“One of the major driving factors of the extreme polarization that we’re living through right now is that most news consumers can very easily … tune in somewhere where they are just being force fed worldviews and perspectives that confirm all their priors,” says journalist Isaac Saul.
“Think about what media outlets are really making their audience uncomfortable on a regular basis, and there’s very few of them,” he says.
After writing for a wide variety of media outlets and seeing some disturbing trends, Saul decided to found Tangle, a newsletter that puts viewpoints from both the left and the right side by side.
CHAPTER TITLES 0:00:00 - The Media Polarization Landscape 0:01:10 - Insidious Forces Shaping Modern Media 0:06:10 - Technology and the Siloing of Information 0:10:19 - Breaking the Media Echo Chamber 0:11:00 - Isaac Saul's Journalistic Journey 0:13:04 - Behind the Scenes: How Media Sausage is Made 0:16:44 - The Birth of Tangle: A Non-Partisan Vision 0:22:52 - Challenging Political Perceptions Through Balanced Reporting
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
One of the major driving factors of the sort of extreme polarization that we're living through
right now is that most news consumers can very easily go out into the wild, open their computer,
turn on their TVs, and tune in somewhere where they are just being force-fed worldviews and
perspectives that confirm all their priors. You think about what media outlets are really making
their audience uncomfortable on a regular basis, and there's very few of them.
After writing for a wide variety of media outlets and seeing many disturbing trends,
Isaac Saul decided to found Tangle, a newsletter that puts viewpoints from both the left and the
right side by side. We're going to take you out of the little nice cozy bubble you've been in,
and you're going to be made uncomfortable by the news that we're publishing,
because we're going to expose you to arguments from people across the political spectrum.
This is American Thought Leaders, and I'm Jan Jekielek.
Isaac Saul, such a pleasure to have you on American Thought Leaders.
I'm glad to be here. Thanks for having me.
Let's talk about the insidious forces, to use your language, that shape media today.
Most Americans by now are probably familiar with some of them. One of the common examples is
advertising revenue or advertising pressure. If you're a big media organization that makes
their money off advertising revenue, then that means you necessarily need traffic. You need
hits on your website. You need ratings on TV. That has a tendency to turn media companies
into entertainment companies. You have to drive attention, be as sensational as possible.
If it bleeds, it leads, is the old school newspaper parlance.
I've experienced some different insidious media forces that have driven a lot of the
problems that we see today in American media. One of them is groupthink. Roughly 7% of all
journalists in the media space, at least at sort of traditional media outlets,
are Republicans or self-identify as conservative, which is kind of jaw-dropping if you really stop
to think about it. I mean, very, very few people representing the mainstream media
hold views that roughly half the country holds. So when you're in a newsroom and you're a minority
thinker, you might feel compelled not to necessarily speak your mind or to act as a
sort of check on the blind spot that the kind of narrative the rest of the newsroom is putting
forward. Part of that also is the sort of hiring bias that we see that comes out of that. I mean,
I think like most industries, a lot of people who make their way in media make their way in media
because they know people. They have connections from journalism school. They have connections
from previous jobs they've had. And so it's this sort of cycle that feeds itself. It's hard to
break into the space if you are a conservative from a rural part of the country who didn't go
to Columbia Journalism School or didn't work with somebody at Vox before they got hired at the New
York Times or whatever it is. And then some of the stuff that I've written about is kind of the
reflection that we see from these forces onto the space, onto the content that's being produced and
how we sort of encounter it. That might look like story selection bias, which is not always so
obvious as, you know, a headline that looks biased or a sentence in a newspaper that looks biased.
This is just what are we choosing to cover today? What's the story we're going to focus on?
