
Above swords and spears rain down on him. As the story tells us Lancelot crawled very carefully
along this perilous bridge trusting himself to God as he went. In the next scene we have Gawain
again. He's fully armed even though he's asleep on this bed. Again he is lying underneath a hail
of swords and spears and in fact that element comes from Gawain's story not from Lancelot's.
Gawain is lying on quite an unusual bed. At the bottom of it are bells and it's also on wheels.
On Gawain's shield is a lion's paw and quite a sad looking lion is also watching this scene.
In Gawain's story he is in an enchanted castle and as he is told no one who spends the night
on this bed has ever survived to tell the tale. Well during the night the arrows fall down on
Gawain and he is attacked by a lion but he fights back and survives the ordeal. He's watched on at
the end of the panel by the women of this enchanted castle. This final panel is the story
of Galahad. He's famous for his quest to find the holy grail. Galahad has clearly just arrived
because his horse is tethered to the tree. He's standing before an older man who hands him a key.
This key represents the key to the castle of maidens and as Galahad's story tells us on
receiving this key he rescues the women trapped in the castle. You might be wondering why this
casket has so much going on and shows so many different stories. Well they might seem obscure
or difficult for us to understand but actually these were some of the most popular stories for
medieval audiences. So you can think of this casket as containing some of the big hitters
from contemporary literature. Well that's quite a lot of information so I think I'll save the other
casket for the next episode. Join me next week.
