The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
M. Freeman, Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Sweet & Maxwell, 2014). R. Wacks, Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory (Oxford University Press, 2020). J. Penner & E. Melissaris, McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence (Oxford University Press, 2012).
Jurisprudence is the philosophical study of law. It encompasses the examination and analysis of legal principles, concepts, and theories, aiming to understand the nature of law, its origins, and its underlying philosophical foundations. Jurisprudence explores questions about the essence of law, its purpose, and its role in society.
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This lesson explores the historical transition from natural law to legal positivism, focusing on the shift from viewing law as a set of transcendent, discoverable truths to seeing it as a construct of sovereign authority. It examines the influence of secularization, political revolutions, and the pivotal contributions of thinkers like Blackstone, Bentham, and Austin.
Welcome back everybody to our studies in jurisprudence. In this lesson we are
continuing talking about legal positivism and we're going to focus on the idea of its
historical development. Now this isn't going to be a particularly in-depth or even that much of a
long lesson particularly because ultimately we see that legal positivism develops out of the sort of
mid to late 1800s and we will get to some of the more classical theories of legal positivism in
the next few lessons, namely working on the concept of the writings and the work of people
like John Austin. And then we will start to get into the more modern debates about legal positivism
of course coming from philosophers such as that of HLA Hart and then the responses to positivism
from the likes of individuals like Ronald Dworkin. But in this lesson we'll just talk about some of
the situations and some of the ideas and some of the theories that existed at the time in which
legal positivism was starting to gain a little bit more momentum and then really just as a background
an idea of the context in which legal positivism begins to develop. If you remember back to earlier
lessons we remembered that one of the things that happens in the development of legal positivism is
a decline in natural law and the decline in natural law takes place in a number of different
ways. You have of course the secularization of society more generally because of the fact that
natural law is inherently tied or at least historically has inherently been tied to
religious fervour. So for example the writings of Augustine and Aquinas and of course with the
secularization of society we will see a sort of a decline in that kind of religious influence over
legal jurisprudence but also we see the development of atrocities that take place
under the remit of what is perceived to be legal systems. So the legal system of the Third
Reich, you have the legal system of the Soviet state committing atrocities against their own
people and against others and this sort of leads people to turn away from this general idea that
morality and law have an inherent connection given the fact that you have a system which
is inherently a legal system in the Third Reich for example but that is and cannot ever be a
moral system and so you see a decline in natural law for that reason as well. But at the same time
and sort of developing concurrently to this decline in natural law you see the growth in
the concept of legal positivism. So this is going to be more of an introduction to the classical
forms of legal positivism and their theories as well as their critiques and I want to begin with
the works of Blackstone because Blackstone is very very interesting in his interpretation of how
the common law is as described within the English legal system because it is seen here that the
principles of the common law are almost transcendent and this is something of a natural law position
because just like Plato believed that principles such as justice and beauty were transcendent
ideas and you sort of have to look towards the idea the platonic theory of forms for example to
have an understanding of these ideas, Blackstone believed that the common law was and inherently
had basic principles which had these transcendent characteristics, these transcendent ideas attached
to them which is something of a natural law position and what is interesting here is that
a rule in the common law, a view of the common law and the development of the common law by judges
is not the creation of new rules or the idea of the invention of new ideas and new principles of
law, it is instead described as the discovery of new principles. According to this understanding
of law and jurisprudence at least during this period and specifically applied to that of the
common law, the idea here is that the common law exists as it is and has always existed almost as
a transcendent principle or at least the principles within the common law are transcendent in a
similar way to Plato's understanding of justice and beauty for example and that when judges
develop new rules for the common law and they come up with new judgments, they are not inventing
these judgments, they are discovering new rules of the common law that had already existed but
that just human beings had not yet discovered. This is a very natural law perspective and it
is to say essentially that the common law already exists, all the rules already exist within the
common law, it is for the judges to discover them rather than to invent them. This was the
dominant position and the dominant theory for the majority of both philosophers and legal theorists
for the majority of the 1800s. Remember what I said, the concept of legal positivism comes out of
debates that take place in the sort of mid to late 1800s with the work of Bentham and Austin
and then we go into the 20th century. So for the majority of this period, at least for the early
1800s and going into even the later 1800s, this sort of position that is ascribed by individuals
like Blackstone is the majority-held view, the idea of principles of the common law being
transcendent and detached from the workings of the legal mind and instead are discovered
by the legal mind, they're not developed by the legal mind. Now this is sometimes described as a
theory of natural law as common law. It's almost a way of trying to conjoin the two ideas together
and for English common lawyers to try and understand the common law through the lens of a
natural law perspective and almost to essentially repeal and replace natural law with the idea of
the common law while holding some of the basic principles of the natural law, the idea of
objectivity, the idea of morality, the idea of transcendent idealism in relation to concepts and
theories of legal principles and so that's what the dominant position was. And so with this
in mind and with the context of this being established, we start to see the beginnings of
challenges and the concept of legal positivism, at least today and in the 20th century, the latter
half of the 20th century, is seen to be the dominant position, at least this sort of new
improved idea of legal jurisprudence. Today you obviously have a bit more influence from
some of the social theorists and critical legal theorists, but for the most part legal positivism
and positivism more generally is something of an established viewpoint within
academia. And so when we start to see the challenges of the legal positivists or
challenges by legal positivists, we begin by thinking about the political developments
in the revolutionary situations of the 18th century, the 17th century, the 1700s. So
in the 1700s you see a number of revolutions take place. You see the French Revolution,
you see the American Revolution, the century before you see the English Revolution with some
of the political writings being developed out of that being quite influential in French and
American revolutionary thought. So one of the major critiques of revolution more generally
is the work of individuals like Thomas Hobbes and his publishing of Leviathan,
which is an anti-revolution document essentially. It is a document which essentially tries to
explain why one ought to submit to a sovereign authority, to a monarch. But with these new
revolutionary ideas and with these new developments in both the French and American revolutions comes
new ideas such as the rights of man as well as fundamental freedoms and liberty. People like
John Locke begin to have more and more influence within political philosophy. The same for
French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau has again more and more influence in the
liberal thought processes and the development of liberalism in this classical age.
One of the areas where we see further challenges as well is in jurisprudence and with the origins
of some of the theories of the concepts of legal positivism. These pose significant threat to the
concept of monarchical authority and so we start to see in the late 1800s the work of John Austen
who is arguably, in conjunction with Jeremy Bentham, the originators of the ideas of
positivism that we know of today. The legal underpinnings of legal positivism come from
some of the revolutionary works of John Austen. Austen was also a revolutionary in his development
of a theory of law and one of the things that really set Austen apart from the conventional
wisdom of the jurisprudence at the time is this idea that law can be separated from morality.
Within Austen's framework of legal positivism we see the concept of law is derived from the concept
There is no transcendental idea of law, there are no transcendent set of legal principles,
there is no discovery of legal principles in the same way as Blackstone's understanding of
the natural law as common law and so understanding this idea is quite revolutionary in terms of
the break from the natural law theorists going towards this idea of deriving law out of sovereign
authority not out of morality. We'll get to this in more detail in future lessons time.