Cinematography Style: Néstor Almendros

Filmmaking Techniques
4 followers
Although cinematographer Nestor Almendras did most of his work in France, often for
groundbreaking French New Wave directors like Eric Romer and François Truffaut, he is probably
best known for his collaborations with Hollywood directors on some iconic movies in the 70s
and 80s.
Directors were often drawn to his pioneering way of working with natural light, his taste
for cinematic simplicity and a focus on providing them with his creative insights beyond just
his technical expertise.
In this episode let's break down how his thoughts and philosophies on cinematography
influenced his photographic style and also take a look at some of the gear and techniques
that he used to pull off some breathtaking images.
This video is sponsored by Squarespace, the only platform you need to create and manage
your website.
Many of the filmmaking techniques that Almendras would later use on larger feature productions
were actually gleaned in his earliest explorations into cinematography.
Three of these concepts, which appear as threads throughout his filmography, are his knowledge
of movies, his focus on natural lighting and his push for cinematic simplicity.
He developed an early love for cinema, so much so that he eventually became a bit of
a cinephile and started writing movie reviews.
He cites this as one of the best educational resources for DPs, claiming that the technical
side of photography can always be learnt or executed by film technicians and crew that
you work with, but having a solid foundation and understanding of what films came before
and what the current trends are in cinema and photography are incredibly important.
In his early years he wanted to be a director.
This made having a perspective on the narrative a must.
It's the job of the cinematographer to be sensitive to the needs of the story and have
the necessary cultural background to draw from.
An example of a movie that he was influenced by was the early Italian neo-realist film
La Terra Trema, shot by cinematographer G.R.
Aldo.
He was blown away by how Aldo used naturalistic lighting in a way that was very different
from the other much more stylized and over-lit movies of the time, which blasted hard frontal
key light at actors.
Instead of shooting on sets in film studios and shining hard spot-lit key light, fill
light and back light at actors as was the norm, many of these Italian neo-realist films
used available naturalistic light in real locations, which may be hard with unflattering
shadows under direct sun, a soft gentle feel under cloudy conditions, or use the last remnants
of dusk light remaining in the sky after sunset.
His appreciation for naturalistic light may also have been influenced by his filmmaking
originating and shooting documentaries in Cuba, where he could only work with a camera
and available light as there was not enough budget to hire lights or a team of electricians.
To overcome the low levels of light inside some of the houses they would shoot in, they
came up with the idea of using mirrors to bounce the sunlight that was outside into
the house through windows, then bouncing it off the ceiling.
This technique of softening light by bouncing it became important later, but so too did
the function of mimicking the direction of the natural sunlight by angling it through
windows and increasing its strength.
In other words, taking an existing source of natural light and strengthening it by artificial
means.
Elmendras inspired a major transition in thinking about lighting.
Rather than being bound to film school concepts like three point lighting, he instead wanted
the lighting in his films, even when using artificial film lights, to be motivated by
what the natural light sources like the sun does in real life.
He talks about this in his autobiography.
When it comes to lighting, one of my basic principles is that the light sources must
be justified.
I believe that what is functional is beautiful.
That functional light is beautiful light.
I try to make sure that my light is logical rather than aesthetic.
Another aspect to Elmendras' work is an appreciation for simplicity, both in practical,
technical terms as well as aesthetic terms.
Again, this may perhaps have evolved from the beginnings of his career in documentary
and on low budget films, where he became accustomed to making do with a lack of resources.
A great example of his economical way of working was on his first narrative feature, La Collectionneuse,
which he shot for French New Wave director Eric Romer.
Because of an extremely limited budget, they were faced with a choice early on, either
shoot in the less expensive 16mm, or shoot extremely economically on 35mm.
They went with 35mm.
A shooting ratio refers to how much footage was shot in relation to the length of the
finished movie.
So if 20 hours of footage was shot to complete a 2 hour movie, then the production had a
shooting ratio of 10 to 1.
La Collectionneuse had an insanely low shooting ratio of 1.5 to 1.
This meant that they shot only one take for most shots.
Working in such an economical way has a few advantages.
It forces directors to think about exactly what they want and have a refined vision.
As Elmendras says, the problem is that when there are many options, there's a tendency
to use them all.
Even later on in his career when he was working with larger budgets on Hollywood productions,
he always gravitated to finding the simplest method, using the tools that would most easily
produce an image with functional, realistic light that told the story.
For example, not using a big truck full of lights and a large team of electricians if
he could get a more authentic image from only using natural light.
Visually, many of the films he shot also have a certain stylistic simplicity to them.
Although of course it depended on which director he worked with, he often shot quite deliberately
composed static frames without many dynamic camera moves.
This was especially true when working with Romare who liked shooting stationary frames
from a tripod head.
So, Elmendras can be characterised by his cinematic knowledge, naturalistic lighting
and simplicity.
But how did he translate that over with the techniques and gear that he used?
Before we get there I'd like to thank Squarespace for sponsoring this video.
Squarespace is the platform I use to create and run my websites, whether that's for this
channel or my own personal cinematography site.
The reason I use Squarespace is because it's intuitive, easy to set up and guides you into
making beautiful modern design choices through their range of customisable templates that
you can easily tweak and add your own content to.
