Is the pursuit of a dream worth it, even if it’s torn apart in the end? In The Old Man and the Sea, Ernest Hemingway tells the story of Santiago, an aging Cuban fisherman determined to break a long streak of bad luck. Venturing far into the open sea, he hooks the catch of a lifetime—but as he battles to bring it home, he watches it slowly devoured by sharks. @MichaelKnowles is joined by popular Canadian podcaster @VivaFrei to explore the deeper meaning behind Hemingway’s classic—its Christian symbolism, themes of suffering and redemption, and how even in defeat, the human spirit can triumph.
Man is not made for defeat. Man can be destroyed, but not defeated. Do you want a box? Do you want
a fight? We will not be defeated by our book this month. That is Old Man in the Sea by the great,
inimitable, actually eminently imitable, Ernest Hemingway. I am joined by a great and inimitable
man, Viva Frye. Viva, thank you so much for being here. Michael, thank you for giving me an excuse
to re-read a book I read 30 plus years ago. Do you know I had never actually read Old Man in the
Sea, one of the most famous works by Ernest Hemingway, one of the most famous works of
literature probably in the last 300 years, and a really, really magnificent book. The book is
very slim, and yet it's dense. Hemingway is a dense writer. Everything is packed with symbolism.
He uses an economy of language, but he uses language quite well. Can you, in one minute,
give a summary of the book? One minute summary is an old, poor, Cuban fisherman with a strange
relationship with a young boy, down on his luck, decides to go for the all-in of fishing, goes
further out into the ocean to try to turn around his bad luck, hooks a monster, and as he reaches
his dream and tries to bring it ashore, he sees it get literally destroyed by sharks, and his dream
disappears. My takeaway from it, which I'm not sure everybody gets, is that in his pursuit of
his goal, he ended up destroying it through his blind ambition. That is the one-minute summary,
and that's pretty much the book. Guy catches fish, fish gets eaten by shark, and he comes back
empty-handed. That is a very depressing read of Old Man in the Sea. In terms of the plot,
that's exactly what happens. However, I had a much more hopeful read on Old Man in the Sea.
We were discussing that the book is rich in symbolism. The old man's name, Santiago,
and so Santiago means St. James. For some reason, this is a weird quirk of the English language,
Iago comes from Jacobus, Jacob, and Jacob in English becomes James. I don't know how that
happened. It was an Ellis Island thing or something, but that's the meaning. This refers
to St. James. One of the most famous pilgrimage sites is the Camino de Santiago. The boy's name,
this young boy who looks after the old man, his name is Manuel. Manuel comes from Immanuel.
Immanuel means God is with us. You've got, right from the beginning, this tension between nature
and faith and the supernatural and God. The boy has total faith in the old man. He wants to go
out and fish with the old man, but his parents won't let him. This is an amazing thing with
Hemingway. Every line you have to go back and read because he does nothing accidentally.
Right at the beginning, he says, this is the first line of the book, he was an old man who fished
alone in a skiff in the Gulf Stream, and he had gone 84 days now without taking a fish.
In the first 40 days, a boy had been with him, but after 40 days without a fish,
the boy's parents had told him the old man was now definitely and finally salau,
worst form of unlucky. 40 days, immediately, we're getting yet another biblical image. 40 days is the
time of completion. 40 days, Christ in the wilderness, and people lose faith in the old man.
But the young boy does not lose faith. The old man says, well, you got to listen to your parents,
so thanks for helping me out. Thanks for taking care of me. Thanks for bringing me coffee,
but I'm going out on the water alone. Then what happens?
Well, now that you mention it, I do feel kind of silly for not trying to look into the
interpretation of the numbers. I don't not do it as a rule, but you can draw any connection from
numbers, but it is true. 40 days in the desert, now I'm thinking of what the representation of
the 84 days is. The one easy symbology, as I like to call it, at the end was, well, we'll get there
in a bit, but after he's defeated by the sharks eating his catch, and he's lying down palms up,
that sort of imagery I can get much more easily. So he goes out on his own without the boy,
and hooks a massive marlin, and spends a lot of the book wishing the boy were here.
And I was unclear as to whether or not he was wishing the boy was there,
either for assistance, or to show off his cash and impress the child.
