Supreme Court Steps in and FORCES Restoration of Voting and Speaking Rights

Facts Matter
2.9K followers
🇺🇸 Try Epoch Times Sale: https://bit.ly/4lAyebk
🟡 Buy One Gold Oz., Get One Silver Oz.: https://ept.ms/3biH9MN
Episode Resources:
🔵 Censure Resolution:
https://bit.ly/3HedbvA
🔵 George Santos:
https://bit.ly/3Sqq5co
🔵 Supreme Court Order:
https://bit.ly/3Z1voCM
🔵 Federalist Society Analysis:
https://bit.ly/3SsQOF7
-
#transathletes #supremecourt #factsmatter
© All Rights Reserved.
And now let's head on over to the state
of Maine where a very interesting story
is unfolding. Basically last week the US
Supreme Court stepped in and they
reinstated the voting rights and the
speaking rights of a state
representative. Basically up until that
moment this particular state lawmaker,
she was not able to vote or speak in the
house despite the fact that she was
elected for that seat. She was sent
there by her local constituents, but she
was not able to do anything despite
having been elected. And the reason for
why exactly that is is fascinating to
say the least. And so, let's go through
it together right after you take a super
quick moment to smash those like and
subscribe buttons so that this story can
reach ever more people via the YouTube
algorithm. So, let's begin. Right now,
the state legislature of Maine is
currently controlled by Democrats.
Although it is really worth mentioning
that Democrats only have a slight
majority in the state house. Just
looking at the one-sided presidential
election results in the state of Maine,
you might assume that their state
legislature is similar to Oregon or
Washington state, which is really
one-sided almost a super majority by
Democrats. But actually, it's not. In
the state of Maine, out of the 151
available seats in the state house, 76
are controlled by Democrats while 73 are
controlled by Republicans. And then the
remaining two seats are held by
independents. Meaning, as a practical
matter, that the Democrats hold a narrow
majority in the state legislature. And
you'll see why that's relevant in a
moment. Now, back in January, when
President Trump assumed office, one of
his first executive actions was an order
that related to transgender athletes in
sports. Specifically, he signed an
executive order. You can see it up on
your screen right here, titled Keeping
Men Out of Women's Sports. The practical
effect of this executive order was that
schools across the country that
continued to allow transgender athletes
to compete against biological girls,
they ran the risk of having their
federal funding cut. They would no
longer get federal dollars sent to them.
And shortly after this executive order
was signed, you had a very tense
exchange between President Trump and
Miss Janet Mills, the Democrat governor
of the state of Maine. Take a look. The
NCAA has complied immediately. by the
way. That's good. But I understand Maine
is Maine here, the governor of Maine. I
am here. Are you uh not going to comply
with it? I'm complying with state and
federal laws. Well, I'm We are the
federal law. Well, you better do it. You
better do it because you're not going to
get any federal funding at all if you
don't. And by the way, your population,
even though it's somewhat liberal,
although I did very well there, uh your
population doesn't want men playing in
women's sports. So you better comp you
better comply because otherwise you're
not getting any any federal funding. See
you in court. Every state. Good. I'll
see you in court. I look forward to
that. And so all this was the backdrop
for what happened with Miss Laurel
Libby. Miss Laura Libby is a Republican
representative in the main state
legislature. She specifically represents
district number 90 located roughly an
hour's drive north of Portland. And back
in February of this year, amidst this
whole debate surrounding trans athletes,
Laurel posted the following on Facebook
highlighting a certain transgender
student athlete who had won a girls
track and field competition. Here's what
she wrote. Quote, "We've learned that
just one year ago, John was competing in
boys pole vault. That's when he had his
fifth place finish. So all of this
transpired in the last year with a full
blessing of the main principles
association. Two years ago, Jon tied for
fifth place in the boys pole vault.
Tonight, Katie won first place in the
girls main state class B championship.
And then right below that message, she
posted two photos of that same
individual one or two years apart. And
please do note, we here at the Epic
Times, we are the ones who blur the
faces of all the students in those
photos. the original photos, the ones
that were actually posted by Miss Laura
Libby, she very specifically did not
blur all the students faces, including
the face of the transgender student,
which is exactly the point which caused,
you can say, quite a bit of controversy
within the Democratcontrolled Maine
state legislature. Not only because well
the topic of transgender athletes was a
hot button issue at that time as it is
now but also because the athlete in
question the one that Laurel highlighted
in that particular post he was a minor.
He was competing at the high school
level meaning he was probably somewhere
in the range of 15 16 or 17 years old
when those two photos were taken and
when the post was made. The criticism
against Laurel was that by posting the
name and photo of that particular
student, she was putting him in danger
both psychologically and perhaps even
physically. At the time, you had many
news stories running locally in the
state, such as this piece here on a
local ABC affiliate over in Maine. What
about her argument that the student is
participating in a public event? It's at
a high level, state level. Does that
change your opinion at all or do you
still think it was No, I accept the fact
there are many people who know this
student of people in that school in that
district, but that's one thing, but
putting it out on social media means the
whole world can weigh in on this and
that's generally not a good thing.
