State Supreme Court Votes 5-0 for 6-Week Abortion Ban

Facts Matter
2.9K followers
🇺🇸 Try The Epoch Times here: https://ept.ms/RomanSale
📱 Switch to Patriot Mobile: https://ept.ms/46jIA6Z
Episode Resources:
🔵 State Supreme Court Decision:
https://bit.ly/43r23D0
🔵 Georgia Law:
https://bit.ly/3ZyfWOt
🔵 Map of Abortion Laws:
https://bit.ly/3FoqjO8
-
#southcarolina #abortionlaw #factsmatter
© All Rights Reserved.
And now let's move on over to the state
of South Carolina where their state
supreme court just issued an important
ruling on the topic of abortion.
Specifically, you had the South Carolina
state supreme court vote 5 to zero
unanimously to uphold the state's 6-w
week abortion ban. This ruling of
theirs, it came as a response to a
challenge of the law on the books by
Planned Parenthood. And this ruling in
South Carolina, it actually represents a
great microcosm of what's happening
throughout the whole country in regards
to the topic of abortion. And so let's
go through what's happening throughout
the whole country through the lens of
South Carolina. And to start with, let
me just briefly set the stage for you.
In 2022, once Row versus Wade was
overturned at the federal level by the
US Supreme Court, the question of
whether or not abortion was legal was
returned back down to the individual
states. And different states went in
very different directions. Some states
moved to ban abortions entirely. Some
other states though they expanded access
to abortion with some states even going
so far as to enshrine the right to an
abortion in their state constitution.
And so let me put up a map up on your
screen which will show you the abortion
laws that are currently on the books
throughout the whole country which is
again roughly 3 years after Row versus
Wade was overturned. And I will quickly
mention two things before I show you the
map. One is that we're filming this
episode right now sort of at the end of
May 2025. And this map is accurate right
now, but it might change in the near
future. And then secondly, I do hope if
you appreciate content like this, which
takes sometimes a long time to compile
together, you do smash those like and
subscribe buttons so that this video can
reach ever more people via the YouTube
algorithm. And now without further ado,
let's go through the maps. Before 2022,
you had the entire map of the country
basically just be one color. All states
had abortion legalized due to that
Supreme Court decision which stated
basically that there's a constitutional
right to privacy which envelops the
right to an abortion. However, after Row
versus Wade was overturned, the map
instantly fragmented. Here's what it
looks like now. You have states like
Texas, Oklahoma, Louisiana, and several
other states throughout the country
where abortion is basically illegal with
very few exceptions. Those few
exceptions uh differ from state to
state, but they include things like
either danger to the mother's health, uh
pregnancy due to rape or incest, or some
type of fetal abnormality that's
detected in the womb. But in almost all
cases, in those particular states,
abortion is illegal. Then you have one
state, North Dakota, where abortion is
legal, but there are no abortion
providers within the state. Now, there's
a historical reason for why that is.
Basically, after Row versus Wade was
overturned, North Dakota had something
known as a trigger law, which went right
into effect after that Supreme Court
decision was overturned. And that law
effectively banned almost all abortions
in the state. That forced the only
abortion clinic in North Dakota to
immediately move out of the state.
However, since then, that trigger law
was actually deemed unconstitutional by
a state judge, meaning that in a
practical sense, abortions are legal in
that state, but there are just no
clinics there available. Then, moving
on, we've got several states where
abortion is legal up until the point of
cardiac cell activity. These states have
what are known as fetal heartbeat laws
on the books, making it illegal to
perform an abortion after a doctor using
an ultrasound can detect a heartbeat.
and that usually occurs at the 6 week
mark. Then moving along, you have
another two states which allow abortion
up until the 12th week of pregnancy.
Utah allows abortions up until the 18th
week of pregnancy. Other states allow
abortion up until the 22nd week of
pregnancy, which is the 5 month mark.
Then you have a bunch of other states
where abortion is legal up until the
point of fetal viability. And that's the
point where the baby is believed to be
able to survive by itself outside of the
mother's womb. Now, it's hard to exactly
pin down where that point is, but most
people agree it occurs sometime between
the 23rd and the 24th week of pregnancy,
which then ties into another batch of
states that allow abortion up until the
24th week of pregnancy, which is 5 1/2
months. Then you have Virginia and
Massachusetts, which both allow
abortions up through the second
trimester. And then lastly, you have a
significant batch of states that allow
abortions at any stage of the pregnancy
up until the very end. And so putting
all those colors up on the map together,
this, as you can see up on your screen,
is the current fragmented state of
abortion here in America in May of 2025,
which then perfectly brings us back to
our main topic of discussion, which is
South Carolina. The state law that they
have on the books is called the Fetal
Heartbeat Protection from Abortion Act.
And just like the other states that we
mentioned on that map, it says that
abortions cannot be performed after an
ultrasound can detect quote cardiac
activity or the steady and repetitive
rhythmic contraction of the fetal heart
within the gestational sack. And that
cardiac activity begins at a
biologically identifiable moment in
time, normally when the fetal heart is
formed in the gestational sack. And then
later on in the text to give it a bit
more of a plain English meaning they
mentioned that this type of cardiac
activity usually occurs at roughly the
6th week mark after conception. Now
Planned Parenthood they filed a lawsuit
against the state of South Carolina
arguing that the language in this
particular law isn't clear.