Well, there's something quite interesting, especially you mentioned there's this image
of the crucifixion that keeps coming up with Santiago, that Santiago is this Christ figure.
Hemingway says this pretty explicitly at one point, when the fishing line cuts Santiago's hand,
and he says he let out this eye, and it was the sort of sound one makes as a nail is driven
through one's hand. So this is very clear imagery of the cross. Even when Santiago gets to the beach,
he's carrying his mast up, and he has to sit down, and this is clear imagery from the walk to Calvary,
where Christ is carrying the cross, and he falls down. So you have Santiago as this Christ figure,
but then when you say, what does the child represent? Manuel is the name of Christ,
and this is another figural name of Christ, Emmanuel, God is with us.
So you make me think of it just as you mentioned it. When he says, I wish the boy were with me,
there's a natural aspect to that, which is, I wish the boy could help me pull in this marlin.
He says, I've hooked a thousand pound marlin twice in my life, but I've never taken one in
alone. This marlin is bigger than a boat. We find out at the end of the story, it's an 18-foot marlin.
So there's this natural idea, I wish the boy were with me to help me bring in this fish,
but then there's a supernatural element, which is, I really wish God were with me.
You even hear echoes from the cross here, when Christ on the cross says,
my God, my God, why have you forsaken me? I wish, I wish. He says also, I'm not a religious man,
but he keeps trying to make a deal with God. He says, if you help me bring in this fish,
I'll say three Hail Marys and two Our Fathers or something. That's too much to say right now,
but I'll say it later. Please, I'm not a religious man. And yet, he does appear to be a religious
man. At one point, Hemingway observes that he's not conscious, Santiago. He's not always
thinking of everything all the time, but he became humble at some point. He doesn't know
when he became humble, but he certainly did. So he's a humble man. He's willing to do what he has
to do, even when he wakes the boy up so they can both walk down and go on their respective fishing
journeys in the morning. Say, oh, I'm so tired. I don't want to wake up, but
that's what a man must do. There's this sense of duty and following one's station in life. He says,
maybe I shouldn't have been a fisherman, but I was born to be a fisherman. This sense of,
this is just what I am called to do, and there will be pain and struggle that goes along with this,
but that's my lot in life, and I have to pursue my own end.
The religious iconography, I mean, it was, or if I'm not sure if that's the right word,
but the symbolism was obvious to me, but I think I was tainted in this book reading it the second
time around because I went in reading it having discovered that Ernest Hemingway ended up
killing himself. So I'm reading this book with that in mind, and when I come to the famous line
of man can be destroyed but not defeated, I didn't read that as an observation. I read that as a wish
or as an aspiration, and then knowing that he ultimately ended up taking his own life,
which I think is the ultimate, I say non-judgmentally it's a tragedy,
but it's the ultimate form of defeat where you end up taking your own life.
Despair.
Despair, and I read that as he was destroyed, and he did end up defeated even in his own mind,
which is how I ended up reading this entire thing of the pursuit of that fish and his pursuit of his
ambition, going further out than all the other fishermen and taking this in alone when he had
never done it alone, and then once he finally accomplishes that goal or what he thought was
accomplishing it, then the sharks come and they end up defacing the fish, and I remember one line
which stuck for me the first time I read it was he couldn't look at his mutilated fish after the
sharks took a bite of it because you have this beautiful creature.
And it's worth mentioning, the only reason the fish were able to, or the sharks were able to
start eating his prize catch is because the fish was so big.
He couldn't bring it ashore.
And he harpooned it, and then it started bleeding, and then he knew that this was sort of,
he had accomplished his goal at that point, but then as he sees it start getting eaten away,
then he sees his dream starting getting eaten away, but where I also took from this differently
the second time around than the first time is as he sees the fish getting mutilated and destroyed,
his beautiful catch turned into not chum, then he goes to start killing the sharks,
which I did not even, I can't believe I didn't notice this the first time.
It was an action movie.
He's fashioning weapons and stabbing sharks in the brains and seeing them one after another.
Gouging out their eyes.
And I couldn't believe that I didn't realize the graphic nature of the violence
from a literary perspective.