The joke that I like to tell and sort of the way to illustrate this that I talk about is, you know,
if an immigrant who's here in our country illegally gets drunk and crashes his car and
kills somebody, I would bet good money if that story is going to be covered by Fox News basically
10 times out of 10. If an immigrant comes to our country and is here illegally and ends up creating,
you know, the next Google, a major tech company that creates hundreds of thousands of jobs and
drives billions of dollars of revenue, I would bet my life that the New York Times
is going to do a feature person on that story. That story will be covered by the New York Times,
but they rarely do the reverse. You know, Fox News rarely picks that story up. The New York Times
rarely picks up the DUI story. They're selecting the kind of news they want to present to their
audiences, and that's a really big challenge. It's a hard thing to navigate as a newsroom.
One of the major driving factors of the sort of extreme polarization that we're living through
right now is that most news consumers can very easily go out into the wild, open their computer,
turn on their TVs, whatever, and tune in somewhere where they are just being force-fed
worldviews and perspectives that confirm all their priors. If you are a, you know,
never Trump Republican, you can just go read The Bulwark and The Dispatch and never leave
that space and never have your views challenged. If you're, you know, dyed-in-the-wool Democrat,
then it's the New York Times opinion page where you're rarely going to encounter,
you know, maybe you'll get some David French Republican conservative thought,
but you're not going to get like intellectual Trumpism there. And if you're a diehard
conservative and you just want to tune into Fox News or Breitbart or whatever it is and never
really see anybody criticize the Trump presidency, aside from maybe like Jessica Tarloff or something,
then you can do that. And it's really easy to do that. And I think the fact that it's so easy to
do that is a really scary moment for us in the information ecosystem. I mean, that's a
frightening thing to be operating in from my vantage point. And it's a testament to just how
many news organizations are doing this. I mean, you know, you think about what media outlets are
really making their audience uncomfortable on a regular basis, and there's very few of them.
I mean, I like to believe that we're doing that at Tangled, but I think there's really,
really, truly very few of them. And that doesn't seem healthy to me.
Well, and there's theory behind this, too. I don't know how familiar you are with Andre
Mir's work and his idea and this sort of Marshall McLuhan, you know, the media is the message form.
He believes, and he's actually convinced me of this, that just kind of the way that technology
has developed around the media is inherently siloing through social media and so forth,
and that the business of media today largely is serving people things that they already agree,
that validate them sometimes. And the more kind of you can excite them about that,
the more they'll pay. And there's a lot of truth to that. And I think the business models
have gravitated towards that, just as you suggested. This is obviously a real big issue
for someone like the Epoch Times or Tangled, where we're really trying to reach people,
I think, who don't already agree with certain viewpoints, right? I mean, it's a foundational
issue, because even your marketing team, right? We're both subscription-based. Your marketing team
is saying, hey, I want to do what works, right? I want to do what works. And what works is what we
just said. But you're like, but that doesn't really fit with what we want to be doing. So
how do we deal with that? I think this is something we need to solve, actually. I don't know the
answer to that question. Yeah, it's really difficult. I mean, you know, the sort of media
parlance for it is the audience capture, right? You give your audience something, and then you
see that they really like it, and now you want to serve your audience that thing over and over
and over again. I remember during the first Trump presidency, I had a lot of friends and family
who were just enraged by the dominance that he had over the media, you know? Like, they would
say to me, I go to the Washington Post, or even the conservative people, you know? I go to Fox News,
whatever, and it's just Trump, Trump, Trump, Trump, Trump. Everything on the homepage is just Trump.
It's all stories about him. And I want to read about other things, like why do you, the media,
why do you guys do this? And the response that I always had is, you know, if you go to the
homepage of the New York Times, or the Washington Post, or Fox News, whatever, and there's a story
about Melania Trump and Donald Trump having some marital issues on the homepage, next to a story
about Republicans passing a new health care bill in the House, which story do you click? I mean,
really, like, where, how do you vote with your dollars when you're operating in those media
ecosystems? And when they're honest with themselves, they all admit that they click the Trump story,
and that's the first thing that they read. And media organizations see that. And so if you're
Fox News, or the Washington Post, or New York Times, or Wall Street Journal, you're seeing,
oh god, our readers are devouring Trump stuff, and you're an assignment editor. It's a no-brainer.
