'Comtesse d’Haussonville' (1845) by J.-A.-D. Ingres

Academic Art (c.1820–1900)
10 followers
13 Video Views·May 22, 2025
Curator Aimee Ng explores the history behind one of the audience favorites at the Frick, Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres’s “Comtesse d’Haussonville.” Sometimes referred to as the “poster girl” of The Frick Collection, the subject of this celebrated portrait led a fascinating life, taking piano lessons from Chopin and writing biographies of Lord Byron and the Irish revolutionary Robert Emmet.
Hello, I'm Amy Ng, curator at The Frick Collection in New York,
and welcome to another episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
In this episode, I have the pleasure of talking to you about one of the most beloved paintings
at The Frick, and that is Ingres's portrait of Louise de Broglie. It's spelled de Broglie,
but it is pronounced de Broglie, better known as the Comtesse d'Aussanville.
Although, technically, when this portrait was painted, signed 1845, she was still Viscountess.
It wasn't until the year later, 1846, when her father-in-law passed away, that she became
the Countess, Comtesse d'Aussanville. She's been referred to as the poster girl of
The Frick Collection, and she's certainly been a cover girl. The very first color photograph
of her was taken, of this painting was taken, along with a number of other works in The Frick
Collection, for a special issue of Life magazine, an early issue in 1937.
Although the painter, Ingres, and his subject, Louise de Broglie, are both very French,
and in fact, this painting has been referred to as one of the greatest portraits of 19th century
France, she was born in Switzerland. In fact, she was buried there and spent a lot of her life
there. In order to pay some tribute to her Swiss origins and her Swiss roots,
I chose for the cocktail today one that is centered around absinthe. Absinthe is a spirit
of very, very high alcoholic content that was invented in Switzerland in the middle of the
18th century. It's called the Green Fairy sometimes because of its green color. It contains
wormwood, Artemisia absinthium, which is where it gets its name, and it has a green tinge to it
because of the green anise and the sweet fennel that are also part of the concoction. Absinthe
gained a pretty bad reputation over the course of the 19th century and into the early 20th century.
It was thought to cause madness and hallucination, and for these behavioral things, really myths
about its ability to change a person's personality, absinthe was banned in a number
of countries in the early 20th century. Even in its place of invention in Switzerland, it was
banned. For about 100 years, it was not legal again in Switzerland until 2005. The cocktail
today is called a Jaded Countess. It's an ounce of absinthe, half an ounce of vodka, some fresh
lemon juice, simple syrup, strained and topped with champagne. I have a twist of lemon in there
as well. Tomorrow, August 29th, is the birthday of the painter Ingres. He was born August 29th,
1780. We toast to him. The painter Jean-Auguste Dominique Ingres was born in the south of France
in Montauban, which is near Toulouse. He was one of the pupils of Jacques-Louis David, the leader
of the neoclassical school over the late 18th century, early 19th century. Ingres eventually
too became one of the leaders of the neoclassical school in France, although he spent a lot of his
time also in Italy. He aspired to be a history painter. For most academic painters, this was
the highest status one could be in the genre of paintings, history paintings. These large-scale
narrative scenes of historical, biblical, mythological scenes were considered the highest
in the hierarchy with portraiture and other kinds of genre paintings down below. This is his Antiochus
and Stratonice painted in 1840. But like many painters, he had to pay the bills to some degree
by painting portraits. And Ingres was an extremely talented portraitist. Here is his fabulous
portrait of Napoleon enthroned as Emperor Napoleon I. This is 1806, and this is in the Musée de
l'Armée in Paris at the Invalides. And one of his best-known, I would say, portraits,
Ingres' best-known, among Ingres' best-known portraits is Monsieur Bertin here at the Louvre.
Really, really quite majestic. And it reminds us that the subject of a portrait doesn't have
to be beautiful in order for the painting itself to be beautiful. By the time Louise de Pley approached
Ingres to paint her portrait, he was in his 60s. He's very well established in the field.
He was quite reluctant to take on portrait commissions. He just didn't really want to do
them anymore, these sort of, you know, fashionable society portraits. He didn't really want to do them
because they took away time from making those wonderful history paintings.