His catch is now not only being destroyed, but he's turning into a murderer of other animals,
and this entire venture has now proven to be a total disaster in that he kills the beautiful fish,
loses it, and then turns into something of a monster by killing other animals for
only doing what God intended them to do, and then ends up with nothing except,
you know, the scars on the palm of his hands and laying in a position of Christ on the cross.
But isn't he doing what God intended him to do when he was born to be a fisherman?
And he takes some solace in at least killing these sharks, but he says at the end, to your point,
he says to Manuel, they beat me, Manolin.
Manolin is the diminutive, like, you know, like a mandolin too, but of Manuel.
They beat me, Manolin.
They truly beat me.
But Manolin says, he didn't beat you, not the fish.
Santiago beat the marlin.
They were both just doing what they were made to do, and he won through his cleverness and
through his deceit, he points out.
Then the sharks came, made him, and he wound up with nothing.
But I suppose the reason I don't end on a note of despair is, as Hemingway ended his own life,
is the way the book ends is, they get ready to go back out the next day.
And the boy who had been forbidden to go fishing with this old man anymore, he says,
forget about my parents.
I'm, you're due.
You're due for some luck.
And we won't need luck.
You know, I'll bring the luck, he says.
And especially as the figure whose name comes from Emmanuel, that carries a lot of religious
significance.
He says, I'll bring the luck, but we're going to go back out there.
So after this amazing journey, it's gone on day and night, and sharks are coming, and he's
fashioning new harpoons from knives and oars, and he's stabbing out shark brains and everything,
and he gets back, he seems like he's been totally defeated.
He seems, he's lying down, you know, as if entombed.
The novel does end with Manolin coming in and saying, okay, ready to go out tomorrow?
Yeah, true.
He's going to get to ready to go back out because he's got no choice because he's a
fisherman and so impoverished, he needs the, he needed the meat to live.
But all of his adventure, all of the adventure, all of the, whatever he accomplished was actually
misunderstood by the people who looked on at him.
They like, they didn't even see the Marlin skeleton and say, oh my God, look what this
guy accomplished.
They thought that was the shark, which is the ultimate kick in the teeth.
For him, it's like, even from the outside perspectives, nobody knows what I did.
And I was defeated in all senses, except for continuing to dream about the lions as the
last line of the book is.
And so he's dreaming about the lions, but I still didn't even see that as a positive.
I saw that as, again, more of the blind ambition and wanting to be a lion where at the end
of the day, he did not accomplish the goal.
And not only that, but he ultimately destroyed everything within the orbit of what his goal
was, which was the Marlin itself, the sharks themselves, and then coming back empty-handed
only to be misunderstood in his achievement by the tourists.
But you, you, you mentioned the lion.
Where does the lion, the lion is one of the first images in the whole book.
And it's this, this dream he has of his childhood.
He says these lions in Africa.
So you don't really have much of what kind of childhood he had or why he's dreaming.
But he says, I don't dream anymore.
Even with my wife, he took his wife's picture off the wall.
He still has the religious pictures on the wall as a kind of monument to this life he
had with his wife.
But his wife's gone, makes him too sad to look at his wife.
He just has these dreams of his childhood.
And he ends also on those dreams of his childhood.
And you know, this man is, he's old.
You know, his, his, his hand becomes arthritic while he's on the boat.
And he says it's, it's like the hand already had rigor mortis.
He's got a, he says he's, he's thinking about chopping his hand off if it goes stiff again,
which also would, would appear to be an allusion to the New Testament,
where Christ said, if your hand offends you, cut it off.
So, but, but the hand comes, comes back to life.
Just when you think he's dead, that hand comes back to life.
And then at the end, as you say, he's lost everything.
You kind of wonder when he's lying there, finally so exhausted.
And the young boy is looking at him.
You wonder, is this guy dead?
Is this finally it?
I mean, he hasn't, he's barely eaten for days.
And is that, but he comes back to life.
I suppose this is that, that final hopefulness I see is he keeps, there's this theme of,
of the cross, which is indoors throughout the book, but then also resurrection in the hand,
in his whole body, in, in going back out to the sea the following day.
