103 Video Views·Oct 22, 2024
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
This is the TV version of Jan Jekielek’s interview with Martin Gurri. The longer-form version was released on Epoch TV on October 8, 2024.
Martin Gurri is the author of the “The Fifth Wave” Substack column and author of “The Revolt of the Public and the Crisis of Authority in the New Millennium.”
In this interview, Martin Gurri talks to Jan Jekielek about the radical transformation of the media and information ecosystems.
He argues: “All the institutions of the 21st century were started in the 20th which was the heyday of the ‘Top Down: I Talk, You Listen' model of organizing humanity. That model required a semi monopoly over information to be legitimate. That got blown away by the internet. So for the last 20 years, I've seen this revolt of the public. This is, of course, the title of my book, but the subtitle was ’The Crisis of Authority.’ In the 21st century, the elite have seen their authority completely hemorrhage away, and they are on the warpath about it. They are on the warpath about it right now. They're trying to create censorship structures. The elite is giving us reasons why democracy can't survive unless we censor information and communication that the everyday public has access to.”
“You need to allow us to censor it so we can protect the truth, all right? And of course, those of us who come from Cuba have heard this story before, and it's not about truth, it's about control.”
CHAPTER HEADERS
[0:00:01 - 0:00:48] Introduction to Post Journalism
[0:00:48 - 0:05:42] The Transformation of the Media Business Model
[0:05:42 - 0:13:07] The Role of Polarization in Media
[0:13:07 - 0:15:49] The Disconnect Between Online and Offline Behavior
[0:15:49 - 0:20:56] The Crisis of Authority and the Revolt of the Public
[0:20:56 - 0:22:38] Staying Sane in the Current Media Environment
💛 Support us 👉https://donorbox.org/american-thought-leaders
-------------------------------------------------
© All Rights Reserved.
what is post journalism it's an entirely
new business model and it was stumbled
on by the New York Times in 2016 the New
York Times had less than 1 million
digital subscribers and was struggling
Trump comes by the end of the Trump
Administration today the New York Times
has 10 million digital subscribers
Martin G is a writer a former media
Analyst at the CIA and author of the
preent 2014 book The Revolt of the
public and the crisis of authority in
the New Millennium post journalism
essentially is the idea that journalism
commodifies polarization in this deep
dive interview he breaks down the
radical transformation of our media and
information landscape after the internet
in effect fact democratized information
the elites have seen their Authority
completely hammer away and they are on
the war path about it they're trying to
create censorship structures they're
giving us reasons why democracy can't
survive unless we censor information and
communication that the everyday public
has access to this is American thought
leaders and I'm Yan
[Music]
Kell Martin G such a pleasure to have
you on American thought leaders happy to
be here let's talk about post
journalism I'm very excited actually to
have this conversation because we live
in a world today where media do not work
the way that we thought they did and
you've been looking into this uh Andre
Mir who wrote the book post journalism
has been looking into this let's dive in
okay I think uh it's best to go back and
say we never really understood what was
going on with media for example in the
old days of
newspapers um the newspapers were never
sold to the public no American newspaper
ever survived by selling newspapers to
the public they
sold airspace or eye space eyeball space
to
advertisers now when you have
advertisers more or less dominating your
uh business model you're can have a
special kind of um style that's the old
journalistic style that was so kind of
remote and abstract and you will be very
much make a case that you are being
objective you're not taking siid and you
you take opinion to be this dangerous
volatile substance and you can put in a
little corner of your newspaper said
this is opinion over here you can look
at it or not but the rest is fact it's
reporting it it's stra it's
objective well that model blew up with
the internet because all the advertisers
went online so now what is post
journalism it's an entirely new business
model and it was stumbled on by the New
York Times and the New York Times may be
the only one who can be successful
because I'm not sure you can have more
than one uh but it basically means that
um you are now a uh a a temple of
ideology for a specific set of people
who believe in that ideology right so in
this case obviously is very liberal very
Progressive people very anti-trump
people when I say the New York Times
stumbled into this it was 2016 in 2016
the New York Times had less than 1
million uh digital subscribers and was
struggling Trump
comes U by the end of the Trump
Administration today New York Times has
10 million uh digital subscribers uh
they by trial and error realized that by
posing as as the the sort of like
handholding therapy almost religious
it's a credal thing uh safety Garden
where everybody who was terrified by
Trump could kind come trooping into this
protected garden and be told the right
words be told no no no he's going to get
impeached no don't worry look at all the
horrible things that he did for example