They met in Rome. He was there as the director of the Académie de France for some time, based in the
Villa Medici in Rome, and she was there traveling. Her husband was a politician, diplomat, and so she
lived in a number of cities around Europe. She walked into his studio, and he was painting at
the time, the Antiochus and Stratonice paintings. This is 1840. And she fell in love with the
painting and really wanted him to paint her portrait. And some might see similarities in the
pose of Stratonice, the female figure at the left of this composition, might see some similarities
in pose to what he eventually paints of Louise. So although Ingres is turning down most commissions
for portraits at the time, he agrees to do it. He agrees to paint her portrait. Some like to say
that it is because of her unbelievable beauty, he just couldn't turn it down. Probably more likely,
and the sense that we get from some of his letters, is that there were some patrons whose social
status was so high, whose power and authority were so strong, that he couldn't turn them down.
And she was the daughter of the Duc de Breuil. He couldn't turn this patron down. So he agrees
to paint her portrait. The other kind of painting, by the way, that Ingres is very well known for
is this group of orientalizing Turkish baths and odalisque scenes. This is Grand Odalisque
at the Louvre, a very well-known painting. And they're about this sort of impossible beauty of
these women. They're at once extremely precise, not a brushstroke out of place, not a single flaw
across the skin, not a hair out of place. And yet, the anatomy is impossible. Just one look at this
extremely long back and backside tells us that she probably has a few extra vertebrae than
most human beings. And this tension of precision but impossible beauty informs as well some
portraits, and especially his portrait of Louise de Breuil at the Comtesse d'Ausonvie.
When you look closely at it, the precision is something that must be appreciated through
details like this or looking up close. And one of my favorite details is the sort of surprising
flutter of these blonde eyelashes that are each sort of painted in very carefully, but gives the
sense and texture of softness against those pale blue eyes. And he studies these details. He studies
her face in several sittings. It's so funny because it's understood that when he proposed
to his wife for marriage, he had never actually met her in person. But it was so important that
his sitters were there in the flesh, and he studied very carefully their faces and their
appearances. So that's an interesting sort of contrast and anecdote in his life. This is a
drawing that studies details of her face down to the arc of her nostril. There are some 80, probably
some 80 drawings that he made in preparation for the Comtesse's portrait. Only under 20 survive
today. And in them, they're playing with composition. She's turned to one side, eventually changes it to
the other side, playing with costume, with pose. A lot of thinking and work getting this absolutely
right. And yet, and yet, the precision is paired with this impossible anatomy. And it takes some
people looking at this portrait for the first time to notice that her arm, her right arm crossed over
her belly, could not possibly have appeared there. Where would her shoulder have been if her arm was
so low? And at the same time, that was a studied detail. That wasn't something that was a mistake.
Here is a drawing that's actually in the Frick's collection, mostly studying the dress. And in this
iteration, she has a shawl on. The way the dress falls, the way the skirt falls, but the arms and
that very low, impossible anatomy is part already of the design of the composition. And there is
another drawing, many of these drawings at the Musée Ingres in Montauban, his birthplace.
Again, carefully studying the impossible anatomy of her arms. He's creating something for the
composition. And it does not have to be grounded in the reality. And it reminds us, of course,
that these portraits are inventions. They are constructed. It is signed 1845 under his name,
just on the side of that chair. But the painting is nearly an end point of a very, very long
process. This is a painting that he paints over the course of three years. They meet in 1840 in
Rome, and he begins painting her 1842 in Paris, and he carries on 43, 44, finally finishes in 45.
These interruptions are caused by his own other projects for other people, her travel schedule,
as well as a whole pregnancy and birth and the newborn months that happen over the course
of those three years in 1844. Three years go by from the inception to the final product.
