Japanese History: The Nara Period Pt. 2 (Japanese History: The Textbook

Ancient Asia - China
17 followers
In the Great Buddha Hall of Todai-ji Temple in Nara stands the colossal bronze statue known as
the Nara Daibutsu, a symbol of Japan worldwide and a must-see destination for any first-time
visitor to the country. For many, it is little more than a photo-op, a place to check off their
Japan bucket list. But behind this massive monument is the tale of a nation in turmoil,
an emperor wracked by anxiety about his country's future, and the countless individuals,
both highborn and low, who shed their blood, sweat, and tears to put that anxiety to rest.
Join me today as we make our final dive into Japan's short but dramatic Nara period,
exploring the era's unique places and events, and meeting its colorful cast of characters
in all their ambitious, scheming, and rebellious glory.
You're watching Japanese History The Textbook, and this is the Buyuuden Japanese History Channel.
Hello everyone, welcome back to Japanese History The Textbook,
the series where we make our way chronologically through Japanese history,
focusing on the people, events, and themes emphasized by Japanese language educational
materials made for Japanese kids and teens learning their own country's history.
This is part 7 of the series as a whole, and part 2 of our look at the 8th century era known as the
Nara period, so if you are new to the channel, I suggest that you at least backtrack to the
previous video to get yourself caught up. I'd like to extend a warm welcome to all the new
people who have subscribed to the channel recently, as well as my continuing gratitude
to everyone who's been on board for a while now. If you are not subscribed but you're liking what
you see, then please don't hesitate to hit that subscribe button, and if you enjoy the video then
please give it a like and maybe even drop a comment for the YouTube algorithm. Alright,
I've got nothing else of particular note to say today, so let's get right into the video.
On our last episode, we saw the rise to power of Fujiwara no Fushito,
the son of the Asuka period politician Nakatomi no Kamatari, and a key player in the creation of
Japan's first two Ritsuryô law codes. Fushito was the man pulling the strings behind the throne
during the early Nara period, after the move to the new capital of Heijô-kyô,
colloquially known as Nara. But after his death, the top spot was once again up for grabs.
The power vacuum was initially filled by the royal family member Prince Nagaya,
who attempted to encourage new land development out in the provinces by temporarily permitting
the private ownership of land, a move that achieved its goal but simultaneously undermined
the central government's fundamental philosophy that all land in the country was the property of
the state. Prince Nagaya was eventually overthrown by the late Fushito's four sons, known collectively
as the Fujiwara Yonkyôdai, or the Four Fujiwara Brothers, who maneuvered to get their non-royal
sister Kômyô-shi installed as the empress consort of the reigning tenô, Emperor Shômu.
The Fujiwara brothers seemed poised to begin a glorious age of political dominance,
but less than ten years after their kureta, all four of them were wiped out by a smallpox plague
which was sweeping through Japan at the time. The Fujiwara clan were influential,
but they had not yet established a total stranglehold on Japan's political world,
and much like what had happened with the death of Fujiwara no Fushito and the rise of Prince Nagaya,
the untimely deaths of the four brothers saw a new anti-Fujiwara political force emerge in
their wake. Stepping to the forefront on this occasion was a man named Tachibana no Moroe,
a branch member of the imperial family and the older half-brother of the new empress consort
Kômyô-shi, with whom he shared the same mother. Notably, he did not share the same father with
the empress consort, making him completely unrelated to the Fujiwara and thus quite
uninterested in helping them at all with their political goals. Rather, Moroe employed two men
who had recently returned to Japan from Tang China, where they had spent close to two decades
studying the government, culture, and religion there. These men were the monk Genbô and the
learned aristocrat Kibi no Makibi, the latter of whom was so renowned for his intellect that later
generations came to view him as almost akin to a wizard, and Heian period illustrations depict
him performing such miraculous feats as flying in the sky and manipulating demons. With the help of
these two men, Tachibana no Moroe hoped to steer Japan's new ritsuryô system in a direction closer
to that of the original blueprint laid in Tang China, with particular emphasis placed on
hamstringing the Fujiwara clan so that the emperor could take his rightful place as the supreme and
absolute leader of government. Let's step back for a moment and talk about Japan's relationship
with Tang China during this period. You will recall that, during the time of Prince Shôtoku
way back in the early 600s, Japan had sent several embassies called Kenzushi to China's Sui dynasty,
both to establish diplomatic relations and to learn from the example of the culturally
sophisticated Chinese. When the short-lived Sui dynasty fell in 618 and the Tang dynasty
arose in its place, Japan continued to send scholarly embassies, now called Kentôshi,
throughout the mid-7th century. However, with Japan's military clash against the Tang-Silla
alliance at the Battle of Bekkan aka Hakuson-Kô in 663, the relationship between the two countries
became somewhat awkward, and Kentôshi embassies effectively stopped for the next 40 or so years.
