“The [academic] institution wanting to protect people who have committed fraud is another level of fraud. So, that's like another story. So, you have: plagiarism is one, entire bodies of literature that are corrupt, institutions protecting people who ‘cheated’ - there's really no there's no politic or polite way to say it, nor should there be. And then you have other things that we can talk about, like citation cartels, etc. But those are the three areas of corruption to me.”- Peter Boghossian
you've been talking a lot about academic
corruption notably um the plagiarism
Wars I think right is the term that that
that you've been using so let's start
with this plagiarism thing because
basically it's being it's being
described as actually a weapon now
that's going to be used by the right to
attack The Establishment so tell me
about this you're laughing I'm I'm
laughing because well first of all if
you didn't play eyes you have nothing to
worry about and for the record I had my
dissertation run and it's it's a clean
uh so the idea that somehow this is a
vast right-wing conspiracy to weed
out to weed out what people who have
obtained their credentials fraud
fraudulently o okay what would it matter
if it was a right-wing conspir any kind
of conspir like it there are people a
non-trivial number of people who have
who teach in the academy me many of whom
have tenure who have obtained their
credentials fraudulently they have lied
they have cheated on their
PHD and that is an extraordinarily
serious problem on multiple levels makes
perfect sense to me yeah right but I
somehow somehow it doesn't seem to be
like people are treating it as seriously
as you and I would that's because they
don't understand the depth of the
problem they don't understand the
severity of the problem and they don't
they don't understand I mean look
Claudine gay $900,000 a year president
of
Harvard she got caught for plagiarism in
an egregious way she kept her job for
$900,000 she's no longer president but
she kept a $900,000 a year post at
Harvard
University that's
shocking that's shocking well because
there's other criteria that are more
important to these administrations right
okay yes and the minimum bar to get in
is it's assumed when you have your
PhD that you went through a process a
rigorous process to get that and you did
not commit fraud to obtain that
credential if you committed fraud to
obtain that credential then we can have
a conversation about what should happen
it's a little bit off topic you know
should you lose your PhD I mean as a
minimum you should lose any academic
appointment you have think that's a
minimum this is at the most arguably the
most elite University in the world on
you know almost definitely the top five
universities in the world and you have
somebody who has obtained their degree
fraudulently still in a position of
authority well it's it's as you're I
think suggesting it undermines the whole
system but the whole system is already
undermined correct you're right it
further undermines it further
delegitimizes a system that's already
not legitimate don't hire college
graduates especially from the elite ivys
in the I I'll use the term woke in the
woke world view okay everything is
politics everything is a power play and
the means of getting there seem to be
discretionary right so you can kind of
imagine how this sort of situation arose
yeah think about the first thing that
you said that caused me to laugh that
this is a right-wing conspiracy can you
imagine saying that we need to keep
people who have obtained their
credentials dishonestly they've cheated
lied through fraud that we need to
retain those people in service to some
other ideology that ended up of itself
should completely delegitimize the whole
institution so my viewpoint has
developed through many interviews
including some with you in the past
okay for decades now in the academy and
then further in industry and in V
various institutions including
government there's been this strong
selection process of people through who
through coded language and ability to
write a certain way and a ability to you
know demonstrate their
bonafed in I'll say glibly wokeism okay
okay getting positions of Merit
positions of power and there's a
disproportionate number of these people
not getting positions of Merit getting
positions of authority positions of
authority that okay that's right that's
right um and so here we are right so I
would expect based on everything that
that probably there's a heck of a lot of
this cheating going on that's the
question right that's the million dooll
question so here here are the
questions what percentage of
dissertations in the humanities are
plagiarized I don't know I can take a
guess what percentage of dissertations
in certain fields are plagiarized the
best thing that we have now is called
turn it in but there are too many false
positives and false negatives so there
are tools being developed to analyze
plagiarism
and very soon within 8 months is the
best prediction that we're going to know
in Mass how many people have committed
fraud so my guess to you is you're
looking at
79% of dissertations in the humanities
that are plagiarized if I'm wrong it's
not because there are fewer it's because
there are far far more but that the 7
to9 is a very conservative EST and my
next guess to you educated guess would
be that there would be in
Fields with the word studies in them
gender studies anything any member of
the grievance studies they would be in
Black studies anything with the word
shico studies indigenous studies but
again that's a guess that's that's my
prediction I don't know but I want to
say something that gets lost in this
conversation because someone's saying
well you know maybe it wasn't
intentional or there was a mistake okay
people who would say that tend to be
younger and the reason they would say
that is because they're working on
screens they're moving text when Claud
and gay dist when I wrote my distraction
you're talking about taking a book
copying from the book onto the computer
that's not merely pasting and copying
text it's a level of intentionality with
that so when I give the the figure of
79% I mean could be independently
adjudicated we could bring someone in
they'd be like wow that is a clear
instance of plagiarism like Claud and
gay and not as Harvard tried to say
duplicative language it's not it's plagi
is cheating she
cheated you know the other thing I have
to obviously the the the sort of the
elephant in the room here I suppose you
know when we talk about the grievance
studies of er SoCal squared you know
these you and just to remind our viewers
you know you and two others submitting
these false papers because you kind of
crack the code of what you thought could
get published in these various blank
studies journals you know your ability
to do that and figure out that there is
a code was that these aren't actually
genuine areas of scholarship in the
first place they're all fraudulent so so
I'm really glad you said that cuz that's
also lost in the discussion I'm just
going to use the figure 10% it's not
that just 10% of the people are Have
Cheated to obtain their credentials it's
that there are entire lines of
literature that are fraudulent so that's
an that's a deeper level of Fraud and
then there's another level of fraud that
we haven't talked about is the
universities protecting the people
either through uh making it more
difficult to find those dissertations
pulling off the names of people on Dei
websites now do I know that's because
they don't want them to search no I have
no idea but it's certainly a rather
remarkable coincidence since the claing
gay Scandal I don't know that I can't
prove that but causally it's
extraordinarily suspicious so the
institution wanting to protect people
who have committed fraud is another
level OFA so that's like another story
so you have plagiarism as one entire
bodies of literature that are corrupt
institutions protecting people
who cheated there's really no there's no
politic or polite way to say it nor nor
should there be so you have and then you
have other things that we can talk about
like citation cartels Etc but those are
the three areas of corruption well to me
there's a there's a fourth areae okay
the fourth area is uh the administrators
because in many I think this is a trend
in every single University almost right
almost um is that the number of these uh
administrators has grown in some cases
Beyond The Faculty um it's not again
100% clear what they
administrate um however they're very
dedicated to maintaining the
structure and the ideological structure
that exists that's my observation that's
certainly been written about somewhat
correct right so so you know I'm what
guess what I'm trying to say it might
not be the the the academics that are
trying to do this it might be this other
group which is built an Empire so to
speak and wants to keep the Empire no
that's absolutely correct it is the
administrative staff it is Dei boards
that the Dei board is kind of the engine
the weaponization of the ideological
capture so there's no question that
that's true so there are layers and
layers of
corruption and