She's aged three years. She begins age 24. She, at the end of it, is 27. You know, so many
iterations take place through drawings, and yet the final product and the composition is sort of
structured in order to give a sense of ease, an instant. We've interrupted her at a very casual
moment where she's just returned from the opera. So there's a yellow shawl just thrown onto the
chair next to her. On the mantle behind her, she's dropped her opera glasses, those black
small binoculars. Her evening handbag in bright blue is just draped, sort of tossed and draped
on the gilt bronze-mounted porcelain. The reflection in the mirror allows us to see
more of her, sort of that lovely plaited hair behind her, with a comb that's just set in
as if it's just about to be taken out. Her hair is going to come down for the night,
and the detail that goes into conveying the sense of decoration on the porcelain.
And I'm just going to draw us in a little bit closer to see the articulation of the lace of
her dress. Now, how slender his paintbrush had to be in order to convey every stitch, basically,
every line of that lace. And one criticism of Ingres during his life was that he was rather
Gothic. And what that meant was, it was a reference to sort of the early northern
Renaissance artists like Jan van Eyck, whose paintings were so, so very tight and very,
very precise. It was a criticism that was given to Ingres, although I don't think that everybody
thought that was necessarily a bad thing. I certainly don't. Just another detail of her
jewelry, gold bracelet and ring, embedded with just a small bit of turquoise, and France Pierre
Tourque, Turkish stone. It was believed to have some origin in Turkey, obviously.
The idea of the East, probably mined, or probably taken from Egypt or Persia, not Iran.
And just to give you a sense of the wonderful snake-formed ring with the turquoise embedded
in the head and the top of the neck. These rings were fashionable, and the fashion was called
à la Cleopâtre, as in, of Cleopatra. The small joke being, of course, that Cleopatra is killed by
the bite of a snake. His painting is so precise that so many of these objects could be identified.
And a number of them that had belonged to the Comtesse d'Haussonville were brought together
in an exhibition held at the Frick Collection in 1985. This is a photograph of the exhibition and
installation around the painting at the exhibition, organized by the Frick's very first chief curator,
the late Edgar Munhall. So, a number of her objects were brought together,
as well as representative objects. So, carte de visite, for example, that were lying on the
ledge of the mantel. These were visitor cards that were left by people who visited while she
was out. The little corner turned up to show that she was out when the visitor came by. And so,
a nice collection of these objects brought together to bring the world of Louise d'Haussonville to
life. And it seems like we have a window into her world, but we don't know that much about her. I
mean, we know from the painting that she's very beautiful, she's young, she's wealthy, and she
very much likes opera. We know more about her through biographical things like her own writings,
and we know that she loved opera. She, in fact, was an artist herself in a certain way.
She made a number of drawings inspired by opera. She also played the piano. She had piano lessons
with Frederic Chopin, who, of course, was a Polish émigré who came to Paris and made much of his
livelihood giving piano lessons to wealthy young French women like Louise de Bray. And she was also
a prolific writer. She was the granddaughter of an extremely important writer, Madame de Stael,
who was exiled under Napoleon and, in fact, spent most of her time in exile in the family château
in Switzerland. This is Copé. It's still there. As of a little while ago, one could still
take public tours, although it is a private château still. And this is the château that
Madame de Stael held many salons in. It was a cultural fixture in European circles. This château
is inherited by Louise de Bray at a certain point in her adult life. Louise publishes a number of
books, mostly biographies, for example, of Lord Byron, another one of the Irish revolutionary
called Robert Emmet, who was executed for high treason under the British crown. You can see
from the title page, if you can read that text, her name doesn't appear on this or any of the
books she publishes. She was forced, to some degree, by her husband to publish anonymously.
And in the case of the book of Robert Emmet, one can kind of see why. Her husband was a politician
and diplomat, and her writing a book about an Irish revolutionary who was executed for treason
probably would not have been good for him and his circles and would have attracted some
public scrutiny. It's in her personal writings, though, that we get a better sense of who
she is in terms of a darkness to her personality. She looks so young and beautiful and fresh in the
portrait. She was rather troubled. She always lived under the shadow of her grandmother as
this wonderful author, and Louise never really acquired the same kind of status,
not even close, as an author that her grandmother did. She was very troubled by and never really
got over the death of her sister at age 14. This is something that haunted her. She became
preoccupied from a young age and through her life with death, with the decomposition of bodies, with
the haunting of her sister. And she thought a lot about her own body and her own mortality.
