儒 Confucianism Explained from East Asian Perspective (Ruism)

Ancient Asia - China
17 followers
Since quite a few people have asked me to explain what Confucianism is,
in this video, I'm going to answer a few of your frequently asked questions.
Okay, let's start with an easy one.
Is Confucianism a religion?
The short and simple answer is, no.
But the long and nuanced answer is, it depends on what you consider to be a religion.
The prime definition for religion in the Oxford English Dictionary is,
the belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power,
especially a personal god or gods.
But French sociologist Emile Durkheim defined religion as,
Using the second definition,
of course, Confucianism and a lot of other philosophies
which many people don't usually consider to be religions,
would also be categorized as one.
On the other hand, French philosopher Voltaire,
who advocated for the separation of church and state,
considered Confucius' philosophy and his emphasis on meritocracy,
a great model for a secular government.
The thing about Confucianism is that,
it provides a moral and ritual framework for the Chinese society.
But it leaves blank spaces for god and afterlife.
It doesn't prescribe what god should be worshipped.
So that's how Mahayana Buddhism and Taoism can co-exist in Imperial China.
In fact, Ming Dynasty Christian convert Xu Guangqi even said that,
The problem for the Christians, however,
is that the Confucian rituals of paying respect to one's parents
seem to resemble idolatry too closely for the Catholic Church.
And it kept flip-flopping whether they should ban it or not.
This dispute was called the Chinese Rights Controversy.
But since 1939, the Vatican had stuck with the decision
to let Chinese Catholics pay respect to their ancestors.
I will talk more about how Confucianism, Buddhism,
and Taoism could co-exist in the next episode.
As a side note, on other parts of the world,
there is a recent movement in the 20th century
that wanted to turn Confucianism into an actual religion.
It is a relatively small movement
that's mainly located in United States and Indonesia.
So what is Confucianism really?
Well, Confucianism is an English-language term
that had only existed since 1862,
used to describe the Chinese philosophical and scholarly traditions
that had spanned for over two and a half millennia.
This term comes from the Latinization of Kong Fuzi's name in the West.
Kong Fuzi is the most influential scholar and teacher
that had greatly shaped this tradition.
In China, however, this tradition is called ru.
It is not named after Confucius.
And in Japanese, it is named ju.
And in Korean, yu.
And Vietnamese, nho.
The character ru means scholar,
and it had been used since before Confucius's time.
And scholars who are part of this tradition are called ru jia.
Sinologists argued that the term Confucian
is likely to have been invented in the West
because of the misunderstanding
of the Jesuitist translation of Confucian texts,
which are not the most perfect translations themselves.
That is why nowadays,
sinologists are pushing to change the name back to ruism
to better reflect the tradition.
For this video, I will use the term ruism from now on.
It is true that Confucius is the most important sage of ruism.
Ruism is a living tradition that existed before his time
and evolved constantly past his death.
Confucius did not receive any revelation or words from gods.
He just promoted the ethics of the legendary rulers
of the first three Chinese dynasties and those before it,
especially Yao and Sun,
who gave their throne to the most meritorious man
instead of their own sons.
I covered this in a previous episode,
so check it out if you want more details.
And he also promoted the virtues of the nobles of the Zhou dynasty,
mainly the Duke of Zhou.
The Duke of Zhou was well known for his integrity.
He was the brother of the founder of the Zhou dynasty,
King Wu.
When his brother, King Wu died,
he could have seized power from his nephew anytime he wanted,
but he loyally served his nephew
and gave up power when the young king came of age.
The Duke of Zhou was credited with the establishment
of Chinese imperial bureaucracy,
rituals,
and feudal system.
The three fundamental bonds and five constant virtues
are brought up to represent the core rules principles.
The three bonds are
relationship between father and sons,
lord and retainer,
and husband and wife.
The five virtues are
benevolence,
righteousness,
propriety,
wisdom,
and trustworthiness.
But this list was only mentioned long after Confucius's death
during the Han dynasty by Dong Zhongshu.
Dong Zhongshu was a Rui scholar who promoted Ruism
to Emperor Han Wudi,
leading it to become the national philosophy of China.