I, I was, I'd say, tainted by the fact that knowing how Hemingway ended his life,
is this book intended to be the, you know, human accomplishment or a testament to the
human spirit, but I, I read that line as written by someone who ultimately would be
defeated and that it was a hope and an aspiration for himself, but ultimately it didn't even
pan out that way for Hemingway.
Maybe there's a, there's a divergence between, uh, Hemingway's aspiration, you know, what
he's putting into his work and what happens in his own life.
You mentioned the, the persistence of the human spirit, and that brings up one figure,
personally, very important figure to me as a New Yorker and a baseball fan.
Oh, DiMaggio.
DiMaggio is all over the book, and, you know, baseball really matters to Cubans.
Cubans are big baseball people, and the reason I think he keeps bringing up DiMaggio is because
DiMaggio just persisted.
He'd go through dry periods.
He also had his amazing hit streak, but, you know, he's Jolton Joe.
I mean, you think about the, the Paul Simon song, Where Have You Gone, Joe DiMaggio?
Our nation turns its lonely eyes to you.
He was this symbol of just absolute perseverance.
You just couldn't keep the guy down.
And, and then this brings up another tension in the book, which is the tension between
the individual capacity for achievement and broader collective forces.
So there's a disagreement.
I forget exactly where it is in the book.
But they're talking about the, the boy and, and Santiago about the baseball games.
You know, how are the Yankees doing?
He says, the Yankees, they're going to be okay because DiMaggio's back.
I said, but DiMaggio is just one player.
He said, yeah, but he's just one player, but he's, he's the heart of the team.
You know, he's the, he, that one individual is actually motivating the team and carrying
the team.
And then when, when Santiago's out at sea and it's just him and the fish, he, he straps
the fish to the side, they're coming in and he raises this question.
He said, am I bringing the fish in?
Or is the fish bringing me in?
Who really has agency here?
Who's, or are we just both kind of coming on in together?
What, what is the driving spirit in the action of our lives?
The, um, the DiMaggio part, I, I knew only the summary, you know, DiMaggio is a great
name in baseball and the Cuban connection to baseball.
I appreciate it as well, but yeah, it is, um, the, the question, well, there was a point
in the book where he, he says that he sees himself in the fish and then he sees himself
getting devoured by the forces of nature.
And then ultimately at the end of the book, does he end up ever becoming the DiMaggio
that he wanted to be?
Or does he have to accept the fact that he's no DiMaggio?
Well, isn't, isn't the answer both?
That according to the order of nature, he's going to wind up a skeleton just like that
fish and people aren't going to recognize him and they might think he's a shark too,
but they certainly, they won't be able to distinguish him from any other human being
just as they can't distinguish the Marlin from the shark.
But according to the order of grace, there is more than just the skeleton.
There is more than just the rigor mortis.
There is a, there is a resurrection.
There is a, there is a next day.
There is more fishing.
I mean, even just the, the setting of the, the, of the boat, you know, when, when Christ
comes to call the apostles, he's calling a lot of fishermen or you think of St. Peter
who the first Pope, well, the Pope's wear a ring and it's the fisher's ring because
Peter's a fisherman.
He says, well, you know, I look for fish and Christ says, well, I'll make you a fisher
of men.
The, the, when Christ is resurrected, the, his appearance to the apostles on the sea
is when they're out in the boat and he's just broiling fish for them.
So even the, an early Christian symbol is the fish.
Sometimes certain Protestants put it on their cars now to a little fish symbol.
So the whole, all of this, the whole imagery, the entire universe of the, of the story is,
is this religious, specifically Christian kind of universe.
And so it seems to me that the book is always playing on those two orders, the order of
nature, as well as the order of grace.
So in our own lives, in the order of nature, we're defeated.
Ain't no one here getting out alive, man, but, but according to the order of grace,
perhaps there is some hope beyond that.
And, and you, you even see Santiago going back and forth, not a religious man.
Oh no, I'm going, maybe it would be better if I weren't a fisherman.
Maybe this is going to defeat me.
It's going to take me down.
I should have, if I were the fish, but then he keeps saying, he says, I'm not thinking
right.
No, I shouldn't cut my arm.
No, I'm not thinking, no, there's more.
I've got to stay focused, focus on your task at hand.
You've got to come into port.