By the beginning of the 8th century, though, the two countries had repaired their relationship,
and in 702, embassies resumed and continued periodically thereafter for close to another
200 years. Early embassies had adopted a relatively safe route of travel,
hugging the western coast of the Korean peninsula until making landfall in China,
but as a result of the soured relations with the Silla kingdom in Korea,
embassies from the 700s on were forced to cut directly across the East China Sea,
a perilous route which often resulted in shipwrecks and disasters.
As such, those who successfully made it to China typically stayed for several years,
if not decades, and there is even the famous case of one Abe no Nakamaro who became a high-ranking
bureaucrat in the Tang government and ended up staying in China permanently.
Getting back to Japan, there were naturally some individuals in the political world who were
less than thrilled with Tachibana no Moroe's administration and his recruitment of the Tang
embassy returnees, Kibi no Makibi and Genbo. Chief among these was Fujiwara no Hirotsugu,
son of one of the four Fujiwara brothers, Fujiwara no Umakai.
Hirotsugu was at this time serving in a bureaucratic position in the Dazaifu in Kyushu,
already amply at arm's length from the halls of power in the capital, and he saw Tachibana no
Moroe's favoring of non-Fujiwara advisors as a direct attempt to oust his family from their
perch at the top of the political totem pole. In the year 740, in an effort to have Kibi no
Makibi and Genbo removed from their influential new roles in the government, Hirotsugu raised an
army in Kyushu in rebellion against the central government in Nara. Faced with this sudden
military threat, the government, not unnaturally, dispatched their own army, and the two forces
ultimately met in battle, with Hirotsugu's force being defeated and the man himself being executed
shortly thereafter. Despite the rebellion being successfully extinguished, it was the largest
internal military conflict since the Jinshin War, and it rocked not only Japan's political world,
but also the psychological state of the country's sovereign, Emperor Shomu.
Shomu's reign had by now seen several dramatic and worrisome episodes, beginning with the Prince
Nagaya incident in 729, and continuing on with the smallpox epidemic that ravaged the country in the
30s, and now this most recent rebellion in Kyushu. Emperor Shomu abandoned the new city of Heijokyo
and began frantically transitioning his base of operations, moving through three different
capitals in the span of five years before finally returning to Heijokyo in 745.
We don't know exactly what the Emperor's reasoning behind his actions here was, but it seems clear
that he was in a state of great unease, and it was during this phase of rapid capital jumping
that he issued the two imperial decrees that would become the legacy by which he is remembered
today. The first of these decrees, the Kokubunji Konryū no Mikotonori, ordered the construction
of special Buddhist temples and convents throughout Japan, and was based on a type of
thinking called Jingo-Kokka, basically the concept of relying on the power of Buddhism to bring peace
and safety to the country. In his decree, the Emperor was strikingly modest and even self-deprecating,
and we get something of a glimpse at both his character and his mental state in its wording.
Its opening lines are as follows.
Despite the fact that I am poor in virtue, I have come into this position of most heavy
responsibility which is the office of Emperor. I am as of yet unable to guide my people,
and I am beset by shame day and night. As of late, the crop yield has been poor,
and disease has been spreading, and it is to my disgrace that these are the result of my
virtuelessness, and I do nothing but torture myself with guilt. Therefore,
I have decided that I wish to pursue widespread happiness for all my people.