As for the canons of Confucianism,
the four books and five classics
have actually evolved through time.
Before it became the five classics,
there were six classics.
It was traditionally believed
that they were edited and compiled by Confucius himself,
but they were mostly texts that had existed before him,
though some sections were his later editions.
The Classic of Poetry
is a collection of poems from early Zhou dynasty.
The Book of Documents
is a collection of speeches by the legendary emperors
Yao, Sun, Yu the Great
and other rulers of Xia, Shang, Zhou dynasties.
The Book of Rites
is an instruction on how to perform the rites of Zhou dynasty.
Yijing, the Book of Definition,
was attributed to King Wen of Zhou,
the father of the founder of Zhou dynasty.
The Spring and Autumn Annals
is a history of the state of Lu,
which is traditionally believed
to have been written by Confucius himself.
And the Book of Music
had been lost since Qin Shi Huang did a mass book burning
after he unified the Warring States China.
The four books was then added by Zhu Xi,
a Ruist scholar who lived during the Song dynasty.
And after his death,
it became the basic test subjects for imperial examinations.
The four books place stronger emphasis
on Confucius' own writing and thoughts.
Understandable,
since he was the most important Ruist philosopher after all.
There were major intellectual movements
to redefine the methods to attain moral clarity.
Zhu Xi from Song dynasty advocated
for the investigation of things
or various elements of an issue
in almost a quasi-scientific way.
But Wang Yangming from Ming dynasty
developed the idea of innate knowing,
arguing that the ultimate truth already existed in our minds.
All we had to do is to unclutter it from desires
so that it can be seen.
These various different schools of Ruism existed side by side
and they gained popularity and wane in different periods.
Even today, there are new Ruists
trying to redefine Ruism
into something that works for today's society.
Okay, now that we know that Ruism is a living tradition
redefined by the literati through time,
how did it actually spread into the masses?
There were no Ruist missionaries and church after all.
In imperial China,
it was really the imperial examination system that did that.
To advance in life,
many hopeful students studied the Confucian classics
in the hope of passing the examination
and getting employed as government officials.
Then, the knowledge just spread by osmosis,
through schooling and also literature and folk stories
with Ruist themes.
Eventually, it just became part of the mainstream Chinese culture.
It became similar to something like
cultural Jew, Muslim or Christian.
Lots of Chinese people practice Ruist rituals
just because it was part of their tradition.
Most Chinese people won't even know which passage
or which books the practice came from.
But then again, it is also a chicken and egg problem.
Since Ruism is derived out of ancient Chinese tradition,
it is hard to tell which one came first.
Recently, there is a bit of a revival in Ruist education
since the 1980s.
There was a small movement to repackage Ruist values
to be taught in mainland Chinese schools.
But some parents think that it is not enough.
And recently, wealthier families are sending their children
to specialized Ruist schools.
Additionally, Ruism on paper is sometimes very different
from the actual practice.
The Three Obediences and Four Virtues, for example,
is a set of moral principles created for women.
It said that after the death of her husband,
a woman must obey her son.
But I bet you that not a single Chinese son
would ever dare to imagine that they could
order a Chinese mom around.
Even 2,000 years ago, this is just unconscionable,
not to mention suicidal.
So that thing is more like a wishlist
rather than a lived reality.
When Ruism was imported to other countries,
such as Japan, Korea and Vietnam,
it was also adapted and recontextualized
according to the local customs.
Let's take Japan, for example.
I have covered this in more detail in a previous video.
But just to summarize,
during the Sakoku or Japan's isolationist period,
the Kokugaku intellectual movement
reframed Japan's own historical figures
to be their moral exemplars
instead of the ancient Chinese kings.
Look, it is practically impossible
to understand all of East Asia
by just learning about Confucianism,
just like how it is impossible to learn about Europe
by just understanding the history of the church.
But it is a good starting point.
On the next episode, I will talk about
how Confucianism, Buddhism and Taoism
coexisted peacefully in ancient China.
So if you don't want to miss it, then subscribe.
If you like what we're doing,
then you can also support us on Patreon.
Until next time, stay cool, my bros.