if you take uh the Russia um story where
he was supposed to have been you know
basically V Vladimir Putin's agent um
they published 3,000 at least 3,000 by
my estimate stories
on uh Trump being manipulated by the
Russians was that correct well in the
old journalistic world it would have
been very incorrect because when the
report was made on on that particular
subject it was said there was no
collusion whatsoever right was it
correct from a business model sense well
yeah they got millions and millions of
subscribers because of that so now you
have a very different model and you have
a very different tone and you can call
Trump a liar then the word is used all
the time uh you can censor certain news
if you talk to Barry wife who lived in
the New York Times for a while she'll
tell you she could not she could not get
certain stories published because they
went against the great story that
they're trying to promote post
journalism essentially is the idea that
journalism is commodifies
polarization and um so far the New York
Times has done it really well as I say
they can only be one Pope there can only
be one one church I'm not sure that any
other newspaper can survive doing that
particular trick but they're doing it
pretty well and by the way the word is
not mine is is my friend Andre Mir who
wrote a book called post journalism who
I would recommend to anybody who uh
who's interested in the subject why
don't I tell you how I've been
describing what has happened and this is
actually from my reading of Andre Mir
which you know frankly has changed a lot
of my thinking about media he's really
coming from the vantage point I mean as
as you do that that it's actually the
the nature of how media work has this
profound even a greater influence on
what we how we communicate than the
actual topics that are being discussed
right or the opinions right I mean Andre
he a m mlist um I am somewhat of a
mlist um maybe just briefly so Marshall
mclu just give us a little thumbnail of
of what well he was a uh a very
brilliant very accent writer he's famous
for saying uh the medium is the message
know the medium is the structure right
you and I tend to you know most
everybody tends to just bicker over well
he said this about that and this is a
lie this is truth deal with content
mcluen dealt with structure uh and and
Andre me does the same thing he he
believes that the structure of of uh of
communications of information determines
a great deal of our Behavior simply by
being uh an ecological Force by being
transformative of the landscape that we
live in so if you're you have a
television set you have the whole family
gathered there kind of like passively
taking things on if you have the
internet you're sitting pounding away
going I like I this like I'm I'm going
to yell at this guy you know it's very
different the structure is different
your landscape is different you're going
to be different it can't help and you
can deal with a little tactical content
questions but what matters is the bigger
picture the structure has been imposed
on the
landscape well so I'm going to explain
in my very glib way of what I see
Andre's argument is and I'm going to get
you to comment on it okay because
actually maybe maybe I can learn a bit
more and add to my story or or or fix it
okay you know back in the day you know
before the printing press before the
Gutenberg Press um human beings lived
and tended to Liv in small groups they
would share a a value system the whole
kind of cosmology whole you know con
concept of reality and a lot of the as
we know through a lot of Psych studies
in Psychology a lot of our communication
is actually non-verbal right our emoting
can be much more important in a way what
we're emoting with the eye contact and
everything is very maybe has a much
bigger influence than even the words
that I'm using and some some people
would argue if you ever talk to somebody
who speaks a foreign language you don't
understand you know that's true because
you can communicate right yeah exact
exactly 100% so then with time suddenly
we get to you know the Gutenberg Bible
of course you get to the written word
and there there's a few steps now and
suddenly you can actually Mass produce
information and send it out a a single
message right but the written word is
much more abstract than this type of
communication right so it's actually
hard you need you know Shakespeare was
good at transmitting emotion and and of
of course there's pamphleteers and
propaganda and things like that but it's
actually difficult like you have to be
really good at it to transmit that stuff
in the written word but what happens
subsequently right we we get radio then
we get television we get the internet we
get social media and then we get AI
Juiced up social media okay just I mean
this is a very rapid progression we have
this way of transmitting a single idea
or a single video or you know to
millions of people in many cases but now
we have that same that ability to emote
that ability to communicate in all these
other ways than just the written word
and for people to receive them that
don't share that same value system
necessarily and so we basically end up
in this situation where we either kind
of pick we pick the people that we're
that we agree with and and we push away
the people that we don't or the messages
and that's inherently polarizing and
hence uh what I think Andre said that he
he says that polar a is the software of
media today which I when I first read