I've been relating to the idea of saying, I'm not a religious man.
And then finding yourself praying to God multiple times a day.
Many such cases.
I very much appreciated that element of the book because I can relate to that on a daily
basis.
Now, the, the one question I did have about the book was the relationship between the
boy and Santiago and the parents role in that.
Having no idea as to what life was like as a fisherman and living in today's age, where
you would be very skeptical and ask a lot of questions about a relationship of an elderly
man with a young, with a young boy.
And I say not to be funny.
And says something about our age.
No question.
And so that, that was another element where I'm reading this, like, okay, what kind of
parents let their kid hang out with an old fisherman without, without, I mean, to say
without supervision, but without asking many more questions.
Santiago mentions early in the book, when he's recounting, you know, having trained
this boy says, you remember when I took you out and you were five years old and you almost
died because the fish was so big and almost, you know, rip the boat apart.
And that did make me think, well, hold on, that's dangerous.
This is a dangerous job.
They're going out there with sharks and barracudas and giant marlins.
And this is, they're sending their kids out there because, well, not because it's easy,
but because this is what they have to do.
As the boy says, when they're walking down to the shore, this is what it means to be
a man.
And so there's this, this relationship is a relationship of education.
You know, he, he is teaching the boy.
The boy says, I still have so much to learn.
You know, you've given me so many skills and the old man, he's a great fisherman.
He out there alone, broken, not having eaten, arthritic.
He, he still does hook this 18 foot marlin.
He's a thousand pound marlin.
So he's, he's really good.
He does have something to teach the boy.
But then there's also this beautiful turn to the relationship where, well, it's a turn
that we all have in our own lives when our parents take care of us.
And then when our parents get old, we have to take care of our parents.
That just as the, this old man has professionally at least looked after the boy since he was
five years old and an apprentice, I suppose you'd say.
So too now in the man's old age, the boy is looking after him, bringing him food, bringing
him coffee, spurring him on to say, well, we'll go out there and we'll go get him tomorrow.
Giving him not just a natural physical encouragement, but a, but a spiritual one is too, which,
which rejuvenates the old man.
No, absolutely.
Oh, the, the, the story about how they almost got killed on a boat or the kid almost got
killed.
I read that as the exaggeration of either the old, the old fisherman in the memory,
having known, like when I'm with my kids, like, oh, we hooked a 20 pounder and I never
do it.
I'm always very honest, but that's how the memory evolves over time and things become
bigger than what they were at the time in hindsight.
But no, the, the, the transition of the cycle of life being capable, elderly men or old
capable man teaches to the kid who then takes care of the parents.
Absolutely understood that transit transition in the book, or at least that evolution.
But one thing I read about Hemingway in general is that he wrote about what is now referred
to as alpha males versus beta males and the man that defines the man.
And then the men that fail to accomplish what men are supposed to accomplish that, that
idea that Santiago is what a man is supposed to be going out, defying all odds, you know,
living off what he catches and achieving that ideal of what a man is, even if it means
occasionally getting beaten only to get back up.
Right.
And, you know, going for these long, dry spells, you know, and he, even when he's making
the comparison to DiMaggio, he says, I'd like to go fishing with DiMaggio.
I wonder was DiMaggio was poor like us when he's, he's clearly, you know, identifying
with this wealthy American baseball player who's married to Marilyn Monroe, but he sees
that beyond those superficial attributes, there's this, this deeper connection.
And ultimately that is, he's describing something, I think, of human nature.
The, there's one, this is a really minor point, but it's something that if you're
reading this book for the first time, you'll probably have the reaction I did.
One point he says some dolphins come by, he pulls a dolphin into the boat and he decides
he's going to eat the dolphin raw to give himself energy to carry on.
And in my mind, and I actually know a little bit about fish, so I should have realized
what he was talking about.
That it's a mahi-mahi.
A mahi-mahi, the dolphin fish.
Yes.
Not like a porpoise, not like a, you know, not flipper.
And so in my mind, this absolute psycho is ripping a dolphin apart, but he's not.
He's eating the mahi-mahi.
And, but then he says something that is, I think, profound.
He says, it was too late to, to be nourished by food.