A part of her will later on in her life specifies that she would like to be embalmed if that was
possible, but if cremation was more popular then, then she would prefer to be cremated
because she found that to be more seemly and a more poetic treatment of her body.
She struggled with her own beauty. One of the most famous quotes that come from Louise's writings
in her personal memoir, I was destined to beguile, she wrote, to attract, to seduce,
and in the final reckoning to cause suffering in all those who sought their happiness in me.
There's a late description of her by, a sort of cruel description, by a man called Prosper
Merinet. And he describes her about 20 years after this painting is made. She's in her mid-40s by
then. And he writes to somebody describing the Comtesse d'Ausonvie as quite fat, with hardly
any hair left. It's hard to reconcile that late description with what we see in front of us.
The same thing happens to Ingres in his self-portrait. This is at the Musée Condé in
Chantilly. He's about 25 years old when he begins this, and he's so dashing and young.
There's a late account of him as well, published during his life by Théophile Sylvestre,
A History of Living Painters, and it describes Ingres at the age of 75 in, again, some pretty
cruel terms. He's called a bourgeois little elephant, put together out of misshapen stumps
of an outward vulgarity that contrasts startlingly with the mannered elegance of his works.
Again, hard to reconcile those late descriptions with the portraits, and it reminds us that
portraits are of one moment, of one part of somebody's life. There's the portrait,
and there's the life. In fact, we have a photograph of Ingres at the age of 75,
and this juxtaposition with his younger self-portrait really brings to life the sense of
paintings having this creative potential, this inventive potential that
early photography really did not. It really drives home the point that life goes on,
that portraits capture a moment, and life goes on. We don't have a later photograph
of the Comtesse d'Haussonville. Maybe that's a good thing, and we remember her just as Ingres
has captured her. When Ingres completed this painting in 1845, he received a ton of praise.
A lot of people loved it. In fact, one naughty commentator said to Louise Deploy,
well, Monsieur Ingres must have been in love with you in order to paint you like that.
She loved it. In fact, when she wrote her will later on in her life, she died around the age
of 64. A few years before that, she wrote her final will, and in a long list of her belongings
that were going to be left with various family members, the portrait is the second thing she
lists, and it's second only to the chateau itself, the chateau at Copé. She leaves this painting to
her daughter with the chateau, and she requests that the portrait remain in the chateau in Copé.
That's where she's born, where she ends up being buried, and the portrait by Monsieur Ingres
would be there, and it remained there installed in the main dining room until the death of her
youngest child, a son, in 1924, at which point it was sold to the Frick Collection.
But what a lot of people don't realize is, although this is an iconic painting for the
Frick Collection, and for some people represents the Frick Collections and its great qualities
in painting, it was not acquired by Henry Clay Frick. In fact, Henry Clay Frick may never have
laid eyes on it. Frick died in 1919, and this, just like many of the paintings,
the paintings collection grew about a third after the death of Henry Clay Frick, came into the
collection under the leadership of Frick's daughter, Helen Clay Frick, and here's a wonderful sassy
photograph of her taken in Belgium. The role that Miss Frick had in the shaping of the Frick
Collection, as we know it today, is extremely significant, not very well known. The painting
of Louise came over to New York City in 1927, at which point the Frick was not yet open as
a museum. It was still a private home because Henry Clay Frick's widow and Helen's mother,
Adelaide Frick, still resided in the mansion on 1 East 70th Street until 1931. The museum opened
to the public after her death in 1935, finally opened to the public. The Angus portrait of the
Comtesse d'Orsonville goes on public view, and this opening of the Frick Collection in 1935 is what
is being celebrated in the Life magazine issue of 1937, her portrait chosen as the key work
to represent this grand opening of Frick's museum. What couldn't come to New York City in 1927
was a bottle of absinthe. It was banned in the United States in 1912 and did not become legal
again until 2007. So with that in mind, I hope you've enjoyed your cocktail. Thank you so much
for joining us on this episode of Cocktails with the Curator. We'll see you next time.
