LESSON 35 - THE COURT OF JUSTICE

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
#internationallaw #ilawproject #education #RegionalSystems #AU #AfricanUnion #TeachingIL
For the thirty-fifth lecture in this series, we will speak to another African Union organ – The Court of Justice. In this lesson, we will address:
What it is;
Its Composition; and
Its function?
Hello, thank you for joining me on my YouTube channel. My name is Christiana Sagie. On this
channel, I will be teaching about international law and these teachings will be in the form of
short weekly lecture series. Over time, I will be surfacing varied concepts of international law.
When and where applicable, these concepts will be analyzed and brought to you as it relates to
current trends in international law as they arise. At the end of this lecture, you will find
the transcript of the lecture in the link below. Also, for current trend and analysis in international
law, you can subscribe to my blog. All the details you will find in the comment section below.
For the 35th lecture in this lecture series, we will be exploring another organ of the African
Union encapsulated in Article 5d of the Constitutive Act of the AU and established by
Article 18.1 of the Constitutive Act of the AU, the Court of Justice. In this lesson, we will
answer the questions, what is the Court of Justice? What is its composition? How does it function?
So, let's dive in. What is the Court of Justice? According to Article 18.2 of the Constitutive Act
of the AU, the statute, composition and functions of the Court of Justice shall be defined in a
protocol relating thereto. Following the provisions of Article 18.2, which we just read, the protocol
of the Court of Justice of the African Union was adopted in July 1, 2003 and came into force on
February 11, 2009. I have created a hyperlink to the document in the transcript below.
Article 2.2 of the protocol states that the Court shall be the principal organ of the Union.
The verbiage of the protocol seems to indicate that there are other judicial organs of the Union,
given that the Court of Justice is the principal organ. Indeed, the AU also functions through
several other legal organs. Some of these legal organs are creations of the Assembly
under the authority of Article 5.2 of the Constitutive Act of the AU.
Each of these legal organs have their very structures and threshold requirements
before their jurisdiction can be triggered. The nuts and bolts of each of these organs
are beyond the scope of this lesson, but I'll briefly itemize them. These organs are
the African Commission on Human and People's Rights, the African Court on Human and People's
Rights, the Extraordinary African Chambers, the AU Commission on International Law,
the AU Advisory Board on Corruption, and the African Committee of Experts on the Rights and
Welfare of the Child. To its composition, Article 3 of the protocol speaks generally to the
composition of the Court of Justice. Article 3.1 of the protocol stipulates that the Court
shall consist of 11 judges drawn out of member states. This number may however be reviewed by
the Assembly. As such, the Assembly has the authority under Article 3.2 of the protocol
to increase the number of judges of the Court of Justice. The judges of the Court of Justice
are usually elected by the Assembly, by secret ballots, and by two-thirds majority of the member
states eligible to vote. To the functions of the Court of Justice. Essentially, the Court of
Justice has two functions. One, to settle in accordance with laid down sources of law,
legal disputes submitted to it by states, on interpretation of AU treaties, and according to
Article 44 of the protocol, to give advisory opinions on legal questions referred to it by
an authorized organ and specialized agencies of the AU. And the Court's capacity to settle disputes
or deliver advisory opinions, it must make recourse to either one or all of the following sources of
law. First, the constitutive act of the AU, international treaties recognized by contesting
parties, international customs, general principles of law, judicial decisions and writings of the
most qualified publicists, and ex acquia a bodo. In theory, we have looked at the formation,
composition, and functions of the Court of Justice. In reality, the Court of Justice is yet to come
into existence. Within the AU, there is the ongoing conversation or controversy, if you may say,
surrounding the proposal to match the Court of Justice with the African Court on Human and
People's Rights. This led to the adoption of the Protocol on Amendment to the Protocol on the
Statute of the African Court of Justice and Human Rights on June 27, 2014, which is yet to come into
force. I have created a hyperlink to the document in the transcript below. But what we see in this
Protocol is a blend of jurisdiction, creating an international criminal law jurisdiction,
human rights jurisdiction, and international law jurisdiction in one court. Overall, this lesson
has offered a bedside view of the structure of the Court of Justice, one of the organs of the AU.
If there are any more questions on this issue or a topic you would like to see on this channel,
leave a comment below. So I want to say thank you so very much for joining in. Remember to like,
share, subscribe, leave your comments in the comment section below, and hit the notification
bell so that you are notified when there's a new video. We would also like to connect with you on
Facebook and Twitter. Let us know the content you'd like to see. Thank you.