Ethan,
yeah, just really, you know, I used the
word disgusting earlier about what
Donald Trump was doing. This is that uh
times 12. Just really inappropriate to
use kids. You know, we're we're always
very careful when we're in elected
office not to have not to cross certain
lines. She can have whatever position
she wants to have. Main law is clear.
What the main principles association has
done is clear. Now, it was at this time
that Laura was asked by the main
legislature to issue a public apology.
She refused, saying that she will not be
silenced, but then she was actually
silenced. In February of this year,
shortly after she made this post, the
main state legislature voted to
officially censure her. The vote was 75
to 70, falling almost completely along
party lines. The censure resolution was
passed, you can see it up on your
screen, and it accused Laurel of
unapologetically putting this child in
danger and therefore violating the
legislaturator's code of ethics. And it
also said that she quote conducted
herself in a manner incompatible with
her duty and responsibilities as a
member of this house and the public
trust and high standards incumbent in
that office. Then right after the vote
for this resolution went through, you
had the speaker of the main house. He
spoke up in the chamber and he offered
to give Miss Laura Libby an opportunity.
He offered to give her time to draft an
apology and present it to the full
house. Laurel immediately refused this
offer and she went outside and told the
reporters who were there waiting the
following. I will not apologize for
speaking the truth. And the truth is
there are biological males who are
taking the place of biological females
in main sports taking their podiums
taking uh the the that excitement that
they've been working for so many years.
I think about those two girls who should
have been first place in the state
championship pole vault and the
disappointment that they faced when a
biological male took the podium instead
of them. I will not apologize for
speaking up on behalf of main girls. In
that same interview, Laurel also pointed
to several national polls. You can see
them up on screen showing that the vast
majority of Americans don't believe that
transgender athletes should be allowed
to compete in girls sports. All right,
just to pause here for a super quick
moment. I'd like to introduce our
sponsor and my own personal gold dealer,
American Hartford Gold. Now, as soon as
the latest round of tariffs hit, almost
immediately, the stock market hit some
serious waves. We could say it became
super turbulent, very volatile. And of
course, these conditions don't just
affect Wall Street. They affect all of
us with our investments and our
retirement accounts. That's why I want
to introduce a company that I trust and
I use myself to help secure my own
savings, American Hartford Gold. They
specialize in helping Americans move
their assets into something tangible,
something you can actually hold.
Physical gold and physical silver. Two
precious metals that help me sleep
better at night, knowing that I have a
hedge against all those brilliant
decisions being made over in Washington.
Now, they have an A+ rating with a
Better Business Bureau. They have
thousands of five-star reviews, and they
make the whole buying process super
simple. Your medals can be shipped
directly to your doorstep or you can
transfer your current retirement account
to a tax advantaged gold IRA. And the
best part is that right now American
Hartford Gold is offering an exclusive
buy one get one deal for my viewers.
When you call them and mention my name,
Roman for every 1 oz of gold that you
purchase, you can get 1 ounce of free
silver. And so take advantage of this
special offer. Either call
8662422352 or simply text Roman to
65532. That's again
866242-22352 or text Roman to 65532.
I'll also throw their information. It'll
be down in the description box below.
Now, this is where things you could say
got interesting. The censure resolution
that was passed against her. It
mentioned two specific laws. Here's what
it said. quote, "Pursuant to article 4,
part 3, section 4 of the constitution of
Maine, which states that each house may
punish its members for disorderly
behavior, and pursuant to section 561,
subsection 1 of Mason's manual of
legislative procedure, which states that
a legislative body has the right to
regulate the conduct of its members and
may discipline a member as it deems
appropriate, including reprimand,
censure, or expulsion. The House is the
judge of its own membership." What this
meant in practice is that because Laurel
refused to apologize for her post, she
was no longer able to debate on the
House floor or cast any votes. She was
still a member of the state legislature.
She still represented thousands of
constituents. It's only that she could
no longer speak or vote. Now, after
finding herself in the situation, Laurel
filed a lawsuit against the speaker of
the house, arguing that this action
disenfranchised her constituents. Here's
specifically what that lawsuit stated.
Quote, "The verbal censure, unwise as it
may be, is not what we challenge here.
It's what happened next. The speaker
declared Libby was barred from speaking
or voting until she recantss her view."
This means her thousands of constituents
in main House District 90 are now
without a voice or vote for every bill
coming to the House floor for the rest
of her elected term, which runs through
2026. The ongoing and indefinite denial
of Libbyy's voting rights is
unprecedented and goes against what the
US House of Representatives found long
ago that the Constitution forbids that
chamber from preventing one of its
members from voting at the federal
level. The member's vote is not her own.
It belongs to her district and depriving
an entire district of representation is
no more constitutional than excluding
that district from a redistricting plan
in the first place. The same rules apply
in Maine. And as such, she was urging
the US Supreme Court to step in and
issue a preliminary injunction which
will allow her to speak and to cast
votes while the case actually plays
itself out in court. On the flip side,
however, you had the Democrat speaker of
the house arguing that the US Supreme
Court should not take up the case,
writing in his brief that quote, "On
February 17th, Libby targeted a high
school student who had competed in an
event because that student is
transgender and identified that student
by name." The post written on her
official Facebook account quickly went
viral. I saw the post and was
immediately concerned about the students
safety and welfare and sent a letter to
Libby urging her to delete the post.