You're the marketing team. You're on the business side, and you have any kind of pressure you can
apply to the editorial side. It's a no-brainer. It's like, they want Trump. Give them more Trump.
That's gonna do their, it's gonna get us the ratings. It's gonna get us the clicks. And it's a
really, really hard thing to sort of wiggle out of, I think. For us at Tangle, the solution has been,
we tell people up front what we're selling. And what we're selling is, we're gonna take you out
of the little, nice, cozy bubble you've been in, and you're gonna be made uncomfortable by the news
that we're publishing. Because we're gonna expose you to arguments from people across the political
spectrum, and you're gonna hate some of what you read. And if we're doing our jobs right,
some of what you read will feel really representative of the worldview that you
share. You will sort of experience the roller coaster of emotions you might if you were
flipping between Fox News and MSNBC, rather than just sitting and stewing in one of them,
and taking all the stuff that you want, and being fed all the stuff that you want
from these news organizations. That's been helpful for us. I mean, we're saying,
this is how we're different. That's sort of the brand that we're selling. But I think if you're
there already, and you're entrenched in it, it's really, really hard to get out of. I mean,
I don't have a great answer for a more established media organization, either. It's a difficult place
to be. Isaac, just one quick sec. We're gonna take a break, and folks, we'll be right back.
And we're back with Isaac Saul, founder of Tangle News.
The thing I like most in the Tangle Newsletters is the Sunday funnies, or at least that's what
I call them in my mind. It's very cool. You know, you show on often the same topic what the left is
doodling and what the right is doodling. Very, very kind of valuable. I was going to say column,
but I believe that's at the top of the newsletter every Sunday. I look forward to that.
Tell me a little bit about how you cooked this all up and your background. Actually,
you have a very interesting background when it comes to journalism.
Yeah, sure. I mean, my sort of genesis story, I like to say, is kind of two-part. The first is
that I grew up in Bucks County, Pennsylvania, a swing county in the most important swing state,
and it has been for most of my life. And so, growing up somewhere where there's a lot of
class divisions and a lot of political divisions, I just have friends and family from all across the
political spectrum. And so, I, you know, A, socially just empathize with people from a wide
range of political backgrounds, and I see my friends or my mom or my uncle or my old teacher
in all these different political actors who, you know, you encounter in the day-to-day news.
I hear them and I see them and I empathize with them. So, I'm open-minded about, you know,
the state of the country and the two dominant political tribes. And then I, you know,
left Bucks County to go work in the media space, and the first job I ever got was at The Huffington
Post, which I'm sure most of your audience knows is a very liberal left-leaning paper.
And I did not go work at The Huffington Post because I was a bleeding-heart liberal whose
dream was to work at The Huffington Post. I worked there because I was a journalism,
non-fiction writing major who applied to 40 jobs, and I got one job, and it was at The Huffington
Post. And it was a crash course in how that kind of, you know, purposefully slanted media
is produced and pushed out the door. And Huffington Post, you know, to their credit,
they have some really great, talented reporters there. They focus their ire and their lens on very
specific things, you know, the ills of the Republican Party mostly. They focus on people
who are of ours next to their name doing bad things. That's the beat if you're at Huffington
Post. But I got to see sort of how that sausage was made there. And then, you know, after Huffington
Post, I worked for Independent Journal Review. Before you continue, tell me a little more about
how the sausage is made, and we'll talk more about that further. But like, what do you mean when you
say that? What was that? Yeah, sure. I mean, first of all, like if you're a younger staff
reporter, like I was, my job, actually, at Huffington Post, I was kind of on like the viral
trends team initially, which meant we had to drive traffic to the website. What year is this
approximately? Just 2013, 2014. Yeah. So in like the peak era of clickbait on Facebook and kind of
the BuzzFeed domination and that sort of thing before Facebook turned the knob. And yeah, being
on the viral trends team, it's like your success was measured in traffic. That's the job is drive
people to the website. And then hopefully once they get to the website, they'll click around.