Specifically, Planned Parenthood was
making the argument that there is an
ambiguity to the definition of fetal
heartbeat and they quote urged the court
to define it as when the four chambers
of the heart are formed, which is
usually around 17 to 20 weeks as opposed
to the 6 weeks set forth in the BAM.
Basically, their argument is that the
definition of fetal heartbeat within the
context of the statute isn't exactly
clear. And according to them, meaning
according to Planned Parenthood, a
better stoppage point would be when the
four chambers of the baby's heart are
formed, which typically happens in the
17 to 20 week range rather than the 6
week mark currently on the law. In their
case, it made it all the way up to the
state supreme court who just earlier
this month ruled against them.
Specifically, in a 5 to zero decision,
meaning a unanimous decision, the court
decided to uphold the state's six-w week
abortion ban. And what's interesting
about this particular ruling is that the
justices on the state supreme court,
they agreed that the medical language in
the statute was vague. However, the
justices also noted that both the
opponents of the law, the people who are
against the law, as well as the
supporters of the law, both of these two
groups, they both believe that this law
stops abortion from being legal after
the 6 week mark. Meaning that everyone
involved with this law understood what
it meant when it was passed. All right,
just to pause here for a super quick
moment. I'd like to introduce our
longtime sponsor, Patriot Mobile. They
are a great company who has for years
now bridged the gap for Americans who
want great cell service, but who also
believe in faith, family, and freedom.
And so, here's a question. Have you
switched to Patriot Mobile yet? And if
not, well, consider doing so. You'll get
exceptional nationwide coverage because
unlike most other cell phone service
providers, Patriot Mobile utilizes all
three major US networks. And so by
switching today, you'll not only be
working with a company that actually
supports your values, but you will not
be sacrificing quality or service. They
can even add two numbers on two
different networks on one single phone.
So it's like carrying two phones in one
if you need that type of thing. They
have unlimited data plans. They have
mobile hotspots. They have international
roaming. They have internet on the- go
devices, internet backup. Also,
switching is super easy. You can keep
your phone, you can keep your number, or
you can upgrade. Either way, their
customer service team is based 100% in
the US. And so, it's easy. You can get
up and running in minutes. And best of
all, switching to Patriot Mobile
supports your values. If you believe in
the first and second amendments, if you
believe in the sanctity of life, in
supporting our veterans, well, this is
where you belong. And so head on over to
patrimobile.com/roman or call 972
patatriot. You can get a free month of
service if you use the promo code Roman.
So switch today. Go either to
patrimobile.com/roman or call the number
on your screen. I'll also throw
everything down into the description box
below. And again, if you use promo code
Roman, Roman, you can get a free month
of service. In writing for the majority
of the South Carolina State Supreme
Court, you had Justice John Fu write the
following quote. Not one of the terms of
the general assembly used in the
definition. Not cardiac activity, nor
steady, repetitive, rhythmic,
contraction, fetal heart, nor even
justational sack is a precise medically
defined term. However, the court has
counted at least 60 separate instances
during the 2023 legislative session in
which a member of the House or Senate
referred to the 2023 act as a six-week
ban on abortion. We could find not one
instance during the entire 2023
legislative session in which anyone
connected in any way to the general
assembly frame the act as banning
abortion after approximately 9 weeks.
While we do not frame our holding today
in the shorthand terms of a number of
weeks, the biologically identifiable
moment in time we hold is the fetal
heartbeat under the 2023 act occurs in
most instances at approximately 6 weeks
of pregnancy. And as such, Planned
Parenthood lost the case, which as you
could imagine, they were not thrilled
with. Shortly after this ruling was
handed down, you had the CEO of Planned
Parenthood's South Atlantic chapter
released the following statement. Quote,
"Justice did not prevail today, and the
people of South Carolina are paying the
price. People have been forced to carry
pregnancies against their will, suffered
life-threatening infections, and died as
a direct result of this abortion ban."
And so, that's Planned Parenthood. On
the other hand, you had the Republican
governor of South Carolina, Mr. Henry
McMaster, hailing this decision as
quote, "another clear and decisive
victory that will ensure the lives of
countless unborn children remain
protected and that South Carolina
continues to lead the charge in
defending the sanctity of life." And so,
there you have it. South Carolina will
continue to remain a sixweek abortion
ban state into the foreseeable future.
If you'd like to read either this state
supreme court decision or if you'd like
to actually play with an interactive map
of the current state of abortion
throughout the country, I'll throw those
resources down into the description box
below if you'd like to dig into the
weeds. And all I ask in return is that
if you haven't already, please take a
quick moment to smash those like and
subscribe buttons so that this video can
reach ever more people via the YouTube
algorithm. And then until next time, I'm
your host Roman from the Epic Times.
Stay informed. Most importantly, stay
free.