The temples which Emperor Shōmu ordered constructed were to be called Konkōmyō
Shiten no Gokoku no Tera, and the nunneries were to be called Hokke-Metsuzai no Tera,
but today we refer to them as Kokubunji and Kokubun-Niji respectively. They were built
throughout Japan in close proximity to each province's kokuga, its administrative headquarters,
and the combined presence of both institutions led these areas to become both the political
and cultural centers of their respective provinces. While the Emperor's decree itself
was issued in 741, it is thought that the process of constructing the various temples was carried
out over the next half century or so, with many not being completed until near the end of the
Nara Period. Temple building in this era was the cutting edge of high technology,
and it is said that the imperial court even began selling bureaucratic offices to individuals who
gave large donations to aid in the costly construction efforts. The Emperor chose
particular Buddhist scriptures which aligned with the aforementioned chingo-gokuka concept,
and he directed that the monks and nuns staffing the temples should spend their days copying and
scriptures. He believed that if they did this properly, Japan would be pacified and protected
by the various guardian gods of Buddhism, such as the Shiten-no, who were, by the way,
also a popular subject for sculpture in this era. Not just anyone could become a monk or nun
in the Kokubunji and Kokubun-Niji temples, but rather there was a strict licensing system
overseen by the central government. This was due to the fact that Buddhist clergy were exempt from
the various heavy taxes to which the general population was subject, and there was thus an
overabundance of people hoping to join their ranks simply to escape taxation. The widespread
existence of unsanctioned monks was actually a major social problem during this era, and the
government was quite severe in its punishment of these individuals when they were caught.
The second decree which Emperor Shomu issued during his years of capital hopping was the
decree which ordered the construction of what we know today as the Nara Daibutsu.
This decree was essentially an extension of its predecessor, with the creation of the giant Buddha
statue being yet another step in the plan to bring peace to Japan through the power of Buddhism.
It is said that Shomu had been greatly impressed by a Rushanna Buddha statue that he had seen
while on an imperial visit to the province of Kawachi, with this statue having been built
thanks to the numerous small donations of that temple's parishioners. Shomu thus resolved to
recreate this situation on a national scale, and he stated in his decree that even the smallest
donation, from a blade of grass to a pinch of soil, would be permitted if it was given in
contribution to the statue's construction. However, he also warned his provincial governors and their
district managers that they were by no means to force their peasants to donate. Despite these
bold statements, the Daibutsu's creation would prove to be no mean feat, taking nearly 10 years
to complete and requiring a massive number of donors, technicians, and laborers. In order to
drum up support for the project, the emperor famously relied on a man named Gyōki, an itinerant
monk who had built up great renown with the common people of Japan through years of traveling the
country carrying out quality-of-life-improving public works projects. The actual construction
of the statue was carried out in fundamentally the same manner as any bronze statue of the time.
A rough, basic shape was first constructed out of clay, and this was then covered in wax,
which would be sculpted into a prototype version of the statue. This was then covered in a second
layer of clay, and the entire thing was fired, hardening the clay, melting away the wax,
and leaving a cavity into which molten metal could be poured. After the metal was poured
and had cooled, the outer layer of fired clay was chipped away, and what remained was the finished
bronze statue. In the case of the Nara Daibutsu, the finished product would be about 16 meters,
or 52 and a half feet tall, so the process which I just described was carried out in eight parts,
rather than doing the entire statue in one go. The completed statue weighed 380 tons and was
plated in gold from top to bottom, and it was housed in a special hall called the Daibutsuden,
which was constructed in the temple complex of Todai-ji in Heijo-kyo. Todai-ji served as the
head temple of the nationwide Kokubunji temples, and it still houses the Daibutsu statue today,
though both temple and statue have seen numerous repairs and rebuilds. This name, Daibutsu, by the
way, is just a Japanese word meaning large Buddha, and it is used in reference to a myriad of
statues throughout Japan. The name of the actual Buddha represented by the statue is Rushanabutsu,
a celestial being held to be the origin point of the universe, whose divine light illuminates all
creation. When the statue was finally finished in 752, its kaigen-kuyo ceremony, literally its
eye-opening ceremony, where its eyes were painted in and its soul was believed to enter the statue,
was carried out on a grandiose scale. In attendance were Emperor Shomu, by now retired,
as well as his wife Komyoshi and his successor, the new Empress Koken. Song and dance was performed,
and the eyes of the statue were painted in by an Indian monk named Bodai Senna,
while 10,000 monks chanted Buddhist sutras around him.