We have advertisements all across the site. And so that's how we drive revenue. So sometimes,
you know, the the really simple and obvious thing is like, how do you make a headline clicky? How
do you how do you have the curiosity gap in a story that makes people want to click into it?
That was a big part of my early training. It's just like it was almost irrelevant what the
content of the story was. It was like we just need to get people onto the page and into the
website. What's this going to look like when it's shared on Facebook? That sort of thing.
And I started to see when I was writing political pieces the way certain edits were suggested or how
the headline was framed. You know, if I wanted to write a story that was really critical of Hillary
Clinton, sort of in a vacuum, there would be suggestions to like, OK, well, let's explore why
Bernie Sanders is a better candidate. Maybe we can make this, you know, use this paragraph to
compare Hillary to Bernie and sort of do it in a way that puts him in a more positive light.
And I saw a similar thing at different news outlets I worked with. You said you went to
the Independent Journal Review after that. Yeah. And I worked there and I saw the Mirror thing,
I mean, a magazine that was sort of going online that has a very explicit conservative
slant. And I would submit a story and the ask from editors would be about, you know,
seeking out a different quote or, you know, can you dig into this statistic a little more,
add this stat to balance the piece in a way that to me looked clearly favorable to the right?
Or you see the way the headlines are changed or whatever it is, or, you know, you tell your editor
I'm having trouble getting a hold of X, Y, Z. Can we talk to an expert about,
you know, the impact of immigration on the economy? And the expert that they have is from
AEI or Heritage Foundation. It's not from, you know, the Brennan Center for Justice or whatever
it is. So you just see how these forces kind of happen in the space. And I think for me,
it's just like it really opened my eyes to the way all this stuff is being crafted,
kind of behind the scenes, both explicitly and intentionally, and also the stuff that,
you know, these newsrooms can't help. I mean, if you are a journalist or an editor who has
no relationships in the conservative movement, it's so much easier to get a quote from a sitting
Democrat than it is from a sitting Republican. You can do it in less time. And so you just go
do that because it's easier and you're on a deadline and you have to get your story published.
But that comes out in the paper as a kind of bias that I think matters and changes the actual
thrust of the story and the impact of it. And you saw all this happening. I mean,
tell me, you had the dream to have a kind of a nonpartisan space, but probably you were wondering
how that business would work. I mean, tell me what was on your mind, how this came about.
Yeah. So, I mean, the true story is that I was working at a company called A-Plus, which was
the last job that I had before I started Tangle. And we were kind of like a solutions journalism,
sort of a sort of anti-mainstream media outlet in a different way. We were trying to focus on the
people fixing things rather than the people breaking things. That was kind of our shtick.
That was what we were putting out in the world was like, you know, the news is obsessed with
all the corrupt politicians. Who are the people doing good? Who are the people finding solutions
to big problems? Let's write stories about them. And that has sort of run its course. The business
wasn't doing great. I was applying for a bunch of jobs and I had like seven final interviews at
places like the Washington Post or Business Insider, you know, big news outlets that a lot
of people know. And I didn't get any of the jobs. And I was really frustrated and, you know, kind
of down and out and beat up and was like, this industry is tough. And I knew I was good at what
I did. I knew I was a good writer and a good reporter. And I'd always had this kind of idea
for like a big tent media organization, a place where the people from home were like my friends
and family from home could all read the same thing and actually meet and have like a shared set of
facts and also share like a wide range of arguments where they're being exposed to views from the left
and exposed to views from the right. And I wanted that big tent media organization to exist
somewhere. And so I kind of came up with a formula, which I think is our special sauce, a
format for the for the newsletter, which is what if we just explain the story in the most neutral
language possible, which, by the way, is the hardest part. It's the introduction is the
hardest part of the story to write because you have to do it in a way that's so, so balanced
and so even handed with neutral language that you're not going to offend the sensibilities of,
you know, either the left or the right tribe in our country. And then just explicitly say,
here are three arguments from people on the left and here are three arguments from people on the
right. And that was the concept. Just I'm going to I'm going to just show you the best arguments I
can find, the most compelling, convincing arguments I can find from conservatives and from liberals
about this divisive topic. And you can sort of make up your mind. And I sent this newsletter
out to a bunch of friends and family and former colleagues and, you know, a kind of beta version
of it. And the number one response I got from people was like, well, what do you think? There's
no like there's no conclusion to this. I'm so curious. Like there's this big story about,
you know, a bill in Congress. You're a politics reporter. You have moderate centrist seeming
politics. Like where do you land? I'd be curious to hear your analysis calls and balls and strikes.