He says it more eloquently, but he says, no, because he's getting a little sickened,
nauseated by eating the raw mahi-mahi.
He said, mahi-mahi is really good cooked, but it's really bad raw.
And so he's starting to get nauseated and he says, it's, it's too late in the game for
me to be nourished by food.
And, but you can tell he's unclear in the head.
He keeps vacillating back and forth.
But I think there's something true here, which ties in with the persistent religious symbolism,
which is, he says, you know, look, my body is going to decay.
It is decaying.
It's going to die.
If there is to be an ultimate nourishment for me, it's, it's not probably going to be
a physical nourishment.
That's going to fail me.
There's got, there's got to be some other kind of nourishment.
And he, he does, you know, gird his loins and, and, uh, but, but that nourishment comes
through his representation of, of the passion of the, of the walk of Christ.
Every interpretation that I've read, uh, refers to that, you know, dreaming of lions as
triumph and I be viewing it negatively.
And not only did I not view it as triumph, I viewed it as sort of like,
uh, almost remorse or almost jealousy.
But now putting all of this together, if we're going to go with a very, very religious
interpretation of the ending.
Now I'm wondering if he doesn't actually just die in his sleep and ascend to the heavens.
Well, you're certainly right in that he will die.
So if it's not today, I don't think it literally happens at the end of the book, but it could be
the next day.
He's a really old guy.
Fishing is a really hard life and he doesn't eat that much.
So it, that will happen.
And I think that, that, uh, constant reminder, you know, the, the memento mori, which you
even see in the blood and the kind of, uh, the natural churning of life throughout the
book, uh, reminds you that this will happen.
So then what, uh, what do we, what do we set our minds on to prepare for that?
It's interesting.
I reading it, I do wonder, and I felt that he felt the remorse for having killed the
sharks and not prided at the end of the day, but I'm not sure if that's me projecting how
I would feel under such circumstances where.
I thought he felt good about killing the sharks.
At the moment, I think he, on the boat, when he's in the battle, where he thinks that there's
still a chance of him salvaging half of the fish.
But then my impression was by the end of it, he just, he feels tremendous remorse that
he's destroyed.
But then, then once again, this does bring up our lives, you know, we're born, we, we
do things, we struggle, we endure pain, we forge relationships, we build families, we,
we do all this stuff.
And then at the end, we all end up in the same place, at least as a matter of nature.
But even this, this image, this is a persistent image in literature, the image of, of the
shipwreck of, you know, even the image of transgressing the limits within the sea.
You see this in Dante, the image of Ulysses, as soon as he transgresses the limits and
this leads to the, the shipwreck.
So this, this idea of the shipwreck persists throughout all of Western literature.
And you come into the end and you say, well, what was it all for?
All I have here is, I haven't really eaten anything other than some gross mahi-mahi raw,
and all I got is a skeleton.
And what was it all for?
But then he goes out and does it again.
Well, what was it for?
This is what you're born for.
This is, this is part of your nature.
You're not even always conscious of it.
But well, is there some meaning to it?
I guess if the, if names like Santiago and Manuel have meaning to you, then maybe you
would say there is some meaning to this.
But if not, it looks pretty hopeless.
My question is this, should he have just let the sharks eat the fish without killing the
sharks?
Because by that point, he knew that it was dirty, rotten sharks.
He's a man.
That's what he's born to do.
But then I look at the sharks as much of a creation of God as the, as the Marlin.
And at that point, he said, I'm not, I know I'm not getting, we're not getting out of
here alive.
Do we all become monsters in our, you know, in this ultimate goal of not getting out of
here alive?
We know what Santiago thinks about it.
Because he goes, he says, he's at least prepared to go back out the next day.
Yeah, we know that.
And so I think that, that interpretation is, is rather a modern view.
It's probably a widespread view, which is, you know, man, come on, let's kumbaya, you
know, come on sharks.
To me, it's more like he knew that he was not going to accomplish his goal, period.
And at some point you say, okay, well, at least let this fish be eaten in the way nature
intended, as opposed to me, stubbornly trying to preserve my, my trophy and destroying further
nature in the process.
But doesn't, because I don't, isn't Santiago part of nature and isn't it part, isn't it
his natural end?
