The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
M. Freeman, Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Sweet & Maxwell, 2014). R. Wacks, Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory (Oxford University Press, 2020). J. Penner & E. Melissaris, McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence (Oxford University Press, 2012).
Jurisprudence is the philosophical study of law. It encompasses the examination and analysis of legal principles, concepts, and theories, aiming to understand the nature of law, its origins, and its underlying philosophical foundations. Jurisprudence explores questions about the essence of law, its purpose, and its role in society.
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the previous lesson, what we did was take an introduction to legal positivism in a little
bit more detail, exploring and examining the general context in which legal positivism begins
to grow and gain in popularity. We talked about some of the historical developments of the common
law as natural law, so one of the theories being that the common law had in it and as part of it
fundamental principles which were transcendent in a very similar way to how Plato used to argue
when he was alive, how Plato used to argue that things like beauty and justice were transcendent
ideas. We also took a look at the work of Blackstone in a little bit of detail, focusing
on the idea that according to the common understanding of the common law as a natural
law theory in the mid to late 1800s, the concept of a new principle of the common law was not one
that was developed by lawyers or new theories and new ideas as applied to new facts, rather it was
discovered by lawyers. There is no such thing as inventing new concepts within the common law
according to these basic ideas, there is instead discovering new principles of the common law.
We also talked about the fact that as natural law began to decline as a result of a number of
different things, it wasn't one thing particularly, there was the impact of the Second World War on
the one hand, there was also the sort of growing shift away from very religious and religion-oriented
theories of both politics and of philosophy and also of law with the sort of general secularization
that came with the wave of the Enlightenment. We see the beginnings of a shift in the development
of legal jurisprudence away from this concept that law is inherently tied to morality and instead
separating those two concepts law and morality, which is what legal positivism essentially does.
This is not to suggest, however, that there is not a single theory of legal positivism that doesn't
take into account concepts of morality, there are of course ideas that link with morality,
but that essentially in rejecting natural law the legal positivists understand that law is not
inherently derived out of morality and is not inherently linked to morality. In this lesson
we're going to talk a little bit more about the traditional theory of legal positivism, focusing
on the theories of Austinian positivism. We'll talk about Austinian positivism in this lesson,
we'll talk about one of the major critiques to Austinian positivism, this being the idea of
international law not being considered law, which is of course a theory that I certainly reject
personally. As a general recap, legal positivism originates from some of the revolutionary works
and some of the revolutionary theories of law from the works and from the likes of people such as
John Austin and people like Jeremy Bentham. John Austin was a revolutionary in his development,
he believed that you could develop a theory of law which was separate to that of morality,
there was a separation between law and morality in this way. And within this Austinian framework
we can see that the concept of law is not derived out of morality, instead the concept of law is
derived out of the sovereign. So what John Austin essentially does is he takes the view of
law and morality and replaces morality with this idea of sovereignty, this idea of the sovereign
within the concept of legal creation. And what this essentially does is, because the sovereign
is a tangible thing, it's often, at least when we talk about monarchies, a person, or it could be a
legislature, this essentially taking away from ethereal concepts like morality and applying
instead concepts like sovereignty, which are much more concrete, they actually represent a person
or an institution. And what we do is we get rid of this idea that there are transcendent sets of
legal norms and principles. So according to the Austinian positivist, there are no transcendent
sets of legal norms that exist in the same kind of way of a natural lawyer and how a natural
lawyer would understand the concepts of the development of law and the interrelationship
between law and morality. So the Austinian positivist is revolutionary in this regard,
rejecting basic principles of law and morality as being inherently tied to each other, which
maybe today is not too much of a controversial opinion, but at the time was relatively
revolutionary. And so legal positivism is the rejection of basic principles of a priori logic.
So what this essentially tells us is the same kind of a priori reasoning that natural law depends
on to exist is rejected by the positivist and the Austinian positivist specifically. So a priori
is an epistemic mode of understanding knowledge essentially. So epistemology is the philosophy
of knowledge and the ways in which we understand knowledge and how we derive knowledge and our
justifications for believing certain actions and certain things. A priori knowledge or a priori
reasoning is reasoning that requires no external empirical evidence. So you can understand something
and you can derive conclusions about things a priori if you could do so using your own
rationality, your own reasoning, your own logic. And then you have the almost the opposite,
the polar opposite to a priori logic or a priori reasoning, which is a posteriori reasoning,
which relies on external empirical evidence for things. So for example, a classic example is that
I could say that all triangles have three sides. This is a statement, a proposition,
that is either true or false. I can conclude from my own a priori reasoning that this is true
because I know that a definition of a triangle is a shape with three sides. So to say that something
is a shape with three sides and saying that that has three sides, which is what essentially the
proposition is, is tautological. It is obviously true. It is a priori true. I don't have to go out
and empirically measure every single triangle that exists in the universe to try and measure to
conclude that they have three sides or not. That's not how I would come to that conclusion. I could
do so from sitting in my room and I can logically deduce that that is the case. That is an example
of a priori logic or a priori reasoning. This kind of reasoning, this kind of understanding,
is something that is relied upon within natural law. For people like John Austin, the most
important thing about law is that it determines the condition of its own existence, rather than
requiring this a priori reasoning. It means therefore that there are no external factors
upon which law relies on for its own basic existence. Now in concluding this part here,
I want to just make it very clear that one of the major critiques of Austinian jurisprudence
is its relationship with international law. Now international law was not as prominent as it is
today when Austin was writing, but you may come to the conclusion that if law is derived out of the
then what about law that has no sovereign? What about law that does not exist in relation to any
kind of sovereign authority? International law is not derived out of sovereign authority. So by
sovereign authority we're talking about, for example, state sovereignty. The sovereignty of
a state that could be represented as a monarch, as a single individual, as a dynasty, or it could
be represented as an institution like a parliament or a legislature. And so international law doesn't
exist in that same way. And so as a result of which, this is a problematic aspect of the
Austinian positivist theory, should I say, not natural law, is that Austinian jurisprudence
depends on the existence of the sovereign to create law. As a result of that international
law doesn't exist, or at least international law isn't law according to the Austinian positivist,
because there is no sovereign authority, there's no international sovereignty that exists.
So as a result of which, how can an Austinian positivist conclude that international law is
law? This is not to suggest that international law doesn't exist according to an Austinian
positivist. There is a collection of things that we can describe using the phrase
international law, but according to an Austinian positivist or someone who believes in Austinian
jurisprudence, this thing that we call international law, we can call it international
law all we want, but it is not law in the same way as domestic legal systems develop law. Now,
this is not even an uncontroversial opinion in some realms of academia, specifically within common
law jurisdictions. There are lots of common lawyers who do not believe international law to be law,
not necessarily because of this particular justification, but just generally because it
is different to the domestic systems in terms of enforcement and in terms of the ability to apply
said law. That's a general critique of international law, but this is quite interesting
how an Austinian positivist, since it derives, an Austinian positivist will derive their understanding
of where law comes from from the sovereign, the concept of international law cannot exist
as law in the same way according to this kind of positivism.