that I I was really kind of stunned but
I I I think there's truth to that you
know so okay here we go there's my story
uh what do you think well what Andre
says of course is uh he estimates in
some way that I'm I'm not sure I I can
follow that there were possibly in in
the 2500 years of of literacy there were
possibly 300 million people who
considered them M El to be authors to an
audience right 300 million in the last
40 years we have 5 billion okay this is
just exploded exponentially the number
of people he calls it the emancipation
of authorship right now um when you have
five billion people in a room um what
happens well this is gigantic noise this
is gigantic noise so the the thing you
need whereas what you needed in the
olden days of you know down
communication was enough money to get a
printing press to buy newspaper to get a
delivery system if you had that kind of
money you could you know hire the
reporters you could do it that's what
you need what you need now is attention
how do you get attention in this
enormous gigantic room with five billion
people in it all talking at the same
time well number one you want to talk
louder than anybody else so yelling and
screaming is favored by the structure
number two if I can f get you to start
yelling at me and then people start ling
up behind me saying oh yeah he's a bad
guy he's one of those guys and suddenly
I'm a leader of My Tribe you know I get
way more attention so um uh Jonathan hey
who's a assume you know he's a social
psychologist who's written some
wonderful books um he calls it the Tower
of Babel all right where a strange
situation where um we're all speaking
foreign languages to each other uh and
I'm yelling at you and you're yelling at
me and we're both gaining from it
because our people are lining up behind
us but in fact I'm not listening to you
because I barely understand what you're
saying and this the same with you
there's no communication and so
polarization is as much a factor of of a
ret rhetorical posture and it's a
question I have it's a question I have
okay and I don't have the answer which
is to what extent is internet anger Rage
which Everybody Talks so much about real
and to what extent is you know back in
the day of uh the
elizabethans um lovers you the gentleman
would write sonnets to their girlfriends
right I'm pretty sure sonnets didn't
come trippingly out of their mouths that
was just what was expected you know if
you were a gentleman in Elizabeth
Elizabeth in England you're supposed to
write a son it to your girlfriend it
better be a good one if you are if you
are an opinionator as all of us are in
in in the Tower of Babel you better
pretend to be angry whether you are or
not right so is a is it a rhetorical
posture to what extent is it real
underneath that I don't know it's a
question fascinating well because
because again the
medium is dictating the rhetoric is
dictating the nature of the rhetoric
well so and this is what keeps me up at
night I I think I think you're right
right is that you know is there room for
people that don't want to be angry in
their
communication right I I think I mean
this is an enormous uh room with five
billion people I think there's room for
everybody I think if you want increased
attention follow the New York Times
start start your own little uh Church of
progressive El elitism and say this is a
protected Garden come to us you know and
you will go from 1 million to 10 million
subscribers in five years uh otherwise
um there will always be people who you
know don't want to be yelled at and I
never to my knowledge have ever written
in an angry or enraged mode people read
what I write so um yeah you can do it
but you're you're swimming up screen
Martin we're just going to take a quick
break right now and we'll be right
back and we're back with author of
Revolt of the public and his blog fifth
wave Martin gur the thing that keeps me
up at night right since we're since
we're talking about this is I have to
believe that there's enough people out
there who want to learn new things who
want to be challenged who want to figure
out how to communicate uh with people
that have dramatically different ideas
than they do um because my concern is
right to me The Logical conclusion of
this Tower of Babel setup where you have
and you know the people that are more
most effective at kind of uh uh let's
say harnessing their particular tribes
we we we'll just end up fighting each
other I hesitate because there is such a
gigantic air gap between the Tower of
Babel the digital world and you and I
sitting here in this room in the flesh
it's such an air gap and the people who
go and rage online you know go feed
their cats and and take their puppies
for a walk and and are probably the
meekest uh of the meek it's hard to tell
how those two worlds interact
uh far more so than has been with any
previous um U information structure with
a possible exception of the printing
press which was terribly disrupted
basically you're saying in real life you
can be this super nice compassionate
person but suddenly you're on you're on
a or some other place and you're just a
terror well I mean that's what I'm
talking about because you're expected to
be because the structure is telling you
if you just kind of me you know become
this me mouth nice guy nobody's going to
listen to you and you're nobody talks
that way on the web you you Brash loud
scream rage so is that really what's
happening if you were on the street
confronting what we're seeing it we're