So I started writing this sort of mini column in the newsletter that can't comes last. That's just
called the my take section where I give my personal perspective. And it's not spent not
meant to be authoritative. It's often written with a lot of humility. I'll say I don't know
the answer here. I feel torn about this issue. I might be wrong, whatever it is. But I think it's
an act of transparency. It's like I'm the guy delivering this news to you. So I'm going to be
radically honest about where I personally stack up, where I land. And I'm going to just tell you
and you can take that as part of the full picture on the news you're digesting is like,
here are the biases in the world views of the person providing the news. And I'm not going to
try and inject that bias into the introduction into the facts of the story. I'm going to contain
it in this really, you know, isolated space that says my take my opinion. This is explicitly my
view. You can take it or leave it. And it gives me space to sort of have some personality in my
writing. I think it makes the newsletter a little bit more interesting. It gives people something
to attack or to say that they really like most of the responses we get are often to the my take
section, like the criticisms and the support. And it works. People seem to think it was a really
interesting format and they felt like they were, you know, getting a much better, more holistic
view on the news. The number one piece of feedback we get from people on the right and the left
is I feel like I'm going less insane when I read your newsletter. Like I just have a better
understanding of what the other side thinks that the people I perceive as my enemies. And it makes
me easier to it makes it easier to kind of see where they're coming from. And I think the reason
for that is because both sides are guilty of this thing. It's like elevating the radicals of the
other side and making them appear as if they are representative of the whole. So like, you know,
there's a reason in our political dichotomy that every conservative and liberal can tell you about
Marjorie Taylor Greene and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. And it's because they're a little bit more on the
fringe of their party. Maybe they have some views that are outside the mainstream, outside the norm.
And it's because the left takes Marjorie Taylor Greene and they, you know, they'll find the worst
thing she's ever said and her lowest moments as a human being. And they will say this person is
representative of the current Republican Party. She is, you know, and the right will take
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and isolate the dumbest thing she's ever said in an interview. And they'll
say this person is representative of the Democratic Party. But like they have a hard time telling you
who, you know, Representative Jake Auchincloss is, who's like a moderate Democrat from Massachusetts,
who I think is more representative of the mainstream Democratic Party than Alexandria
Ocasio-Cortez. You know, there are a lot of conservatives out there who are like
brilliant economists and thinkers who are standing up behind Trump's tariffs right now.
Nobody on the left can tell you who they are. You know, they are just obsessed with Peter Navarro
and, you know, maybe something a little, some silly or outlandish he said on cable television
yesterday, because that's what the left is feeding them. And we try and bring forward the people who
are making really compelling arguments who are sort of, at least some of our newsletter is representing
the best of the left and the best of the right. And I think that changes the way people feel about
the country in a positive way. Well, Isaac Saul, it's such a pleasure to have had you on.
Thanks for having me.
Thank you all for joining Isaac Saul and me on this episode of American Thought Leaders.
I'm your host, Jan Jekielek.