The year after the completion of the Nara Daibutsu saw the arrival in Japan of the Chinese
monk Ganjin, a renowned holy man in his own country, who possessed the qualifications to
administer ordination rites to those wishing to enter the clergy. During this era, no such
monk yet resided in Japan, as the country was still, on the whole, relatively new to the Buddhist
faith. This was a problem, however, because, as we previously discussed, Japan was striving
earnestly around this time to set up an official system for those wishing to become monks and nuns.
Emperor Shomu had actually sent two monks to China in search of such a qualified individual
way back in the early 730s, but it had taken them a good nine years to encounter Ganjin,
and it then took him another eleven years to actually make it over to Japan.
His successful crossing to the archipelago was actually his sixth such attempt, as both Tang
law and the treacherous path across the East China Sea made the voyage highly challenging,
and he had completely gone blind in both his eyes by the time that he made it over.
Nevertheless, upon his arrival, he promptly constructed an ordination platform at Todai-ji
Temple and ordained some 400 believers, including Empress Kouken and the retired Emperor Shomu
themselves. He went on to construct two more platforms, one in Kanto and the other in Kyushu,
and then built his own temple, Toshodai-ji, in Heijo-kyo, which became the headquarters from
which he founded the Risshū school of Buddhism. Risshū was one of six Buddhist sects which burst
onto the scene in Japan during the Nara period, the others being Hossō-shū, Kegon-shū, Sanron-shū,
Jōjitsu-shū, and Kusha-shū. They are collectively known as the Nantoroku-shū,
or the Six Schools of Nara Buddhism, and they were all based in the capital of Heijo-kyo.
They differed from later Buddhist sects in that they were less religious denominations and more
so scholarly research circles dedicated to the study of Buddhist scripture, and they would go on
to become deeply entrenched in the political scene in the capital. Before we move on to the new
Empress Kouken's reign, we must briefly discuss one more very important development that occurred
while Emperor Shomu was pursuing his great religious projects. This was the passage in 743
of a law called the Konden-einen-shizai-no-hou. This law was the natural extension of the Sanzei-shin-no-hou
which we discussed in our last episode, a law which, you will recall, permitted the private
ownership of land for up to three generations to those who newly opened it up for cultivation.
The new law, however, took this to the extreme, waiving the time limit completely and allowing
permanent ownership of land to those willing to go out and claim it from the wilderness,
albeit with some minor restrictions. While this law was probably created to encourage support for
the Emperor's ambitious projects, it was the final straw in completely undermining the old
public land system envisioned in the Taika Reform Decree nearly a century earlier. Time and resource
rich aristocrats and religious establishments quickly took advantage of the new situation,
employing runaway farmers as workers to reclaim new land and create the beginnings of vast private
estates. The existence of these estates, known to history as shô-en, would go on to drastically
shape the course of Japanese history. The aforementioned Empress Kôken was the daughter
of Emperor Shômu, and she ascended to the throne after her father's retirement in 749.
As we have seen with many emperors, particularly the female ones, it was common to have powerful
bureaucrat advisors behind the curtain who were entrusted with the actual running of the day-to-day
affairs of government. In the case of Empress Kôken, this advisor was one of Fujiwara no Nakamaro,
son of Fujiwara no Muchimaro, another one of the late Fujiwara brothers. Nakamaro rose high
in the government thanks to the backing of Empress Kôken's mother, the retired Empress Consort Kômyô
aka Kômyôshi, who, as you will recall, originally came from the Fujiwara clan. Kômyôshi naturally
wanted to make sure that, when her daughter came to the throne, it would be her family members
pulling the strings behind the scenes. In 756, the retired Emperor Shômu died, and in the power
vacuum he left behind, Fujiwara no Nakamaro's political influence grew even greater. Tachibana
no Moroe, the imperial relative and statesman who we discussed at the beginning of this episode,
was still around at this time, but an inappropriate statement he made at a drinking party led to him
being falsely suspected of treason and retiring from politics. Completely independent from this,
Moroe's son actually was plotting treason against the central government, hoping to overthrow
Nakamaro and force Empress Kôken into retirement so that she could be replaced with his own preferred
candidate. Unfortunately for him, this plot leaked prematurely, and he and his co-conspirators were