A tool I find useful are their galleries, which can host your photo or video content
to show your clients or collaborators what you can do.
All of these files can be uploaded through their asset library, which makes managing
your content a walk in the park.
Head to squarespace.com for a free trial and when you're ready to launch go to squarespace.com
slash indepthcine to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
Nowadays the default for most cinematographers is to base their placement of lights and quality
of illumination on the real life sources that exist in the location.
As I mentioned before, that wasn't always the case.
The prior standard was that actors should always be well illuminated in clear strong
pockets of light, which were usually placed in front of the talent from above and shined
directly at them.
This clearly illuminates the face without shadow, however isn't what light does in real
life.
Compare this shot of how actors used to be lit when placed next to a window, to how Almendros
did it in Days of Heaven.
There are two big takeaways.
Firstly, Almendros places the light source outside the window shining in, mimicking the
direction that the sun would in real life.
While the other shot keys the actor with a high frontal source of light that doesn't
make sense in the real world.
Secondly, the quality of the light is different.
Almendros uses a much more diffused light that is far softer with a natural gentle transition
from shadow to brightness.
While the other example has a very clear, crisp shadow caused by very strong undiffused
artificial light.
A technique he often used to get this soft quality of light when shooting interiors was
to bounce lights, often from outside a window, into the ceiling.
This reflected the source around the room, decreasing the intensity of the light but
lifting the overall ambience in the room in a natural way.
He liked using strong sources with high output to create his artificial sunlight for interiors
on location or in studio sets, such as tungsten mini-brutes, old carbon arc lights or later
on HMIs.
Although he is known for his use of naturalistic soft light in movies like Days of Heaven,
he also did use hard light at times when it was functional and could be justified by a
realistic source.
He also often favoured lighting with a single source, meaning one lighting fixture which
pushed light in a singular direction.
He often did this by using practical light fixtures like lampshades with tungsten bulbs
and not adding any extra full light to lift the exposure levels in the space.
In Days of Heaven he even took this idea and transferred it to the oil lamp props, which
he had replaced with electric quartz bulbs that shined through orange tinted glass, which
were wired under the shirts of actors and attached to a belt with batteries that they
could wear.
These innovative solutions led the way to what is nowadays easily done with battery
powered LEDs.
He paired this warm practical light with another lighting technique he would master, exposing
for very low levels of ambient dusk light in the sky.
Days of Heaven is probably best known for using this dusk light, known as Magic Hour,
but it's actually something he'd been doing since his first feature.
This was especially difficult as for most of his career he worked with a Kodak film
stock that had a very low ASA rating compared to today's standards.
Kodak 5247 is a tungsten balanced film that was rated at only 125EI, which is around 5
stops slower than a modern digital cinema camera like the Sony Venice 2 that can shoot
at 3200EI.
To expose at these extremely low levels of natural light he would rate the 125ASA film
at 200ASA on his light meter, two thirds of a stop underexposed.
As it got darker he would then remove the 85 filter, which changes the colour temperature
of tungsten film to daylight, but also darkens the image by one stop.
Then as it got progressively darker he'd also change to lenses with a faster aperture
that let in more light, ending wide open on a Panavision Superspeed T1.155mm, poor focus
puller.
If they needed to push things even further into low light shooting he would sometimes
even film at 12 or 18 frames per second and change the shutter from 1 over 50 to 1 over
16.
In this case they'd also ask the actors to move more slowly than usual to mask the otherwise
sped up feeling of motion you'd get, reaping the final moments of available natural light
before everything became dark.
However, when he wasn't working with the smallest amounts of available light, Almendras
actually preferred to not shoot with a wide open aperture.
He felt the best depth of field was slightly stopped down so that the background wasn't
a complete blur and could still be made out, yet was slightly soft so as to isolate the
characters from the frame and make them stand out.
He also innovated other DIY tech that could be used to simulate naturalistic lighting.
For example, he ignited flame jets attached to gas tanks which could easily be handled
and had a controllable flame.
These could be brought near actors to naturalistically illuminate them for scenes involving fire,
rather than using electric lights which was standard practice before.
To achieve a wide shot of locusts flying off in camera without post production visual effects,
Almendras again pulled a technique from his knowledge of cinema, this time a movie called
The Good Earth.
They suspended helicopters just above the shot, and released seeds and peanut shells.
Then to get the effect of the insects taking off, they got the actors to perform their
actions in reverse.
This was shot on an old Arriflex which could shoot film backwards, that would later play
out the original action in reverse.
This innovation also extended into camera movement.
Days of Heaven was the first film to use the Panaglide, Panavision's lightweight alternative
to the Steadicam, which could be used to get sweeping, tracking shots with actors over
uneven natural terrain.
Much of what we take for granted in cinematography today, like shooting in low light, using practical
sources and thinking about motivated natural lighting rather than 3 point lighting, are
all innovations aided by Almendras' work.
He was able to use his knowledge of cinema to inform his taste and storytelling techniques,
then pushed established technical boundaries and ways of thinking to make his cinematography
extremely beautiful, but also extremely influential.
Thank you to all the Patrons for your continued support of the channel, as well as everyone
else for engaging with the video.
Otherwise, until next time, thanks for watching and goodbye.