seeing like almost um staged versions of
the online um uh conflicts for example
between pro-israel and pro Palestinian
uh groups um so maybe that's the the bad
future would be that suddenly this
becomes real okay um but honestly if you
look at a lot of the people who have
been for example I have looked at the
protest in Colombia I wrote about
that I mean these are a bunch of
privileged characters that they say a
lot of harsh words about killing Zionist
for example but um I you know most of
them aren't ready to do that I I I think
if you if you Dro them uh in Gaza they
would they would just basically go to
the fetal position and hope that
somebody would rescue them because
they're they're not they're not Killers
they're not really um ideological
Warriors they're they're internet
Warriors which is an entirely different
thing and they've taken it enough that
in a university environment where that
is rewarded they have been very vocal
and in some ways I think very vicious
about the opposite side media has been
democratized right and then on the other
hand one of the constructs I've heard it
described as is you know there's the
sort of the vestiges of the traditional
media model trying to you know basically
stop that you know the the the Revolt of
the public so to speak right but you're
you're making me think about this
differently because you you just
explained to me how the New York Times
you know built its business which is not
definitely not the old model nope no um
everything is going to change
everything's the old the people and no
question in my mind that um it's not
just media which was obviously for for
pretty understandable reasons first to
be disrupted by the internet um there
was a class of individuals with a
following by the way that ran the world
in the 20th century I call them Elites
you can call them whatever you wish um
they basically ran these very important
institutions not just government but for
example the universities um the media of
course uh scientific establishment
business entertainment these are people
who ran these
institutions and they they expected a
certain difference and respect and and
control particularly and that got blown
away got blown away all the institutions
of the 21st century were started in the
20th which was the Heyday of the top
down I talk you listen model of
organizing humanity and that model
required a semi Monopoly over
information to be legitimate and that
got blown away by the internet so the
last 20 years I've seen this Revolt of
the public is of course the title of my
book but this the subtitle was the
crisis of authority of the institution
the crisis of authority in the 21st
century the elit have had their seen
their their Authority completely hammer
away and they are on the war path about
it they are on the war path about right
now they're trying to create censorship
structures they're giving us reasons why
democracy can't survive unless we censor
material as we limit the amount of
material uh uh information and
communication that the everyday public
has access to because the public in this
view is is very gullible and can be
easily misled be misled by these
populists like Donald Trump through
means like fake news for example and
therefore some set of Guardians who are
who don't share this weakness of
gullibility must be interposed between
uh the origin of the of the media of the
source and the public in other words
they must censor and detoxify the flow
of digital information we are at the at
the present moment in this you know very
politicized pre-election moment are
confronting an Administration that
without if sir buts says we I we need to
censor um free speech things are not
like they used to be back in the days of
the Constitution uh
framers uh information was very
different things have changed you need
to allow us to censor it so we can
protect the truth all right um and of
course those of us who come from Cuba
have heard this story before and it's
not about truth it's about control maybe
as we finish up
for you know the typical person that
might be watching this show what's the
best way to stay sane in this
environment that's a really good
question um I'm not sure that I've
succeeded but um I always
say uh read books read books everybody
says well what if they do this you
newspaper's going away how would people
know okay read books
it's fine to read articles I write them
please read them um but there is such a
surfit of people basically opinionating
and explaining and lying and that if you
deep if you dive too deeply into it you
may lose your mind all right so do what
I said before which is do the
perspective but the only way you can do
it is by go read the books and go in
depth you know don't read something that
is that's half an inch deep read
something that gets you to the bottom of
things read Andre's books for example I
mean that will get you halfway there
okay uh read books and not necessarily
books you agree with but a book gives
you enough data and enough argumentation
that you can interact with it and learn
learn whether you are going too much in
One Direction or not or whether you're
just right and this is an interesting
perspective but you can see the the
falsehood in it read books read books
well Martin G it's such a pleasure to
have had you on I've enjoyed this a lot
maybe we can do it again sometime I look
forward to that yep thank you all for
joining Martin G and me on this episode
of American thought leaders I'm your
host Yan Kell
[Music]