arrested and jailed in 757. While they did officially get their death sentences commuted
by the Empress, they all seemed to have died incidentally after some lengthy torture ordered
by Nakamaro. With Moroe's retirement and his son's ignominious death, the Tachibana clan's
influence in the central government was thoroughly extinguished, and Nakamaro stood relatively
unchallenged at the top of the political totem pole. One significant action which Nakamaro would
undertake during his time in power was to implement the Yôrô Ritsuryô law code created by his
grandfather, Fujiwara no Fushitô. While the code had been legally enacted in 718, it had never
actually been put into effect due to Fushitô's death and the emergence of the various anti-Fujiwara
government actors like Prince Nagaya. Nakamaro's rise to the top allowed the code to finally be
dusted off and brought out into the light of day. By the next year, 758, Nakamaro and the
sitting ruler Empress Kôken were no longer getting on as well as they once had, and so Nakamaro used
his massive political influence to force the Empress into retirement and have her replaced by
a new ruler, Emperor Junnin. Junnin came from a slightly different line of descent than the
last few emperors, being the grandson of Emperor Tenmu through his son Prince Toneri, the man who,
as you will recall, was the author of the Nihon Shoki. With the throne occupied by a new ruler
friendly to his ambitions, everything seemed to be going according to plan for Fujiwara no Nakamaro,
but right at this moment misfortune struck. Nakamaro's biggest backer, the retired Empress
consort Kômyôshi, passed away. Right around this time, the ruler whom Nakamaro had just pushed out
of power, the retired Empress Kôken, had begun to heavily favor a Buddhist monk named Dôkyô,
claiming that he had miraculously cured her of disease. The retired Empress still held plenty
of influence in her own right, and without her mother to keep the situation in check,
she and Dôkyô came to butt heads with Nakamaro and his new puppet emperor Junnin.
This tension came to a head in the year 764, when Emperor Junnin criticized Kôken's adoring
patronage of Dôkyô, and the retired Empress responded by stripping Junnin of his duties,
and declaring that she would henceforth carry out the affairs of government.
Nakamaro was naturally quite alarmed by this development, and he began formulating a plot to
seize control of the state's military apparatus, and use it to take back his and Emperor Junnin's
power. However, as seems to be a recurring theme here, Nakamaro's plan was leaked before it could
be put into action, and he was forced to flee to Ōmi province, where he raised an army and
attempted to set up yet another imperial prince as emperor. Ex-Empress Kôken sent her own army
after Nakamaro, choosing, interestingly, to put it under the command of the now 70-year-old Kibi
no Makibi, who had still managed to retain his reputation for shrewdness after all this time.
After some cat and mouse, the two armies finally clashed at Mionosaki on the western coast of Lake
Biwa, where Nakamaro was defeated, captured, and executed along with his entire family.
This conflict is known today as the Rebellion of Emi no Oshikatsu, after the new name, Emi no Oshikatsu,
which Emperor Junnin bestowed upon Nakamaro during the peak of his power. In the rebellion's aftermath,
Emperor Junnin was officially removed from the office of emperor and exiled to the island
province of Awaji in the Seto Inland Sea, dying just a year later at the age of 33.
To replace him, Ex-Empress Kôken came out of her nominal retirement and re-ascended to the office
which she had never wanted to leave in the first place, taking the throne under the new name of
Empress Shôtoku. As we discussed back in episode 5, she's the second of only two Japanese emperors,
or empresses rather, to have ever sat on the imperial throne twice, an act known in Japanese
as chôsô. With the empress, who I will refer to as Shôtoku from here on, back at the government's
helm, the monk Dôkyô only continued to expand his influence in the imperial court. It seems quite
likely that he had in fact become the empress's lover, and in 765 he was promoted to the position
a unique post never seen before or after in history, which put a Buddhist religious spin
on the position of Chancellor of the Realm. The post doesn't seem to have a consistent English
translation, but one which I simply like the ring of is First Minister and Master of Meditation.
In that same year, Dôkyô used his newfound authority to issue a decree banning the cultivation
of new farmland by anyone other than temples or shrines, setting up the country's religious
establishments to gain a significant economic advantage over their secular peers. Just when
it seemed that he couldn't grow any more powerful and influential, the empress promoted him yet
again in 766, giving him the title of Hôô, which translates to something like Buddhist King.