Libby declined. The main house passed a
resolution with a vote of 75 to 70
requiring Libby to accept full
responsibility for the incident and
publicly apologized to the House and to
the people and the state of Maine. Like
other censures of main house members,
the censure resolution required
representative Libby to apologize for
her conduct, not recant her views. Libby
declined to apologize and therefore it
was determined that Libby had violated
House rules and she could not
participate in floor debates and floor
votes until she apologized. And so these
were the two competing briefs that was
sent over to the US Supreme Court. And
it took a few months, but just last
week, the US Supreme Court did decide to
finally get involved in this case in
support of Laurel. Specifically, in an
unsigned order that you can see up on
your screen, the US Supreme Court went
ahead and restored Laura Libbyy's
speaking and voting privileges. Now,
notably, this order from the US Supreme
Court, it was not only unsigned, but
also it did not provide any reasons for
the decision. It only restored her
privileges while the case itself plays
out in the lower courts. meaning that
while the case is still playing itself
out, Laura Libby can continue to vote
and speak on the House floor, which she
has access to until at least 2026.
That's when her current term is up,
although she has already announced plans
to run for reelection. We'll see how
that goes. And there is something else
that I wanted to mention in regards to
this particular case. In doing research
for the story, my initial assumption was
that this was a blatant violation of the
First Amendment. I mean, after all, how
could you silence an American elected
representative unless they apologize for
something they said or did earlier? It
seems on the face of it to be in
violation of the First Amendment.
However, let me read to you an analysis
of this particular case that was posted
on the Federalist Society website. It's
a bit long, but it does add quite a bit
of solid nuance to this particular
situation. So, I'll read it to you.
Quote, "The case involves important
questions about free speech, election
law, and the court's use of its
emergency docket. A few things are
clear. Whether appropriate or not,
Representative Libbyy's post was
protected speech, and her punishment was
imposed because of the content of that
speech. The US Supreme Court's decision
appeared to signal that the discipline
was unconstitutional, although the court
issued only a brief order and did not
explain its reasoning. The main question
then was whether her ability to serve in
the legislature could be conditioned on
compliance with speech restrictions that
could not be applied to the general
public. Had Representative Libby been
expelled from the main house, even on
the basis of her speech, she might not
have a first amendment claim. Under
article 1, section 5, clause 2 of the US
Constitution, each house of Congress may
expel a member by a twothirds vote. And
under the political question doctrine,
federal courts could not review the
basis for Congress's determination to
expel a member. It is hard to believe
that states would be prohibited from
expelling legislators for their speech
if Congress is permitted to expel its
own members on that basis. But a refusal
to seed a member is different from an
expulsion. Although Representative Libby
was neither excluded nor expelled from
the main legislature, her punishment is
more like an exclusion in that it was
affected on the basis of a majority vote
rather than the twothirds threshold
required for expulsion. And so what
they're essentially saying here in my
limited understanding is that the US
Congress at the federal level is able to
expel its own members if they so choose.
Such as a great example, George Santos.
He was expelled in December of 2023.
Congress had the power to do that and
they did that with a twothirds vote.
expelling George Santos. It stripped him
of all the privileges that came from
being in Congress, which of course
included being able to speak on the
House floor, debate issues, as well as
to vote. And so, does what happened to
Laura Libby in Maine fall under that
general purview? Is her getting stripped
of her voting and speaking privileges
the same thing as George Santos getting
kicked out of office? Is that something
that the state house is able to do
without question or are they not because
it was done by a majority vote rather
than a twothirds vote? It's an
interesting question that'll have to get
answered by the co court courts.
However, as this article from the
Federalist Society does mention at the
very end, well, just based on the US
Supreme Court's order, it seems that
they are siding with Laurel. Quote, "For
the majority on the US Supreme Court, it
was indisputably clear that stripping
Representative Libby of her authority as
a legislator because of her speech
violated her rights and the rights of
her constituents." But I'd love to know
your thoughts on this particular matter.
Do you think that what Laurel did was
protected free speech or and or if it
was protected free speech, do you think
that her highlighting a specific student
who was a minor and dragging him into
the national spotlight was an
appropriate thing for a lawmaker to do?
And if it was inappropriate, do you
think it was grounds enough for the
state legislature to censor her for
violating their code of ethics? I'd love
to know your thoughts. Please leave them
in the comments section below. I'll be
reading through them tonight as well as
into the latter part of the week. And
then also, if you'd like to read any of
the documents related to this whole
story, I'll throw those links down into
the description box below, which I will
mention as always is that same
description box right below those like
and subscribe buttons. Both of which, if
you haven't already, I hope you smash so
that this content can reach ever more
people via the YouTube algorithm. And
then until next time, I'm your host,
Roman from the Epic Times. Stay informed
and most importantly, stay free.