Just as it's the natural end of the shark to kill the marlin, isn't it the natural end
of Santiago to kill the shark?
That's what I'm not sure about.
I know that he hates the sharks and he views them as the villains.
And so he's, he's, he's, he's protecting his catch against villains.
And maybe it is a modern beta male thing to say, well, why kill another creature when
there's, there's no purpose, not to any of this, we're all going to end up dead, but
let the sharks be the sharks.
And you've lost this battle.
Let Santiago be Santiago.
And kill the sharks.
This is the old joke.
Like when you get in front of a judge and the criminal says to the judge, your honor,
I was predisposed to commit the crime.
And then the judge says, well, now I'm predisposed to sentence you to jail.
And so I can appreciate that.
I'm just wondering at the end, I don't feel that Santiago was proud of what he did.
That's, that's my.
He does, he clearly is, is troubled by, he's troubled by life, just as we all are.
And we have questions about what we do.
He's constantly, you'll notice he's saying, I wish this.
I wish that I wonder this.
A wish is not something you have for the future, really, so much as, as some way you'd like
to have changed the past.
You know, I want something in the future, but I wish I could have done something different.
Maybe I shouldn't have been a fisherman.
I wish I had the boy.
I wish I did this.
So he's, he's constantly going back.
Should I have even caught the marlin?
Had I, he certainly says this, had I known what this would all come to, I, I probably
shouldn't have even gotten the marlin.
You know, what was it all for?
I should be, I should be home sleeping now.
I should, right.
Yeah.
And, and so he, but of course we all do that too.
We second guess ourselves.
We look back.
We, we.
Especially when it turns to utter horror and loss in terms of what.
As it does.
Had I just not done A, then we wouldn't be here at all.
Had you heard of the psychiatric analyses of Hemingway potentially having suffered from
CTE as a result of car crashes and plane crashes?
No, no.
So there, there was a, a psychiatric analysis or a psychiatric, I guess, post-mortem of
Hemingway's life, which suggested that he, uh, suffered from behavioral disorders, which
might've been the result of, of repeated head injuries.
He would, he'd like to fight.
Yeah, apparently he had plane crashes, car crashes.
And, um, but so, so when reading and not knowing when CTE fully kicks in and, uh, the behavioral
issues that that causes, you know, I go back and read this book and in terms of how it
could be interpreted in light of being written by someone who might be suffering from undiagnosed
mental issues.
Um, you know, I, I always appreciate these kinds of, uh, novel analyses and there's probably
something to it because the guy definitely took some blows to the head on a number of
occasions, but the Hemingway family, they all killed themselves basically.
You know, this was something that was generational.
Yeah.
They call it a, like a, a hereditary issue.
No, I think his sister, multiple members of the family.
Yeah.
It's a, it's a, I don't know if I have always wondered if that's a self-fulfilling prophecy
or an underlying issue of, uh, of, you know, undiagnosed mental issues that are, that are
genetic.
And that in itself raises this question that's constantly, you know, throughout the book,
which is, uh, how much of this is just kind of how nature unfolds and how, how much of
this do I have an individual autonomy over?
And to what degree is my individual autonomy really autonomous?
To what degree must it cooperate with grace?
You know, the nice young boy named Manuel who brings me fish and questions that, well,
even for a tiny little book, I said it at the beginning of the episode, we could sit
here forever talking about it.
But I've already run extraordinarily late.
So Viva, thank you so much for being here.
My pleasure.
Thank you for having me.
We will have to do, I don't know, I would say we do part two on Old Man and the Sea,
but there are like a billion other Hemingway works.
So maybe.
Like I said to you before, like I read this, the first book I read beginning to end at
my parents' cottage up in Quebec.
And I've always been a fisherman and I read it and it's like, when I read it as a kid,
it was the dream of catching a fish so big it pulls you out to sea.
When I reread it as an adult, I read it with a different view.
But thank you for getting me to reread it again because it was beautiful.
I read it with my kid and he now, I wake up the morning after reading it to him and he
says, a man can be, a man can be destroyed, but not defeated.
Thank you for getting me to read it one time.
Thank all of you for encouraging me to read this book for the first time.
And we will see you next time on The Book Club.