The thinking behind this new position was that Dôkyô would reign over the religious world
while Empress Shôtoku ruled the secular one. Perhaps his latest promotion had kicked his
ambitions into overdrive, or perhaps he just knew that his position was precarious as long
as he was relying on the empress's favor, but either way, it seems likely that it was around
this time that Dôkyô began to set his sights on the ultimate prize, the office of emperor itself.
In 769, an oracle was issued by the Usajingu Shrine of Bizen province, which declared that
making Dôkyô emperor of Japan would bring peace and stability to the country. It is widely accepted
today that Dôkyô himself was behind this prophecy, but in the highly superstitious culture of Nara
period Japan, such an oracle held great weight and the imperial court was thrown into an uproar.
Torn between her faith in her beloved Dôkyô and her reluctance to allow a non-royal to sit
on the imperial throne, the empress dispatched the aristocrat and civil servant Wake no Kiyomaro
to the shrine to double-check the oracle's authenticity, and he returned with the message
that the original oracle had been mistaken. Kiyomaro's reward for a job well done was to
have an angry Dôkyô force him to change his name to Kitana Maro, which basically means
This did, however, mark the end of Dôkyô's delusions of grandeur, as the empress died of
disease the following year and, without her to protect him, he himself was promptly exiled off
into the boondocks by his political opponents. Wake no Kiyomaro was allowed to return to the
capital, and he was remembered by future generations as something of a hero, the man
who had prevented the Japanese imperial throne from being usurped by a crooked monk,
and his popularity has persisted until the modern era, with his face even making it on to Japan's
pre-World War II ten-yen bill. Most importantly, once Dôkyô was gone, his law restricting new
land cultivation to religious establishments was promptly repealed, and Japan's aristocracy could
breathe a collective sigh of relief. They could finally get back to building up their own
independent financial bases out in the provinces, an activity which was growing particularly
profitable for our old friends the Fujiwara clan. Before we end this video, I'd like to briefly
touch on the art and culture of the Nara period, which is typically referred to as tempyô-bunka
or tempyô culture. This cultural flowering was focused around the reign of Emperor Shômu,
and was heavily influenced by cultural artifacts brought back from Tang China by the Kentoshi
embassies. These artifacts included not only Chinese items, but also items from the various
countries along the Silk Road, such as India and Persia. Emperor Shômu in particular was an avid
collector of such items, and upon his death his widow Kômyôshi donated his collection to Tôdaiji
temple, where they were housed in the Shôsôin repository. The collection contained such famous
artifacts as the radenshitan no gogenbiwa, a five-stringed lute elaborately decorated with
mother-of-pearl, and the torigeritsujôbyôbu, a folding screen depicting slightly plump,
thick-eyebrowed women, whose traits would have been classic markers of beauty in Tang dynasty China.
The Shôsôin itself is actually a prime example of Nara period architecture, being built in the
style of azekura zukuri, which piles up geometrically cut logs such that they interlock
at the corners and create a sort of sawtooth pattern. The Nara period was also the era when
bronze Buddhist statues began to be superseded by those made out of clay, called sozô, or those
made out of hardened and lacquered cloth, called kanshutsuzô. A representative example of the
former is Kôfuku-ji temple's six-armed, three-faced ashura statue, with its beautiful and youthful
features that differ ever so slightly from face to face. A prime example of the latter is the
which stands 360 centimeters tall, nearly 12 feet, and strikes quite an imposing figure.
Finally, the rugged old monk Ganjin, who we discussed earlier, is said to have brought over
the first wooden Buddhist statuary to Japan, and this style of sculpture would go on to become the
one most commonly seen in later eras due to the easy accessibility of wood as a material.
Well, my friends, we have done it. We have managed to close out the Nara period without
going into a third episode. We do still technically have about two decades left before the era
concludes, but I think we can safely consider this stretch of time to be a run-up of sorts
to our next topic, the iconic Heian period. I am almost positive that we will not complete this
one in two episodes, but I suppose we'll just have to wait and see how things go. Regardless,
I'm quite excited to get into it, as the Heian period is one I've been looking forward to doing
since creating this channel. Anyway, if you enjoyed the video, please do like, subscribe,
and share, and if you're interested in seeing a Japanese mnemonic for remembering the date of the
Nara Daibutsu's completion, then stay tuned, because I'll have that popping up at the end
As always, thanks for watching, have a great day, and HOOOYOLAZ!
