“Comtesse du Cayla” by Jean-Antoine Houdon (1741–1828)

Neoclassical Art (c.1760–1850)
2 followers
6 Video Views·May 20, 2025
Assistant Curator Giulio Dalvit examines the beguiling marble bust The Comtesse du Cayla by Jean-Antoine Houdon. This beautifully intimate portrait reveals the artist’s virtuoso skill in rendering surface and form—it's nearly impossible to believe the grapevine-crowned Comtesse emerged from a single block of marble.
Good evening, I'm Giulio Dalvit, the Assistant Curator of Sculpture at the Frick Collection in
New York. Thank you for joining me tonight for another episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
Tonight I want to talk to you about this rather small marble portrait bust of the Comtesse du
Caillat, the Countess of Caillat. Her maiden name was Elisabeth-Suzanne de Jocourt and she was
only just a girl, a 20-year-old girl, when she was portrayed here in this marble bust
by the French sculptor Jean-Antoine Houdon. Houdon is still celebrated for his effigies of
the great men of the French 18th and early 19th century, the age of the Enlightenment,
the French Revolution, and ultimately the Napoleonic Empire. And here, for example,
you see a portrait of a bust of Jean-Jacques Rousseau on the left and Voltaire on the right.
But Houdon's story is also something of an American story because in the early 1780s he was asked by
Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin to come to America to carry out a major commission of
full-length marble statue of George Washington. And he did so. He traveled all the way from France
to America, across the Atlantic. He went to Mount Vernon, met with Washington, took a live mask of
his face, which you still see on the left because it amazingly survives to this day at the Morgan
Library in New York, so you can go and see it. Houdon used the mask not just to carry out the
full-length statue, which you see on the right, which was meant to be and has always been at the
capital of the state of Virginia in Richmond, but also to carve a number of busts of Washington
that are scattered across America and really across the globe. And this contributed to
creating something of an official iconography for George Washington in the newborn United States
of America. So Houdon is really as important in France as he is in the States. But tonight I don't
want to talk about Houdon's portraits of great men, but rather the portrait of this little-known
18th century woman. And before doing that, I want to concentrate with you on two little details
which really set in a way the emotional tone of this marble bust that actually surpasses and
outshines most of Houdon's portraits of men, precisely because this is the portrait of a
woman probably, because he didn't have to create an official stately iconography. There is much
more intimacy in this portrait of Madame du Cayla, and it's an intimacy which speaks in a way of
summer, of flowery summers in the south of France, as we will see later. And I want to
concentrate with you on these two little details, the spray of grape leaves across her chest and
her hair strewn with flowers, which really evokes summer for me. And I wanted to pair tonight's
with a cocktail which is known as a frosé. She's just frozen rosé wine, strawberries,
lemon juice, and a touch of sugar. It's very simple, but delicious and very refreshing. So
cheers. Why is this portrait of Madame du Cayla so special? It is special because it's
a wonderful example of Houdon's virtuoso carving of marble. He can go from very smooth,
polished surfaces of the skin, for example, to rougher, coarser surfaces for the hair.
He can go from thin bales of marble for the grape leaves, and imagine how difficult it is to carve
this marble so thin, to thicker masses of marble for the hair. And really here you see Houdon
define the hard texture of marble, achieving so many different effects in the same area,
on the same bust, and it is impossible almost to imagine that this actually came originally as
one marble block to Houdon's studio. And if we concentrate on the hair, we also see that Houdon
manages to sculpt not just marble, but also light. He manages to create these areas of deep shadow
that articulate the volumes of this wonderfully cascading hair on the back of Madame du Cayla
in such a wondrous way. Beyond that, beyond the artistic achievements of this marble bust,
there is one detail that has always puzzled scholars, and it's this spray of grape leaves,
which I've already mentioned. Why is it there? There's three different hypotheses. The first
one is that it's a reference to the surname of Madame du Cayla's husband's family, the Basquiat.
Madame du Cayla married her own cousin, actually, Hercule-Thien-Philippe de Basquiat,
and the Basquiat name sort of rhymes with the name Bacchus, the god of wine, and there is
a branch of grape leaves which features in the coat of arms of the Basquiat family. So
this might be a reference to the name Basquiat and their coat of arms. And this is not new in
Houdon's oeuvre. We see that, for example, here in this portrait of Mademoiselle Olivier,
which came out of Houdon's workshop, we can see that he plays with the name Olivier with this
branch of olive tree that cuts across the chest of Madame Olivier. But there is a second hypothesis,
which does not exclude the previous one, but is more interesting and more compelling,
and that's that Madame du Cayla is portrayed here as a Bacchante, and that's also the
interpretation that contemporary viewers gave of this object. When this was first shown at the
Parisian Salon in 1777, a visitor to the Salon wrote in his diaries, and I'm going to quote,
we see in Madame la Comtesse du Cayla the sweet drunkenness, the lively gaiety,
the frivolous abandonment of a Bacchante at the beginning of an orgy during the first moments
of pleasure. He might have gone a step too far with the interpretation of this bust, but
it is true that if we compare this bust with, for example, this portrait of Lady Hamilton,
which is now in Liverpool by Elisabeth Vigée Le Brun, we realize that this was very fashionable
at the time. Eighteenth-century women had themselves portrayed as Bacchantes,
so priestesses of the god Bacchus, the god of wine, drunkenness, and also ecstasy.
And we see here Lady Hamilton, who was the long-term lover of Lord Nelson and the artistic
muse of the painter George Romney, and you can still see at the Frick a portrait of Lady
Hamilton as nature by Romney. But here, in this comparison with the portrait by Vigée Le Brun,
we realize that not only is Madame du Cayla portrayed as a Bacchante, but she is a running
Bacchante. We see her hair and the cloak floating in the wind behind her.
And this is extraordinary, if you think about it, because it means that Houdon plays with
busts, which are the most static, rigid kind of representation ever, and turns this into a
figure in movement. He catches this woman while she's running. He manages to freeze this instance
in stone forever. And this is truly amazing. It means that he's pushing
bust portraiture to its structural and conceptual limits, really. And it's funny that you can only
realize this as you move yourself as a viewer around the sculpture and you look at it from the
side, because from the front, you will never be able to realize that she's actually running away
from something. So this very powerful bust also manages to prompt you as a viewer to turn and to
move around this figure in movement. So this is really an outstanding achievement for Houdon.
There is also a more prosaic explanation, let's say, of why the grape leaves might be included
in the bust, and that's that the Basquiat family owned vast estates in southern France, in Languedoc,
and here you see the wonderful Chateau du Cailat at Andillac in southern France.
And they also owned vast vineyards, which produced huge amounts of wine. And so it might be
also a reference to one of the main sources of income for the Basquiat family, the presence of
these grape leaves. And the portrait of Madame du Cailat is really part of a family history,
in a way, because in the same year, 1777, Houdon also made a bust of the Cailat's mother,
the Comtesse de Jocour, which you see here, and it's at the Louvre now, on the right. They are
very different. They're different in attitude, because you go from the frivolous gaiety of Madame
du Cailat to this very severe and austere, algid figure of the Comtesse de Jocour. And they are also
ill-matched in terms of size. The Comtesse du Cailat is slightly smaller, which tells us that
probably they weren't conceived as a pair. But still, we see also in the Comtesse de Jocour,
kind of a reference to antiquity. She's definitely not wearing contemporary dress.
And she has this sash that cuts across her chest, which might be a reference to the figure
of Diana, for example, which you see on the right, this wonderful full-length marble sculpture by
Houdon. And the terracotta version is obviously at the Frick, and you might have seen it.
But whether or not she's Diana, or she may be an Amazon, for example, still, she is resolved by
Houdon as an ancient figure. In 1777, Houdon showed a number of busts at the Parisian Salon
of that year. And we know that because we have lists of all the exhibits of the Salon of that
year. And we see all the busts by Houdon. You can see that the portrait of the du Cailat is listed
as is that of her mother. But there is also a mysterious portrait, the Madame de and then three
asterisks, which can only be identified because we have a copy which was owned of this catalogue,
which was owned by the French painter Gabriel de Saint-Aubin. And he made sketches of the busts
shown by Houdon, all the busts shown by Houdon on this page. And you can recognize the two busts
we've talked about. But also we are able to identify the portrait, the Madame de whatever,
with this bust against a blue background that you see on the right. This bust has actually a strong
connection to the Frick because in 1916, it was presented by the Duveen brothers, a dealing firm,
to Henry Clay Frick for purchase. Frick was tempted by this bust. He kept it for three years
in his home, but then was convinced by an art critic at the time, Charles Henry Hart,
that this wasn't a genuine Houdon. Part of it had also to do with the identification of the sitter
because Duveen claimed that this was a portrait of La Clarion. La Clarion was a famous French
18th century actress. And actually, she's not. We now know that this is Anne Germaine Larrivée
de Vermeneux, who was a famous, very rich widow in Paris at the time, who was friends with some
of the most important intellectual circles of the city. And she was very good friends, for example,
but that wasn't known at the time. And Frick was persuaded by Hart that this wasn't a Houdon,
that this was a fake. Hart claimed that this didn't breathe like a Houdon. So Frick rejected
it after three years, sent it back to Duveen, who had to lower the price. A lot of controversy ensued.
The Duveen brothers also sued Mr. Hart. They lowered the price and they eventually sold it
to someone else. And it ended up in, now it's in the Huntington Library in San Marino, California,
where you can still see it. And now it's universally accepted as one of the most beautiful
marble portraits ever made by Houdon. But Frick unfortunately rejected it. And it is a pity,
also because we know that Frick only managed to acquire this one Houdon, the portrait of
Madame du Cailat, during his lifetime. And he was so fond of it and liked it so much that
when it came to having a portrait made of his own daughter, Ellen Clay Frick, he asked the
marble, sorry, the American sculptor Malvina Hoffman to, and I quote, do my daughter in the
18th century manner. And we see here that Malvina Hoffman really looked for inspiration at Madame
du Cailat for her portrait of Helen Clay Frick. We don't really know why, but Helen Clay Frick
later destroyed the marble version of this portrait. But fortunately, the plaster still
survived. And it was given as a very generous gift to the Frick in 2016. So we still know
what this looked like. Frick was very fond of Houdon, but he only, as I said, managed to acquire
Madame du Cailat during his lifetime. But later on, after 1919, after his death, and after the opening
of the museum in 1935, Frick managed to acquire a number of pieces by Houdon. You see the portrait
of the Marquis de Miron-Menil on the left here, the wonderful full-scale terracotta Diana de
Hunters, one of the most outstanding technical achievements of sculpture of all times. It is now
in the Portico in the Frick Historic Building. You see it in the middle. And then much later,
the Frick also got hold of this wonderful portrait of Madame His, which came
as a gift, and you see it on the right. In 2007, it came as a gift. And there's also a smaller
version of Diana de Hunters in plaster, which is also at the Frick. So overall now, nowadays,
you can see five different pieces by Houdon at the Frick, which has become something of
an international hub for the study of Houdon sculpture. So next time you come at the Frick,
I hope you will spend some time looking at all the Houdons that you can find there.
Paying attention to his wonderful Bercoso carving of them, but also especially spend some time in
the company of this beguiling portrait of Madame du Caidat. Thank you for joining me tonight,
and I'm looking forward to another episode of Cocktails with a Curator with you very soon. Goodbye.
